CS Paper Radar

MuseCritic: Learning Multi-Aspect Song Rewards through Natural-Language Aesthetic Critiques

Jiabao Zhuang, Changhao Jiang, Hanchen Wang, Jiahao Chen, Zhixiong Yang, Zhenghao Xiang, Yifei Cao, Jiajun Sun, Hui Li, Ming Zhang, Tao Ji, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang

cs.SD cs.CL ·submitted 2026-08-12 07:49 UTC · v2
benchmarkcode/data

Abstract

Long-form song generation models continue to improve in duration, structural coherence, and acoustic complexity, increasing the need for reliable aesthetic rewards aligned with human preferences. However, reward models for complete songs remain limited, and existing evaluators typically predict scores in a single forward pass without readable explanations. To this end, we introduce MuseCritic, a semi-scalar reward model that generates a natural-language critique covering five aesthetic dimensions and uses it as an intermediate representation to predict continuous reward scores. MuseCritic follows a two-stage training pipeline: a teacher model first provides high-quality critiques for supervised fine-tuning, then the fine-tuned model generates its own critiques for reward learning, mitigating training-inference distribution shift. On an in-domain test set of 200 SongEval songs, MuseCritic reduces macro-averaged mean squared error from 0.2875 to 0.2316 and improves macro-averaged LCC, SRCC, and Kendall's tau to 0.9068, 0.8838, and 0.7178, respectively. On the out-of-domain Music Arena benchmark with 733 preference pairs, it achieves 71.35% accuracy and remains competitive with strong music-specific reward models. Using MuseCritic with GRPO also improves Muse-0.6B on all nine aesthetic metrics from SongEval and Audiobox Aesthetics. These results show that critique-conditioned reward modeling reduces scoring error and provides an effective optimization signal for song generation. The project repository is available at https://github.com/WuqnEl/MuseCritic.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Rubric-Based Optimization for Text-to-Music Generation

cs.SD ·2026-10-02 ·Ping Wang, Guang Yang, Shao-Rong Su, Junkai Wu, Pang Wei Koh +1 more
similarity 0.72
Abstract · 27 pages

Post-training text-to-music generation requires reward signals that capture multiple aspects of musical quality beyond what any single automatic metric can measure. We study structured, rubric-based rewards from pretrained audio-language models (ALMs) as training signals for both autoregressive and diffusion-based music generators. An ALM scores each generated clip against the rubric; we rank candidates generated for the same text prompt by their scores and convert these rankings into preference pairs for DPO on both MusicGen-small and ACE-Step v1, and additionally use the rubric scores directly as scalar rewards for DiffusionNFT on ACE-Step v1. On MusicCaps, rubric-based optimization improves CLAP, SongEval, and Audiobox-Aesthetics simultaneously, with the strongest gains obtained by DiffusionNFT on ACE-Step. By contrast, on MusicGen-small, building preferences from any one of these automatic evaluators produces clear cross-metric trade-offs: the targeted evaluator improves while other independent evaluators deteriorate. We further study tempo, key, and instrumentation, where precise objective rewards are available. Directly optimizing these specialized rewards reliably improves the target attributes, whereas ALM rubrics provide only partial transfer for tempo and instrumentation and no measurable improvement for key. Together, these results suggest a practical division of labor: ALM rubrics are effective for broad perceptual qualities that are difficult to formalize, while specialized objective rewards remain preferable when reliable measurements are available.

0.16

Unifying Score and Performance for Fine-Grained Music Understanding in Audio-Language Models

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-09-09 ·Milan Liessens Dujardin, Song-Ze Yu, Kevin Miao
benchmark similarity 0.72
Abstract

Large audio language models (LALMs) have shown promising progress in broad music-understanding tasks such as tagging, retrieval, and captioning. Music understanding that requires finer hearing over both the content and how it is realized within a performance through dynamics, phrasing, articulation, time, and other performance techniques, however, remains at an earlier stage. Existing audio-language model (ALM) training pipelines typically rely on coarse, weakly grounded captions and therefore provide little support for learning these subtle nuances in music, limiting their ability to serve real-world applications in education or artistic practice. We therefore introduce MuNo-SP (Music Notation unifying Score and Performance), a text-based representation that jointly encodes score content and performance information. Building on MuNo-SP, we develop an automatic training-data generation pipeline that uses aligned scores and performances to produce long-form auditory analyses and musically informed question-answer pairs. We use this pipeline to construct MAESTROCaps, a classical piano dataset comprising 148 long-form performance analyses and 31,080 question-answer pairs derived from 148 aligned score-performance pairs. In a human evaluation, MuNo-SP analyses were preferred by majority vote over MIDI-only analyses for eight of nine excerpts. MuNo-SP also performed strongly on a benchmark of score-performance understanding, suggesting that integrating score and performance information enables more reliable and musically informative LALM supervision than a MIDI-only baseline.

0.17

Does Notation Matter? MusicXML Tokenisation for Symbolic Music Generation and Understanding

cs.SD cs.LG ·2026-10-25 ·Andrea Poltronieri, Matteo Spanio, Simone Chieppa, Xavier Serra, Martín Rocamora
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 9 pages, 1 figure, 4 tables

Symbolic music representations encode musical content at varying levels of completeness, from performance-oriented formats such as MIDI to fully notated scores such as MusicXML. Yet the impact of this representational richness on deep learning models remains poorly understood. While tokenisation has been extensively studied for MIDI, score-based formats have received considerably less attention, and MusicXML in particular remains largely unexplored despite being the de-facto standard for score interchange. In this paper, we introduce the first general-purpose tokenisation framework for MusicXML, and conduct a systematic empirical study to determine whether notational richness confers a measurable advantage for deep learning on symbolic music. We train 26 autoregressive and masked language models, comparing MusicXML tokenisation against MIDI and ABC-based representations, probing the effect of different tokenisation strategies within MusicXML, and testing whether music-grammar-aware tokenisation outperforms treating scores as plain text. We evaluate music understanding tasks using linear probing across composer classification, difficulty estimation, and accompaniment suggestion, and generative tasks using objective statistical metrics and a human pairwise preference study. Our results show that MusicXML-tokenised models outperform MIDI and text-based counterparts on understanding and generative tasks.

0.34

PianoBench: Evaluating Musical Perception and Reasoning in Language Models

cs.SD cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-11-02 ·Louis Bradshaw, Irmak Bukey, Daniel Chenyu Lin, John Thickstun, Chris Donahue
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

Multimodal language models continue to improve on broad music understanding benchmarks, but which musical features can they perceive and reason about? We investigate this question by introducing PianoBench, a benchmark that tasks language models with reasoning about musical performances across congruent acoustic and symbolic input representations. PianoBench is derived from our new multimodal, training-scale dataset comprising more than 20,000 hours of interleaved transcripts of music and spoken musical commentary from instructional piano videos. Open-weight audio-language models achieve at most 52.8% accuracy on PianoBench, and at best only modestly outperform their accuracy on a no-audio control. In contrast, frontier models using chain of thought achieve up to 93.2% accuracy when provided transcripts of music as text, exposing a gap between perceiving musical features from audio and reasoning about musical events when they are given explicitly. We then test whether mid-training on interleaved musical instruction can improve question answering without chain of thought, raising Qwen 3.5 9B Base's zero-shot accuracy on PianoBench with music transcripts from 42.8% to 56.0% after instruction tuning. These experiments suggest that instructional videos may represent an overlooked source of multimodal supervision for music. Available: https://gclef-cmu.org/pianobench.

0.17

Do Music Generative Models Understand Musical Qualities? Automatic Music Evaluation with Model-Intrinsic Signals

cs.SD ·2026-09-29 ·Xiaosha Li, Chun Liu, Ziyu Wang
published similarity 0.69
Abstract · Accepted by the 27th International Society for Music Information Retrieval Conference (ISMIR 2026)

Current music generative models can produce high-quality music, but does this ability imply that they ``understand'' the musical qualities of their outputs, and is that understanding aligned with human evaluation? Previous attempts to use the likelihood of a generative model to evaluate music, an approach commonly used in text, have proven unsuccessful, leading researchers to rely on standalone supervised music evaluation models. In this paper, we answer this question affirmatively: we show that a model's intrinsic signals---derived from its hidden representations and predictions---are strongly correlated with human ratings. In particular, we study MusicGen and consider three types of features: (1) prediction loss, (2) prediction entropy, and (3) concepts extracted from the model using a sparse autoencoder (SAE). Using these features, we train a lightweight prediction model to estimate subjective ratings. We evaluate these features both individually and in combination. We hypothesize that these signals parallel the listening process: the temporal and frequency-domain structure of loss and entropy reflects listeners' expectation and surprise, while gradient directions in SAE latent space predict perceived quality. Experiments on five human-evaluation benchmarks spanning continuous ratings and pairwise preferences confirm this hypothesis, with SAE latents carrying most of the predictive signal.

0.49

Do Language Models Need Music Supervision? Verifiable Rewards for Multi-Constraint Symbolic Music Generation

cs.SD cs.AI ·2026-09-20 ·Haoyue Liu, Xiaoying Tang
benchmark similarity 0.68
Abstract

Language models can now generate symbolic music from natural-language instructions. However, existing models still struggle to satisfy multiple explicit musical constraints simultaneously. To systematically evaluate this capability, we introduce MusicConstraintBench, a benchmark of 2180 items spanning eight families of programmatically verifiable constraints. On this benchmark, Llama-3.1-70B satisfies 0.630 of single-constraint items but only 0.044 of four-constraint ones. To address this challenge, we propose MusicRLVR, which trains a language model with group relative policy optimisation (GRPO) on verifier rewards alone, needing no human annotation, reward model or music-domain supervised fine-tuning. MusicRLVR incorporates (1) a hard validation gate that rejects malformed scores, (2) graded per-family credit that, unlike a binary reward, separates partially correct outputs, and (3) an all-satisfied bonus for meeting every constraint at once. Extensive experiments show that, after 300 GRPO updates, MusicRLVR raises Qwen3-4B-Instruct-2507 from 0.160 to 0.807 on mixed constraints, outperforming Llama-3.1-70B, and generalises to unseen property combinations, out-of-range parameters and more constraints than any training prompt. The recipe transfers to Qwen3-8B, and neither trained model loses significant accuracy on general benchmarks.

0.23

How Well Do Generative Music Models Follow Emotion Conditioning?

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-08-30 ·Morteza Heydari
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 7 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables

Recent generative music models offer increasingly fine-grained control through text and audio conditioning, yet how faithfully they follow intended emotional cues remains an open question. We address this gap with a unified evaluation pipeline for emotion-following in generated music. Using all 1000 tracks in GTZAN, we extract semantic audio descriptions with DashengLM, an audio captioning model, and estimate source-track valence and arousal with Music2Emotion, a music emotion recognition model. We construct affect-aware text prompts by combining descriptions with top-ranked emotion tags and generate 30-second outputs with three systems, Stable Audio Open, MusicGen, and InspireMusic, evaluating both text- and audio-conditioned generation. To measure emotion-following, we compute valence and arousal on generated audio and compare them with the source tracks using absolute error and Euclidean distance in valence-arousal space. Text-conditioned generation consistently outperforms audio conditioning, with MusicGen (text) and InspireMusic (text) achieving the best performance, while audio-conditioned variants prove less stable. We further find that valence is preserved more reliably than arousal and that emotion-following varies substantially across genres. These findings underscore the importance of evaluating affective controllability directly rather than relying solely on general quality or prompt-relevance metrics.

0.22

Note-Level Temporal Grounding of Musical Concepts in Large Audio-Language Models

cs.SD cs.IR ·2026-08-30 ·Kun Fang, Ziyu Wang, Ichiro Fujinaga
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large audio-language models (LALMs) demonstrate growing music-understanding capabilities, but whether their responses are grounded in acoustic evidence remains unclear. Musical language often involves abstract concepts whose acoustic evidence is difficult to define and evaluate precisely. We introduce MusicGroundingBench, a controlled benchmark of algorithmically generated piano audio with exact symbolic alignment, comprising three-note and two-bar settings. We evaluate two complementary capabilities: grounding, which localizes the acoustic evidence for a musical query, and understanding, which answers questions about the same excerpts. Our experiments show that cross-modal fine-tuning enables models to learn each capability, but adding grounding supervision does not consistently improve understanding across backbones. We further test whether understanding requires listening through audio-ablation controls that remove or replace the input audio, and use attention analysis to examine whether grounding supervision shifts attention toward note boundaries. Meanwhile, the two evaluated LALMs show limited zero-shot grounding even for basic musical concepts, highlighting grounded music understanding as an important open challenge.

0.20