CS Paper Radar

Artly: Exploring Digital Artists' Perceptions of AI-Generated Feedback

Ulvi Rajabli, Alexander Wiethoff, Zelun Tony Zhang

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-08-17 07:10 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Recent developments in generative AI have lowered barriers to image generation, but existing tools mostly optimize for efficiency, producing generic results and offering little support for artistic growth. We present Artly, an AI system that combines personalizable AI feedback with human-authored learning resources. In a between-subjects study with artists, we compared a mode without image generation features against one that allowed to generate variations of users' illustrations. Artly was perceived as helpful for learning and self-improvement, with the exception of the most proficient participants. Participants who used the image generation feature interacted slightly less with the AI feedback. They reported feeling more creative after using Artly than participants using the restricted mode, while reporting slightly lower scores on new ideas for their work. Overall, our findings underline the potential of our feedback approach for supporting artistic growth in a manner that is well received by artists.

Journal ref
Proceedings of the 14th Nordic Conference on Human-Computer Interaction (NordiCHI '26), October 03-07, 2026, Vaasa, Finland
DOI
10.1145/3829807.3829878

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Style Replication to Style Exploration: Enabling Art Style Exploration with Analyze-Experiment-Resituate Framework

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-08-14 ·Wen-Fan Wang, TsaiHsuan Lin, Chi-Lan Yang, An-Ru Cheng, Bing-Yu Chen
top venue similarity 0.74
Abstract · Accepted to UIST '26

Art style is a signature of professional digital artists that develops through repeated experimentation, reflection, and adaptation. While generative AI (GenAI) can reproduce styles with high fidelity, current tools provide limited support for exploring new stylistic directions and may encourage style replication over exploration. To address this gap, we propose Analyze-Experiment-Resituate (AER), a framework for AI-assisted style exploration derived from interviews with 10 professional digital artists. Rather than prioritizing visually appealing outputs alone, AER supports three core practices of style exploration, including interpreting references, trying out stylistic possibilities, and reflecting on how emerging styles may be received. Specifically, AER enabled artists to (1) analyze artworks into interpretable stylistic elements, (2) have controllable experimentation guided by their own choices, and (3) resituate emerging styles through simulated social perspectives. We implemented AER in a prototype system and evaluated it in a controlled study with 16 artists. Compared with a direct style-transfer workflow, AER increased artists' agency and reflection as they pursued new stylistic directions. A two-week field study with four artists revealed how the AER framework influenced daily style exploration, such as reflection, experimentation, and stylistic decision-making at each stage. We discuss opportunities and challenges in designing AI-assisted style-exploration workflows, and outline implications for future artistic support tools.

0.68

Beyond Explicit Intent: Discovering and Shaping Artistic Intent through Human-AI Co-Creation

cs.AI cs.CVcs.HC ·2026-10-15 ·Renye Yan, Jialun Zhong, Jikang Cheng, Yi Gao, Yanzeng Li +1 more
similarity 0.72
Abstract · Human-AI Co-Creation, Reinforcement Learning

Generative AI is becoming an important medium for artistic creation, yet existing interactions often assume that creators can specify intentions in advance and accurately communicate them through text prompts. Artistic intentions, however, may be vague, latent, or recognizable only after seeing concrete visual possibilities. We propose a human-AI co-creation paradigm beyond explicit intent expression. By expanding model exploration, we expose artists to diverse visual possibilities, allowing them to identify previously unarticulated preferences through observation, comparison, and selection. We then integrate artists' curatorial judgments into reinforcement learning, assigning different learning strengths based on preferences over generation trajectories, so recognized directions are more strongly reinforced and the model gradually adapts to individual aesthetics. This creates a continuous "explore-identify-shape-re-explore" loop in which artistic intent is progressively discovered, externalized, and shaped. Through three user studies, we examine latent-preference discovery, personalized preference alignment, and the externalization of vague, difficult-to-express creative intentions.

0.37

Drawing the Line: Where AI Guidance and Human Creativity Meet in Emotion-Driven Comic Storyboarding

cs.HC ·2026-10-06 ·Jocelyn Shen, Isabella Pu, Alessandro Briseño, Hyun Kim, Fiona Lu +3 more
published similarity 0.72
Abstract · Copyright protected by IEEE, 10 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables, in proceedings of 14th International Conference on Affective Computing and Intel…

While generative AI models can produce visually faithful artwork, they often fall short in conveying emotional authenticity--a key driver of human expression. In visual storytelling, particularly comic storyboarding, this gap becomes pronounced: effective storyboards require both technical knowledge (e.g., anatomical accuracy or scenic composition) and emotional insight (from lived experience). We explore how human-AI collaboration can support emotion-driven creativity, where the user's feelings guide generation and emotional resonance is the goal. We present EmoToon, a technology probe that helps non-professional artists generate sketch-like storyboards and iterate on visual ideas. In a controlled study with N=25 participants, we find that AI assistance significantly improves emotional expression, aesthetic quality, and exploration, but reduces users' creative ownership. Our findings offer broader insights for human-AI co-creation in the domain of comic storytelling, emphasizing balance between output quality and user freedom, and raising new challenges for image generation models in this domain.

0.20

Reflecting on Creative-Boundaries with an AI Co-Doodler

cs.HC cs.AIcs.GR ·2026-10-04 ·Samia Menon, Samyukta Jayaram, Chetan Goenka, Shm Garanganao Almeda
similarity 0.70
Abstract · In Proceedings of The First Reflection in Creative Experience (RiCE) Workshop (RiCE W1) arXiv:2607.24558

In this pictorial, we consider how the negotiation of creative boundaries with a co-creative AI system can create moments for personal creative reflection. We ground this in our experiences with Froggi-Draw, a single-initiative co-doodling system that gives users power to decide when and how much an AI "collaborator" (Froggi) contributes to their drawing. From a 1-week pilot study where (n=8) novice and experienced artists doodled daily with the system, we report on ways participants navigated creative risk and uncertainty, and how their usage and perceptions of Froggi shifted over time. In moments of disruption, participants described the system as encroaching on their creative territory. We consider how the design of a supportive, co-creative AI "collaborator" might look like the design of a supportive power dynamic---and finding ways to offer users control to find, reflect upon, and flexibly negotiate the boundaries of that dynamic.

0.12

reComposer: Editable Planning for Controllable Image Generation

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-11-09 ·Susie S. Y. Li, Angie Boggust, Fred Hohman, Donghao Ren, Dominik Moritz +1 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 21 pages, 14 figures, 4 tables

Prompt-based image generation makes it easy to produce visual assets, but offers little support for engaging with the creative process. Prompting collapses interdependent creative decisions into a monolithic instruction and returns a finished image, leaving control limited to revising the prompt or correcting the model's output. We present reComposer, a process-oriented image-generation interface built around editable planning, which decomposes users' evolving intent into meaningful creative decisions - such as subject, composition, or palette - and collaborates with users to explore underspecified goals and alternatives. reComposer supports conversational and direct manipulation of the plan, moving between concept-level intent and visual-level control. We evaluated reComposer with 8 design and non-design professionals. Compared to prompting, participants felt greater control and ownership while developing visual assets, exploring alternatives, and iterating on details. Our findings suggest how shifting generative AI interaction from specifying outputs to shaping process can support creative thinking alongside asset production.

0.12

DesignTaste: Benchmarking AI-Generator Visual Design Against Award-Wining Works

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-11-12 ·Zhou Chen, JiaXiang Li, DanYing Pan, Ye Li, TianRui Yang +12 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · 31 pages, 12 figures, including appendices. Code and data: https://github.com/ArtArk-AI/DesignTaste

Text-to-image benchmarks commonly assess text-image alignment or overall preference. Whether models can produce good designs when a brief leaves the appearance open remains less well understood. We introduce DesignTaste, a visual design benchmark that compares generated images with award-winning works. From these works and their publicly available context, we derive 403 design briefs: 100 poster tasks from 100 Beste Plakate 2025 and 303 tasks spanning 20 categories from ADC 2026. Six leading commercial text-to-image models each generate an image from the same brief. A single model judge scores each output and the corresponding award-winning work independently on five evaluation dimensions. On each dataset, only ArtArk achieves a higher mean overall score than the award-winning works. All six models score lower in Creative Originality on both datasets. These results show that producing finished, visually appealing images does not imply that a model can develop good design solutions.

0.40

AI-Experiment: an augmented reality art project co-created with artificial intelligence

cs.CV ·2026-09-29 ·Bernhard Egger, Hans Furer
publishedcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · presented and published at AI for Visual Arts Workshop and Challenges (AI4VA) in conjunction with European Conference on Computer Vision (EC…

We describe the creation of a physical artwork that was performed in synergy between an artist, a computer scientist and generative AI tools. A latent diffusion model was finetuned on photographs of the artwork of the specific artist and the generative model then generated synthetic artworks in a similar style. From the generated artworks a subset was selected to be painted again with acrylic on canvas by the original artist. In addition to the physical artifact an augmented reality component was added which brings the artwork to life with a set of generative video models. Together with this paper we release part of the artwork (training data), the code that was deployed to generate the artwork as well as the augmented reality experience for arts, research and education under https://github.com/BernhardEgger/ARTimate

0.45

Exploring the Affordances of Generative Image AI for Supporting Early-stage Architect-client Communication

cs.HC ·2026-09-28 ·Chengzhi Zhang, Weijie Wang
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 18 pages

Text-to-image generative AI can produce renderings from natural-language prompts in near real time, making it increasingly popular for rapidly visualizing concepts in early-stage architectural design. Meanwhile, exchanging ideas efficiently and building shared understanding have long been central challenges in architect-client communication. How might the speed of generative image AI change this communication? To explore this question, we conducted a study with 11 architect-client pairs, in which each pair used generative image AI over video conference to collaboratively produce early-stage renderings of the client's "dream house." Our findings suggest that generative image AI helped pairs develop a solid shared understanding by providing concrete visual materials and supporting the exchange of ideas. It also shifted conversation dynamics, enabling clients to participate more actively in shaping design direction. However, challenges emerged, including a stylistic bias toward particular types of images and unpredictable shifts in design direction caused by variation across generations. We conclude with implications for the design of future generative image AI-based systems that support architect-client communication.

0.13