CS Paper Radar

Numerical and perceptual validity of synthetic Head-Related Transfer Functions at scale

Katarina C. Poole, Lorenzo Picinali

eess.AS ·submitted 2026-08-17 15:38 UTC · v2
unusual

Abstract

Individually measuring head-related transfer functions (HRTFs) at scale remains a central challenge for personalised spatial audio, motivating growing interest in synthetic HRTFs. We evaluated the numerical, computational, and behavioural validity of synthetic HRTFs, generated through the boundary element method simulation using Mesh2HRTF, against measured and KEMAR HRTFs using the Extended SONICOM dataset. Across 200 subjects, synthetic HRTFs deviated less from measured than KEMAR in interaural time and level differences, but residual errors, together with elevated spectral distortion, concentrated at low, rear elevations. This is consistent with the omission of torso geometry from the synthesis pipeline. Two computational models revealed a corresponding pattern of predicted localisation errors, with synthetic HRTFs positioned between measured and KEMAR. In a virtual reality localisation task (N = 20), synthetic HRTFs matched measured on every polar metric, while KEMAR was significantly worse. However, behavioural error clustered around the front-back midline regardless of condition, not at the low elevations implicated numerically or by the models. A separate spatial release from masking task (N = 18) showed no effect of HRTF type. Together, these results indicate that high-resolution synthetic HRTFs preserve behavioural localisation performance, despite discrepancies between the numerical/model-predicted bias and the spatial pattern of behavioural error.

Comment
Version 2 clarifies in the pdf this is a preprint submitted to JASA and awaiting review

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond Localisation Accuracy: Sensorimotor Effects of HRTF Individualisation

eess.AS ·2026-09-08 ·Fulvio Missoni, Katarina C. Poole, Tim Murray-Browne, Andrea Canessa, Lorenzo Picinali
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 18 pages, 5 figures

Everyday listening requires the brain to integrate cues from the body, environment, other senses, and movement, continuously translating auditory information into action. Yet HRTF individualisation is still commonly assessed through localisation accuracy, which may not fully capture its effects on this sensorimotor process. Here, we investigate whether these effects can instead be revealed through behaviour in a more ecologically valid listening task. We used an aurally guided visual search paradigm in which listeners located a visual target using a co-located virtual sound while moving freely, comparing individualised and non-individualised HRTFs under anechoic and reverberant conditions. Performance was assessed through response times and measures of movement organisation. In anechoic conditions, individualised HRTFs produced faster responses than non-individualised HRTFs, with an average reduction of approximately 200ms and the clearest benefit for front-back source locations. This advantage was expressed primarily in movement initiation, whereas overall movement extent was only weakly affected. Under reverberant conditions, HRTF-dependent differences disappeared. These results suggest that HRTF individualisation can influence how listeners plan and initiate orienting actions even when differences in conventional localisation outcomes are limited. Assessing sensorimotor behaviour alongside localisation performance may therefore provide a more sensitive and ecologically relevant account of the perceptual benefits of HRTF individualisation.

0.26

Audiovisual Disparities in VR: Impact on Spatial Perception

cs.GR ·2026-11-06 ·Edurne Bernal-Berdun, Mateo Vallejo, Qi Sun, Ana Serrano, Diego Gutierrez
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract · 2025 IEEE International Symposium on Mixed and Augmented Reality (ISMAR)

Virtual reality (VR) experiences often leverage rich and spatialized multimodal environments to increase immersion and engagement. This demands a consistent spatial perception of audiovisual stimuli, since perceived discrepancies can disrupt the sense of presence. In this work, we investigate the consequences of two types of spatial audiovisual disparities: true disparity, where there is a measurable spatial offset between auditory and visual cues, and perceptual disparity, where users report misalignment despite cues being colocated. Unlike most previous studies that employed controlled but simplified experimental setups, our research focuses on complex, realistic VR environments, allowing us to assess the actual implications for VR content design. Our experiments indicate that users are highly sensitive to true audiovisual disparities in controlled environments, detecting even minor misalignments. However, when engaged in additional tasks within realistic settings, their ability to notice such discrepancies diminishes significantly. We also observed that previously found perceptual disparities persist in complex audiovisual environments. However, we identify self-initiated head rotations as a key factor; its absence prevents the effect entirely. We hope our findings offer practical insights for designing more immersive and perceptually coherent VR experiences.

0.58

Effects of HRTF Augmentation on Predicted Spatial Release from Masking in Music

eess.AS ·2026-08-28 ·Jack Webb, Christophe Lesimple, Volker Kuehnel, Lorenzo Picinali
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted for publication in the Proceedings of Forum Acusticum 2026

Separating individual musical instruments within a complex mixture of sounds poses a persistent challenge for listeners with hearing loss. Although spatial separation of sources improves speech recognition in this population, the potential benefits of spatial cue enhancement for music perception remain largely unexplored. This paper introduces a method to increase spatial cue salience through the augmentation of individual head-related transfer functions (HRTFs). Auditory model analyses indicate that augmented HRTFs may enhance the separability of musical instruments relative to individual HRTFs. Predicted benefits persist when moderate sensorineural hearing loss is modelled, though they are substantially reduced. Simulated hearing aid processing does not restore these benefits to normal-hearing levels.

0.30

Spatial DJ: Spatial Audio Control for Arbitrary Loudspeaker Layouts

cs.SD cs.HCeess.AS ·2026-10-31 ·Anastasia Geleta, Margarita Geleta
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 20 pages, 6 figures

Object-based spatial audio promises render-anywhere playback, yet deploying it in a new venue still requires two tasks that are rarely addressed together: acquiring the physical loudspeaker geometry and enabling creators manipulate spatial audio while listening through the target loudspeaker system rather than a headphone proxy. We present Spatial DJ, a system for on-site loudspeaker layout acquisition and real-time spatial audio rendering and control, using head-worn AR in a coordinate frame aligned to the physical loudspeakers. In an 18-loudspeaker room, we evaluate calibration accuracy, repeatability, and control latency, and conduct an 18-participant listener study comparing diffuse and orbiting point-source rendering configurations applied to vocal and instrumental layers. Orbiting point-source conditions received higher ratings of perceived immersion, energy, and novelty than the diffuse baseline. Beyond this controlled setting, four representative deployments illustrate reuse of the same system across heterogeneous loudspeaker venues.

0.35

Auditory and Visual Virtualization in 6DoF XR: Effects on Plausibility and Dynamic Auditory Distance Perception

eess.AS ·2026-11-05 ·Johannes M. Arend, Christian Scheer, Melissa Ramírez, Stefan Weinzierl, Fabian Brinkmann
similarity 0.58
Abstract · Submitted to a peer-reviewed journal

Extended reality (XR) enables controlled yet naturalistic multisensory experiments, but its validity depends on whether virtualized cues are perceptually plausible and lead to behavior comparable to the real world. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study to perceptually evaluate a six-degree-of-freedom (6DoF) XR system that combines real-time room acoustic simulation, binaural rendering, and an audio-visually matched virtual replica of a large laboratory room in terms of both plausibility and behavior. In two experiments with 45 participants, we investigated how auditory and visual virtualization affect plausibility and dynamic auditory distance perception (ADP). A plausibility experiment compared real and virtual sound sources in audio-augmented reality (AAR) and virtual reality (VR), while a locomotion-based ADP experiment assessed distance-judgment accuracy, signed error, and task effort across four virtualization conditions. The system produced plausible binaural rendering in both AAR and VR, with higher plausibility in VR, indicating that perceptual requirements for XR audio depend on the visual reference frame. In the ADP task, any form of virtualization reduced accuracy and increased effort, although performance remained high overall. Virtual audio produced a bias toward nearer perceived source distances, whereas visual-only virtualization reduced accuracy without a significant directional bias. These effects did not add up in full VR. Overall, the findings demonstrate the strong potential of current 6DoF XR systems for interactive perceptual research, while revealing that task-specific behavioral validation may be necessary.

0.31

HRTF Upsampling and Personalization via Neural Operators

cs.SD cs.LG ·2026-10-14 ·Meenakshi Krishnan, You Zhang, Ramani Duraiswami, C. Phillip Brown
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Head-related transfer function (HRTF) spatial upsampling from sparse measurements is a fundamental challenge in personalized binaural audio. We formulate HRTF upsampling as an operator learning problem and introduce SPARO, a neural operator that maps sparse measurements at a set of spatial directions to the HRTF field, a continuous representation that can be queried at arbitrary positions. SPARO projects the measurements onto a learned set of spherical latent modes, processes the latent modes with Transformer blocks, and decodes the resulting representations at query directions. On SONICOM, using the LAP24 measurement configuration, SPARO attains the best log-spectral distortion (LSD) and interaural level difference (ILD) error at every sparsity level from 3 to 100 measurements (18% lower LSD and 43% lower ILD error than the strongest baseline at 100 measurements) while remaining competitive in interaural time difference (ITD) error. It reconstructs a dense HRTF 15 to 373 times faster than the leading neural-field method RANF. We further validate the approach on HUTUBS, demonstrating its effectiveness across HRTF datasets.

0.11

Bin2Ambi: Learning Ambisonic Soundfield Reconstruction from Head-Tracked Binaural Audio

eess.AS ·2026-09-30 ·Gavin Milner, Nils Peters
similarity 0.55
Abstract

User-generated content has become one of the most-consumed content types. However, capturing spatial audio with consumer hardware is still challenging. Given the widespread success of smart earbuds, binaural audio could be a promising option to capture spatial audio on consumer devices, but its inherent signal characteristic limits its usability as a recording format. In this paper, we propose and define a new task, Binaural to Ambisonics conversion (Bin2Ambi). In our proposed system, we exploit simultaneously captured head-tracking data provided from the motion sensors in smart earbuds. We show that this motion data help resolve the inherent directional uncertainty of two-channel binaural audio due to front-back localization ambiguities and lateral errors in the cone of confusion. Our results show that our system learns directional and diffuse-field information and that head-tracking especially reduces extreme localization errors. Objective metrics and a subjective listening test suggest that the converted Ambisonics soundfield achieves an average directional error of up to $11.8^\circ$ and a perceived spatial quality similar to a DirAC ground-truth model. The proposed algorithm can serve as a baseline for future improvements to this novel Bin2Ambi task.

0.23

HRTF Upsampling Across Varying Measurement Configurations with Geometry-Aware Query-Conditioned Aggregation

eess.AS ·2026-09-22 ·Xingyu Chen, Hanwen Bi, Sipei Zhao, Fei Ma, Eva Cheng +1 more
similarity 0.53
Abstract · Submitted to IEEE ICASSP 2027

Personalized head-related transfer functions (HRTFs) are essential for spatial audio rendering, but densely measuring an individual's HRTFs is costly and time-consuming. HRTF upsampling reduces this burden by estimating dense HRTFs from sparse measurements. Recent learning-based methods have achieved promising performance, but many remain tied to predefined measurement configurations. In this work, we propose GeoAtt, a variable-context HRTF upsampling framework that uses a single trained model across varying measurement configurations. GeoAtt performs geometry-aware, query-conditioned spatial aggregation over the available measurements independently at each frequency bin, followed by frequency-domain modeling using Conformer blocks. The relative geometry between the target and measured directions is incorporated as an additive bias in the cross-attention. Experiments on the SONICOM dataset show that a single trained model achieves the lowest log-spectral distortion across all four canonical Listener Acoustic Personalization (LAP) challenge measurement configurations and further generalizes to configurations that are not explicitly included during training.

0.35