CS Paper Radar

Rigorous Statements and Proofs of the Lemmas in Simon's Algorithm for the Dihedral Coset Problem and Their Underlying Hypothesis

Yuchen Guo, Shuo Yang

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-08-17 13:53 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

In a recent preprint, Simon proposed a polynomial-time quantum algorithm for the Dihedral Coset Problem and rested the analysis on four lemmas. Three of them carry only proof sketches, and this paper gives each of those three a statement that admits a single reading together with a complete proof. Lemma 1 follows from an exact second-moment computation for the subset-sum counts, and it holds with probability tending to one in place of the constant originally claimed. The amplitude bound of Lemma 3 follows from an exact Parseval identity on the cube of measurement outcomes and holds at every threshold with no well-behavedness hypothesis, so that predicate leaves the argument entirely. For Lemma 4, we compute both balls-in-bins covariances exactly and find that the second carries a term a fixed ball count leaves out. The assumption that the distinguished group contains no faulty samples can also be dropped. The two branch amplitudes share a signed prefactor, so the counting estimates control their difference and not the ratio the lemma states. We prove the additive form and show that the closing argument consumes nothing more than that. A single hypothesis survives all of this. It asks that the partition into the two sides be fixed independently of the measured string, and the rule the algorithm gives for choosing that partition does not supply it. Establishing these four lemmas therefore does not by itself establish the correctness of the algorithm.

Comment
19 pages, 1 figure

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Fourier-Label Information-Loss Barrier for Dihedral Coset Algorithms

cs.CR quant-ph ·2026-09-30 ·Aparna Gupte, Seyoon Ragavan, Mark Zhandry
theory similarity 0.75
Abstract

We establish a no-go theorem for a broad class of quantum algorithms for the dihedral coset problem (DCP). We consider the Fourier-sampling and subset-sum-measurement template proposed by Regev (SIAM Journal on Computing, 2004), which is one of the main approaches to solving DCP. Suppose that, after measuring the lower $n-1$ bits of the subset sum, the algorithm discards any $ω(\log n)$ bits from each of the Fourier labels. Then we prove that the algorithm cannot succeed in solving DCP. This shows that any algorithm following this template must make extensive use of the Fourier labels, and thus serves as a useful guide for developing algorithms for DCP. As a main application, we show that the recent algorithm by Simon (IACR ePrint:2026/1591, August 11 2026) does not solve DCP. We show that after the subset-sum measurement, this algorithm can be implemented (up to exponentially-small error) using only the most-significant third of the Fourier labels, and is therefore subject to our general no-go theorem. To help with verifiability, we release Lean 4 code for our results.

0.22

Beyond LWE: Post-Quantum Assumptions under a Counterfactual Break of the Dihedral Coset Problem

cs.CR ·2026-10-27 ·Ramses Fernandez
survey similarity 0.65
Abstract

A refuted 2026 claim of an efficient quantum algorithm for the Dihedral Coset Problem (DCP) motivates this survey of the consequences of a genuine breakthrough. We distinguish a noiseless cyclic coset-state solver, a solver with a prescribed failure exponent, and an extrapolated-state solver. Regev's rare-corruption observation already makes the first hypothesis sufficient for lattice algorithms at some polynomial approximation factors; the witnessing algorithm determines the quantitative bounds. We compose unstructured reductions with explicit sample, state-preparation and success conditions, and compare their sufficient guarantees with more than thirty lattice and non-lattice assumptions. We restate the structured state conversion of Wen and Zheng and audit its forward parameter certificate; the printed bound supplies no certificate at the ML-KEM ring and modulus. We use an explicit affine embedding for heuristic gap estimates, explain the lossiness connection from decision NTRU to search Ring-LWE, and distinguish ordinary from module uniqueness. Chen's withdrawn 2024 quantum algorithm for LWE and a proposed repair of its post-processing would, if correct, reach only a many-sample, small-noise LWE regime that the failure-exponent hypothesis already covers for exponents below $1/2$, and no deployed parameter set. Tables separate rigorous consequences, heuristic comparisons and unverified applications, and distinguish solving a proof assumption from attacking a scheme. Classical structural attacks on Classic McEliece, which do not involve DCP but put the concrete security of the scheme under revision, are summarised here and analysed in detail in a companion paper. The survey closes with open questions and a scenario-planning checklist that requires a complete efficient reduction.

0.37

Planted Cliques and Quantum Symmetry-Adapted Measurements

cs.CC quant-ph ·2026-09-30 ·Vojtech Havlicek, Jordan Docter, Subhash Khot
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract · 21 pages, no figures. Revised it to improve clarity and readability. VH takes responsibility for the previous submission prepared under a ti…

We study how quantum encodings and symmetry-adapted measurements preserve information for planted-clique detection from one classical graph. For $k=\lfloor n^{1/2-\varepsilon}\rfloor$, with fixed $0<\varepsilon<1/2$, detection is statistically possible but conjectured hard for polynomial-time classical algorithms. For a compact binary phase encoding, we prove that constant-advantage detection requires $Ω(n^{1+2\varepsilon}\ln^2 n)$ copies of the phase state of the same graph, even under arbitrary joint measurements. In the large-copy limit, the optimal decision rule thresholds the total number of $k$-cliques in the graph and its complement, but this characterization provides no efficient detector. We therefore explore measurements guided by the symmetries of the input distributions, starting with the efficient Schur transform on the full graph register. We show that weak Schur sampling, which measures only the representation label, depends only on edge count and has vanishing distinguishing power in this regime. When the label and multiplicity registers are discarded, the remaining quantum states are almost perfectly distinguishable. We show that the support of the planted state occupies only a vanishing fraction of the graph Hilbert space. Any subspace containing it still permits near-perfect detection if its relative dimension also vanishes. This gives us freedom to choose a subspace that is easier to measure. We propose exploring subgroup isotypic measurements to find such subspaces. Whether they can yield an efficient detector remains open. Finally, we show that a single supplied coherent quantum sample permits efficient detection, yielding a conditional computational separation from one classical sample under quantum planted-clique hardness.

0.32

An alternate proof of the QMA lower bound for set-size estimation

cs.CC quant-ph ·2026-11-16 ·Chinmay Nirkhe
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 5 pages

In the set-size estimation query task, a query algorithm decides whether an $N$-bit input has Hamming weight $\ge B$ or $\le A$ (with $\ge B$ as the yes instances and $\le A$ as the no instances). When $B = 2A$, this is sometimes called approximate counting. The query complexity for this problem with a quantum witness (i.e., $\mathsf{QMA}$ query bounds) was resolved by Aaronson, Kothari, Kretschmer, and Thaler (CCC 2020) and proved using Laurent polynomials. Here we give a morally similar but distinct proof of the lower bound using the polynomial method.

0.35

Quantum Fine-Grained Lower Bounds for SetDisjointness via Sub-Linear Reductions from 3SUM

cs.CC cs.DSquant-ph ·2026-09-30 ·Jeremy Huang, Young Kun Ko, Chunhao Wang
hot direction similarity 0.62
Abstract

In classical fine-grained complexity, the 3SUM Conjecture is used to prove a variety of conditional lower bounds on data structure and graph problems via an initial reduction to the SetDisjointness problem. However, there is an $\tilde{O}(n)$-time quantum algorithm for 3SUM and a direct application of Grover's algorithm to SetDisjointness queries beats the state-of-the-art classical conditional bound by Kopelowitz, Pettie, and Porat (SODA 2016); this shows that these classical bounds do not apply in the quantum setting. Thus establishing analogous conditional lower bounds in the quantum setting requires applying the quantum 3SUM Conjecture to a \emph{quantum} fine-grained reduction from 3SUM to SetDisjointness. We give the first sub-linear time quantum reductions from 3SUM to online SetDisjointness. Via our reduction, the quantum 3SUM conjecture implies a $p + 2q \geqslant 1$ tradeoff bound for quantum SetDisjointness algorithms with $O(N^p)$ preprocessing time and $O(N^q)$ query time. We also give an analogous reduction from 3XOR. These results are derived from a general framework for fine-grained reductions to SetDisjointness which applies to any Abelian 3-Orthogonal Array (3OA) problem with suitable almost-linear hash functions.

0.27

The Most Informative Bit and Beyond: A Proof of the Courtade--Kumar Conjecture and Multibit Extensions

cs.IT ·2026-09-22 ·Hessam Mahdavifar, Ahmad Beirami
benchmarktheoryhighly cited similarity 0.61
Abstract

Let \(X=(X_1,\ldots,X_n)\) be uniform on the Boolean cube, and let \(Y\) be obtained by passing its coordinates independently through a binary symmetric channel with crossover probability \(p\). For a \(k\)-bit quantizer \(Q(X)\), reporting \(k\) input coordinates retains \(k(1-h_2(p))\) bits of information, making coordinate projections a natural quantization benchmark. For \(k=1\), this is the Courtade--Kumar conjecture: every Boolean function \(f\) satisfies \(I(f(X);Y)\leq 1-h_2(p)\), with equality for coordinate functions. We prove the conjecture in every dimension and for every crossover probability, without a balance assumption. The proof tracks the information gap relative to a coordinate as the channel correlation varies. After a monotone rearrangement, an entropy-flow identity relates the derivative of this gap to the edge boundary of the associated Boolean decision set. A sharp local entropy comparison, Fourier analysis, and logarithmic Sobolev estimates for pivotal sets imply that any positive gap must grow as the noise decreases, contradicting its nonpositive value at the noiseless endpoint. For \(k\geq8\), a coding-theoretic phenomenon emerges. We construct a shortened-Hamming-code quantizer that beats the coordinate benchmark for \(k=8\), and a direct-sum argument extends the failure to every \(k\geq8\). Thus structured coding can retain more information than coordinate selection. Exhaustive searches within several structured code families and Monte Carlo searches over random codebooks for \(2\leq k\leq7\) find that structured codebooks outperform random ones but remain below the coordinate benchmark. This motivates our conjecture that coordinate projections are optimal for \(2\leq k\leq7\).

0.48

Comments on the recent improvements of the MRRW bounds

cs.IT math.COquant-ph ·2026-09-01 ·Alexander Barg
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 17 pages. This note contains a set of comments on the results in Chapter 2 of the OpenAI manuscript "Ten Advances in Mathematics and Theoret…

The asymptotic McEliece--Rodemich--Rumsey--Welch bound (1977) limits the largest attainable rate of binary codes as a function of the relative distance. After a nearly half-century hiatus, this result was recently improved in two concurrent works, by OpenAI and by O. Alrabiah and V. Guruswami. The two arguments look entirely different, a Delsarte certificate on the one hand, a classical-quantum channel and the pretty good measurement on the other, and they yield the same bound. The purpose of this note is to explain why: in both proofs, a subspace is attached to every codeword and moved with it, and the bound counts how many such subspaces fit in the ambient space, exactly in the first case and in the probabilistic sense of typicality in the second. We also present the OpenAI proof in the language and context of coding theory, as an extension of the spectral method in which the single vector attached to a codeword is replaced by a subspace.

0.47

Nearly Optimal Quantum Sample Complexity of Learning Fourier-Sparse Boolean Functions

cs.CC quant-phcs.DS ·2026-10-13 ·Zekun Ye
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

We study the number of uniform quantum examples needed to exactly learn a Boolean function with at most $k$ nonzero Fourier coefficients. We give a learner with near-optimal $\widetilde{O}(k)$ sample complexity independent of the input length $n$. The learner uses only separate measurements of individual examples. This improves the previous $O(k^{3/2}\log^2 k)$ upper bound (Arunachalam, Chakraborty, Lee, Paraashar, and de Wolf, 2021). The main ingredient is a candidate set formed by symmetric differences of subsets from independent groups of Fourier samples. A multilinear majority polynomial combines unbiased random approximations into an accurate witness whose Fourier support lies in this set. Granularity then forces the set to contain the entire Fourier support, including subsets never directly sampled. For comparison, we derive the tight classical sample complexity $Θ(nk)$ by combining known sparse-recovery and lower-bound results.

0.05