CS Paper Radar

Player Perceptions of Generative AI in Games: A Steam Review Analysis

Mahsa Bazzaz, Seth Cooper

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-08-12 01:05 UTC · v1
publishedposition

Abstract

The rapid adoption of generative AI in game development has created large discussions among players, yet little empirical work has examined how players actually perceive AI-generated content. Employing quantitative methods, we study the adoption of generative AI in games in the Steam marketplace, using procedural content generation (PCG) as a baseline of a generative technology that was successfully integrated into games over several decades. Furthermore, using qualitative methods, we study player reception of generative AI by analyzing 508,192 English-language reviews. We found that games disclosing generative AI use receive lower recommendation rates and more negative overall sentiment than PCG games. Thematic analysis of 600 reviews shows that players perceive the use of generative AI in games as low developer investment in the game. Drawing on human-centered AI frameworks, we argue that successful generative AI adoption requires deploying generative AI for what players need, not for what makes development cheaper.

DOI
10.1145/3831347

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Association between Player Perception and AI Disclosure on Steam: An Exploratory Study

cs.IR cs.HC ·2026-10-19 ·Fabian Wiesinger, Johanna Pirker, Denis Helic
published similarity 0.74
Abstract

The use of generative AI in game development is growing rapidly and is the subject of intense debate in which player reactions play a central role. This paper contributes to this discussion by analyzing Steam reviews to examine whether games with AI disclosure are associated with different review patterns. Using a dataset across multiple disclosure groups, we apply linguistic analysis including keyword-based, word frequency, and characteristic word analysis to investigate the AI-related discussion on Steam. Our results show that AI-disclosed games are associated with higher levels of AI-related criticism in negative reviews. Our findings provide a first exploratory step towards understanding how players perceive AI disclosure.

0.20

Deciphering the Babel of Play: A Human-AI Collaborative Approach for Large-Scale Cross-Language Analysis of Game Reviews

cs.HC ·2026-09-19 ·Zixiaofan Yang, Chang Xiao
similarity 0.69
Abstract

We present a large-scale cross-language analysis of game reviews using a human-AI collaborative framework that combines quantitative screening with multilingual large language models (LLMs). Starting from 17 million Steam reviews across 30 languages and 2,000 top-selling titles, we select 28 games with notable cross-language rating patterns. We then apply LLM-assisted content analysis to 442,162 reviews spanning 17 languages, with human researchers guiding codebook development and interpreting the results. Our findings reveal differences in both the aspects language communities prioritize and how they evaluate them, highlighting the roles of narrative expectations, game mechanics and stability, localization quality, cultural proximity, and perceptions of developers and publishers. We also identify rare cases of cross-language consensus. This work offers empirical insights into cross-cultural game evaluation and a scalable methodological approach to multilingual content analysis that preserves human interpretation.

0.21

"Pharos Night: Crown Pursuit": An AI-Native Deck-Building and Tactical Arena Game Design Based on Multi-Agent Systems

cs.HC ·2026-08-12 ·Ting-Chen Hsu, Jueyao Liu, Yanzi Zhou, Jiangxu Lin, Haoyu Xu +3 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted to 2026 Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play (CHI Play)

With advancements in generative AI technology, an increasing number of researchers have begun exploring AI-native games in which gameplay rules are directly driven by generative AI. This paper presents "Pharos Night: Crown Pursuit," an AI-native deck-building and tactical arena game based on a multi-agent system. The game uses large language models to generate materials and cards, support NPC decision-making, and mediate natural-language interactions. During play, players collect materials, describe desired card effects in natural language, and choose whether to negotiate or fight with NPCs in the arena. To constrain model-generated outcomes, the system parses responses as structured JSON, constructs card effects from predefined mechanics, and maps qualitative effect levels to designer-specified numerical values. A small-scale playtest with 13 participants suggests that the system can provide strategically meaningful and engaging AI-driven gameplay, while also revealing challenges related to predictability, transparency, and player control. This work demonstrates the potential of multi-agent generative AI systems for creating more emergent digital game experiences.

0.15

Recursive Game Creator: An Agentic Product-Level Experience-Oriented Game Harness

cs.AI cs.MAcs.SE ·2026-10-06 ·Jiajun Chen, Haoyu Wu, Mingda Jia, Xihui Liu
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · Project page: https://imbaldy.github.io/recursive-game-creator/ ; Code: https://github.com/IMBALDY/RecursiveGameCreator

Recent game design agents have made substantial progress in generating playable games. However, program correctness does not ensure an enjoyable experience for players. We present Recursive Game Creator, an experience-oriented harness to advance agentic game development from rough game prototypes into entertaining games. Recursive Game Creator organizes recursive development around four components: Designer, Builder, Player, and Reviewer. The Designer translates user instructions and Reviewer's feedback into detailed plans. The Builder turns these plans into candidate games. The coding-native Player creates and executes reusable policies through programmatic interfaces to efficiently collect diverse gameplay trajectories, mitigating evaluation bias caused by slow GUI-based collection. The Reviewer uses carefully designed trajectory-based metrics to induce player preferences, integrating with visual evidence and explicit textual preferences to evaluate games against game-specific criteria. Finally, the Reviewer accepts the better version and provides improvement reviews for the next round, closing the recursive loop. Our method achieves state-of-the-art overall performance of 77.89 on GameCraft-Bench. On GameASG-Bench, it achieves a strict task success rate of 53.2%, a 34.1% improvement over the same-model baseline, and the highest mean runtime-check pass rate at 93.4% among compared methods. A user study shows longer playtime and higher ratings. Project page is at: https://imbaldy.github.io/recursive-game-creator/.

0.53

GameCommBench: A Unified Benchmark and Type-Aware Evaluation for AI-Generated Game Commentary

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-10-08 ·Qirui Zheng, Zhengteng Lin, Yunyi Xiao, Junhao Li, Keyuan Cheng +5 more
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Game commentary is an open-ended generation task requiring multimodal perception, strategic reasoning, and contextual knowledge. Existing AI-Generated Game Commentary (AI-GGC) studies remain fragmented across games, modalities, and evaluation protocols, while overlap-based or holistic evaluators fail to capture the functional heterogeneity of commentary. We introduce \textsc{GameCommBench}, a unified benchmark spanning board games, sports, and esports, with commentary aligned to heterogeneous game contexts and annotated by commentary type. We further propose Type-Aware Commentary Evaluation (TACE), a structured framework for evaluating different types of commentary. We then validate TACE for reliability and human agreement, and use it to benchmark representative AI commentators. Results reveal non-uniform capability profiles, with live observation and strategic analysis emerging as major bottlenecks. Together, \textsc{GameCommBench} and TACE provide a diagnostic foundation for comparable and interpretable AI-GGC evaluation.

0.16

PREFER: From Player Experience to Personalized Game Refinement

cs.AI ·2026-10-13 ·Qi Chai, Zhang Zheng, Lu Yang, Zixun Sun, Hao Wang
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

Understanding how large language models (LLMs) evaluate gameplay experience is important for using their feedback to guide game design. However, overall ratings alone provide limited insight into which aspects of experience are associated with these judgments and how they can inform concrete game changes. We introduce PREFER, a framework that uses a shared set of experience dimensions adapted from established psychometric questionnaires to benchmark how models evaluate gameplay and to guide persona-specific game refinement. Through these dimensions, we characterize the perspectives models offer as virtual playtesters by examining how their overall assessments relate to specific aspects of experience and to the gameplay they produce. To examine how the same dimensions can guide refinement for players with different preferences, we use personas to simulate distinct player profiles. For each persona, PREFER uses experience-preference relationships to select refinement objectives, revises game rules and their implementations, and playtests candidate games to assess experience changes and predicted preference gains. Experiments with five personas show that PREFER achieves 9.2% higher mean post-play preference ratings than the strongest evaluated baseline.

0.20

Designing the Future of User Feedback for Generative AI

cs.AI ·2026-10-02 ·Alisa Frik, Julia Bernd, Amitis Karami, Mohammad Tahaei
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

Post-deployment feedback from users can be a cost-effective, scalable, and representative means to monitor and improve generative AI systems and features. When implemented effectively, giving such feedback can increase users' engagement with and trust in GenAI systems. Government regulations and industry guidelines call for post-deployment user engagement, but there is little guidance on designing mechanisms that are usable for consumers and provide actionable input for product teams. We conducted a multi-phase study as a collaboration between academic researchers and eBay. Our benchmark evaluation of current industry approaches identified common issues including lack of discoverability, unclear terminology, and inattention to user value. Based on these findings, we developed best-practice recommendations and designed and tested a prototype feedback-collection tool. The tool aimed to provide users with an efficient, flexible, and positive feedback-giving experience, and provide product teams with rich data on performance and potential problems in a usable format.

0.21

Investigating the Impacts of Generative AI on Information Seeking

cs.HC cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-09-13 ·Alexi Orchard, Shannon Lodoen
published similarity 0.59
Abstract · 4 pages, accepted to CSCW Workshops 2026

This paper is an encore submission of our 2026 journal article "Expertise and Information Seeking in the Age of Generative AI: New Procedures, New Problematics" with an extended discussion for the CSCW 2026 "Broader Impacts of GenAI in Communication" Workshop on October 10, 2026. In the original article, we employ procedural rhetoric to analyze how generative AI chatbots leverage natural language signifiers of expertise and intelligence to influence users' perception of their trustworthiness. In this submission, we extend our conversation in the CSCW community with the goal of cultivating a cross-disciplinary vocabulary for describing, analyzing, and mitigating the risks posed by the integration of generative AI into human communication practices. It is important to develop an understanding of how the procedures surrounding information-seeking practices are informed by users' values, experiences, and expectations - and how these procedures might in future be altered by the emerging turn toward AI "experts" and authority.

0.28