CS Paper Radar

TractorBeam: Personalized AI Sensemaking Support via Collaborative Machine Annotation

Sireesh Gururaja, Jordan Taylor, Emma Strubell

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-08-19 14:59 UTC · v2
published

Abstract

Language model-based systems which allow asking questions of documents have become popular tools for sensemaking. Despite their implied capability, these systems still suffer from issues of factuality and provenance, while encouraging confirmatory, rather than exploratory, research. We present TractorBeam, a browser extension-based mixed-initiative system that uses collaborative annotation as an interface metaphor for sensemaking, re-framing language model (LM) outputs as suggested highlights in a process that we call collaborative machine annotation. This metaphor allows us to present LM results in-context on PDF documents, directly addressing concerns of provenance and factuality, while allowing users to iteratively construct mental schemas and queries for language models directly in the context of a document. In a preliminary user study, all of our participants felt that TractorBeam enabled them evaluate and iteratively improve the model's reflection of their intended highlighting, and several found suggestions that made them reconsider their original schema. TractorBeam suggests that systems that facilitate exploratory research on individual documents may lead to verifiable sensemaking for users and complement tools that work across broader corpora.

Comment
UIST Poster Extended Abstract
DOI
10.1145/3830397.3841814

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

How Much Can AI Understand? Toward AI-Assisted Sensemaking of Collaborative Discussion in Groups with Shared History

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-08-28 ·Soobin Cho, Mark Zachry, David W. McDonald
position similarity 0.69
Abstract

AI tools that support collaborative discussion typically treat the discussion as a standalone task, focusing only on its content and setting aside the social context of the group having it. But it is groups with a shared history, with their own norms, hierarchies, and relationships, where the most tangled and complex discussions tend to arise. These discussions cannot be understood apart from that context, and AI that overlooks it risks failing to convey what a discussion means, or even misrepresenting it. Drawing on two studies of how experienced Wikipedia editors read and make sense of discussions, we propose an AI-Assisted Sensemaking Model for Collaborative Discussions, which captures not only a discussion's arguments but also the norms and participants behind it, along with the context that gives each meaning. In this model, the system supports the early stages of the sensemaking process, and the degree to which it performs interpretive work can range from low to high. We argue that higher interpretive work reduces the burden on users but increases their reliance on the system's judgment. We then discuss the risks of an insufficiently intelligible system, what it would take to make one more intelligible, and the safeguards it still requires.

0.26

HiPaper: A Human-AI Collaborative System for Academic Literature Triage and Scholarly Sensemaking

cs.HC cs.AIcs.IR ·2026-10-31 ·Ye Jia, Pangjing Wu, Hayley Y. W. Gu, Zhuohang Jiang, Xu Yuan +4 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Scholarly sensemaking requires researchers to iteratively retrieve, collect, and synthesize literature as their understanding evolves. However, existing scholarly tools provide only partial support for this process. Recent artificial intelligence (AI)-based systems generally rely on opaque submit-and-wait pipelines that it users' ability to inspect, revise, and validate intermediate outputs. In this study, we present HiPaper, a human-AI collaborative literature review system informed by a formative study with academic experts. HiPaper organizes scholarly sensemaking as a three-stage interactive workflow spanning Retrieval, Collection, andSynthesis, centralized on the human-in-the-loop paradigm that exposes intermediate AI-generated content for user inspection and intervention through a persistent workspace called Knowledge Pocket. Through this workflow, users can iteratively refine search intent, curate and organize papers with AI-enriched metadata and clustering, and conduct evidence-traceable synthesis over selected literature. Our user study with 14 Ph.D. students showed that HiPaper efficiently supports scholarly sensemaking by enabling human-AI collaboration in both familiar and unfamiliar domains. Furthermore, the findings highlight how staged interactions with intermediate AI-generated content successfully scaffold user interactions throughout the sensemaking process.

0.05

GroundWork: Bridging Human and LLM Reasoning Through a Structured Argumentation Model

cs.HC ·2026-11-06 ·Sjoerd Vink, Byungmoo Kim, Michael Behrisch, Adam Coscia, Remco Chang
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly integrated into workflows that require reasoning over text documents, yet interaction remains largely conversational. This leaves argumentative structure implicit or embedded in text, making it difficult to maintain, compare, and revise arguments as analyses evolve. We present GroundWork, a mixed-initiative system that makes argument structure a shared, editable state for humans and LLMs. GroundWork operationalizes the Toulmin model of argumentation as a typed graph with explicit operations for human and LLM edits. It exposes this structure through coordinated corpus views and an editable workbench for constructing, comparing, testing, and tracing source-grounded arguments. We evaluate GroundWork through an expert study with four participants spanning consulting, product development, law, and immunology, and three use-case scenarios in intelligence, law, and medicine. Our findings show that GroundWork makes source-grounded arguments inspectable, comparable, and revisable as shared human-LLM state.

0.06

EviMap: Evidence-Grounded Hierarchical Topic Maps for Exploring Unlabeled Corpora

cs.IR cs.CLcs.HC ·2026-09-06 ·Zhiyin Tan, Changxu Duan
top venuesurveycode/datahot direction similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at the 35th ACM International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM '26)

Research teams and organizations often explore unfamiliar free-text collections, from survey comments and reviews to reports and domain documents, before labels, queries or coding schemes exist. At this stage, the first thematic map shapes what users notice, prioritize and carry into downstream analysis, so it should be trusted only insofar as it can be verified. Existing options force a trade-off between scale and verifiability. Qualitative coding preserves evidence but is slow. Search presupposes a query. Clustering and topic models scale but produce labels users must interpret. One-shot large language model (LLM) summaries are fluent yet difficult to reproduce or audit. We present EviMap, an interactive system providing researchers and practitioners with an auditable thematic overview of such corpora. Guided by model-generated context describing the corpus and hypothesized stakeholder concerns, EviMap extracts within-document evidence phrases and organizes them, rather than whole documents, into a three-level map of aspects, groups and fine-grained topics. Embedding-based clustering narrows the search space for finer semantic judgments by the LLM. Each node traces back to supporting phrase spans, so documents link to topics through evidence they contain and users can audit labels against the original text. Users can start from a top-level corpus map, drill into topics, inspect highlighted evidence in original documents, and combine two topics to find documents discussing both. We demonstrate this workflow across six heterogeneous corpora spanning 2,108 to 101,699 documents, with a comparison against flat and hierarchical LLM baselines. By grounding every label in verbatim source spans, EviMap makes a topic map not just readable, but verifiable. Code, demo video, and interactive dashboard are available at https://github.com/zhiyintan/EviMap.

0.60

Modeling Student Sensemaking with LLMs and Knowledge-Graph-Guided Inference

cs.CL ·2026-09-25 ·Özge Alacam, Zübeyde Demet Kirbulut Güneş, Funda Ekici, Nurcan Turan-Oluk, Dilay Dinçdemir +5 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Collaborative science learning requires nuanced interpretation of student dialogue to characterize how learners identify knowledge gaps, build explanations, and work toward resolution - a theory-driven analysis that is labor-intensive and difficult to scale. We investigate whether instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs) can support multidimensional analysis of collaborative sensemaking without task-specific training, and whether structured knowledge-state information improves model inference. We evaluate two mid-size LLMs on 23 richly annotated, expert-labeled episodes across prompting conditions that vary definitional scaffolding, reasoning mode, and turn structure. Without reasoning, models tend to overpredict successful sensemaking; reasoning-enabled prompting improves identification of unsuccessful cases. Knowledge-state diagnostics provide additional grounding, improving detection of unsuccessful sensemaking and increasing agreement with expert annotations. No single configuration performs best across all sensemaking dimensions, underscoring the multidimensional nature of the task.

0.18

Supporting Researcher Control in AI-Assisted Social Media Analysis: A Mixed-Methods Study of AI4OSN

cs.HC ·2026-11-16 ·Qile Wang, Abhishek Karwankar, Shukria Muhammadi, Srikanth Kumar Perumalla, Abhin Suresh +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

High-quality annotated datasets are critical for advancing computational social science (CSS) research, yet collecting, curating, and analyzing large-scale data from dynamic sources such as online social networks (OSNs) remains a persistent bottleneck. Researchers must also translate substantive questions into queries, relevance criteria, and defensible interpretations. Large language models (LLMs) can assist, but they can also obscure the judgments, potentially reducing researcher oversight and critical evaluation. We present AI4OSN, a mixed-initiative platform that keeps researchers in control of data collection, relevance labeling, and sensemaking while making AI assistance available as an inspectable advisory resource. In a systematic user study (N=18) using X/Twitter data, participants reported above-benchmark perceived usability (mean SUS score of 79.7), increased confidence in LLM-assisted annotation and analysis tasks, and low cognitive workload during AI-supported sensemaking. Notably, novice participants showed descriptively greater alignment and higher reported agreement with AI output than experienced participants, underscoring the need to support differentiated verification practices across expertise levels. Overall, this work contributes both a human-centered system for social data analysis and empirical insights into how AI-assisted interfaces shape researcher behavior, trust, and decision-making. Our findings highlight design opportunities and tensions in building accessible, transparent, and agentic AI systems for social media and web research.

0.10

Goldsmith: Gold-Loss-Guided Definition Optimization with an Agentic Annotation Harness

cs.CL ·2026-10-07 ·Yihan Li, Hanyi Zhang, Xiaoxi Jiang, Man Guo
top venue similarity 0.64
Abstract · 20 pages, 4 figures, 11 tables. Accepted to the main conference of EMNLP 2026

Many annotation projects begin before experts have a stable guideline or enough labels to train a task-specific model. We present Goldsmith, an agentic pipeline that turns a small gold set---expert-annotated calibration examples representing the intended task boundaries---into a reusable structured annotation definition. Goldsmith treats this definition as a trainable textual object. Candidate definitions are run on the same gold examples and scored with an executable structured loss, while the output schema, formatting, retrieval, repair, judging, and human review remain in an external harness. A large language model (LLM) editor converts the highest-loss failures into textual-gradient revisions, which are accepted only when the measured loss decreases. In prompt-optimization comparisons, Goldsmith improves over direct rewriting, OPRO, APE, and PromptBreeder under matched evaluation protocols. The resulting definition also improves downstream annotation when combined with retrieval, score-based routing, and human review across typed span, pair-level relation, and fixed-trigger event-argument tasks. These results show that scarce expert supervision can support both task-definition learning and scalable annotation.

0.40

AnnoSketch: Evaluating and Collecting Human Sketches for MLLM-assisted Chart Annotation

cs.HC ·2026-09-13 ·Yoonjae Oh, Seon Gyeom Kim, Jae Young Choi, Ryan Rossi, Jihyung Kil +2 more
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract

As multimodal large language models (MLLMs) support a growing range of input modalities, increasing work explores how to incorporate rough sketches to convey user intent. For annotated chart generation, it remains unclear what annotation sketches people provide and when such visual input helps MLLMs generate more useful annotations. In this study, we examine when sketch input is useful for MLLM-generated chart annotations across variation in chart type and caption type. In addition, we qualitatively analyze participants' explanations of their output preferences to characterize what made generated annotations more or less helpful. To further document participants' annotation sketches, we present AnnoSketch, comprising 1,600 annotation sketches collected across 160 chart-caption pairs from the conditions in which sketch guidance proved most beneficial, together with participants' annotation intents, perceived comprehension difficulty, and self-reported expressive limitations. We also label these sketches with structured metadata describing how each sketch relates to its caption and how participants express annotations through visual marks. Together, our study and AnnoSketch help determine when to solicit sketch input and provide empirical source for how people sketch chart annotations to support captions. The dataset and supplemental materials are available in our OSF repository.

0.15