CS Paper Radar

How Fragile Is Your Watermark? Training-Free Structural Removal of Neural Audio Watermarks

Likhith Kumara

cs.SD ·submitted 2026-08-17 13:34 UTC · v1
publishedbenchmark

Abstract

Neural audio watermarks are increasingly used to attribute and detect AI-generated speech, so their practical value rests on how cheaply an adversary can remove them. Robustness is usually measured by running a fixed battery of distortions blindly against every scheme. We instead make removal diagnostic: from a few clean/watermarked pairs we compute cheap structural probes that reveal where a watermark sits in the signal (its embedding domain), then apply a single domain-matched attack rather than a blind sweep. We further summarize each scheme with one threshold-free fragility score, the area under its accuracy-versus-quality trade-off, which an accuracy-only benchmark cannot provide. Across ten watermarking schemes the probes separate fragile from robust marks: for magnitude and carrier-domain watermarks a single matched attack erases the payload (WavMark, SilentCipher, audiowmark) or removes the detection flag (AudioSeal) at high objective quality (PESQ >= 3.6), whereas latent-domain marks (VoiceMark, WMCodec, AlignMark, AWARE) resist every training-free attack we apply. The same pair-only probe signatures also identify which watermarking scheme is present (84% over ten schemes).

Comment
Accepted at APSIPA ASC 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Vulnerability of Neural Audio Watermarks under Speech Enhancement

cs.SD cs.CR ·2026-09-24 ·Xincong Zhong, Shengyao Wang, Lingfeng Yao, Yihang Bao, Jinze Yu +2 more
similarity 0.75
Abstract

Neural audio watermarks are increasingly deployed in commercial speech generation systems to make AI-generated speech traceable, yet their robustness has been studied mainly under conventional signal distortions. Since a watermark can be regarded as imperceptible noise added to the speech signal, a natural question is whether speech enhancement (SE), as a denoising model, can remove it. In this paper, we cascade Gaussian noise with SE models as a black-box watermark removal attack, covering both discriminative and generative SE paradigms, against six neural watermarks: AudioSeal, WavMark, SilentCipher, Timbre, Perth, and AlignMark. Experimental results show that the proposed attack significantly outperforms existing neural re-synthesis methods in watermark removal. In particular, we find that generative SE, which reconstructs the harmonic regions of speech while denoising, is highly destructive to watermarks. These findings show that SE poses a serious threat to current audio watermarking methods, and we call for SE-aware robustness evaluation in watermark design.

0.41

No Time to Collapse: Unlocking Robustness and Multiplexed Capacity in Frozen Audio Watermarkers

cs.SD ·2026-09-24 ·Xuanye Wang, Linxi Li, Yechen Wang, Liwei Jin, Qianwei Guo +1 more
position similarity 0.72
Abstract

Modern neural audio watermarking systems typically embed a message repeatedly across time and then collapse the resulting temporal evidence into a single payload using averaging, voting, or another fixed aggregation rule. We argue that this temporal collapse limits both robustness and the recovery of multiple payloads, and that the limitation can be addressed without retraining the underlying watermarker. We freeze a pretrained watermarker's encoder and detector and train only a low-latency Conformer-based decoder. The decoder consumes the detector's temporal soft outputs, which a system-specific adapter pools into a sequence of window-level representations, and predicts the embedded message. On three frozen watermarkers (AURA, AudioSeal, and WavMark), the learned decoder improves recovery of attacked messages and yields higher detection AUROC point estimates on all three. Under controlled full- and partial-coverage multiplexing, it improves joint-exact recovery of two alternating payload words by 9.7-48.0, 6.9-17.3, and 8.2-14.2 percentage points, respectively, under one to three chained attacks on feasible clips.

0.19

Averaging Collusion Breaks Traceability in Personalized Neural Audio Watermarking

cs.SD cs.CR ·2026-11-03 ·Yangming Liu, Haiyun Li, Dongfu Song, Ziang Xu, Jiehui Luo +2 more
code/data similarity 0.72
Abstract · 5 pages, 4 figures, 4 tables. Submitted to ICASSP 2027. Code and results available at https://github.com/Silwan5z/neural-audio-watermark-col…

Personalized neural audio watermarking systems embed user-specific payloads into audio to trace the user associated with a leaked or misused copy. Existing evaluations mainly assume access to a single personalized copy, but real-world distribution may expose multiple copies of the same recording. We find that simple sample-wise averaging breaks traceability: averaging only two copies produces tracing-failure rates of 87.7-99.7% across the five systems while largely preserving audio quality. Decoder outputs show distinct responses to coalition payload composition across systems, with high majority agreement in TimbreWM but substantially lower agreement in WMCodec. In a more sophisticated payload-aware setting, mixture weighting can further steer the decoder toward a selected nonmember, achieving a target success rate of 92.3% in TimbreWM. Preliminary confidence screening rejects many collusion-induced assignments while retaining most valid single-copy outputs. Code and results are available at https://github.com/Silwan5z/neural-audio-watermark-collusion-attack. This work highlights multi-copy traceability as an additional evaluation dimension for personalized neural audio watermarking alongside conventional single-copy robustness.

0.31

CRAW: Codec Robust Audio Watermarking

cs.SD cs.CRcs.LG ·2026-09-02 ·David Chernin, Ethan Fetaya
code/data similarity 0.72
Abstract

Recent advances in generative speech models have made it increasingly difficult to distinguish authentic from synthetic audio, enabling new forms of fraud and misinformation. Audio watermarking offers a promising defense by embedding an imperceptible signal into generated speech that can later be detected to verify its provenance. However, recent studies have shown that existing post-hoc watermarking methods fail under neural codecs and denoisers, transformations routinely applied during real-world storage, transmission, and processing, severely limiting their practical utility. Here we introduce CRAW, a codec-robust audio watermarking framework that jointly improves robustness against neural re-synthesis while maintaining high perceptual quality. CRAW combines distortion-aware training with an attention-based pooling mechanism, inference-time perceptual mask- ing, and an error-correcting code to recover the fidelity lost during robust training. Experiments demonstrate that CRAW achieves state-of-the-art robustness against neural codecs, denoisers, and vocoders while maintaining perceptual quality comparable to existing post-hoc watermarking methods. The code is available at https://github.com/DavidC1212/craw.

0.46

SweepMark: Query-Free and High-Fidelity Attacks on Robust Audio Watermarking

cs.CR ·2026-09-27 ·Weikang Ding, Binhao Ma, Hanqing Guo, Rui Duan
hot direction similarity 0.71
Abstract

Audio watermarking embeds imperceptible signals into speech to trace misuse in text-to-speech (TTS) synthesis. Existing removal attacks may retain watermark-related artifacts or degrade speech quality when suppressing them. We propose SweepMark, a query-free black-box attack that targets these artifacts without access to target watermarking models or paired clean and watermarked samples. Our key insight is that watermark embedding introduces spectral patterns that are not fully aligned with natural speech, including persistent structures that conventional speech enhancement may retain. Diverse Artifact Learning extracts complementary stationary and non-stationary patterns, using customized spectral artifacts added to public speech to learn persistent structures without target watermark examples. Adaptive Artifact Scaling then combines and amplifies these patterns for subtraction while constraining distortion. Across two speech datasets and four watermarking methods, SweepMark achieves average attack success rates of 92% and 96%, with higher perceptual quality scores overall than the evaluated adaptive attacks. Automatic speech recognition evaluation indicates that linguistic content is largely preserved. Further experiments with three TTS systems show high attack success against two synthesis-resistant watermarking methods in speech generated after fine-tuning on attacked recordings.

0.21

Tokens Change, Structure Endures: Spectral Watermarking for Generated Speech

cs.SD cs.CLcs.CRcs.LG+1 ·2026-09-27 ·Kanghwi Lee, Kyeongseok Jeong, Jeongmin Liu
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Watermarking is a promising tool for establishing the provenance of AI-generated speech. While many neural audio watermarking methods rely on a separately trained watermark generator, token-level watermarking is a training-free alternative that operates directly during generation. Its main weakness is retokenization: decoding generated speech to a waveform and encoding it again can change token identities and erode the watermark. To make the watermark robust to these changes, we propose Redwing, REtokenization-Durable Watermarking IN Generation. It builds a graph from the token substitutions observed under retokenization, whose Laplacian yields a basis that assigns similar values to tokens likely to substitute for one another. Over this basis, embedding and detection functions are jointly optimized to preserve watermark signal through retokenization while limiting embedding distortion and detector variability on unwatermarked speech. On the Moshi full-duplex system, after eight consecutive passes of Mimi resynthesis, Redwing achieves 80.7% TPR at a calibrated 1% FPR, compared with 8.3% for KGW and at most 7.3% for WMAR. It also has the highest TPR after eight passes through three other neural codecs (77.5-93.0%), and the gains generalize to TTS models at a speech-quality cost close to that of KGW. These results show that retokenization is not merely a source of noise: its transition structure can be exploited as a design principle for robust token-level watermarking.

0.21

NeuMark: Neural Codec Resynthesis-Robust Audio Watermarking in the Codec Latent Space

cs.SD ·2026-09-22 ·Annan Wu, Wen-Chin Huang, Tomoki Toda
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Audio watermarking is increasingly important for tracing generated speech. Several audio watermarking methods have been proposed to embed the watermark in various domains, such as waveform, timbre feature, or latent representations, for making the embedded watermark robust against traditional digital signal processing (DSP) attacks. On the other hand, modern neural codecs introduce a different threat from DSP attacks: they resynthesize speech through quantized acoustic representations and can remove the embedded watermark evi- dence that is not aligned with codec-preserved structure. In this paper, we propose NeuMark, a codec-latent audio watermarking framework that embeds watermark evidence into SpeechTok- enizer acoustic tokens to address this resynthesis threat. NeuMark uses cross-attention to inject a 16-bit message across residual vector quantization (RVQ) layers, distributing the watermark over codec-aligned latent structure. Experimental results show that NeuMark substantially improves robustness under neural- codec resynthesis while supporting both watermark detection and message recovery. We also analyze the trade-off between reconstruction-referenced transparency and original-referenced robustness.

0.36

Cross-Codec Robustness in Speech Watermarking

eess.AS ·2026-11-03 ·Olli-Pekka Pauna, Xin Wang, Lauri Juvela
similarity 0.70
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Generative speech models synthesize audio that is difficult to distinguish from human recordings. Synthetic speech can be watermarked as a proactive disclosure method, but watermarking models remain vulnerable to resynthesis attacks using neural audio codecs. This article investigates speech watermarking robustness across neural codec and digital signal processing attacks, when specific neural codecs are used for channel augmentation during training. We also present a novel zero-bit watermarking system that uses Descript Audio Codec as the generator. Our results demonstrate that the choice of augmentation codec significantly influences robustness generalization. Experiments show that augmentation with low-bitrate, high-quality neural codecs-Mimi and SNAC-results in promising robustness against unseen neural codecs and traditional attacks with limited quality impact.

0.11