CS Paper Radar

Anytime Solver Evaluation with a Normalized Signed Primal Integral and Explicit Reference Policies - Extended Version

Florian Rascoussier, Romain Billot, Lina Fahed, Christine Solnon

cs.MS math.OCcs.PF ·submitted 2026-08-18 20:13 UTC · v3
code/data

Abstract

Anytime solvers return usable solutions before they terminate and improve them while time remains. Their progress is commonly summarized by a primal integral, a final gap, or convergence curves. Each summary leaves consequential choices open: how to score a run before its first feasible solution, whether poor incumbents are truncated, and whether the reference value is updated after the experiment or version-frozen beforehand. These choices become visible when runs produce no valid incumbent or improve a published best-known value. We study a normalized signed primal integral built from a bounded relative gap. It assigns an intrinsic worst value to an empty run, requires no acceptance threshold, and assigns negative instantaneous gaps to incumbents that beat a frozen reference. We compare the smooth difference-over-sum kernel with a signed version of Berthold's max-normalized gap and use the former as a working default. We also distinguish analysis-time from version-frozen reference policies and recommend reading the score with the raw final gap, mean convergence curve, and target-attainment curve. We evaluate these choices on a five-arm routing campaign and two model-fidelity ladders. The two signed kernels preserve every panel ordering in this study, whereas a common acceptance threshold compresses the distances between arms and reverses one panel ordering. Updating 54 of the 212 reference values changes score levels and removes all negative scores, while leaving the observed panel orderings unchanged. An exploratory screen also identifies 12 panel comparisons in which similar integral scores conceal materially different endpoints or attainment rates. The implementation, frozen inputs, and generators are openly released.

Comment
v3: 40 pages, 8 figures, 10 tables. Updated authorship, ORCID identifiers, author declarations and references. No new experiments. Extended version of a manuscript prepared for journal submission. Companion reports: arXiv:2607.23116, arXiv:2608.10079. Data and code: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22095718, https://github.com/0nyr/kayros-campaign-analysis

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Prequential E-Values for Selected-GP Near-Optimality Certificates

cs.LG ·2026-09-30 ·Ami Tavory, Noa Cohen
publishedtheory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 9 pages, 2 figures. Accepted at the NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on E-Values: From Statistics to ML

When optimizing an expensive black-box function sequentially, as in hyperparameter optimization, we may want to stop once the best evaluated value is certified within $\varepsilon$ of the global optimum. Such a certificate needs two ingredients: a lower confidence bound for the selected value and an upper confidence envelope over the domain, typically supplied by a Gaussian process (GP). GP-UCB-style stopping rules are valid when the kernel and constants defining this envelope are fixed before the run, but the practical temptation is to tune the envelope from the same adaptive evaluations and then certify as if it had been fixed. We use prequential e-values to make this selection auditable: starting from a predeclared set of fully specified GP/RKHS envelopes, each candidate is tested by its own one-step-ahead e-process, contradicted candidates are deleted, and certification uses the largest upper bound among the survivors. With a valid selected-point lower bound and one declared candidate having valid latent coverage and noise calibration, the rule is anytime-valid. On a 512-seed noisy RBF stress sweep, it roughly halves false-certification risk at comparable power versus fit-then-certify. Relative to random fixed GP precommitment on smooth $d=3,4$ objectives, each additional false certificate is accompanied by 3.0 and 13.5 additional correct certificates, respectively.

0.33

Imperfect Is Perfect: Learned Column Prefilling for Branch-Price-and-Cut

cs.LG ·2026-10-14 ·Haoran Liu, Yu Yang
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract · 27 pages, 3 figures

Column generation folklore warns that initial columns hurt: a warm start may bias the dual and slow the root of branch-price-and-cut. We show the opposite once the columns are imperfect in the right way. Preloading the support of the optimal root LP, the best columns one could know in advance, fails to finish on half of our hardest instances; a pool of ordinary routes that need not belong to any optimal solution, held outside the master and priced at the current smoothed dual, speeds the root up. Because the columns need not be optimal, producing them becomes a learning task: a neural edge scorer guides a constructive generator that builds the pool in seconds. A second network predicts the initial center of Wentges smoothing from the instance file, and with it the direction of the smoothed pricing queries; the solver's own updates run unchanged. With prefill and center in place, exact pricing dominates root pricing time, so we rebuild bucket-graph labeling around its dominance test for the GPU and certify on the CPU. Inside RouteOpt, the state-of-the-art exact solver for capacitated vehicle routing, the pipeline reaches the same certified root bound in 13.2% of vanilla RouteOpt's root pricing time over 95 instances with 300 to 1000 customers, prefill alone in 26.1%, and 17.5 times faster in the best case. In an exact branch-price-and-cut solver for unrelated parallel machine scheduling, prefill with smoothing and the learned center certifies all 25 benchmark instances, 12 times faster than the solver's own column generation, which certifies 20 of them.

0.50

Certified Behavioral Retention for Continual Adaptation with Held-Out Anchors

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-10-29 ·Ahanaf Hasan Ariq, Abrar Shahid
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · 11 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables. Accepted at the NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on Continual Learning in the Era of Foundation Models and Embodied Agent…

Continual adaptation requires deciding not only how to update a model, but whether to commit an update without exceeding a declared budget for changes to protected behavior. We introduce Certified Anchor-Based Adaptation (CABA), a candidate-agnostic post-update gate that reserves historical observations from candidate optimization, compares old and candidate policies on frozen representations, and selects the largest tested interpolation coefficient whose worst-anchor forward KL divergence remains within budget. The finite check requires neither action labels nor complete trajectories. We develop a theory-led certification framework that separates measured anchor retention from conditional off-anchor guarantees. Under explicit representation-coverage and Lipschitz assumptions, an accepted update satisfies a uniform behavioral-divergence bound on protected support. The analysis gives regularity bounds for affine softmax heads, probabilistic coverage and compression guarantees, interpolation monotonicity conditions, grid-resolution bounds, and trajectory-level and sequential-composition guarantees. In a controlled UCI Human Activity Recognition study used as a non-stationary sensor-policy proxy, CABA reduces mean forgetting from 1.01 percent for unconstrained adaptation to 0.00 percent at budget epsilon = 0.05, while reducing final average accuracy from 93.04 percent to 88.48 percent. The experiment illustrates a retention-plasticity trade-off and does not establish foundation-model or robotic performance. CABA provides an auditable retention check for candidate generators exposing comparable policy distributions and a declared update path, while deployment also requires separate evidence of current-task utility.

0.29

Budget Boundary Effects in Test-Time Mathematical Reasoning

cs.AI ·2026-09-30 ·Guilin Zhang, Ziqi Tan, Wulan Guo, Kai Zhao, Hongyun Yang +3 more
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted as a poster at the 6th Workshop on Mathematical Reasoning and AI (MATH-AI), NeurIPS 2026. 11 pages, 3 figures, 8 tables. Includes a…

A cumulative token cap can fall inside a mathematical derivation, forcing a test-time controller to choose between stopping at the cap (strict) and allowing the current attempt to finish (advisory). We measure this boundary choice with paired offline replays of 19,200 public traces: 120 AIME, BrUMO and HMMT problems and two archive configurations of one model. Candidate order and a 16-attempt cap are fixed, and answer selection is blind to reference answers and correctness labels. Three findings emerge. First, at the 4k cap, most advisory accuracy gains replace abstention with a correct answer; strict stopping pays for an unfinished prefix that the completed-only selector cannot use. Second, comparisons along realized cost differ from same-cap comparisons: advisory 4k in low has higher accuracy than strict 8k at comparable mean completion cost, while in high its observed accuracy is 0.42 points below strict 32k using 59% of its mean tokens. These aggregate comparisons do not establish equal-compute superiority or accuracy equivalence. Third, increased candidate coverage does not guarantee higher answer accuracy: a log-probability selector loses accuracy while coverage rises, including after a source-grade consistency repair. Same-cap majority-accuracy differences shrink below 1.3 percentage points at 32k. Budget curves should jointly state the cap, realized cost, eligible candidates, stopping rule and selector information.

0.65

A Sharper Explicit Bound on the Subtour-LP Integrality Gap for Metric TSP

cs.DS ·2026-09-28 ·Zhao Song
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract

Karlin, Klein, and Oveis Gharan introduced a randomized better-than-$3/2$ approximation algorithm for metric TSP [KKO21] and subsequently established the corresponding improvement in the integrality gap of the subtour-elimination LP [KKO22], with an explicit constant $\varepsilon>1.00000\cdot10^{-36}$. Gurvits, Klein, and Leake subsequently improved the certified saving to $2.18000\cdot10^{-34}$ [GKL24]. In this paper, we obtain a randomized polynomial-time $(3/2-\varepsilon)$-approximation for every fixed $0<\varepsilon<\varepsilon_\star$, where $\varepsilon_\star>2.78621\cdot10^{-18}$, and consequently the subtour-elimination LP has integrality gap at most $3/2-\varepsilon_\star$. The classical worst-case integrality-gap lower bound is $4/3$ [Wil90].

0.39

Last-Iterate Convergence Rate of Normalized Gradient Descent under Hölder Smoothness

cs.LG math.OC ·2026-10-05 ·Yuki Takezawa, Eduard Gorbunov
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract

Normalized gradient descent is a widely studied adaptive optimization method. Most existing analyses focus on the best iterate or a weighted average of the iterates, whereas practical implementations typically return the last iterate. In this paper, we study the last-iterate convergence of normalized gradient descent for convex, $(ν,M_ν)$-Hölder-smooth objectives. For a constant stepsize, we establish an upper bound of $\mathcal{O}\bigl((\log^2(T)/T)^{(1+ν)/2}\bigr)$, which contains a logarithmic overhead relative to the known $\mathcal{O}\bigl(T^{-(1+ν)/2}\bigr)$ guarantees for the best and weighted-average iterates. For $ν= 0$, this overhead is known to be unavoidable. We complement this analysis with numerical results based on the performance estimation problem (PEP), investigating the finite-horizon worst-case behavior in the smooth setting and whether the logarithmic overhead reflects an intrinsic limitation of constant-step normalized gradient descent. We then show that a linearly decreasing stepsize yields a last-iterate guarantee of $\mathcal{O}\bigl(T^{-(1+ν)/2}\bigr)$, matching the order of the best-iterate/weighted-average guarantees without requiring knowledge of $ν$ and $M_ν$.

0.14

QAM: Quadratic-Accurate Checkpoint Merging via Sequential Consistency

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-09-28 ·Shihao Wang, Rui Kong, Xinran Chen, Hui Wu, Qipeng Qian +5 more
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract

Saved checkpoints record states along a training trajectory, but generally do not determine the updates at states that would be visited under a different schedule. We study how accurately these checkpoints can reconstruct the endpoint of a sequential reference with prescribed update strengths. Under a common local transition model, two checkpoint-index moment conditions characterize all convex merges that agree with this reference through second order. We then prove an information limit that for nondegenerate profiles, no algorithm using only a fixed-length gradient-descent (GD) history with step size $h$ can achieve $o(h^3)$ endpoint error uniformly over a fixed class of smooth, strongly convex losses. The lower bound follows from two losses with identical GD checkpoint histories but sequential reference endpoints separated by $Ω(h^3)$. \textbf{Quadratic-Accurate Merging} (QAM) achieves a matching uniform $O(h^3)$ endpoint error bound. Its explicit coefficients also define the unique profile-dependent merge that exactly matches the sequential GD reference across all fixed quadratic objectives. Across two public Adam checkpoint trajectories (SmolLM3-3B and OpenEuroLLM-Prelude-9B), three windows and three profiles per model, and 15 tasks, QAM shows mixed results for short windows and broader advantages over \textbf{Warmup-Stable and Merge} (WSM) for longer windows. Matched-moment GSM8K diagnostics further show that local consistency alone does not fully determine downstream scores. These results characterize the reconstruction limits of saved histories, provide a coefficient rule that attains the optimal rate, and assess its practical utility.

0.27

Beyond Optimal Rates in Stochastic Optimization: Trajectory-Adaptive Stopping Rules

cs.LG math.OCmath.STstat.ML ·2026-08-26 ·Liviu Aolaritei, Lucas Lévy, Francis Bach, Michael I. Jordan
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Stochastic gradient descent (SGD) is typically analyzed at a deterministic horizon chosen before the algorithm is run, even though practical stopping decisions are made adaptively by inspecting the evolving trajectory. This mismatch creates a fundamental certification problem: fixed-time guarantees do not generally remain valid at data-dependent stopping times, while deterministic horizons derived from worst-case bounds can be highly conservative. We address this problem for strongly convex stochastic optimization by constructing fully observable, trajectory-adaptive upper confidence sequences for the squared distance of the last iterate to the optimizer and the suboptimality of a weighted average. These bounds hold simultaneously over time, attain the optimal $1/t$ decay rate up to iterated-logarithmic factors in the worst case, and adapt to the realized stochastic gradients, allowing SGD to stop as soon as a prescribed accuracy is certified without sacrificing statistical validity. Our approach treats the evolving SGD trajectory as a sequential experiment whose observations provide evidence about the unknown optimization error. To formalize this perspective, we develop new recursive confidence-sequence techniques and a general time-uniform empirical Bernstein inequality for adapted processes with time-varying conditional means and predictable ranges that may grow without bound. We further extend these confidence-sequence constructions to minibatch SGD, with the empirical Bernstein bounds exploiting the realized second-moment structure within each minibatch. Numerical experiments show that the resulting stopping rules can require several orders of magnitude fewer iterations than natural deterministic horizons.

0.18