CS Paper Radar

Weighted First-Order Model Counting over Ordered Domains

Jan Tóth, Qipeng Kuang, Kuncheng Zou, Václav Kůla, Yuyi Wang, Yuanhong Wang, Ondřej Kuželka

cs.LO ·submitted 2026-08-11 12:54 UTC · v1

Abstract

The Weighted First-Order Model Counting Problem (WFOMC) asks for the weighted sum of models of a first-order logical sentence over a domain. It is a fundamental problem in statistical relational learning, with applications extending to enumerative combinatorics and graph polynomials. Computing WFOMC for the three-variable fragment is $\mathsf{\#P}_1$-hard, whereas polynomial-time algorithms exist for the two-variable fragment and its extensions by cardinality constraints and counting quantifiers. In this work, we explore computing WFOMC in polynomial time over linearly ordered domains, enabling tractable reasoning across inference scenarios and combinatorial problems involving sequences. Because encoding a linear order in standard first-order logic requires three variables, negating our polynomial-time aspirations, we add a linear order axiom directly to the language. This forces one predicate to impose a total ordering on domain elements. We first prove that WFOMC with the linear order axiom can be solved in time polynomial in the domain size. We then extend this result to ordered domains with access to successor relations. While this holds when successors are explicitly defined via the linear order, we demonstrate an alternative implicit approach where successor relations are part of the axiom. This implicit method exhibits significantly better performance on all tested instances, sometimes providing exponential runtime improvements. Finally, we analyze scenarios with two distinct linear orders. We show that WFOMC over the two-variable fragment with two linear orders is $\mathsf{\#P}_1$-hard. However, we develop a polynomial-time algorithm for WFOMC with one linear order and a successor relation of another, pushing the intractability barrier further, yet still leaving the question of how close to a second full linear order one can get.

Comment
Submitted to JAIR

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Unary Functions, Automorphisms, and Unlabeled First-Order Model Counting

cs.LO cs.DM ·2026-08-31 ·Ondřej Kuželka
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · fixed typos, 61 pages

Every fixed first-order sentence $\varphi$ determines an enumerative sequence $n\mapsto \mathrm{FOMC}(\varphi,n)$, counting its models on the labeled domain $[n]$. We study the complexity of these sequences when logical specifications may use genuine unary function symbols and hence nested terms such as $x,f(x),f^2(x),\ldots$. We prove that, for every fixed sentence $\varphi\in \mathrm{C}^1_{=}[f]$ with one unary function and an arbitrary finite relational vocabulary, $\mathrm{FOMC}(\varphi,n)$ is computable in time polynomial in $n$. By contrast, either a second variable or a second unary function yields hardness: there is a fixed sentence in $\mathrm{FO}^2_{=}[f]$ whose model-counting function is $\#\mathrm{P}_1$-complete, and there is a fixed constant-free universal sentence in $\mathrm{FO}^1_{=}[f,g]$, using only unary predicates besides $f$ and $g$, with the same property. We also relate labeled and unlabeled enumeration exactly. For every relational sentence $\varphi$, we construct an extension $\varphi_{\mathrm{aut}}$ in which a unary function records an automorphism and $\mathrm{FOMC}(\varphi_{\mathrm{aut}},n)=n! \cdot \mathrm{UFOMC}(\varphi,n)$, where $\mathrm{UFOMC}(\varphi,n)$ counts the $n$-element models of $\varphi$ up to isomorphism. This gives a one-query exact reduction from unlabeled to labeled model counting at the same domain size. If $\varphi$ belongs to $\mathrm{FO}^k_{=}$, respectively $\mathrm{C}^k$, and its relational vocabulary has maximum arity $r$, eliminating the auxiliary function yields a single-query reduction to labeled model counting in $\mathrm{FO}^{\max\{k,r+1\}}_{=}$, respectively $\mathrm{C}^{\max\{k,r+1\}}$.

0.19

A Fine-Grained Dichotomy for Bounded-Variable Query Evaluation: The Calculus of Relations, a Boolean Modal Logic, and One-Variable Counting Logic

cs.DB cs.CCcs.LO ·2026-10-03 ·Yoshiki Nakamura, Yuya Uezato
publishedtheory similarity 0.64
Abstract · Long version of PODS'27 paper

We study the fine-grained complexity of evaluating Boolean bounded-variable first-order queries over sparse relational structures. For every fixed $k \ge 2$, every relational signature, and every fragment between $k$-variable primitive positive ($\mathrm{PP}^{k}$) and first-order ($\mathrm{FO}^{k}$) logic, we prove, assuming the Sparse MAX-$3$-SAT hypothesis, a dichotomy theorem for evaluation in $O(m^{k-\varepsilon})$ time, where $m$ is the number of tuples in the input structure. The only tractable cases fall into three families: (1) three-variable fragments, (2) two-variable fragments, and (3) fragments over unary signatures. On the hard side, for every fixed $k \ge 4$ and every $\varepsilon > 0$, there is a fixed sentence $\varphi_\varepsilon$ in $\mathrm{PP}^{k}$ over a single binary relation symbol, depending on $\varepsilon$ but not on the input structure, whose evaluation cannot be performed in $O(m^{k-\varepsilon})$ time. For the tractable cases, we show that the evaluation problem can be solved in $2^{O(|\varphi|)} \cdot m^{k-\varepsilon}$ time for some $\varepsilon > 0$. Moreover, every tractable fragment reduces, with a $2^{O(|\varphi|)}$ blowup in formula size under DAG representations, to one of the following query languages: (1) Tarski's calculus of relations, (2) a new Boolean modal logic for sparse model checking, and (3) one-variable counting logic.

0.29

Deciding two-variable logic with global and local Presburger quantification

cs.LO math.LO ·2026-10-29 ·Michael Benedikt, Chia-Hsuan Lu, Alex Perry, Tony Tan
similarity 0.63
Abstract

We look at a two-variable logic over finite graphs that allows Presburger quantifiers: linear arithmetic inequalities between the number of elements that satisfy subformulas. The prior literature shows that closing two-variable logic under Presburger quantification leads to undecidability, while closing under \emph{local quantification} -- the counts are always over neighbors of a given node -- preserves decidability. Here we show decidability of satisfiability for an intermediate logic that allows both local counts and global counts, but where the linear constraints do not mix the two. The proof requires a significant extension of the prior machinery developed for two-variable logic with counting. As a corollary we obtain decidability of satisfiability for an important family of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs). GNNs are a popular graph learning formalism. For example, in a variation of GNNs considered in the past literature, local aggregation is used in each layer to create modified values at each vertex of a graph, and then global aggregation is used in a final layer to obtain a single numerical value for the graph as a whole. Our logic is motivated by the fact that mixing of local counting and global aggregation in GNNs has been shown to lead to undecidability. Our results here show that if global and local aggregation are separated, one regains decidability. Decidability of other static analysis problems, like equivalence of GNNs, follows from the decidability of satisfiability.

0.23

Counting on Nowhere Dense Classes

cs.LO ·2026-09-16 ·Steffen van Bergerem, Nicole Schweikardt
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 22 pages

For every effectively nowhere dense class $\mathcal{C}$ of relational structures, we present an algorithm that runs an almost-linear-time preprocessing step on a given structure $\mathcal{A} \in \mathcal{C}$ and a first-order formula $φ(x_1, \dots, x_k, y_1, \dots, y_\ell)$. After the preprocessing, whenever given a tuple $\bar{v} \in A^k$, the algorithm computes the number of tuples $\bar{w} \in A^\ell$ that satisfy $\mathcal{A} \models φ(\bar{v}, \bar{w})$ in constant time. Building on this, we provide an algorithm for constant-time query answering and constant-delay enumeration after almost-linear-time preprocessing for the recently introduced logic clique-guarded first-order logic with counting (cgFOC) on effectively nowhere dense classes. This generalises the testing and enumeration results for first-order logic [Schweikardt, Segoufin, and Vigny, JACM 2022] and the evaluation result for the first-order logic with counting FOC1 [Grohe and Schweikardt, PODS 2018] on nowhere dense classes.

0.32

Query-Driven Learning for Lifted Reasoning

cs.AI ·2026-10-26 ·Luise Ge, Brendan Juba
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Learning and reasoning are both essential to intelligent agents, but have traditionally been treated as two separate stages: first learning a knowledge base from data (or taking one as given), and then verifying queries as if the knowledge base were complete. This separation has been shown to be inefficient when the downstream goal is to verify only a small set of queries. Moreover, it neglects the possibility that data and a knowledge base contain partial yet complementary information, requiring an agent to combine both sources to justify or refute a query. Motivated by the need to integrate learning and reasoning more tightly, we study the problem of query-driven learning for reasoning. More specifically, we extend prior work to the first-order setting, which is critical for practical applications as the number of ground atoms typically grows rapidly. We begin by asking when validating or refuting a universal query given partial data and knowledge base is even possible, and identify a necessary and sufficient condition called bounded concealment. We then propose a quasi-polynomial-time algorithm that solves the task at the lifted level. Finally, we establish soundness and completeness guarantees relative to space-bounded lifted proofs, along with quasipolynomial sample and runtime bounds, demonstrating that lifted query-driven reasoning can be efficient even when unrestricted knowledge-base learning is not.

0.28

The Canonical Order Problem: When Large Language Models Are Unreliable Knowledge Bases for Multi-Valued Relations

cs.CL ·2026-09-28 ·Timo Pierre Schrader, Annemarie Friedrich, Simon Razniewski, Lukas Lange
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted at AKBC@EMNLP2026

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as knowledge bases (KBs) due to the vast amount of knowledge they acquire during pre-training. While many works focus on extracting single relational triples, most real-world relations are multi-valued and require generating sets of entities. In this paper, we investigate how LLMs represent and generate multi-valued relations. We identify the canonical order problem: The probabilistic distributions inside LLMs organize many multi-valued relations according to a canonical ordering (e.g., alphabetical or chronological). Through mechanistic analysis, we show that set generation in LLMs can be thought of in terms of three phases: (1) retrieval of candidate entities, (2) internal sorting, and (3) selection of the next element. As a result, prompts aiming to construct KBs that deviate from this internal canonical ordering lead to a markedly reduced reliability of LLMs when aiming to generate complete sets for multi-valued relations.

0.35

A Catalogue of Properties of Binary Relations: Entailments, Incompatibilities, and Independence Results

cs.LO math.LO ·2026-09-10 ·Magnus Boman
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 17 pages, 1 figure, 1 table

We study fifteen properties of binary relations that have established uses in modal logic, order and preference theory, and relation algebra. The organising question is pragmatic: once some properties of a relation are known, which further properties follow, which combinations force degeneracy, and which properties remain independent? We give a proved Horn basis of elementary and compound entailments, explicit countermodels for non-entailments, and a relation-algebraic translation of all fifteen properties. The modal discussion includes the usual Scott--Lemmon correspondences and the logic of transitive dense frames studied by Ghilardi and Mints. Exhaustive finite enumeration and targeted model search are used for discovery, while the catalogue is certified in Lean. A kernel-checked coverage calculation ranges over all 2^15 = 32,768 antecedent sets and all fifteen possible consequents. Its 51-rule Horn manifest is coupled definitionally to Lean proofs of semantic soundness, and its 49 witness rows are coupled definitionally to Lean-certified finite or infinite relations. Consequently, over non-empty domains, the Horn closure is complete for positive entailment among the fifteen selected properties, and the consistency classification is complete for their positive combinations.

0.26

First-Order Model Checking on Monadically Dependent Graph Classes

cs.LO cs.DMcs.DSmath.CO+1 ·2026-11-05 ·Jan Dreier, Nikolas Mählmann, Szymon Toruńczyk
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Monadically dependent graph classes are those in which first-order logic cannot encode all graphs. They include all nowhere dense classes and all classes of bounded twin-width. We show that first-order model checking is fixed-parameter tractable on every monadically dependent graph class. Together with the known hardness result for hereditary classes that are not monadically dependent, this gives a complete characterization of the hereditary graph classes with fixed-parameter tractable first-order model checking. This resolves a central open problem in algorithmic model theory. Our proof combines ideas from structural graph theory (graph decompositions), finite model theory (locality of first-order logic), and model theory (counting types). In particular, we show that in monadically dependent classes, tuples of fixed length have only $|U|^{O(1)}$ types of fixed quantifier rank over any set of parameters $U$.

0.18