CS Paper Radar

Weaker Coherence, Weaker Reciprocity: Comparing the Semantic and Social Organization of Moltbook and Reddit

Favio Di Ciocco, Lucas Díaz Celauro, Sebastián Pinto, Marcelo Kuperman, Pablo Balenzuela

cs.SI physics.soc-ph ·submitted 2026-08-14 21:01 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Large language models enable the creation of autonomous agents that interact in social environments, raising the question of whether agent-based platforms reproduce the organizational properties of human social networks. We compare Moltbook, a social network populated by AI agents, with early Reddit, focusing on how communities organize and differentiate semantic content, using network analysis and NLP methods to characterize semantic coherence and diversity within and between communities, and their relationship to user activity. We find a systematic difference between the two platforms. Reddit communities show stronger semantic coherence, closer alignment with community names, and greater semantic diversity, with individual communities spanning broader content and communities more differentiated from one another. This combination distinguishes Reddit from Moltbook, whose communities are more homogeneous, less differentiated, and increasingly misaligned with their names over time. Users on Reddit also participate across communities that are more semantically related than those connected by activity in Moltbook. At the interaction level, comment-network motif analysis shows Moltbook dominated by non-reciprocal, broadcast-like exchanges, whereas Reddit shows more reciprocal, chained interaction patterns. These results indicate that Reddit combines semantic coherence with diversity across organizational levels, a pattern not reproduced by the AI-agent network.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Finding Common Ground: Graded Communal Knowledge in Bluesky Starter Packs

cs.SI cs.CL ·2026-09-17 ·Sagar Kumar, Lawrence Swaminathan Xavier Prince, Julia Mendelsohn, Brooke Foucault Welles, Nicholas W. Landry
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Communication is made possible by common ground---the unspoken knowledge that people share and presuppose of one another, whether that be online or offline. In his conception of common ground, Clark (1996) distinguishes between personal and communal common ground, and asserts that the latter is graded: the more community affiliations two people share, the more common ground they share as well. Social media research has invoked this mechanism to explain how users connect, but it has gone largely untested because community memberships are rarely visible and, where they are, they are coupled to user interactions in a way that leads to conflating effects. To circumvent these challenges, this study repurposes Bluesky starter packs (SPs) as user-curated community affiliation labels. Across 191,648 pairs of users, we show that shared lexical repertoire---our proxy for common ground---grows monotonically with the number of SPs that users share, with users sharing a single pack being roughly twice as similar as equally connected strangers. A semantic renormalization of SP co-membership shows furthermore that it is more so the number of topically \emph{distinct} communities, rather than the raw count, in which common ground is graded. Finally, we show that community co-membership adds to common ground independently of proximity in the Bluesky follow network. These results lead to the conclusion that community membership is a measurable, separable, and semantically structured carrier of common ground. Reading it as such makes common ground observable before an exchange rather than inferred from it, and thus opens the door for large-scale observational approaches to a set of questions that have so far only been posed in the laboratory.

0.14

Who Belongs Together? Topical and Social Structure in Bluesky Starter Packs

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-09-25 ·Sima Adleyba, Onur Varol
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Bluesky starter packs are human curated collections of accounts and feeds aimed at helping users discover new communities, especially during onboarding. Prior research has examined their effects on platform growth and account visibility. However, whether these packs capture meaningful topical and social structure remains unanswered. We study 2718 active starter packs containing approximately 144K accounts, combining pack metadata, follow graphs, user post histories and inferred demographic attributes to answer this question. We assign starter packs to 17 topical categories, and examine semantic coherence, curator--member resemblance, shared audiences, and follow reciprocity. We found that pack members are closely aligned with both their fellow pack members and their pack's description compared to accounts included in other packs of the same topic, indicating topical specificity beyond the broader topical categories. We also identify semantic resemblance between curators and their pack members, while demographic resemblance varies by attribute and topic. Network analyses show higher follow reciprocity among members of the same pack and between members and curators than between a pack member and either another member from the same broader topic or a nonmember. Members also share substantial portions of their follower networks with fellow pack members. Despite this coherence, a typical member's follower follows only a small fraction of other members in the pack, indicating limited audience coverage. These results suggest that starter packs capture coherent topical and social groups while leaving opportunities for further account discovery. More broadly, results show human-curation can be useful to capture relevant communities and connections, and platforms could integrate human-curation into recommendation systems as a complement to algorithmic systems to expand opportunities for discovery.

0.12

The Bureaucratization of the Internet: Analyzing the Diffusion of Governance Regimes on Reddit (2011--2023)

cs.SI ·2026-09-29 ·Katherine Van Koevering, Yuanhao Liu, Jon Kleinberg
similarity 0.64
Abstract

As online platforms scale, distributed communities must develop complex governance structures to maintain order. Reddit represents a unique experiment in this process: millions of subreddits manage their own digital commons, yet together they form an interconnected ecosystem of platform governance. Using a historical dataset of subreddit rules from 2011 to 2023, we apply computational methods to characterize that ecosystem and identify mechanisms driving change. We identify seven distinct governance regimes and document a platform-wide drift toward irreversible bureaucratization operating through two reinforcing dynamics: a ratchet effect among existing communities and a cohort shift in which new communities increasingly launch with pre-packaged regulatory frameworks. Using Dyadic Event History Analysis, we find that community scale is the dominant and universal predictor of rule adoption, independent of network exposure. Diffusion flows through two complementary channels: normative transmission via shared moderator networks and mimetic transmission among topically similar communities. However, mimetic copying is selective: it drives adoption of content rules addressing shared topical challenges while communities resist copying operational and behavioral rules. Additionally, communities with overlapping user bases differentiate rather than converge, consistent with ecological accounts of niche competition, and prestige-based contagion is firmly rejected. Together, these findings reveal decentralized platform governance as a stratified ecosystem in which lateral coordination, scale pressure, structural inertia, cohort effects, and episodic platform coercion jointly produce irreversible formalization with direct implications for platform management.

0.07

Do AI Agents Gossip? Evaluative Talk in Human and AI-Agent Online Communities

cs.CL cs.CY ·2026-10-14 ·Yong-Hui Hua, Chih-Han Lin, Shu-Kai Hsieh
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 20 pages, 1 figure

Gossip, defined as evaluative talk about absent third parties, is widely seen as a uniquely human social practice. This study examines whether comparable discourse emerges spontaneously in a community of autonomous AI agents. We compare Moltbook, a Reddit-style platform populated by AI agents, with PTT, a large human-operated bulletin board in Taiwan. To reduce differences attributable to communicative setting, we analyze two public, asynchronous forums using the same operational definition of gossip. Gossip occurs on Moltbook, but its prevalence is 2.6 to 6 times lower than on PTT, depending on the denominator used. On both platforms, gossip frequently targets locally prominent figures, tends to elicit agreement from the first respondent, and is rarely presented as unsupported rumor. The clearest difference concerns how subsequent responses develop. Among threads containing at least one codable reply, challenges occur in 65.1% of human threads but only 21.3% of agent threads. Moreover, following an early aligning response, consensus remains unchallenged in 83.6% of agent threads, compared with 44.7% of human threads. This thread-level contrast remains after controlling for thread depth and board composition and under recalibration against two human annotators. Estimates based on individual reply turns are less robust and are therefore reported as bounds. These findings suggest that AI-agent communities reproduce the informational dimension of gossip, while the extent to which gossip performs comparable relational functions remains unresolved.

0.34

From Web(logs) to Web(AI): Questions, Platforms, and Methods across Twenty Editions of ICWSM

cs.SI cs.CLcs.CYcs.HC ·2026-09-20 ·Koustuv Saha, Eshwar Chandrasekharan
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Over twenty editions, the ICWSM community has examined social life online as platforms, interactions, and research methods have changed. What can this body of research tell us at this critical juncture, as AI increasingly reshapes how people communicate online? We analyzed 2,139 indexed contributions from 2007 to 2026, distinguishing topics identified through nonnegative matrix factorization from problem framings captured through explicit textual cues. We find that platform mentions shift from blogs toward Twitter and, more recently, Reddit. Online community research maintains a similar topic share (10.5% to 10.0%), but governance cues within it increase from 4.0% to 34.3%. Harm-related cues also increase after restricting abstracts to a fixed length. Our review also traces advances in sampling, measurement, and causal and experimental methods. We discuss how AI-mediated interactions complicate these questions and provide a reporting checklist to support research across changing platforms.

0.21

Modeling Group Socialization in Online Communities

cs.SI cs.HC ·2026-10-16 ·Vinay Koshy, Iris Zhong, Karrie Karahalios, Benjamin Mako Hill, Amy X. Zhang
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Newcomers to online communities must learn a group's norms to participate successfully. This process is known as socialization, and has been the subject of considerable study in the online communities literature. Foundational work on group socialization in social psychology, however, suggests that socialization is actually a bidirectional process: individuals and communities adapt to each other's needs. In this work we develop a formal quantitative model of socialization, and present the first large scale empirical validation of the bidirectional socialization hypothesis using Reddit data. More specifically, we focus on linguistic socialization, and model users' comments in online communities as a mixture of in-group language and language from ``background'' communities they previously participated in. On a dataset of 112 subreddits (7.8 million tokens) find that our bidirectional model makes predictions that better generalize across users and time than two unidirectional socialization models. Furthermore, we conduct a qualitative analysis in which we demonstrate that our model is able to extract interpretable socialization patterns from the data that align with the existing literature. Specifically our model is able to learn that users conform more to group norms in topically niche communities with stricter content moderation rules, and that long time users conform more than newcomers. We emphasize that the claims made in this paper are explicitly falsifiable -- we are staking out a clear claim about what the socialization process looks like, and encourage future work to challenge our model.

0.19

How Agents Represent Humans: Human-Directed Stereotypes in an Open Agent Social Network

cs.CL ·2026-08-23 ·Huangchen Xu, Yuan Wu, Yi Chang
similarity 0.62
Abstract

LLM-based agents are increasingly deployed in persistent social environments, where generated claims can be posted, replied to, remembered, and reused. We study human-directed stereotypes on Moltbook, an open agent-native social platform, asking how agents construct humans as a social category. For this human-target analysis, we introduce an annotation framework with four evaluative dimensions---morality, friendliness, competence, and autonomy---and a second-stage subtype scheme for descriptive \textit{other} attributions. We find that competence dominates human-directed evaluations, while many \textit{other} attributions describe humans as epistemic, cultural, or embodied subjects. We further examine how these human representations appear in human--agent narrative contexts and platform-level circulation. As an auxiliary comparison, we analyze agent-internal community feedback through behavioral host affinity. Rather than reproducing the stable insider--outsider rejection often observed in human online communities, Moltbook feedback patterns are better explained by exposure, author visibility, and content selection. These findings suggest that bias in agent societies should be studied not only as isolated model output, but also as a discourse process.

0.51

Lexical Persistence Without Semantic Entrenchment in AI Agent Communities

cs.CL cs.CY ·2026-10-14 ·Chih-Han Lin, Yu-Yun Chang, Po-Ya Angela Wang, Shu-Kai Hsieh
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 18 pages, 6 figures

AI agent communities sustain lexical persistence, popular terms spread, recur, and achieve broad adoption, but whether they also develop the temporal semantic structure characteristic of human linguistic communities remains open. We compare MoltBook (AI agent community, 8 weeks), PTT (Chinese human BBS, 19 years), and Reddit (English human forum, in matched 8-week windows) using Compass-Aligned Distributional Embeddings (CADE), measuring semantic drift (B1), neighborhood stability (B2), and lag-1 autocorrelation of per-word drift trajectories. Across the platforms, lag-1 autocorrelation forms a memory-horizon continuum. AI agents' result clusters at the low end, while human platforms show longer-range temporal dependence. MoltBook exhibits approximately 2$\times$ the B1 drift and 20-30% lower B2 stability than both human platforms. As a partial control for community age, r/vibecoding (founded 2025-02-08) shows significant ACF in its first 8 weeks ($0.082$, $p<.001$) and over 15 weeks ($0.220$, $p<.001$); MoltBook's ACF remains non-significant ($p = 0.41$), consistent with the gap not reducing to developmental stage alone. We interpret this pattern as evidence that lexical diffusion alone does not guarantee diachronic semantic consolidation. The findings are consistent with a contrast between communities whose semantic trajectories accumulate long-range interaction constraints and communities whose outputs are repeatedly regenerated from largely fixed pretrained distributions.

0.22