CS Paper Radar

Whose Posts Get Ranked: Identical-Text Exposure Gaps in Bluesky Custom Feeds

Yipeng Wang, Mohit Singhal

cs.SI cs.IR ·submitted 2026-08-14 02:08 UTC · v1
top venue

Abstract

Bluesky lets users deploy custom feeds, independently operated recommendation algorithms that the platform serves alongside thousands of others. This paper investigates how evenly these feeds treat posts with the same text. To measure this, we take repeated snapshots of the Top-50 lists that 1,366 public feeds return, and we group posts with identical text, from different authors, that were created before the same list response and closely matched in age. Exposure diverges widely inside these matched sets, which span 250 feeds: in 33% of sets, one copy appears on the list while another does not. Fixed-effects regressions show that this divergence is associated with the author's history on the specific feed. Authors new to a feed receive less exposure for the same text (-0.061 in reciprocal-rank weight), while authors whose posts the feed has returned before receive more. A new author with more followers than the competing author still loses 74\% of head-to-head comparisons. Media and post-type features show no detectable association after multiple-comparison correction. These results are early evidence that access to many independent feeds is not enough to give identical texts equal exposure.

Comment
To appear at The 20th ACM Recommender Systems Conference (RecSys 2026), please cite accordingly
DOI
10.1145/3773078.3841250

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Predicting Custom-Feed Returns for New Bluesky Posts: A Prospective Study

cs.IR cs.CY ·2026-08-14 ·Yipeng Wang, Mohit Singhal
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract · To appear at The 20th ACM Recommender Systems Conference (RecSys 2026), please cite accordingly

The conventional approach to cold-start recommendation addresses new users or newly introduced items. Bluesky custom feeds create a different setting: independently operated feeds filter content from a shared public stream. In this setting, newly published posts are the cold-start objects, while the feeds serve as candidates. We propose a cold-start routing task in which a newly ingested public post is the query and all rankable feeds in the monitored panel are ranked according to whether each will subsequently return it. We build a still-evolving collect-first, label-later benchmark dataset. The collected dataset covers a fixed panel of 5,000 monitored feeds and contains 17.804 million public posts, 1.865 million observable post--feed return records, and 625,083 valid feed polls. The labels record whether a post is observed among a feed's AppView Top-50 results in at least one poll during the 24 hours after publication. The current experiments use two disjoint 24-hour test folds, each paired with a 24-hour training window and separated by a 24-hour outcome-availability gap. Evaluation is conditional on the 602,186 test posts that have at least one positive observed label and satisfy the metric eligibility criteria; these posts account for 9.04% of all 6,661,658 test posts. Across the two folds, LambdaRank achieves the best equal-fold mean values among the evaluated models: 0.7361 for capped Recall@10, 0.6127 for NDCG@10, and 0.7749 for Hit@10.

0.29

Reading Position Is the Baseline to Beat: A Time-Ordered Evaluation of Personalised Highlight Prediction

cs.IR cs.HC ·2026-10-07 ·Kazuki Nakayashiki, Keisuke Watanabe
position similarity 0.65
Abstract · 13 pages, 1 figure, 5 tables. Ancillary files include the specifications, the results write-ups, the analysis scripts, and the aggregate art…

A reader's first highlights on a page are the cheapest personal signal a reading product has. The natural plan is to suggest what similar earlier readers marked, and to judge the result against popularity. We argue that the baseline to beat is reading position. In a time-ordered evaluation on one social highlighting platform (7,343 reader-page pairs on 1,511 pages after one highlight), ranking the sentences just below a reader's first highlight, with no other reader's data, puts the next highlight in the top five 47% of the time, against 26% for popularity and 29% for the better of two similarity methods. The baseline depends on the target: over all later highlights that ranking loses to popularity, while popularity discounted by distance from the latest highlight, at the scale with the best average precision of three tried, beats popularity and both similarity methods on both targets. In a comparison specified in advance, neither similarity method shows a gain over popularity in average precision over all later highlights, from one to five highlights, and a gain of +0.01 is excluded. Nor would a gain by itself show that a method has found a reader's preferences: synthetic readers who share one set of preferences produce one, and an evaluation out of time order shows a method where the reader went. The position results are exploratory and unconfirmed. Personalisation inside a document should be evaluated in time order and against reading position.

0.24

Attentional DoS: Repeat Reposting, Collective Attention, and Information Diffusion on X

cs.SI ·2026-09-28 ·Genta Toya, Bruno T. Sugano, Kei Ichikawa, Qianyun Wu, Shuhei Saigusa +4 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 13 pages, 5 figures

Collective attention is a finite shared resource, and social media posts compete for limited opportunities to be seen. On X, users can undo a repost and repost it again. By repeating this cycle, a user can put the same post back into followers' timelines any number of times without making new content. We call this procedure repeat reposting, and we read it as placing repeated demand on this shared resource (Attentional DoS). We formalize this idea and explore repeat reposting in a large-scale dataset of cascades with at least 1,000 reactions, originating from posts classified as Japanese on X, covering April 2025 to March 2026. Repeat reposts are rare, appearing in a small share of all (user, post) pairs. Even so, close to a million posts have at least one repeater, and most repeats come from a small group of habitual accounts. The central result is that subsequent audience growth is associated less with the number of repeats than with the estimated reach of the repeating accounts. Through the lens of seriality, how habitually the same groups of accounts repeat reposts across many posts, a distinct distributed form emerges: several serial amplifiers converge on the same post (Attentional DDoS). Its synchrony, how closely their actions are timed together, forms a continuum from bursts on the scale of minutes to a daily clock. A check of the content of 99.7% of amplified posts shows that most ADDoS repeat events are directed at Chinese-script content, which our vocabulary matching and sample inspection indicate is predominantly commercial spam. Repeat reposting thus lets a post re-enter the competition for visibility. The observed pattern is better characterized as repeated temporal coverage of an existing audience and the self-reinforcement of posts that are already growing, rather than as evidence that repeat reposting takes reach from other content.

0.28

Out-of-Network Attention Dynamics on Bluesky

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-10-01 ·Andrea Failla, Veronica Mesina, Giulio Rossetti
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted at Int. Conf. on Complex Networks and their Applications 2026

Personalized social media commonly relies on explicit follow graphs to shape what content users encounter; yet how much attention crosses ties they have not formed remains largely undocumented at scale. We study this question on Bluesky, a large decentralized microblogging platform whose default feed relies on a simple, reverse-chronological content recommender. We analyze 173 million user-author interactions (likes, reposts, replies, and quotes) collected from a near-complete platform dump between February and September 2023. We decompose each interaction by attention-path length (already followed, relayed by a followed account, reachable within two follow-hops, or beyond) and find that 74.5% of interactions reach the user through an account they already follow. Measured by distance in the follow graph rather than by route, 80.6% of interaction lands within two follow hops, far beyond the 22.4% an expected-degree null predicts. We then characterize how exploration varies across users and over tenure. A broad-reaching minority generates three quarters of all exploratory activity, while aggregate declines in exploration with tenure mask three distinct individual trajectories. Finally, attention reaching beyond two hops converts into new follow ties at less than one third the rate of two-hop-local exploratory attention. Together, these results depict a platform where out-of-network exploration is substantial in volume but strongly constrained by network proximity and unlikely to translate into new social ties.

0.26

Peer-Voted LLM-Agent Stress Tests Find Feed-Induced Lexical Convergence but No Reliable Matched-Exposure Advantage for Distributed Sources

cs.AI physics.soc-phcs.MAcs.SI ·2026-08-20 ·Rana Muhammad Usman, Dominic Williamson
code/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 9 pages, 3 figures. Code, frozen protocol, configurations, summary tables, and data are publicly available at https://github.com/ranausmanai…

Population-level behavior in large-language-model (LLM) agents cannot be characterized by single-agent benchmarks. We introduce PV-SST, a peer-voted social-platform testbed, and report a separately frozen, preregistered matched-exposure experiment spanning four topics, four unused seeds, four open-weight model families, and three prespecified larger variants. The experiment comprises 448 trials and 112 complete model-by-topic-by-seed blocks. Relative to a topic-only control, a feed of previous-round peer posts ranked by peer-generated likes increases final-round lexical similarity in both the four-family core panel (paired mean difference +0.0082 TF-IDF cosine units, 95% block-bootstrap CI [0.0043, 0.0121], randomization p=0.000105, n=64 blocks) and the three-variant size extension (+0.0109 [0.0069, 0.0151], p=0.000001, n=48). This contrast bundles peer-post exposure with ranking and therefore does not identify a ranking-only effect. Opposite-side survival falls in the core panel (-3.9 percentage points [-6.8, -1.6], p=0.0068) but not conclusively in the larger variants (-1.0 pp [-3.1, 0.4], p=0.50). Holding adversarial impressions fixed, four distributed sources do not reliably move honest-agent stance more than one source. The preregistered distributed-minus-single contrast is positive but inconclusive in the core panel (+0.057 [-0.009, 0.125], p=0.112) and negative in the larger variants (-0.040 [-0.113, 0.035], p=0.332), failing the prespecified cross-model and cross-topic consistency criterion. Thus the robust result is lexical convergence under the tested peer-ranked feed, not general opinion capture or a general coordination advantage. The study evaluates synthetic LLM-agent populations; it does not estimate effects on people or production platforms.

0.60

LLM Recommenders Produce Demographic Inequality Through Content Preferences

cs.CY cs.SI ·2026-10-30 ·Nicolò Pagan, Petter Törnberg, Christopher A. Bail, Christopher Barrie
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being integrated into systems that rank and recommend online content. We examine how this shift can produce demographic inequality in whose voices are surfaced. Using 10,000 Twitter/X posts written by 1,000 survey respondents and linked to verified self-reported characteristics across nine demographic attributes, we conduct a controlled recommendation experiment across three LLM providers, six recommendation objectives, and five levels of contextual information. By varying whether models receive post text alone, platform metadata, or explicit author demographics, we isolate three pathways to unequal recommendation: preferences for demographically patterned content, reliance on unequal engagement signals, and direct use of disclosed identity. We find that demographic inequality emerges from text alone. Models consistently favour longer, more negative, and more opinionated posts, particularly those concerning news and social issues, producing systematic differences in the demographic composition of recommended authors. Platform metadata generally amplifies these inequalities, while explicitly disclosing authors' demographic characteristics produces little additional change. Recommendation objectives mainly affect the magnitude of these patterns: controversial framing intensifies both content and demographic skew, whereas popularity-oriented framing dampens it, although for some attributes - most notably age - the objective can also reverse which group is favoured. LLM-based recommenders can therefore reproduce demographic inequality by proxy, not through explicit demographic targeting, but through preferences for content and engagement signals already structured by social inequality.

0.24

Why Does Misinformation Propagate Faster? An Algorithmic Perspective on X

cs.SI cs.LGecon.GN ·2026-09-24 ·Pan Li, Shuang Gao
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Misinformation is widely reported to propagate faster on engagement-based platforms, yet prior work largely focused on empirical analysis, without identifying a specific algorithmic mechanism that results in this phenomenon. Thanks to the open-sourcing of X's recommendation algorithms, we conduct what is, to our knowledge, the first component-level study of the recommendation algorithm deployed by a social media platform, which examines how each of its components affects misinformation propagation. Specifically, we identify the engagement fungibility mechanism in the algorithm, where the final recommendation score is constructed as a weighted sum of all predicted user activities. As a result, a tweet can be repeatedly recommended simply because it is predicted to draw many instant reactions (e.g., likes and retweets), even when it is not expected to draw thoughtful responses (e.g., replies and quotes). Since misinformation typically draws a larger share of its engagement from instant reactions, this mechanism enables it to receive more recommendation exposure and to propagate faster. To empirically validate this mechanism, we re-implement X's recommendation algorithm on the USC X 2024 election corpus, and build a calibrated simulation study to analyze the impact of different scoring rules. We find that re-tuning the metric weights has little or even a negative impact on reducing the credibility exposure gap, while those scoring rules that set a precondition of thoughtful engagement for amplification would be able to alleviate the gap significantly, across 46 robustness checks. Our diagnosis, therefore, yields a simple and deployable fix, a reflective-threshold gate that withholds amplification until a tweet is predicted to draw thoughtful engagement, which we find to reallocate exposure away from low-credibility content at no cost to mainstream exposure and with no loss of engagement.

0.23

Who Belongs Together? Topical and Social Structure in Bluesky Starter Packs

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-09-25 ·Sima Adleyba, Onur Varol
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Bluesky starter packs are human curated collections of accounts and feeds aimed at helping users discover new communities, especially during onboarding. Prior research has examined their effects on platform growth and account visibility. However, whether these packs capture meaningful topical and social structure remains unanswered. We study 2718 active starter packs containing approximately 144K accounts, combining pack metadata, follow graphs, user post histories and inferred demographic attributes to answer this question. We assign starter packs to 17 topical categories, and examine semantic coherence, curator--member resemblance, shared audiences, and follow reciprocity. We found that pack members are closely aligned with both their fellow pack members and their pack's description compared to accounts included in other packs of the same topic, indicating topical specificity beyond the broader topical categories. We also identify semantic resemblance between curators and their pack members, while demographic resemblance varies by attribute and topic. Network analyses show higher follow reciprocity among members of the same pack and between members and curators than between a pack member and either another member from the same broader topic or a nonmember. Members also share substantial portions of their follower networks with fellow pack members. Despite this coherence, a typical member's follower follows only a small fraction of other members in the pack, indicating limited audience coverage. These results suggest that starter packs capture coherent topical and social groups while leaving opportunities for further account discovery. More broadly, results show human-curation can be useful to capture relevant communities and connections, and platforms could integrate human-curation into recommendation systems as a complement to algorithmic systems to expand opportunities for discovery.

0.12