CS Paper Radar

Tight Energy Lower Bounds for Distributed Graph Algorithms

Fabien Dufoulon, Gopal Pandurangan, Peter Robinson

cs.DC cs.DS ·submitted 2026-08-19 14:58 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

There has been a significant recent interest in designing distributed algorithms in the SLEEPING model that minimize the {energy (a.k.a awake) complexity, which measures the number of rounds a node is awake during the algorithm. A node spends non-trivial resources (messages, energy, etc.) only when it is awake and not while sleeping. Energy complexity has been studied for various fundamental problems with respect to minimizing the maximum (worst-case) or the average number of rounds a node is awake. It has been shown that the energy complexities of several fundamental problems such as leader election (LE), broadcast, Minimum Spanning Tree (MST), Maximal Independent Set (MIS) is exponentially smaller compared to their respective best-possible round complexities in the standard CONGEST model (where nodes can only send messages of small size). This raises a fundamental question of whether such significant energy gains are possible for many other fundamental problems. Our main contribution is a general and powerful technique for showing energy lower bounds using information theory. It gives almost a "plug-in" way to show energy lower bounds for various problems in the standard CONGEST model. Our information-theoretic technique allows us to leverage known lower bounds on communication complexity to obtain new, almost optimal (up to logarithmic factors) polynomial (in $n$) lower bounds on energy complexity --- for both worst-case and average-case --- for fundamental graph problems such as triangle enumeration, All-Pairs Shortest Paths (APSP), diameter computation, minimum weight cycle, Maximum Independent Set (MaxIS), Minimum Dominating Set (MinDS), Minimum Vertex Cover (MinVC). The energy lower bounds of these problems match their respective round lower bounds, implying that one cannot obtain any significant gains in energy complexity.

Comment
To appear at DISC 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Approximating Minimum Dominating Set with Few Awake Rounds

cs.DC ·2026-08-19 ·Hongyan Ji, Shreyas Pai, Sriram V. Pemmaraju
top venue similarity 0.71
Abstract · Full version of the conference paper published in the proceedings of the 40th International Symposium on Distributed Computing (DISC 2026)

We study the Minimum Dominating Set (MDS) problem in the sleeping CONGEST model (Chatterjee, Gmyr, and Pandurangan, PODC 2020), a generalization of the standard CONGEST model, in which a node may sleep in some rounds and can only compute, send messages, or receive messages when it is awake. The awake complexity of an algorithm in this model is the worst case number (over all inputs and all nodes) of rounds a node is awake for during the execution of the algorithm. While there are several $O(\log Δ)$-approximation algorithms (in expectation) for MDS that run in $O(\log^2 Δ)$ rounds, all of these have $Ω(\log^2 Δ)$ awake complexity. Whether this awake complexity can be improved is the question that drives our work. We present the first $O(\log Δ)$-approximation algorithm for MDS with $O(\log Δ)$ awake complexity. The approximation guarantee holds in expectation, and the algorithm runs in $O(\log^2Δ)$ rounds. We can reduce the awake complexity further, but at the cost of approximation: we present, for any $1<α\le\min\{Δ,\log n\}$, an algorithm in the sleeping CONGEST model that computes an $\tilde{O}(α\log_αΔ)$-approximate dominating set in expectation in $\tilde{O}(\logΔ\cdot \log_α Δ)$ rounds with $\tilde{O}(\log_α Δ)$ awake complexity. Our results depend on a generalization of the CONGEST model Set Cover algorithm of Grunau, Mitrović, Rubinfeld, and Vakilian (SODA 2020) that we develop. This generalization computes an $O(p\cdot q\cdot\log_pΔ)$-approximate dominating set in $O(\log_pΔ\cdot\log_qΔ)$ rounds for parameters $1<p,q\leΔ$. Our sleeping CONGEST algorithms apply a variety of techniques including sampling-based estimation and scheduling using virtual binary trees to the aforementioned 2-parameter Set Cover algorithm.

0.48

Polynomial Lower Bounds for Distributed Graph Sketching with Tiny Error: Connectivity and Spanning Tree Construction

cs.DS cs.DC ·2026-09-05 ·Peter Robinson, Ming Ming Tan
theory similarity 0.69
Abstract

We present the first polynomial lower bounds for several fundamental problems in the distributed graph sketching model in the tiny-error regime, which includes deterministic algorithms as a special case. In the graph sketching model, every node sends a single message to the referee who does not have any prior knowledge of the graph and must output the answer. While the work of Nelson and Yu (SODA 2019) and Yu (SODA 2021) showed that $Θ( \log^3n )$ is optimal for constructing a spanning forest or deciding whether the graph is connected with error at most $\frac{1}{\text{poly}(n)}$ , their approach does not yield any stronger bounds for significantly smaller error probabilities. Our main result is to show that solving either connectivity or spanning tree construction with error at most $δ$ requires messages of length $Ω( \min\{n, \log_2 \frac{1}δ\}^{1/3} )$, which implies that algorithms with exponentially small error must send messages of $Ω( n^{1/3} )$ bits in the worst case. Our results significantly narrows the current gap between the Jelani-Yu threshold of $Θ( \log^3n )$ and the trivial upper bound of sending $O(n)$ bits per node for deterministic graph sketching. We also extend our results to $k$-edge connectivity. For any $k=O(n^{1/7})$, we recover the same bound of $Ω( k )$ on the message length for algorithms with exponentially small error that was shown by Robinson and Tan (PODS 2026) only for deterministic algorithms. Finally, for $k=n^{o(1)}$, our result implies a stronger lower bound of $Ω_ε( n^ε )$ bits, for any constant $ε<\tfrac{1}{3}$.

0.09

Beating Quadratic Time--Message Trade-off in Distributed Minimum Spanning Tree Construction

cs.DS cs.DC ·2026-08-31 ·Taisuke Izumi, Naoki Kitamura, Toshimitsu Masuzawa
similarity 0.66
Abstract

We present a new distributed algorithm for computing a minimum spanning tree (MST) in the \textsf{CONGEST-KT$_{1}$} model, where messages are limited to $O(\log n)$ bits and each vertex initially knows the identifiers of its neighbors. Our algorithm exposes a two-parameter time--message trade-off: for any $0 \leq λ\leq κ\leq 1/2$, it runs in $\tilde{O}(n^λD_G + n^{1 - κ- λ} + n^{1 - 2κ+ λ} + n^{1/2})$ rounds and uses $\tilde{O}(\min\{m, n^{1 + κ}\})$ messages, where $n$, $m$, and $D_G$ are the number of vertices, edges, and thenetwork diameter, respectively. In particular, setting $(κ, λ) = (1/3, 1/6)$ yields an MST algorithm running in $\tilde{O}(n^{1/2} + n^{1/6}D_G)$ rounds with only $\tilde{O}(n^{4/3})$ messages. Under the mild assumption $D_G = O(n^{1/3})$, this is round-optimal while improving the best known message bound of $\tilde{O}(n^{3/2})$. More broadly, our algorithm breaks the quadratic time--message trade-off barrier $\mathrm{\# rounds} \cdot \mathrm{\# messages} = \tildeΩ(n^2)$, which no previous MST algorithm in the \textsf{CONGEST-KT$_{1}$} model has been able to overcome, and it does so for almost the entire range of the diameter $D_G$. As a byproduct, we also obtain new low-message broadcast, spanning-tree, and leader-election algorithms.

0.18

Settling Nondeterministic Communication Complexity of Graph Connectivity

cs.CC ·2026-10-23 ·Zhijun Zhang
publishedtheory similarity 0.64
Abstract

Determining the communication complexity of graph connectivity has been one of the longest standing open problems in communication complexity since the seminal work of Babai, Frankl, and Simon [FOCS'86]. A simple protocol transmits a spanning forest using $O(N\log N)$ communication on $N$-vertex graphs. While this was shown optimal for deterministic protocols by Hajnal, Maass, and Turán [STOC'88], the optimal nondeterministic and randomized complexities have remained unresolved for decades. We settle the nondeterministic communication complexity of graph connectivity by proving an optimal $Ω(N\log N)$ lower bound. The best prior bound was $Ω(N\log\log N)$ due to Raz and Spieker [Combinatorica'95]. Our bound is shown by upper bounding the maximum size of $1$-monochromatic rectangles. Generalizing our techniques to weighted, almost $1$-monochromatic rectangles yields an $Ω(N \cdot \log(\min(1/\varepsilon,N)))$ lower bound for randomized protocols with error probability $\varepsilon$. In particular, this bound is optimal for any polynomially small $\varepsilon$. For constant error probability, we also prove that any $r$-round protocol requires $Ω(N/r \cdot \log N)$ communication, which is optimal for every constant $r$. Previously, optimal $Ω(N\log N)$ lower bounds for graph connectivity were known only for $1$-round [Sun, Woodruff; APPROX/RANDOM'15] and $2$-round protocols [Radhakrishnan, Reddy, Venkat; ITCS'26]. Our proof introduces a new communication problem which can be viewed as a composition of inner product and pointer chasing problems. Our lower bounds can be extended to other fundamental graph properties, and also imply optimality of known query and streaming algorithms for related problems.

0.31

A note on efficient k-limited broadcast domination in graphs

cs.DS math.CO ·2026-08-20 ·Bharadwaj, A. Senthil Thilak
theoryhot direction similarity 0.64
Abstract · 10 pages, 2 figures

An efficient $k$-limited dominating broadcast, or $k$-ELDB, is a $k$-limited broadcast in which every vertex is dominated exactly once. This notion brings together efficient domination and limited broadcast domination in a common framework. For a graph $G$, we write $mcr(G)$ for the smallest integer $k$ for which $G$ admits a $k$-ELDB. For an admissible value $k\ge mcr(G)$, we denote by $γ_{ebk}(G)$ the minimum cost of a $k$-ELDB on $G$, and is called the $k$-efficient broadcast domination number of $G$. In this paper, we study these parameters from an algorithmic perspective with complexity analysis. We develop a dynamic programming algorithm for trees which, for fixed $k$, computes $γ_{ebk}(T)$ and thereby obtains a polynomial-time procedure for determining $mcr(T) $. In contrast, we prove that, for every fixed integer $k\ge 1$, deciding whether a graph admits a $k$-ELDB is NP-complete for arbitrary graphs. These results place efficient limited broadcast domination in a natural complexity framework, with trees forming a tractable class and arbitrary graphs remaining computationally hard.

0.27

Paying for Fractional Error: Tight Constant-Round Approximation of Covering Problems with Short Broadcasts

cs.DS cs.DC ·2026-11-01 ·Saeed Amiri, Sebastian Siebertz, Wojciech Wawrzyniak
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract

We present a general framework for deterministic constant-round approximation of covering problems in sparse networks in the broadcast CONGEST model, where every vertex broadcasts the same $O(\log n)$-bit message to all its neighbors. The framework combines two independent tools. The first is a solver that computes a $(1+δ)$-approximate solution of any local covering linear program with bounded positive integer costs on every class that excludes a fixed minor. The second is a rounding principle: a rounding rule that saves a fixed fraction of its own output, for every feasible input, pays for a solver error fixed in advance, so that an approximate fractional solution yields an exact coefficient. For ordinary domination, we achieve a $2a+1$ approximation against the fractional optimum $γ_f(G)$ for every fixed rational $a\ge1$, whenever every minor has a ratio of edges to vertices of at most $a$. On planar graphs this is seven, matching the lower bound of Hilke, Lenzen, and Suomela. The coefficients are also optimal at bounded treewidth and pathwidth, for $K_t$-minor-free graphs with $3\le t\le9$, on triangle-free planar graphs (five), and on planar graphs of large girth, where it approaches the optimal three. On every fixed surface the exact bound is $7γ(G)$, and we show that a bound of $7γ_f(G)$ is impossible on some fixed surfaces even sequentially. For total domination, on graphs without isolated vertices and under the same minor-density assumption, the exact coefficient is $2a$ against the fractional optimum, including the optimal six on planar graphs. Red-blue domination, and hence set cover and hitting set on planar incidence graphs, has the optimal limiting coefficient four. Our method also gives randomized constant-round and deterministic $O(\log^* n)$-round $(1+\varepsilon)$-approximation schemes, with the randomized cost guarantee holding in expectation.

0.45

Smoothed Analysis for Distributed MIS

cs.DC ·2026-11-12 ·Dipan Dey, Fabien Dufoulon, William K. Moses, Gopal Pandurangan
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

We study smoothed analysis of the distributed Maximal Independent Set (MIS) problem. Luby's algorithm computes an MIS in $O(\log n)$ rounds, while the recent $Ω(\log n/\log\log n)$ lower bound of Khoury and Schild (2026) shows that it is nearly optimal even in the LOCAL model. We ask whether small random perturbations can overcome this worst-case barrier. Given an arbitrary base graph $G$ on $n$ nodes, we consider the smoothed graph $\mathcal{G}_s=G\triangle G(n,p)$, where $G(n,p)$ is an independent random graph and $\triangle$ denotes symmetric difference. Thus, each possible edge is independently toggled with probability $p$. We establish nearly tight bounds on the smoothing needed for faster distributed MIS. For every base graph $G$, when $p=β\ln n/n$ for a sufficiently large constant $β$, a randomized LOCAL algorithm, given only $\mathcal{G}_s$, computes an MIS of $\mathcal{G}_s$ in $O(\sqrt{\log n})$ rounds with high probability. This is almost quadratically faster than the worst-case lower bound. Conversely, if $p\le(1/2-δ)\ln n/n$ for a fixed constant $δ>0$, there exists a base graph on which every randomized LOCAL MIS algorithm requires $Ω(\log n/\log\log n)$ rounds on the smoothed graph. Hence, the smoothing parameter required for this speedup is optimal up to a constant factor. These results show that smoothed analysis can overcome worst-case lower-bound barriers for distributed local graph problems.

0.10

Lower Bounds for the Distributed Computation of Degeneracy and k-Core

cs.DC ·2026-11-16 ·Lélia Blin, Yan S. Couto, Cristina G. Fernandes, Pierre Fraigniaud, Marcos Kiwi +2 more
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

The degeneracy of a graph $G$ is the maximum integer $k$ such that $G$ has a non-empty $k$-core, where the $k$-core is the largest induced subgraph with minimum degree $k$. Computing the $k$-core of a graph $G$ is P-complete. In the decentralized setting, the sequential peeling algorithm can be distributed so that the core value of every node, i.e., the largest integer $k$ for which the node belongs to the $k$-core, is computed in $O(n)$ rounds in $n$-node networks, where adjacent nodes exchange only $O(\log n)$ bits at each round, i.e., in the standard CONGEST model. However, while $Ω(D)$ rounds is a trivial lower bound for these problems in networks of diameter $D$, this does not rule out the existence of an algorithm running in $O(D)+o(n)$ rounds in CONGEST, as it is the case for many very important graph problems, including MST. We show that it is unlikely that such an algorithm exists, or, if it does exist, then it requires $\tildeΩ(\sqrt{n})$ rounds. Specifically, our first main result states that, for any $ε>0$, approximating the degeneracy up to a multiplicative factor $2-ε$ requires $\tildeΩ(\sqrt{n})$ rounds in CONGEST even in networks of diameter $O(\log n)$, and still $\tildeΩ(n^{1/3})$ rounds in networks of constant diameter. We also show that improving this lower bound seems challenging, as we demonstrate that the newer frameworks cannot be used as black boxes to obtain a better lower bound for degeneracy. Our second main result provides a better bound, albeit conditional. It states that, unless the well-known circuit value problem (CVP) admits a parallel polynomial speedup -- an outcome considered unlikely -- it holds that, for every $ε>δ>0$, deciding whether a graph is 2-degenerate cannot be solved in $O(D+ n^{1-ε})$ rounds with $O(n^δ)$-time parallel local computation per round at each node.

0.12