CS Paper Radar

A Control-Theoretic Formulation of Global Workspace Theory

Ryota Kanai

cs.NE q-bio.NC ·submitted 2026-08-16 20:39 UTC · v1

Abstract

Global workspace theory explains conscious access as the broadcasting of selected information to the rest of the network, but it lacks a formal criterion for identifying the mechanism that enables this access. We propose that a global workspace is a mediator, namely, a subnetwork that receives activity from distributed systems, transforms it through internal modes, and returns differentiated effects to the broader network. We formalize this claim as the Global Mediation Workspace (GMW), a control-theoretic formulation in which a candidate subnetwork is treated as an open system embedded in the remainder of the network. In this framework, reachability characterizes how the remainder can drive the candidate, observability characterizes how candidate states affect the remainder, and a boundary Hankel operator identifies the internal modes linking the two directions. The resulting signature quantifies mediation capacity, input-output alignment, effective dimensionality, and routed source-target breadth, each of which characterizes different components of global workspace. In synthetic benchmarks, we tested whether the signature can distinguish a planted differentiated mediator from dense hubs, one-sided receivers or broadcasters, and a split read/write aggregate with no common internal route. A nonlinear extension characterizes mediation through trajectory-conditioned differential operators, finite-amplitude response profiles, and state-dependent coalitions. As a preliminary application, we estimated the signature from ECoG recordings in four macaques under ketamine anesthesia. We found that input-output alignment was reduced during unconsciousness whereas potential capacity was increased. The GMW thus provides a formal and testable criterion for locating candidate global workspaces in neural recordings and for asking which aspects of mediation is crucial for conscious access.

Comment
52 pages,28 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Does the Workspace Do the Work? A Causal Protocol for Verifying Global-Workspace Computation in a Language Model

cs.LG cs.AIq-bio.NC ·2026-11-19 ·Diaoxuan He, Linqian Wu
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 39 pages, 8 figures

Global Workspace Theory (GWT), a leading theory of consciousness, holds that information becomes conscious when it is broadcast to specialized processes that use it. Building a workspace into a network does not reveal what the trained network computes with it: a module that reports an answer may have combined a broadcast message with its own knowledge, or merely forwarded an answer computed elsewhere, and task accuracy and ablation cannot tell these apart. We introduce a causal protocol that identifies who computes when modules communicate. Its central test transplants a message from another input, chosen so that ignoring, relaying and recombining it predict three different answers. On networks built to relay or to recombine, the test assigns the right computation in every case. Among trained workspace models it finds all three outcomes: one leaves its broadcast nearly unused, and of two models that differ only in their training data, one relays and the other recombines. In AFGW, a language model whose modules communicate only through a learned workspace, a transplanted message yields the answer that recombination predicts in 97% of cases, and its content acts by redirecting what the receiver retrieves from its own memory. The tests carry over to other communication designs and to a known interface of a pretrained Transformer, turning GWT's central claim into a testable property of trained models.

0.30

Degrees of Freedom in Multi-Agent Coordination: Between Centralized and Decentralized Regimes

cs.MA cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-13 ·Yiqing Peng, Hehai Lin, Zixuan Wang, Dongyi Zhang, Zhengjie Zhu +5 more
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Large language model (LLM)-based multi-agent systems (MAS) are commonly organized around two coordination regimes. Centralized coordination provides explicit control but can create a bottleneck at a single coordination locus, whereas decentralized coordination offers local autonomy but must achieve effective collaboration through distributed decisions and experience. These trade-offs motivate a systematic study of the space between the two regimes. We introduce Degrees of Freedom (DoF), a continuous configuration framework that quantifies the size of the decision space delegated to downstream agents. DoF controls the granularity of delegated work and the target probability that each task unit is assigned to the branches. Its endpoints recover the two coordination regimes. Across multiple task domains, DoF reveals a hierarchy of organizational effects. Delegated granularity and within-regime routing produce structured but bounded profile reallocations, whereas task domain and retained experience are associated with stronger differences between the centralized- and decentralized-branch profiles. The resulting performance landscape is task-dependent: different domains favor different DoF configurations, while atomic-target conditions are more consistent across runs. In-domain retained experience brings the two branch profiles closer together. The same controlled sweep reveals a task-dependent coordination landscape: some domains exhibit higher-performing configurations, whereas others show flatter responses and no single configuration dominates across domains. In five of the six evaluated state, an intermediate DoF configuration achieves higher mean accuracy than both endpoints, demonstrating the value of exploring the coordination space between them. Together, these findings provide empirical guidance for studying and designing intermediate coordination regimes in LLM-based MAS.

0.45

Top-Level Operational Equilibrium: When is the response of a distributed system predictable from its own telemetry?

cs.DC cs.PF ·2026-11-16 ·Víctor Casamayor Pujol, Nefeli-Marina Rouska, Boris Sedlak
theorycode/data similarity 0.53
Abstract · 38 pages, 1 figure, 14 tables. Code and data: https://github.com/vikcas/TLOE-theoretical_analysis (doi:10.5281/zenodo.24200155)

Distributed systems deployed across the edge-cloud continuum are adapted continuously: scaled, re-routed, given more or less capacity. Each adaptation rests on an expectation of how the system will respond, yet operators cannot tell from the telemetry they already collect whether that response is predictable. We define top-level operational equilibrium (TLOE), a notion of equilibrium for a running system, stated relative to the controls its operator declares. TLOE has three conditions: stationarity with time-scale separation, sufficiency of a top-level aggregate for the controls, and time-reversibility of that aggregate. We prove that an aggregate satisfying the last two exists if and only if the minimal sufficient statistic of the controls is time-reversible, so the coarsest admissible aggregate is derived rather than chosen. Under the first two conditions, the response to a small control change follows from passive telemetry through the steady-state fluctuation-response identity, with a conjugate observable fixed by the type of control: the total work in progress for a change of load, the occupancy of a stage for a change of its capacity. For chains of exponential single-server stages with Poisson input, TLOE holds exactly for load control at every stable throughput, but never for a control on the capacity of the first or last stage. On reference models, a per-stage conjugate overestimates the early response about threefold, blocking between stages breaks both conditions weakly, and a hysteretic autoscaler leaves no admissible aggregate at any reaction time computed. We specify a test for each condition, show that a static sufficiency test with an estimated top-level conjugate has no power, and quantify on simulated telemetry the window lengths the prediction and the reversibility test need. The evidence is on reference models; real telemetry is left to future work.

0.37

What is a Good Projection?: Correctness and Separation Results of End-Point Projections

cs.PL cs.LO ·2026-10-20 ·Jake Masters, Nobuko Yoshida
top venuetheory similarity 0.51
Abstract · 91 pages. 6 figures. Conditionally accepted to POPL 2027

\emph{Multiparty session types} (MPST) is a type discipline for ensuring distributed programs are implemented correctly \emph{by construction}. MPST starts by specifying a choreographic protocol as a \emph{global type} and \emph{projects} it onto each participant, generating \emph{local types} with a guarantee of type soundness and deadlock-freedom. A central issue of MPST is that its type soundness is fragile, as it must be proven each time with respect to a chosen projection algorithm under specific semantics with a specific program correctness goal. To overcome this problem, we propose general criteria for a \emph{good projection} -- a set of requirements for projection algorithms by which type soundness, deadlock-freedom and liveness of distributed programs are \emph{automatically} derived. Using the criteria, we prove that 8 distinct projections in the literature are good under both synchronous and asynchronous semantics, and that 4 are incorrect, failing type soundness. We extend the good projection criteria to mixed choice global types and asynchronous communication optimisations, proposing new ``good projection'' algorithms. We apply properties of good projections to prove \emph{separation} and \emph{expressiveness} results over the projection algorithms and MPST typing systems. Having a generalised typing system that is robust with respect to the good projection criteria, we provide an implementation with mixed choice global types that is \emph{modular} with respect to a chosen projection algorithm and desired program properties. Our separation results help programmers make informed trade-offs between complexity and expressiveness when choosing projection algorithms, and our theory ensures their chosen algorithms are correctly applied.

0.45

Work Agents: Systems, Capabilities, and Optimization

cs.LG ·2026-10-26 ·Zishan Xu, Enjun Du, Mingqi Gao, Cheng Yang, Junhao Shen +11 more
community pick similarity 0.51
Abstract

As foundation models evolve from information generation to digital work execution, agents are increasingly capable of completing complex tasks across tools, applications, and workflows. However, existing research lacks a unified perspective on how agents reliably accomplish delegated work. To address this gap, we present a work-centric, system-level perspective that views work agents as systems combining foundation models and runtime harnesses to execute tasks in stateful workspaces and deliver verifiable outcomes. We introduce two complementary dimensions, work persistence and work openness, to characterize working conditions, and classify digital work into five forms according to task scope and organization. Building on this framework, we identify five core capability families required for reliable work execution and examine approaches to model optimization, harness optimization, and their joint optimization. We further analyze existing evaluation methods and metrics from the perspective of work outcomes. Finally, we discuss future research directions, including sustained work delegation, adaptation to open environments, and the interaction between work execution and capability improvement. This paper provides a unified framework for understanding, optimizing, and evaluating work agents, supporting the development of systems capable of delivering reliable, verifiable, and practically valuable work outcomes.

0.24

Observability Blocking in a Linear Synchronization Network with Partial State Measurements

eess.SY ·2026-08-26 ·Alexis Moreno, Abdullah Al Maruf
similarity 0.50
Abstract · 8 pages, 3 figures, submitted to the IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)

Large-scale networked systems are increasingly vulnerable to adversaries that can infer system dynamics from a small set of compromised nodes. This paper addresses the problem of blocking such inference using limited state information. While existing state-feedback methods achieve observability blocking with eigenvalue preservation, they require full state access and are impractical for large networks. We propose multiple control strategies that operate under partial state measurements. The first approach employs output feedback to achieve observability blocking while preserving a subset of open-loop eigenvalues. The second approach leverages an observer to reconstruct the system state and enables full-state feedback control, preserving all eigenvalues and providing greater flexibility in sensor placement. We further extend the observer-based design to a distributed framework. Numerical examples demonstrate the scope and validity of the proposed methods.

0.30

On the Discernibility of Topology Changes in Networked LTI Systems

eess.SY ·2026-10-23 ·Giulio Fattore, Maria Elena Valcher
similarity 0.50
Abstract · Submitted as an invited paper to the Bicentennial Special Issue of the Journal of the Franklin Institute. Under review

This article investigates the discernibility of topology changes in networked linear time-invariant systems, with particular focus on edge disconnection. We introduce a new notion of discernibility motivated by a limitation of the definition commonly adopted in the literature. In consensus networks, topology changes are inherently indiscernible for all initial conditions belonging to the synchronization subspace. To overcome this issue, we first introduce the notion of dynamical discernibility of a topology change for elementary consensus networks. This notion explicitly disregards the intrinsic indiscernibility associated with states in the consensus subspace. We characterize this property for directed communication graphs and then specialize the resulting conditions to topology changes arising from either the disconnection of an edge or a variation in its weight. We then extend the analysis to networks of homogeneous agents by introducing discernibility modulo synchronization, which factors out the unavoidable indiscernibility associated with synchronized trajectories. We derive a general characterization showing how discernibility depends jointly on the topology change and on the dynamics of the individual agents. Finally, we specialize the analysis to undirected communication graphs and show that, under mild additional assumptions, discernibility modulo synchronization is equivalent to the dynamical discernibility of the corresponding topology change. This establishes a direct connection between the two notions and extends existing results on the discernibility of topology variations in dynamical networks. The resulting characterizations are then further specialized to the case of edge disconnection.

0.20

Beyond Quantum Messages: Toward Quantum-Native Network Functioning

cs.NI quant-ph ·2026-11-05 ·Angela Sara Cacciapuoti, Jessica Illiano, Caterina De Risi, Marcello Caleffi
published similarity 0.50
Abstract · Accepted manuscript for publication in Frontiers in Communications and Networks . This work has been funded by the European Union under Hori…

The Quantum Internet is commonly envisioned as a network that transports quantum states and distributes entanglement as the key resource underpinning distributed quantum applications. This view is necessary but incomplete if quantum phenomena are confined to what the network carries or manages, while network functionalities remain grounded predominantly in classical abstractions. This Perspective advances a broader thesis: quantum phenomena can also participate directly in the realization of network functionalities. We first establish the architectural baseline by introducing entanglement as a stateful network resource whose operational condition is non-locally distributed across remote nodes, evolves through manipulation or consumption, and degrades over time through decoherence. Its evolving state must therefore remain visible to the functionalities acting on it. We then move beyond resource visibility and use two mechanisms as proof points of a broader quantum-native functional design space: entanglement generation during propagation through coherent spatial-path superposition, and operational connectivity induced by shared entanglement that can depart from the physical graph. These examples show that paths, neighbors, or participating nodes may become operationally relevant in ways determined by quantum coherence and shared entanglement, rather than by physical connectivity alone. We identify Quantum Addressing as a transversal abstraction capable of representing such relations while complementing, rather than replacing, classical addressing and signaling. The resulting perspective broadens the Quantum Internet from transporting quantum information and distributing entanglement to exploiting quantum phenomena in network functioning, opening a coupled frontier spanning routing, forwarding, control, and functionality placement.

0.41