CS Paper Radar

Tight Inapproximability of Pacing and Throttling Equilibria in Second-Price Auctions

Zhengyang Liu

cs.GT cs.CC ·submitted 2026-08-17 15:06 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Budget-constrained advertisers commonly rely on two control mechanisms: pacing scales bids, whereas throttling randomizes participation. We prove that, in second-price auctions, these two different mechanisms share the same sharp approximation-hardness threshold. For pacing, computing a $γ$-approximate equilibrium is $\mathsf{PPAD}$-hard for every constant $γ\in[0,1)$. For throttling, computing a $δ$-approximate equilibrium is $\mathsf{PPAD}$-hard for every constant $δ\in(0,1)$. At parameter $1$, the complementarity requirement becomes vacuous and the all-zero solution is feasible. That is, approximation does not eliminate the fixed-point barrier at any nontrivial parameter value.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Pacing Equilibria in Abstract Mechanisms

cs.GT ·2026-09-23 ·Salam Afiouni, Christian Kroer
benchmarktheory similarity 0.75
Abstract

Digital platforms increasingly rely on automated budget-management systems to regulate participation across allocation opportunities. A common tool is multiplicative pacing, which scales buyers' bids so that campaign-level budgets are spent gradually. Although pacing is operationally simple, its aggregate behavior depends on the underlying mechanism. In first-price single-item auction markets, pacing enjoys strong structural and computational properties that often fail in second-price auctions. It is unclear whether these properties extend to richer platform mechanisms. We develop a unified theory of pacing equilibria across a hierarchy of mechanisms. We first show that, even in first-price position auctions, the market-equilibrium interpretation of the single-item benchmark can fail. We then identify bid-maximizing pay-your-bid mechanisms as a broad class in which pacing equilibria exist, are unique, and admit an Eisenberg-Gale-type convex-program characterization. This implies efficient computation, Pareto-efficiency, and liquid-welfare guarantees, enabling pacing integration into large-scale optimization-based allocation routines. Finally, for abstract mechanisms satisfying a payment monotonicity condition, we prove equilibrium existence by smoothing discontinuities. With additional conditions and appropriate tie-breaking, we obtain uniqueness, revenue maximality among budget-feasible pacing vectors, and shill-proof implementability, and provide convergent budget-adjustment dynamics for approximate equilibria. Overall, many favorable properties of first-price pacing extend beyond single-item auctions under appropriate mechanism-level conditions.

0.29

FIXP-Completeness in Second-Price Auctions

cs.GT cs.CC ·2026-10-31 ·Nobutaka Shimizu
theory similarity 0.73
Abstract

Computing equilibria is a fundamental algorithmic problem in game theory and economics. Although general frameworks are available for proving membership in FIXP, the class capturing exact fixed-point computation, establishing FIXP-completeness often remains challenging. We prove FIXP-completeness of exact equilibrium computation in three second-price auction models: (1). pacing with return-on-investment constraints, with multiplier cap $1+δ$ for every fixed rational $δ>0$ [Filos-Ratsikas, Hansen, Høgh, and Hollender (2024)]; (2). budget-constrained generalized second-price sponsored shopping [Hansen, Li, and Nie (2026)]; (3). budget-constrained throttling [Liu (2026)]. These results resolve open questions on the exact complexity of automated bidding. Our technical ingredient is a FIXP-complete generalized-circuit problem using only clipped affine gates and the reciprocal $x\mapsto1/(1+τx)$, for any fixed positive rational $τ$. This gate basis provides a common framework for the three auction reductions: simulating these gates in each model establishes FIXP-hardness without directly implementing multiplication or squaring.

0.15

On the Complexity of Exact Autobidding Equilibria

cs.GT cs.CC ·2026-11-03 ·Yiyang Huang, Zhengyang Liu, Yonglei Yan
similarity 0.70
Abstract · Full version with appendices

Autobidding equilibria link advertisers' value multipliers or participation probabilities through aggregate budget and return-on-investment (ROI) constraints. We establish the exact computational complexity of finding these equilibria across several canonical settings: exact equilibrium computation is $\mathsf{FIXP}$-complete for second-price ROI pacing, budget- or ROI-constrained generalized second-price (GSP) sponsored shopping, and second-price throttling. Furthermore, approximating the equilibrium control vector in distance to a true equilibrium is $\mathsf{FIXP}_{a}$-complete when the target accuracy is provided as input.

0.10

Nash Equilibria in Auctions with Pacing Strategies: Complexity and Inefficiency

cs.GT cs.CC ·2026-09-28 ·Aris Filos-Ratsikas, Charalampos Kokkalis, Mohamad Latifian
publishedtheory similarity 0.69
Abstract · 29 pages, to appear in The 22nd Conference on Web and Internet Economics (WINE 2026)

We introduce and study Auctions with Pacing Strategies (APS) games, a full-information model in which utility-maximizing bidders compete across many simultaneous first-price auctions, each choosing a single pacing multiplier that uniformly scales their values into bids. We settle three central questions. First, we show that there are instances that admit no approximate pure Nash equilibria. Then, we prove that the problem of deciding whether an APS game admits an (approximate) equilibrium is NP-complete in general, but can be solved in polynomial time if either the number of bidders or the number of items is fixed. Finally, when an equilibrium does exist, we characterize its inefficiency exactly, showing that both the Price of Anarchy and the Price of Stability equal $\frac{e}{e-1}$.

0.34

Computing Multi-Slot First-Price Pacing Equilibria at Scale via Entropic Smoothing

cs.GT math.OC ·2026-10-16 ·Yuchen Xie, Shenyinying Tu, Yuan Gao, Yi Zhang, Deepak Kumar
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 40 pages, 6 figures, 5 tables

Pacing equilibria describe how budget-constrained advertisers clear an ad market, but computing one at production scale is hard when every request fills several slots: the allocation jumps whenever two campaigns' scores cross. We consider the first-price pacing equilibrium (FPPE) of auctions with $K$ homogeneous slots and unit-demand campaigns, whose Eisenberg-Gale dual reduces, via a TopK identity, to a convex program over bids. Regularizing each request's allocation with the binary (Fermi-Dirac) entropy gives a smooth, strictly convex dual whose gradient is exactly spend minus budget and whose evaluation splits into independent one-dimensional threshold solves, one per request. The smoothed equilibrium converges to the hard one at an explicit $O(\sqrt{T})$ rate, and a duality gap certifies how far any bids are from the hard equilibrium. We implement an efficient multi-GPU solver and test it on a production ad workload. We use it to compute an equilibrium price anchor: each campaign's hindsight equilibrium cost per key result.

0.12

Efficiency of Generalized Proportional First-Price Auctions Under Auto-bidding

cs.GT ·2026-09-30 ·Yang Cai, Vineet Gupta, Yanchen Jiang, Christopher Liaw, Aranyak Mehta +2 more
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Auto-bidding is now widely adopted in online advertising platforms, allowing advertisers to specify high-level campaign objectives--such as maximizing total value subject to a return-on-spend (ROS) constraint--rather than manual per-query bids. A central question in algorithmic mechanism design is characterizing the worst-case efficiency loss, or Price of Anarchy (PoA), across auction formats in this prior-free setting. While randomized auctions are known to strictly improve efficiency over deterministic mechanisms for two bidders, two fundamental questions have remained open: (1) what is the optimal PoA for two bidders, and (2) can any mechanism beat the barrier of 2 for general $n \ge 3$ bidders? We resolve both questions using the family of $r$-proportional first-price auctions ($\text{pFPA}_r$), in which each bidder wins with probability proportional to their bid raised to an exponent $r > 0$ and pays their bid upon winning. First, for two bidders, we prove that the standard proportional first-price auction ($r = 1$) achieves a tight $\text{PoA} \le 1.5$, complemented by a matching lower bound showing that no anonymous, monotone mechanism can do better. Second, for general $n \ge 2$ bidders, setting $r = 2n$ achieves $\text{PoA} \le 2 - \frac{1}{4n+1} = 2 - Ω(1/n)$ across all undominated bid profiles, breaking the deterministic barrier of 2 for every finite $n$ and asymptotically matching the known $2 - Θ(1/n)$ lower bound.

0.46

Impossibility of No-Regret in Multi-Agent Bidding

cs.GT cs.CCcs.LG ·2026-10-27 ·Zongjun Yang, Rachitesh Kumar, Christian Kroer
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

We consider $T$ repeated second-price auctions across $n$ pacing bidders with i.i.d. item arrivals, and show that it is computationally impossible for all bidders to achieve no-regret simultaneously while satisfying their respective budget or return-on-investment constraints. Therefore, in the prominent internet auction systems where buyers simultaneously deploy pacing algorithms or automated bidding agents, we cannot hope to achieve joint no-regret guarantees in general. We establish a deterministic relationship that high variance in online bidding systems implies high regret. By showing that one can extract a pacing equilibrium from a low-variance system, we prove PPAD-hardness of attaining joint no-regret. For several widely used bidding algorithms, we also show evidence from dynamical systems and numerical simulations that they can indeed display high-variance behavior through cycling, even on simple market instances.

0.08

Tight Liquid Welfare Guarantees for Auctions with Budgets via LP Duality

cs.GT ·2026-09-30 ·Twan Kroll, Guido Schäfer, Artem Tsikiridis
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

We study the efficiency of auctions with budget-constrained bidders and derive tight price of anarchy (PoA) bounds for coarse correlated equilibria (CCE). To this end, we develop a general framework that reduces proving PoA guarantees to finding feasible solutions to the dual of a linear program. The LP is formulated over a small number of per-bidder equilibrium statistics, incorporates constraints implied by the auction setting and equilibrium behavior, and captures a novel smoothness notion tailored to budget-constrained environments; we provide a reduction from classical smoothness to this new notion. Our approach enables simple and tight PoA analyses across a broad range of auction formats. Using our framework, we obtain tight liquid welfare guarantees for simultaneous first-price, second-price, and all-pay auctions, simultaneous auctions with restricted uniform bidding interfaces, discriminatory and uniform price multi-unit auctions, and generalized first-price position auctions. Beyond budget-constrained settings, we derive new lower bounds for the budget-free uniform price auction and generalized second-price auction; in particular, our lower bound for the uniform price auction matches the upper bound of $3.146$ by de Keijzer et al. (2013).

0.16