CS Paper Radar

Balanced Fair Division for Three Agents under General Valuations and Laminar Constraints

Max Dupré la Tour

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-08-10 11:10 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We study fair allocations of indivisible items under general set valuations. We prove that every instance with three agents and arbitrary real-valued valuations admits a balanced allocation that is envy-free up to one good and one chore (EF$1^c_g$). This directly implies balanced EF$1$ when each valuation is either monotone nondecreasing or monotone nonincreasing. We also show that balanced EF$1$ cannot be guaranteed without monotonicity: there exists an instance with three agents, nine items, and identical nonmonotone valuations that admits no balanced EF$1$ allocation. We then consider a common laminar matroid constraint. Whenever a complete feasible allocation exists, we prove that there is a complete feasible allocation that is balanced and envy-free up to two goods and two chores (EF$2^c_g$) for arbitrary valuations. The allocation can additionally be chosen so that the numbers of items from every laminar set assigned to the three agents differ by at most two. Most proofs in this paper were obtained using GPT-5.6. We subsequently verified the proofs for correctness and refined their exposition and arguments, also with the aid of GPT-5.6.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Constrained Fair Allocations via Partition Matroid Reductions

cs.GT ·2026-08-31 ·Benjamin Cookson, Nisarg Shah
published similarity 0.80
Abstract · Accepted to ACM EAAMO 2026

We study fair allocation of indivisible goods under additive valuations and matroid constraints. A challenging open question is whether a complete and feasible envy-free up to one good (EF1) allocation exists under every matroid that admits a complete and feasible allocation. The state-of-the-art result by Biswas and Barman [2018] positively resolves this question for partition matroids. Our first result positively resolves it for laminar matroids, which generalize partition matroids, when there are three agents. Our technique reduces this general existence question to finding an EF1 allocation satisfying a mild additional condition under a single finite-sized key laminar matroid, and we establish the required allocation by case analysis. We show that our technique somewhat extends to four agents, reducing the analogous problem to finding EF1 allocations under two finite-sized laminar matroids, although we are unable to establish their existence. We also use recent matroid decomposition results to establish EF1 existence under broader classes of matroids. Specifically, we show that EF1 allocations always exist under transversal matroids whenever a complete allocation is feasible, and obtain existence results for graphic matroids and gammoids under stronger assumptions.

0.48

To EFX OR to MMS, That is the Question

cs.GT ·2026-08-11 ·Hadi Hosseini, Payas Khurana, Shraddha Pathak, Rohit Vaish
theory similarity 0.80
Abstract

We study the agent-wise disjunction of two central fairness notions for indivisible items, where every agent must be either envy-free up to any item (EFX) or maximin-share (MMS) satisfied. One might expect that having a flexible fairness requirement for individual agents will restore existence, especially because the existence of EFX itself resisted resolution for nearly a decade. Surprisingly, it does not. We construct counterexamples with three agents and eight submodular goods, and with three agents and seven submodular chores, significantly strengthening recent EFX impossibility results. On the positive side, we prove existence for additive mixed items with at most three valuation types when one type is a singleton. Additionally, we obtain polynomial-time approximation schemes for additive goods-only and chores-only instances. We also identify a clean separation between the disjunction and its constituents: For additive chores with two valuation types, EFX and MMS are both known to fail, whereas an EFX $\vee$ MMS allocation always exists. Finally, we show that identical additive valuations even admit the conjunction EFX $\wedge$ MMS for mixed items. Overall, our results show that allowing flexibility in choosing agent-specific fairness certificates expands the frontier of fair solutions while also uncovering surprising impossibilities.

0.32

Weighted Fair Division of Indivisible Mixed Manna

cs.GT ·2026-09-01 ·Nicholas Teh
similarity 0.79
Abstract

We study weighted fair division of indivisible mixed manna under additive valuations. First, we resolve the general existence open question for weighted envy-freeness up to one item (WEF1), and show that every instance with arbitrary positive entitlements admits a complete WEF1 allocation computable in polynomial time. We then show that existence does not imply any welfare guarantee, i.e., the utilitarian price of WEF1 is infinite, even for two unweighted agents with normalized valuations, common item signs, and singleton values in a fixed four-value set; a welfare-maximizing WEF1 allocation in the construction is fractionally Pareto optimal. Second, suppose each agent $i$ has a number $a_i>0$ such that their valuation for any item is $-a_i$, $0$, or $a_i$. Then, for arbitrary entitlements, a weighted maximin share (WMMS) allocation always exists, is computable in polynomial time, and can be chosen to be fractionally Pareto optimal. An exact formula for each WMMS value leads to a polynomial-time flow algorithm. In this class, every WEF1 allocation satisfies a best possible additive WMMS guarantee whose loss depends on the agent's entitlement relative to the largest entitlement. Thus maximum entitlement agents receive exact WMMS and, under equal entitlements, every WEF1 allocation is also MMS-fair. Allowing a second positive magnitude can violate exact WMMS, while unrestricted entitlement ratios rule out any fixed multiplicative WMMS guarantee compatible with WEF1 for chores.

0.44

Pareto Inefficiency of EFX

cs.GT ·2026-10-21 ·Sepideh Mahabadi, Prasanna Ramakrishnan, Jakub Tarnawski
similarity 0.78
Abstract

We consider the problem of allocating indivisible goods to agents with additive valuations, under two classic notions of fairness and efficiency: envy-freeness up to any good (EFX) and Pareto optimality. While some of the earliest work on EFX showed that Pareto optimal EFX allocations may not exist if agents can have zero value for some goods, it has remained open whether the same is true when all values are positive. We present a simple instance in which every good has positive value to every agent, but no Pareto optimal EFX allocation exists. We then generalize to a family of instances showing that Pareto optimal $α$-EFX allocations may not exist for any $α> 2/3$.

0.39

Revisiting the Fairness of Pure Nash Equilibria of Round-Robin

cs.GT ·2026-10-16 ·Georgios Amanatidis, Haris Aziz, Georgios Birmpas, Federico Fusco, Stefano Leonardi +1 more
theory similarity 0.76
Abstract · Corrects the claim in arXiv:2109.08644 (WINE 2021; Math. Oper. Res. 49(4), 2024) that every pure Nash equilibrium of Round-Robin is EF1. We …

We prove that for additive valuations, not every pure Nash equilibrium of the Round-Robin mechanism induces an allocation that is envy-free up to one good (EF1) with respect to the agents' true valuations. This corrects an earlier claim of Amanatidis et al. (WINE 2021; Math. Oper. Res. 2024). On the positive side, every pure Nash equilibrium of every fixed recursively balanced picking sequence mechanism induces an allocation that is $1/2$-EF1 and proportional up to one good (PROP1). We prove the approximate EF1 guarantee through a potential function comparing two executions, and the proportionality guarantee via a deviation that preserves the agent's most valuable goods. We also give a family of Round Robin equilibria showing that it is not possible to have a strictly better guarantee than $2/3$-EF1 for all equilibria.

0.06

Best-of-Both-Worlds Fair Division via Subsidies

cs.GT ·2026-10-10 ·Surya Panchapakesan, Rohit Vaish
theory similarity 0.76
Abstract · 16 pages in main body, 1 page appendix

We study the relationship between fair division with $\textit{subsidies}$ and $\textit{best-of-both-worlds}$ (BoBW) fairness for indivisible items. We prove a general reduction of BoBW existence to envy-freeability. Specifically, for any scale-free ex-post property $P$ (e.g., EF1, EFX, PO) and any scale-free valuation class $\mathcal{V}$ (e.g, additive, submodular, subadditive, monotone), if every instance in $\mathcal{V}$ admits a $P$-allocation that can be made envy-free using subsidies, then every such instance admits an ex-ante envy-free lottery supported on $P$-allocations. The proof uses linear programming duality. As applications, the reduction gives alternative proofs of BoBW existence results for additive goods, chores, and mixtures of goods and chores. The converse of our general reduction holds for two agents but fails for three: We provide a four-good counterexample with monotone submodular valuations where an ex-ante envy-free and ex-post EF1 lottery exists, but no allocation is simultaneously EF1 and envy-freeable. For lexicographic valuations, we prove simultaneous EFX, Pareto optimality, and envy-freeability (and hence BoBW guarantees for EFX+PO) for three agents, and show that even EFX and envy-freeability can be incompatible for four agents.

0.16

Almost Envy-Freeness for Additive Mixed Manna with Entitlements: Deterministic and Randomized Guarantees

cs.GT ·2026-09-02 ·Zehan Lin, Shengxin Liu, Biaoshuai Tao, Shengwei Zhou
hot direction similarity 0.76
Abstract

We investigate the fair allocation of indivisible items among agents with asymmetric entitlements in mixed manna settings, where the items consist of both goods and chores. For additive valuations, we establish that weighted envy-free up to one item (WEF1) allocations always exist and can be computed in polynomial time. We also study fair and efficient allocation and show that weighted envy-freeness up to one transfer (WEF1T) is compatible with fractional Pareto optimality (fPO) for every mixed-manna instance. This relaxation from WEF1 to WEF1T is tight, as demonstrated by our impossibility result. We further show a best-of-both-worlds result via a finite lottery that guarantees weighted envy-freeness (WEF) in expectation, with every realized allocation satisfying WEF1T and achieving the tight characterization complemented by the existing impossibility result.

0.43

Computing EF1 Allocations under Budget Constraints in Polynomial Time

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-11-09 ·Tingwei Hu, Lili Mei, Guochuan Zhang
similarity 0.76
Abstract

We study the fair allocation of indivisible items to agents with budget constraints and additive valuations. Each agent compares its own bundle with the subsets of another bundle that fit its budget. An allocation is envy-free up to one item (EF1) if, for every agent and every nonempty subset under comparison, removing an item of maximum value to that agent eliminates its envy. We require EF1 both between agents and towards the charity, which contains all unallocated items. EF1 allocations exist, but computing them in polynomial time has remained open even for homogeneous valuations. We resolve this problem with a polynomial-time algorithm for EF1 allocations under heterogeneous valuations. We also prove that detecting an EF1 violation is NP-complete. Equivalently, checking whether a given allocation is EF1 is coNP-complete. Finally, we give polynomial-time algorithms for envy-freeness up to any item (EFX) both when each agent's valuation is proportional to item size and when each agent has a fixed number of distinct positive item values. As an application, for homogeneous valuations and any $\varepsilon>0$, we obtain an EF1 allocation with at least a $(1/2-\varepsilon)$ fraction of the maximum social welfare in time polynomial in the input length and $1/\varepsilon$.

0.04