CS Paper Radar

Witness-Certified Fair Division with Comparison Queries

Tatsuhito Yamagata, Hanna Sumita

cs.GT cs.DS ·submitted 2026-08-17 05:02 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We study fair division of indivisible goods when agents' valuations are accessed only through ordinal comparisons between bundles, with arbitrary tie-breaking. In this model, even deciding whether a given allocation is envy-free up to one good (EF1) can be impossible. This suggests explicit fairness certificates as a natural algorithmic object. Our main contribution is a certificate-preserving scaling framework, which recursively contracts goods, solves a smaller instance, and expands the solution while repairing an explicit envy-eliminating witness certificate. For arbitrary identical monotone valuations, this yields a certified EF1 allocation for $n$ agents and $m$ goods using $O(n \log n \log(m/n))$ comparison queries, within an $O(\log n)$ factor of the $Ω(n \log (m/n))$ communication lower bound. For identical additive valuations, we additionally obtain a $1/2$-MMS guarantee within the same query complexity. For non-identical additive valuations, exploiting our EF1+$1/2$-MMS algorithm, we accelerate the existing matching-based PROP1+$1/2$-MMS framework, improving the query complexity from $O(n^4\log m)$ to $O(n^3\log m)$. Finally, we study the structure of such certificates through $k$-witness EF1, a hierarchy between EF1 and EFX.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Computing EF1 Allocations with Few Value Queries

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-11-17 ·Max Dupré la Tour, Ayumi Igarashi
similarity 0.77
Abstract

We give a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm that allocates $m$ indivisible goods among $n$ agents with nonnegative additive valuations using $O(n^5\log^2 m)$ value queries and guarantees envy-freeness up to one good (EF1). Concurrent work of Lin, Liu, Tao, and Zhou achieves $O(n^8\log m)$ comparison queries, attaining the optimal $O(\log m)$ dependence on $m$ for fixed $n$. Each comparison query can be simulated using two value queries, so their bound also holds for value queries. Our contributions are a much simpler algorithm and proofs, and polynomial-time computation.

0.23

Logarithmic Comparison-Query Complexity for EF1 Allocations

cs.GT ·2026-11-03 ·Zehan Lin, Shengxin Liu, Biaoshuai Tao, Shengwei Zhou
theory similarity 0.77
Abstract

We study the comparison-query complexity of computing allocations that are envy-free up to one item (EF1) for $n$ agents with heterogeneous additive preferences over $m$ indivisible items. In this model, the algorithm may only query which of two bundles an agent prefers, without ever observing numerical valuations or costs. Prior work established $O(\log m)$ query bounds for at most three agents, leaving open whether query complexity logarithmic in $m$ is achievable for every fixed $n \ge 4$. We resolve this open question in the affirmative: for every fixed $n\ge2$, we design algorithms that compute EF1 allocations using $O(\log m)$ comparison queries, matching the known $Ω(\log m)$ lower bound. Our results hold for both chores with nonnegative costs and goods with nonnegative valuations.

0.12

Comparison-Based Fair Division of Indivisible Chores

cs.GT ·2026-09-08 ·Zehan Lin, Shengxin Liu, Biaoshuai Tao, Shengwei Zhou
similarity 0.75
Abstract

We investigate the query complexity of fairly allocating $m$ indivisible chores among $n$ agents with additive cost functions. We depart from the standard cardinal model and assume only comparison access: an algorithm may ask an agent which of two bundles is less costly, but never observes numerical costs. Our first results concern proportionality up to one item (PROP1). We design comparison-based algorithms that compute PROP1 allocations using $O(n^3\log m)$ comparison queries. When the chores are arranged in a fixed order and allocations are required to be contiguous, we compute a contiguous PROP1 allocation using $O(n^3 \log^2 m)$ comparison queries. Our main result concerns the maximin share (MMS) guarantee. We show that for any fixed number of agents $n$ and constant $\varepsilon>0$, a $\left(13/11 +\varepsilon\right)$-MMS allocation can be computed with a comparison complexity logarithmic in $m$. Remarkably, comparison access suffices to match the state-of-the-art $13/11$ cardinal-access guarantee of Huang and Segal-Halevi up to an arbitrarily small loss. Furthermore, our result implies that the MMS distortion of comparison access (i.e., the worst-case multiplicative loss in MMS fairness incurred by observing only comparisons rather than numerical costs) is at most $13/11$. Finally, we show that, for three agents, an allocation satisfying envy-freeness up to one item (EF1) can be computed using $O(\log m)$ comparison queries.

0.16

Computing EF1 Allocations under Budget Constraints in Polynomial Time

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-11-09 ·Tingwei Hu, Lili Mei, Guochuan Zhang
similarity 0.72
Abstract

We study the fair allocation of indivisible items to agents with budget constraints and additive valuations. Each agent compares its own bundle with the subsets of another bundle that fit its budget. An allocation is envy-free up to one item (EF1) if, for every agent and every nonempty subset under comparison, removing an item of maximum value to that agent eliminates its envy. We require EF1 both between agents and towards the charity, which contains all unallocated items. EF1 allocations exist, but computing them in polynomial time has remained open even for homogeneous valuations. We resolve this problem with a polynomial-time algorithm for EF1 allocations under heterogeneous valuations. We also prove that detecting an EF1 violation is NP-complete. Equivalently, checking whether a given allocation is EF1 is coNP-complete. Finally, we give polynomial-time algorithms for envy-freeness up to any item (EFX) both when each agent's valuation is proportional to item size and when each agent has a fixed number of distinct positive item values. As an application, for homogeneous valuations and any $\varepsilon>0$, we obtain an EF1 allocation with at least a $(1/2-\varepsilon)$ fraction of the maximum social welfare in time polynomial in the input length and $1/\varepsilon$.

0.04

To EFX OR to MMS, That is the Question

cs.GT ·2026-08-11 ·Hadi Hosseini, Payas Khurana, Shraddha Pathak, Rohit Vaish
theory similarity 0.71
Abstract

We study the agent-wise disjunction of two central fairness notions for indivisible items, where every agent must be either envy-free up to any item (EFX) or maximin-share (MMS) satisfied. One might expect that having a flexible fairness requirement for individual agents will restore existence, especially because the existence of EFX itself resisted resolution for nearly a decade. Surprisingly, it does not. We construct counterexamples with three agents and eight submodular goods, and with three agents and seven submodular chores, significantly strengthening recent EFX impossibility results. On the positive side, we prove existence for additive mixed items with at most three valuation types when one type is a singleton. Additionally, we obtain polynomial-time approximation schemes for additive goods-only and chores-only instances. We also identify a clean separation between the disjunction and its constituents: For additive chores with two valuation types, EFX and MMS are both known to fail, whereas an EFX $\vee$ MMS allocation always exists. Finally, we show that identical additive valuations even admit the conjunction EFX $\wedge$ MMS for mixed items. Overall, our results show that allowing flexibility in choosing agent-specific fairness certificates expands the frontier of fair solutions while also uncovering surprising impossibilities.

0.32

Exact Envy-Free Cake Cutting with Polynomial Expected Queries

cs.GT cs.CC ·2026-10-20 ·Simon Mackenzie, Mashbat Suzuki
theory similarity 0.70
Abstract · 56 pages, 4 figures. Preliminary version

Envy-free cake cutting asks how to divide a resource so that no agent prefers another agent's share. Finding such a division with few queries about preferences has been a longstanding challenge. Aziz and Mackenzie gave the first query bound depending only on the number $n$ of agents: a tower of six $n$'s. Subsequent improvements culminated in Ye and Bai's single-exponential bound of $n^{O(1)}2^n$. A large gap remains between this deterministic upper bound and Procaccia's general lower bound of $Ω(n^2)$. Whether polynomially many queries suffice is a central open question in fair division. We show that a polynomial expected query bound is possible. Our randomised protocol uses only independent, uniformly sampled points from the cake as its source of randomness. For every profile of $n$ agents with nonnegative, additive, nonatomic valuations, the protocol has the following guarantees: (1) It terminates with probability one. (2) Every allocation it returns is complete and exactly envy-free. (3) Its expected number of Robertson-Webb queries is $\widetilde{O}(n^{30})$. The expectation is taken solely over the protocol's random choices, with no distributional assumptions on preferences.

0.31

Simultaneous Envy and Equitability Guarantees

cs.GT cs.AIecon.TH ·2026-08-26 ·Hadi Hosseini, Shraddha Pathak, Lirong Xia, Chengkai Zhang
similarity 0.70
Abstract · 43 pages

Recent work in fair division has focused on either simultaneously satisfying closely related fairness notions or achieving a single notion across the ex-ante and ex-post worlds. We study the compatibility of two fundamentally different fairness notions: envy-freeness and equitability. For indivisible goods-only and chores-only settings, we study the existence and complexity of simultaneously satisfying their relaxations, revealing sharp contrasts between the two settings. For normalized binary goods, we give a polynomial-time algorithm for computing an EF1+EQ1 allocation with at most seven agents, but also construct a normalized instance with a larger number of agents for which no such allocation exists. In sharp contrast, binary chores admit the stronger EFX+EQX guarantee for any number of agents, even without normalization. We further initiate the study of cross-notion ex-ante and ex-post guarantees, asking whether randomized allocations can provide ex-ante guarantees for one notion while preserving ex-post guarantees for another.

0.41

Fair Division Under Boolean Valuations: Beyond Normalization

cs.GT ·2026-08-30 ·Nisarg Shah, Paritosh Verma
similarity 0.69
Abstract

We study fair division of indivisible items when agents have arbitrary two-level preferences: the value of each agent for any set of items is Boolean, which need not be monotone or additive. Notably, we do not impose the standard assumption of normalization, i.e., different agents may value the empty set at different Boolean levels. Since the preferences are nonmonotone, envy-freeness up to one item (EF1) and envy-freeness up to any item (EFX) each admit several variants, depending on which items are tested for removal and whether they are removed from the envious agent's bundle or the envied agent's bundle. This paper investigates the existence of these variants of EF1 and EFX, on their own and together with economic efficiency, incentive compatibility, feasibility constraints, and lottery-based randomization. Our results highlight that the existence landscape depends crucially on the number of normalized agents, who value the empty bundle at the lower Boolean level. The authors used significant assistance from GPT-5.6-Sol for deriving theoretical results, verified any AI-generated proofs for correctness, and expanded on the exposition and simplified arguments, with the aid of GPT-5.6-Sol and Claude Opus 5.

0.17