CS Paper Radar

Liquid democracy under vote correlation: On the fallacies of averaging and the excluded middle

Seth Gilbert, Stefan Schmid, Santiago Schnell, Jakub Svoboda, Michelle Yeo

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-08-17 15:48 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Liquid democracy permits voters to vote directly or delegate their votes to others. Existing algorithmic analyses assign each voter a single scalar parameter, interpreted as an independent probability of voting for the ground truth. This representation is inadequate when delegation is fixed before public information changes different voters' reliability in different ways. In this work, we study a minimal common-signal model of this phenomenon. Delegation occurs before a public binary signal is realised, while voting occurs afterwards. Conditional on the signal, sink votes are independent, and each voter has a signal-specific competence; marginally, correctness events are correlated through the common signal. We show that delegation based on average competence is not a safe scalarisation: it can violate do-no-harm, and a beneficial delegation rule may send votes to voters with lower average competence. We present and analyse three novel delegation mechanisms for this setting. The first is a conservative intersection mechanism that delegates only to neighbours whose competence exceeds the delegator's by a prescribed margin in every signal state; the conservative intersection mechanism inherits all the guarantees of delegation in the scalar competence setting. The next mechanism is a confounded-set mechanism that enable the delegation to neighbours who are favoured in one state and worse by at most a prescribed tolerance in the other. For this mechanism, we prove expected-margin bounds, and identify the weight-dispersion and mechanism-concentration conditions needed to obtain majority-correctness guarantees. Finally, on bounded-in-degree graphs, a multi-round certified-path mechanism propagates nonnegative two-dimensional path certificates; it is acyclic, yields statewise terminal competence improvement, and gives uniform bounds on path length and terminal voting weight.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Multi-Winner Elections: Justified Representation, Strategyproofness, and Risk-Avoiding Truthfulness

cs.GT ·2026-08-15 ·Yizhou Ai, Biaoshuai Tao
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 35 pages

We study approval-based multi-winner elections with Justified Representation (JR) when voters strategically report their ballots. We prove that there does not exist a strategy-proof mechanism that outputs JR committees, even when the mechanism can be randomized and only Ex-Ante strategyproofness is required. The impossibility already holds with three voters, four candidates, and target committee size three, even when the mechanism may select fewer than three candidates. It applies to every common strictly increasing cardinality-based utility function and scales to every target size $k\geq3$, every number of voters divisible by $k$, and every candidate-set size at least $k+1$. Motivated by our negative results, we then ask for weaker strategy-proof guarantees under voters' partial information. We use the notion of Risk-Avoiding Truthfulness and its RAT-Degree proposed by Hartman, Segal-Halevi, and Tao (EC'25), the number of other voters whose information a manipulator must know before a safe and profitable deviation is possible. Standard proportional rules, such as Greedy Approval Voting, Proportional Approval Voting, and the Method of Equal Shares, have poor performances under the RAT-Degree metric (with low RAT-Degrees). Finally, for $n$ voters, we construct a JR mechanism with RAT-Degree at least $n-5$, without a polynomial-time bound. We then use the same idea together with algebraic ballot encodings to obtain a polynomial-time JR mechanism with RAT-Degree at least $n-7$. When voters also have immutable private identifiers and both the identifiers and ballots of unknown voters are unobserved, we obtain a polynomial-time JR mechanism with RAT-Degree at least $n-1$ for $2\le k<m$. This degree is exactly $n-1$ when $k\ge3$ and $k$ divides $n$.

0.38

Representation in Peer Selection: A Liquid Democracy Perspective

cs.GT ·2026-08-13 ·Davide Grossi, Grzegorz Lisowski, Georgios Papasotiropoulos
similarity 0.64
Abstract

We study the peer selection problem in which a group of peers must select a fixed-size committee from among themselves. To this end, we introduce a class of approval-based preference profiles, inspired by delegation graphs in liquid democracy and the transitivity of trust therein, which we call ``liquid profiles''. Under this new domain restriction, each voter designates a single trusted agent and, in turn, approves all those trusted by that individual. After establishing relationships to standard restricted preference profiles and examining computational properties of liquid profiles, we focus on understanding how novel and established proportionality axioms behave in this domain and how they relate to one another. Then, we study their satisfaction under various voting rules, including new ones that are directly inspired by the structure of liquid profiles. Our findings reveal that particularly strong proportionality guarantees are attainable in this new domain, showing promise for applications to real-world peer selection problems via transitive delegations.

0.32

Rewarding Informed Voting in PoS Governance

cs.GT econ.TH ·2026-10-06 ·Juan Beccuti, Manvir Schneider
similarity 0.62
Abstract

We study reward design for delegated representatives who acquire costly information and vote on a binary governance proposal. Effort improves both private information and delegated voting weight. We show that no payment rule can make sincere voting strictly optimal at every positive effort profile under a non-neutral prior, while fixed budgets limit accuracy in large symmetric committees. We then compare proportional sharing with a conditional rule that rewards only members of a sufficiently large winning coalition. Unlike proportional sharing, which supports sincere voting only through indifference, the conditional rule makes sincere voting strictly optimal at symmetric positive effort profiles. It supports sincere equilibria with the same effort as proportional sharing and, under suitable reward-cost conditions, with strictly higher effort and decision accuracy. Insincere equilibria may nevertheless coexist.

0.21

Multi-Winner Voting with Argumentative Ballots

cs.GT cs.AI ·2026-08-24 ·Ryuta Arisaka, Hirotaka Ono
similarity 0.61
Abstract · Corrected Example 1, reflected the update to page 6's counts of winner sets proving axioms for the robust h. No definitions, propositions, l…

We introduce multi-winner voting with argumentative ballots (MVArg) and investigate theoretical properties. As our conceptual contribution, we generalise approval ballots to argumentative ballots, thereby allowing voters to express defeasible preferences over candidates. We accordingly generalise voter cohesion and justified representation axioms JR, PJR and EJR. As our theoretical contribution, we establish several key results. First, MVArg is strictly more expressive than multi-winner voting with approval ballots (MV). Second, our notions of cohesion and justified representation are conservative generalisations of their counterparts in MV. Third, the MVArg counterpart of JR can always be satisfied, whereas the counterparts of PJR and EJR cannot always be. Fourth, although verifying whether a winner set satisfies the MVArg counterpart of JR is already coNP-hard, such a winner set can be constructed in polynomial time. All definitions, propositions, auxiliary lemmas and theorems have been formalised and mechanically checked in Lean 4.

0.24

Rules Before Oracles: Auditable, User-Configurable Argument Selection for Deliberative Polling

cs.AI cs.CRcs.CYcs.GT+1 ·2026-08-25 ·Muntaser Syed, Markus Zanker, Marius Silaghi
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract

In a deliberative poll, once submissions outnumber what anyone will read, some mechanism chooses which arguments each voter sees, acquiring much of the decision; practice delegates it to opaque learned rankers, so a voter cannot recompute or contest the exposure that shaped their vote. We ask whether it can be a published rule over publicly recomputable evidence with parameters held by the voter, treating legibility as an admissibility condition on usable mechanisms, not an objective traded against accuracy. We formalise a poll over bipolar justification sets, judging a slate by reason coverage, the order it arrives in, and captured endorsement mass; we give seven checkable criteria for a civic recommender and a rule meeting them: a one-hop reversed endorsement flow parameterised by a relation-weight function. An agentic simulator records every slate at every vote, over about 17,000 seed-paired runs. Served slates fall 0.035 short of a label-reading ceiling upper-bounding every selection procedure, opaque ones included: any unconstrained ranker's advantage is bounded and small. On coverage alone, with non-degenerate authoring, the rule is indistinguishable from a random slate, a null due to an order-blind, charity-blind instrument; on the other two it leads at every prefix by a margin widening with adversarial pressure and dominates on mass by a factor of 3.3. Once a realistic fraction of submissions carries no reasons, the coverage margin returns and grows. Label-homogeneous flooding collapses completeness from 0.81 to 0.34 under a flat weight policy, only to 0.44 under author-count normalisation, making the weight function a security control worth 10% of completeness. The choice between ranking arms is a position on a coverage-versus-mass frontier, not a fact, the kind of choice only a legible rule can hand to the person it affects. It maps onto an open-source peer-to-peer platform.

0.25

Proportional Representation in Temporal Voting with Ranked Preferences

cs.GT cs.AI ·2026-09-24 ·Noam Hazon, Leora Schmerler, Nicholas Teh
similarity 0.61
Abstract

We study proportional representation in temporal voting, where one candidate is selected in each round. While prior work has focused on approval ballots, we consider ranked preferences, which may change over time. A natural approach treats each voter's top candidates as approved, but the right cutoff may differ across voters and rounds. We therefore require proportionality to hold for every admissible choice of cutoffs, whether fixed and common, common but varying across rounds, or set individually for each voter in each round. Combining these interpretations with temporal versions of justified representation (JR), proportional JR (PJR), extended JR (EJR), and proportionality for solid coalitions (PSC) gives us a hierarchy of axioms. We ask which of these axioms can be guaranteed, and with how much knowledge of the future. Unlike with approval ballots, no version of EJR can be guaranteed, and for the other axioms, flexibility in the cutoffs comes at a price. With a fixed common cutoff, JR, PJR, and PSC can be guaranteed, but only by rules that see all preferences in advance. Once the cutoff may vary across rounds, even such rules cannot guarantee JR or PSC for groups that agree in only some rounds. For groups that agree in every round, however, knowing only the number of rounds suffices for PJR in polynomial time, and PSC needs no knowledge of the future at all. Under individual cutoffs, no version of JR or PJR can be guaranteed, yet a rule as simple as serial dictatorship achieves PJR up to an additive loss that no rule can improve on, however much it knows. Natural preference restrictions restore exact guarantees. Finally, we show that checking our axioms is often coNP-complete; but perhaps surprisingly, a stronger axiom can be easier to check.

0.27

Proportionality in Elections under Feasibility Constraints and Ranked Ballots: The Solid Coalition Refinement Rule

cs.GT ·2026-11-06 ·Grzegorz Kwacz, Georgios Papasotiropoulos, Piotr Skowron
similarity 0.60
Abstract

We study elections with ranked ballots and general feasibility constraints, which indicate which sets of candidates are allowed as outcomes. We introduce the first proportionality axiom for this general setting and show that it extends the established notions from specific models that fit our general framework. We extend the Solid Coalition Refinement (SCR) rule to general constraints and prove that it satisfies our axiom exactly for matroid constraints. Although the naive implementation of SCR involves a step that is computationally intractable for weak orders, we show that in practical cases it can be implemented in polynomial time or efficiently in FPT time. We also illustrate limitations of this rule for approval ballots and provide its first empirical evaluation.

0.08

Veto Proportionality in Multiwinner Voting with Ranked Preferences

cs.GT ·2026-11-14 ·Haris Aziz, Yuhang Guo, Patrick Lederer
similarity 0.60
Abstract · Abstract shortened due to arXiv length restrictions

Proportional representation in committee voting with ranked preferences requires voter groups to influence the selected committee in proportion to their size. Existing axioms, such as proportionality for solid coalitions (PSC), demand that like-minded groups of voters are entitled to elect a fair number of candidates to the committee. However, in applications where voters are collectively affected by the entire committee, it may be equally important that no group is confronted with a disproportionate number of candidates that it regards as undesirable. Motivated by this, we initiate the study of veto proportionality in committee elections with ranked preferences. Our central notion, the proportional multiwinner veto core (PMVC), generalizes Moulin's proportional singlewinner veto core to multiwinner elections by allowing groups of voters to partially veto sets of candidates. We analyze how the PMVC relates to existing fairness notions and design rules that are guaranteed to select committees from the PMVC. Specifically, we first introduce a duality framework that connects inclusion- and exclusion-based fairness notions and show, e.g., that the dual axiom of the PMVC strengthens PSC. We further show that STV satisfies the dual axiom of the PMVC, which also implies the existence of committees in the PMVC. Subject to a strengthening of committee monotonicity, we characterize the rules that always return committees in the PMVC as sequential adaptations of singlewinner voting rules that always select from the proportional singlewinner veto core. By our duality framework, this also gives rise to a new class of rules that satisfy PSC. We further prove that the dual axiom of the PMVC and RankPJR+ are jointly satisfiable, thereby pushing the frontier of fairness guarantees that can always be attained. Finally, we show that deciding whether a given committee belongs to the PMVC is coNP-complete.

0.09