CS Paper Radar

A Tree-Structured Approach for Phishing Template and Attacker Attribution Analysis

Unai Agirre, Imanol Jerico, Felipe Castaño, Andrea Venturi, Francesco Zola

cs.LG cs.AIcs.ET ·submitted 2026-08-17 06:23 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Phishing remains a persistent and evolving cybersecurity threat, with attack volumes reaching record levels. This growth is driven by the industrialization of phishing through widely available phishing kits and reusable templates, which enable cybercriminals to rapidly generate and deploy large numbers of fraudulent webpages. Although surface-level attributes may differ across these websites, their underlying structures often exhibit significant similarities. However, most existing defenses rely on reactive blocklists or supervised classification models that focus on individual phishing instances, limiting their ability to identify structural reuse and detect coordinated phishing campaigns. To address this limitation, this study investigates whether HTML structure can serve as a robust fingerprint for identifying phishing template reuse. We model webpages as Document Object Model (DOM) trees and extract structural features, optionally enriched with HTML tag-based content information. These representations are then clustered using unsupervised learning methods to group structurally similar webpages. Three clustering algorithms are evaluated and compared, while also analyzing how the depth of the extracted DOM-tree affects cluster formation and overall clustering performance. Finally, cluster quality is also evaluated both quantitatively and qualitatively, including a novel level-wise Jaccard Distance Score and manual inspection supported by visualization tools. Results demonstrate that structural representations of webpages can effectively reveal hidden similarities across phishing sites, enabling the detection of emerging and zero-day templates and supporting the analysis of coordinated phishing threats

Comment
Paper accepted and presented @ eCrime 2026 conference

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Large-Scale Empirical Study of Modern Phishing Email Content

cs.CR ·2026-09-25 ·Jaehwan Park, Woonghee Lee, Fujiao Ji, Doowon Kim
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 22 pages

Phishing remains one of the most pervasive threats to Internet users, and email remains its predominant delivery channel. Email content is the attack surface of phishing: it is what the victim reads and what automated defenses inspect. Yet the composition of modern phishing content is poorly measured. Prior work has characterized dimensions such as theme, call-to-action (CTA), and impersonation, but not at scale, and their associations and temporal changes remain unclear, owing to small or source-specific corpora, bag-of-words topic models, and a focus on text alone. We present a content-focused measurement study of 2.9M distinct real-world phishing emails collected over 13 months (June 2025 - June 2026) in collaboration with the Anti-Phishing Working Group (APWG). We treat each email as a composite artifact comprising message text and its attachments: 272K images, 143K PDFs, and 57K calendar invitations. Using an LLM pipeline validated against human-annotated samples, we analyze these components along three dimensions (theme, CTA, and impersonation), examine the associations among them, and measure longer-term change against a historical dataset. We find that attackers diversify what they use to deceive but converge on how victims should respond: no theme exceeds 21.3% of emails, while a single CTA, URL navigation, accounts for 73.0%. CTA and impersonation choices are conditioned on theme. Attachments play three roles: images supplement the message text, PDFs substitute for it by carrying the pretext, and calendar invitations reinforce it by replicating interaction endpoints into a persistent medium. Over the longer term, the dominant CTA for invoice-themed phishing shifted from URL navigation to offline communication, rising from 6.7% in 2015 to 46.9% in 2025.

0.26

PhiShark2026: A Multi-Layer Active-Web Raw-Evidence Dataset for Phishing Website Research

cs.CR ·2026-08-24 ·Furkan Çolhak, Ferhat Demirkıran, Hasan Dağ, Alexander Iliev
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 13 pages, 4 figures, 13 tables

Phishing websites are short-lived and rapidly changing, yet many phishing datasets reduce observations to URLs or precomputed features, constraining researchers to predefined representations and discarding the underlying evidence needed to derive alternative features, apply new extraction methods, examine cross-layer relationships, and reanalyze observations as phishing techniques evolve. This study addresses this limitation with a multi-layer active-web dataset comprising 67,502 scans, including 33,387 phishing observations from operational feeds and 34,115 screened benign reference observations. The corpus preserves raw evidence across HTML content and screenshots, URL and redirect behavior, HTTP and security headers, compliance files, TLS certificates, DNS and domain registration, open ports, geolocation and accessibility measurements, and network infrastructure, while explicitly recording unavailable evidence rather than treating it as negative observations. To avoid misleading infrastructure attribution on shared platforms, the study applies a hosting-aware evidence model that masks provider-owned infrastructure signals for free-hosted tenant pages while retaining meaningful page- and transport-level evidence. Characterization reveals systematic differences between phishing and benign websites across web-resource usage, domain maturity, mail and policy configuration, security headers, and infrastructure context. By preserving raw artifacts together with acquisition metadata and explicit evidence availability, the corpus provides an inspectable and reproducible foundation for future phishing measurement and dataset research.

0.30

PhishGen: Understanding LLM Capabilities in Automated Phishing Website Generation

cs.CR ·2026-10-21 ·Fujiao Ji, Yerim Kim, Yena Cho, Seonhye Park, Hyoungshick Kim +1 more
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract

Phishing relies on visual deception, traditionally requiring web-development skills or pre-built kits. LLMs erode this barrier by generating functional websites from natural-language prompts, yet prior work does not answer how far LLM-driven generation actually reaches: functionality is assessed by inspection rather than execution; visual fidelity is scored by automated metrics or a few internal coders rather than the humans such pages aim to deceive; evaluation is confined to commercial models; and no study benchmarks generated pages against phishing kits deployed in the wild. We present PhishGen, a framework that evaluates the appearance fidelity and end-to-end functionality of LLM-generated phishing pages. PhishGen constructs prompts across three input modalities in seven combinations with twelve safeguard-bypassing rewriting strategies, generates pages using 14 LLMs spanning commercial, open-source, and uncensored categories, and assesses each via automated similarity metrics, reference-based detectors, a crowdsourced user study, and execution-based functionality testing, benchmarking all results against 64 real-world phishing kits. Although 96.2% of safeguard-bypassing outputs render, their perceived fidelity is modest (2.02/5), and only 38.7% complete the full credential-harvesting pipeline, with the Unsaved error as the largest failure mode. Contrary to the belief that uncensored models pose the greatest threat, GPT 4.1 reaches 86.3 to 94.1% functional success while uncensored models rarely exceed 45.4%. Phishing kits remain more complete per sample, yet three strong LLMs surpass the kit-level rate (70.9 to 89.7%), showing that LLMs trade average completeness for scalable, low-barrier generation of working phishing pages. We further identify generator-level fingerprints that current similarity-based defenses miss, and distill recommendations for hybrid detectors.

0.40

Nebulon Enterprise Simulated Threats for Phishing Research (NEST-Phish): A Synthetic Enterprise Phishing Email Dataset for Behavioral and Machine-Learning Research

cs.CR ·2026-09-03 ·Emily J. Winokur, Lauren S. Treiman, Allen G. Moore, Paul Schutte, Joe Ingram +1 more
benchmarkdatasetcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · Dataset paper; associated public dataset available on Kaggle: https://www.kaggle.com/datasets/emilywinokur/synthetic-email-corpus

Phishing remains one of the most persistent cyber threats, yet publicly shareable datasets for studying phishing in realistic enterprise email settings remain limited. To address this gap, we introduce a synthetic enterprise phishing email dataset built around a fictitious organization, Nebulon. The dataset spans a broad set of workplace communication themes and includes matched synthetic legitimate and phishing emails with interpretable phishing-cue annotations. Here, ``legitimate'' denotes the non-phishing class, not legitimately occurring organizational emails. Human-subject categorizations and classifier evaluations show that the dataset supports meaningful variation in phishing judgments while also providing learnable signal for supervised detection. This publicly released resource is intended to support future work on phishing detection, human susceptibility, explainability, and benchmark development in enterprise-like contexts.

0.21

COBRA: A Content-Agnostic Framework for Zero-Day Detection of Suspicious Domains

cs.CR ·2026-09-22 ·Alexandros Fourtounis, Emmanouil Papadogiannakis, Panagiotis Papadopoulos, Nicolas Kourtellis, Evangelos Markatos
published similarity 0.64
Abstract

The use of malicious domains is central to cyberattacks such as phishing, malware distribution, impersonation, and fraudulent transactions. Because domains are inexpensive to register and easy to deploy at scale, they remain one of the most common and damaging tools used in cybercrime across industries. Proactive detection is essential to reducing this window of vulnerability and preventing harm to users. In this work, we propose COBRA: a content-agnostic, registration-time detection framework for identifying and analyzing suspicious domains from day zero. Our approach does not rely on any content-based features, allowing us to classify a domain even before it is populated with content. We analyze the names of newly registered domains and employ a clustering technique to group them based on lexical and structural similarity. We evaluate our methodology using real-world data consisting of 1.5M newly created domains, demonstrating that COBRA detects suspicious domains with a precision of 98.5%, identifying more than 47K distinct newly registered suspicious domains. Furthermore, our results show that domain-name clustering enables accurate early detection, allowing us to identify 80% of suspicious or malicious domains earlier than one of the most widely used threat-intelligence services, which in some cases may require up to 7 days.

0.48

Beyond Node Attributes: A Controlled Evaluation and Ablation of Local Interaction Statistics for Ethereum Phishing Detection

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-11-08 ·Thanh Dat Tran, Duy Loi Duong, Duy Luu Hoang, Minh Huy Tran, Vo Minh Thu Le +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract · 13 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables

Methods for detecting phishing accounts on Ethereum are usually evaluated as complete pipelines that differ in features, architecture, and training protocol, which makes the contribution of interaction information hard to isolate. This paper evaluates the Unlabeled Feature Extension (UFE), a block of 12 local interaction statistics computed from each account's incoming and outgoing call and transfer edges without reading class labels. UFE is appended to the 14 source features of HEIG-Phish and tested with six model families: Logistic Regression, Random Forest, LightGBM, Graph Attention Network, GraphSAGE, and Meta-IFD. Within each pair of Baseline and Plus variants, the data partition, model configuration, random seed, decision threshold, and sampled neighborhoods are identical; only the input feature block changes. Across 20 predetermined stratified partitions of the same 2,763 labeled externally owned accounts, UFE increased test Macro-F1 by 1.0 to 9.1 percentage points across the six models. Every pair improved on all 20 partitions, all Nadeau-Bengio corrected 95% confidence intervals lie above zero, and the false-positive rate decreased for all six models. An exact-edge Random Forest ablation over 10 predetermined partitions associates most of the gain with the incoming transfer-edge sum attribute; once this feature is present, an incremental contribution of the remaining 11 UFE columns was not established. The results support reporting feature-augmented baselines alongside graph models, but they show stability under re-partitioning of one static, transductive benchmark rather than temporal or cross-dataset generalization.

0.30

CyberHull: Deterministic Malicious URL Isolation via Convex Hull

cs.CR cs.CGcs.LGcs.NI ·2026-10-20 ·Avijit Gayen, Aniket Ghosal, Durba Chakraborty, Sayan Mondal, Md Abdul Aziz Al Aman +1 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract

The emergence of increasingly sophisticated and evasion-resistant phishing attack strategies represents a significant threat to modern cybersecurity, particularly in cyber-physical systems and internet-based networks. Traditional probabilistic methods and certain machine learning approaches often struggle to detect novel attacks and may lack interpretability or portability. To address these challenges, we introduce CyberHull, a resource-efficient and deterministic framework for identifying malicious URLs through mathematically defined convex hull boundaries across multiple orthogonal feature domains, including structural content entropy, hyperlink graph topology, and semantic token distribution. CyberHull constructs compact convex hulls, referred to as vaults, using the QuickHull algorithm, with a training complexity of O(n log n) under suitable assumptions. URL classification is performed through point-in-polyhedron tests that impose relatively low computational overhead on standard CPUs. Experimental results demonstrate that CyberHull achieves 92 percent detection accuracy, substantially outperforming a baseline linear approach based on Principal Component Analysis (PCA), which achieves 32 percent accuracy. Furthermore, CyberHull offers a computationally efficient alternative to resource-intensive deep learning approaches for malicious URL detection.

0.21

Social Engineering Attack Detection in Corporate Communications

cs.LG cs.CR ·2026-11-11 ·Hanzla Hamid, Pappu Jha, Nick Rahimi
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Social Engineering attacks continue to pose a significant risk to the corporate world with a growing level of sophistication. It is difficult to distinguish between authentic and phishing communication via email, chat, and phone. They pose a risk of exposing trade secrets and confidential communications and can create a chain of attack from lower-level employees up to executives. Therefore, we study this growing threat using real-world datasets to build baseline machine-learning models. Our TF-IDF models classify emails as phishing or safe, achieving accuracy above 90%. We build on this by exploring whether psychological manipulation and persuasion indicators can be measured to play a significant role in detecting phishing. Instead of relying solely on surface-level lexical features, we derive interpretable lexicon-based indicators of urgency, trust, greed, and other persuasion cues from the combined email dataset. By evaluating these manipulation-oriented features on their own, we measure how much signal they carry (ROC-AUC of 0.74 on a held-out test split) and test whether they transfer to held-out email sources.

0.08