CS Paper Radar

Beyond Prompted Agreement: Instruction Effects on Key and Beat Grouping in Text-to-Music Generation

Yining Wang

cs.SD ·submitted 2026-08-12 10:25 UTC · v2

Abstract

In music-generation models, an explicit instruction to realize a musical attribute can paradoxically make it less common. How, then, should we assess whether a model follows a musical instruction? We use matched inputs that omit an attribute, specify one target, or specify another target, and compare the resulting audio. We evaluate key and beat grouping in ACE-Step 1.5, Stable Audio 3 and LeVo2 on 2,304 primary outputs. In Stable Audio 3, a four-beat instruction reduces detected four-beat occurrence from 96.9% to 56.3%, even though four beats remain more common than three under their respective instructions. Further experiments show that rephrasing can improve attainment while reducing the difference between target instructions, and that ACE-Step shows larger changes in target occurrence when text instructions retain its native attribute field. Our findings suggest that evaluating musical instruction following requires both target attainment and comparisons with generation with an omitted target instruction and with a different specified target.

Comment
18 pages, 3 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From One-Shot Generation to Incremental Music Composition: Adapting a General-Purpose Instruction LLM for Persistent Symbolic Editing

cs.AI cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·André Ricardo Ducca Fernandes, Jean-Pierre Briot, Simone Diniz Junqueira Barbosa1, Hélio Côrtes Vieira Lopes
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Most music-generation systems are still framed and evaluated primarily as producers of complete outputs, whereas composition often proceeds through successive revisions to a shared musical artifact. This paper studies a different use of a general-purpose instruction-following large language model: not as a one-shot music generator, but as a reusable operator over an evolving symbolic score. We formulate incremental composition as a sequence of operation-aware state transitions over persistent ABC notation, with explicit requirements on what each operation may change and what it must preserve. The interaction includes two artifact-initialization variants and three editing operations -- chord addition, inpainting, and transposition. We instantiate the formulation by adapting Llama 3.1 8B Instruct with Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) on 496,038 operation-aware dialogue records derived from Irish traditional music. The comparison with the unadapted model is used to test the feasibility of learning this interaction contract, not to claim novelty for fine-tuning itself. Across 500 dialogues per model (1,750 attempted output states), checker admission rises from 29.37% to 99.37%, while compliance conditional on admission rises from 0.7205 to 0.9798. Strict eligibility for reference-relative musical-feature analysis increases from 14 to 1,548 outputs, and Longest Common Subsequence analysis does not show a systematic increase in high-overlap sequences relative to held-out baselines under the specified protocol. The results support the technical feasibility of persistent, operation-aware symbolic editing with a general-purpose instruction LLM. They do not establish superior musical quality or human-AI co-creativity, which remain questions for musician-centered evaluation.

0.12

ProCraft: Instruction-Driven Music Production from Free-Form Text

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-11-05 ·Yuan-Chiao Cheng, Yi-Hsuan Yang, Vincent K. M. Cheung
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 27 pages, 6 figures, 11 tables

Music production typically involves multiple editing operations that each require specialized tools and expertise. Existing text-guided music editing systems support few operations or instruments, operate on short clips, or handle only one operation per instruction, unlike real workflows where several changes are requested at once. Here, we present ProCraft, a lightweight 0.5B-parameter autoregressive codec language model that edits 30s music excerpts end-to-end from free-form instructions, including compound requests. ProCraft supports seven operations across eight instruments, from tasks with a unique target (e.g., track removal) to creative ones (e.g., accompaniment generation). We align intermediate representations with pretrained music embeddings and pitch and instrument targets to preserve content outside the edit, and gated cross-attention in every decoder layer to keep generation tied to the instruction. To train on compound requests, we introduce On-the-fly Editing-pair Synthesis, which generates paired instructions and audio combining track-level operations with effect changes. ProCraft performs competitively against task-specific systems on single-task editing, and outperforms four free-text editors on compound instructions for track removal, extraction and denoising on real (MoisesDB) and synthetic (Slakh) recordings. In a user study (16 listeners), ProCraft was rated highest on removal and denoising and on-par with a 16-times larger model on extraction and instrument transfer. Ablations further show that representation alignment and cross-attention reduce leakage from unwanted tracks and raise editing success rates, especially on out-of-domain data.

0.11

Note-Level Temporal Grounding of Musical Concepts in Large Audio-Language Models

cs.SD cs.IR ·2026-08-30 ·Kun Fang, Ziyu Wang, Ichiro Fujinaga
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

Large audio-language models (LALMs) demonstrate growing music-understanding capabilities, but whether their responses are grounded in acoustic evidence remains unclear. Musical language often involves abstract concepts whose acoustic evidence is difficult to define and evaluate precisely. We introduce MusicGroundingBench, a controlled benchmark of algorithmically generated piano audio with exact symbolic alignment, comprising three-note and two-bar settings. We evaluate two complementary capabilities: grounding, which localizes the acoustic evidence for a musical query, and understanding, which answers questions about the same excerpts. Our experiments show that cross-modal fine-tuning enables models to learn each capability, but adding grounding supervision does not consistently improve understanding across backbones. We further test whether understanding requires listening through audio-ablation controls that remove or replace the input audio, and use attention analysis to examine whether grounding supervision shifts attention toward note boundaries. Meanwhile, the two evaluated LALMs show limited zero-shot grounding even for basic musical concepts, highlighting grounded music understanding as an important open challenge.

0.20

SMEBENCH: Benchmarking Neural Music Editing with Synthetized MIDI Edits

cs.SD cs.LGeess.AS ·2026-10-27 ·Matthieu Cervera, Francesco Paissan, Micael Antunes, Mirco Ravanelli, Ricard Marxer +1 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract

Neural music editing requires a system to perform a requested change while preserving the musical content that should remain unchanged. Existing evaluations often lack a paired target edit, making these requirements difficult to measure separately. We introduce SMEBench, a large-scale benchmark of controlled music edits constructed by modifying symbolic MIDI performances and rendering matched source and target audio. Each example contains a source, an instruction, a paired target, edit metadata, and complementary descriptions. The benchmark covers twelve instrumentation, articulation, dynamics, and pitch operations and includes a balanced 3,600-example test set together with a smaller real-audio complement derived from multitrack recordings. The paired targets allow source preservation, target agreement, and textual compatibility to be evaluated independently. We use these references to diagnose common audio-editing metrics and benchmark six representative editing systems, showing that the metric used to rank a system can materially change the conclusion. The dataset is available at our repository.

0.24

Reference-Free Singing Pitch Correction via Music-Constrained Sequence Editing

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-10-08 ·Biao Dong, Jiajun Li, Binzhen Zhu, Mingwei Yi, Tong Liu +3 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Existing singing pitch correction approaches rely on target melodies or accompaniment tracks, which may be unavailable in practice. We formulate reference-free singing pitch correction as a music-constrained sequence editing task that determines whether and how each note should be corrected from the input performance alone. A pretrained symbolic music encoder with lightweight singing-domain adapters produces contextual representations of the singing MIDI. Based on these representations, two lightweight correction heads jointly model correction necessity and signed pitch modification through a factorized pitch-editing distribution. An input-dependent tonal prior derived from the estimated key distribution then reranks the candidate offsets, favoring tonally compatible corrections without target melodies or ground-truth key annotations. Experiments on real paired amateur and professional singing recordings show that the method improves note-level pitch accuracy from 73.25 to 83.43, outperforming a context-based baseline by 3.99 percentage points while balancing error correction and preservation of correctly performed notes.

0.20

TTM-Bench: A Framework for Text-to-Music System Performance Benchmarking

cs.SD cs.LGcs.MMeess.AS ·2026-09-16 ·Giorgia Adorni, Michela Papandrea, Battista Rimoldi, Tiziano Leidi
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Text-to-music (TTM) systems are increasingly used to generate musical audio from natural-language descriptions. Robust evaluation is therefore essential, yet reliable performance comparison remains challenging. This difficulty stems from differences in system architecture, supported conditioning information, and access mode, as well as heterogeneous and fragmented metrics that cannot be applied uniformly across systems. To address these challenges, we introduce TTM-Bench, a framework that defines a common protocol for systematic, reproducible performance benchmarking of contemporary TTM systems. It evaluates performance along two dimensions: musical-content alignment, quantified by interpretable semantic, genre, and musical-descriptor agreement scores against a common musical specification and summarized by an aggregate score; and computational efficiency, characterized by generation latency and real-time factor, alongside resource use for local models and cost for hosted services. We demonstrate the framework through a preliminary comparative case study, illustrating the complementary evidence captured by these dimensions. The results show that higher musical-content alignment does not systematically coincide with lower computational demands, highlighting the importance of assessing TTM performance through distinct, interpretable measures rather than a reductive overall indicator.

0.22

Unifying Score and Performance for Fine-Grained Music Understanding in Audio-Language Models

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-09-09 ·Milan Liessens Dujardin, Song-Ze Yu, Kevin Miao
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

Large audio language models (LALMs) have shown promising progress in broad music-understanding tasks such as tagging, retrieval, and captioning. Music understanding that requires finer hearing over both the content and how it is realized within a performance through dynamics, phrasing, articulation, time, and other performance techniques, however, remains at an earlier stage. Existing audio-language model (ALM) training pipelines typically rely on coarse, weakly grounded captions and therefore provide little support for learning these subtle nuances in music, limiting their ability to serve real-world applications in education or artistic practice. We therefore introduce MuNo-SP (Music Notation unifying Score and Performance), a text-based representation that jointly encodes score content and performance information. Building on MuNo-SP, we develop an automatic training-data generation pipeline that uses aligned scores and performances to produce long-form auditory analyses and musically informed question-answer pairs. We use this pipeline to construct MAESTROCaps, a classical piano dataset comprising 148 long-form performance analyses and 31,080 question-answer pairs derived from 148 aligned score-performance pairs. In a human evaluation, MuNo-SP analyses were preferred by majority vote over MIDI-only analyses for eight of nine excerpts. MuNo-SP also performed strongly on a benchmark of score-performance understanding, suggesting that integrating score and performance information enables more reliable and musically informative LALM supervision than a MIDI-only baseline.

0.17

MuLaCover: Flexible Cover Song Generation via Symbolic Tonal Control

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-10-19 ·Lynn Yi, Zihan Xiong, Junjie Cao, Xiaolong Weng, Yingzhe Ma +15 more
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract

A cover song re-renders an existing piece, most commonly by preserving its tonal content -- melody and chord progression -- while reshaping other musical attributes. This suggests a natural formulation for generative cover synthesis with pretrained music language models: explicitly control tonal content, while specifying lyrics and style through text. Existing approaches condition on frame-level features, tightly coupling generation to the reference's timing and structure, and limiting flexibility such as tempo variation, structural rearrangement, or partial conditioning. To this end, we present MuLaCover, a cover generation model that conditions a pretrained text-to-song foundation model on an editable symbolic lead sheet. Our design enables alignment-free control: generated outputs preserve the tonal signature of the source without frame-level alignment, allowing flexible timing, structure, and segment-level generation. We further introduce a training curriculum with partially mismatched audio-symbolic pairs, improving diversity and robustness. We evaluate MuLaCover with objective metrics, standard subjective ratings, and in-depth expert interviews that provide fine-grained diagnostic insights. Experiments show that MuLaCover achieves state-of-the-art performance among open-source systems and is competitive with leading commercial models such as Suno-v5.5. Audio samples and code are available at our project page: https://mulalabs.ai/mulacover/

0.23