CS Paper Radar

A Scoping Review of Methods to Measure the Energy and Carbon Footprint of Web Tracking and Advertising

Nils Bonfils, Christoph Becker

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-08-19 23:12 UTC · v1
surveyunusual

Abstract

The environmental impact of web tracking and advertising is increasingly receiving attention as the ICT sector's carbon footprint keeps rising. Yet the scholarship addressing this question remains scattered across disciplines and inconsistent in its terminology. This paper presents a scoping review of the literature on methods for measuring the energy and carbon footprint of web tracking and advertising. From an initial pool of 46 articles identified through a structured title-based search on Google Scholar, we arrived at a final corpus of 15 papers, from which we identified five distinct methodological approaches: ad blocking, controlled environment, replaying ads, traffic flow analysis, and literature-derived estimation. This review provides a structured overview of the current methodological landscape and a foundation for more comprehensive environmental accounting of the ad tech ecosystem.

Comment
5 pages, 0 figures. Accepted at the 2nd International Workshop on Low Carbon Computing (LOCO 2026), Lancaster University, United Kingdom, 10-11 September 2026. Part of the LOCO 2026 proceedings, arXiv:2608.02072

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Scroll to Sale: Exploring the Impact of Interaction Type and Device Price on TikTok Advertisements

cs.CY cs.HCcs.SI ·2026-09-30 ·Nazanin Sabri, Cat Mai, Haodi Zou, Isha Varada, Damon McCoy +2 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Companies and brands increasingly use dynamic pricing, including targeting social media ads to users based on their income. In this work we audit TikTok's feed using 56 automated accounts, which collect data on over 80,000 videos, across two studies. We test the impact of device price on ad load and ad types, using 12 phones of low ($0-$250), medium ($400-$650), and high ($750-$1,000+) price as a proxy for income. We also test the impact of interaction type (i.e., like, comment, share), age, and gender on the frequency and content of ads. Overall, the ad load was 29.4%, but liking and sharing content increased ad load significantly. We also found that as accounts spend more time on TikTok, the ad load steadily increases. We found some evidence that device price impacts both ad load and content -- more expensive devices were targeted with fewer ads, while the least expensive devices received more discounts.

0.26

Bridging the Gap: A Longitudinal Analysis of Extended Identifiers in the Post-Cookie Era

cs.NI ·2026-09-02 ·Michael Smith, Riley Grossman, Krzysztof Franaszek, Antonio Torres-Agüero, Pritam Sen +2 more
similarity 0.48
Abstract · 10 pages

As third-party cookies fade because of browser restrictions, the online advertising ecosystem is turning to extended identifiers (EIDs) as an alternative. EIDs are persistent user identifiers, such as hashed email addresses, that are employed to link users across domains and devices. This paper presents a 41-month longitudinal study examining EID usage in over 145 million HTTP header bidding requests sent to six major supply-side platforms (SSPs) from 616,539 websites. Our findings show that EIDs are widely used and are becoming increasingly prevalent in the digital advertising ecosystem, reaching 83.76% of studied websites by May 2025. Our analysis of the 18 popular EID providers that account for 99.42% of all transmitted EIDs in our dataset raises concerns about the readiness of EIDs as an alternative to third-party cookie tracking. In terms of accuracy, only one identity provider consistently recognizes and identifies that the visitor is a self-identified bot crawler, and many providers regularly transmit multiple EIDs for the same visitor. We also identify privacy concerns with EIDs, as 12 of the providers create persistent EIDs that can identify the same user across visits, websites, devices, and months. Finally, we found that 16 providers transmit EIDs on EU websites without user consent.

0.28

Do Open-Source Video Ad Clients Follow VAST 4.3? An Empirical Study of Player Conformance

cs.SE cs.MMcs.NI ·2026-10-29 ·Prashant Chaudhary
code/dataunusual similarity 0.48
Abstract · 51 pages, 20 tables, 3 figures. Harness, test vectors and results: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23581408

Context. Video ads reach streaming and connected-TV apps through VAST documents, and companies count ads from the HTTP requests the player's client library sends. A tracking error can leave playback intact and surface later as disagreeing counts. Objective. To measure how far open-source VAST clients meet the player duties of VAST 4.3, whether verdicts depend on the runtime, what generated inputs add, and when deviations were introduced. Method. A catalog of 108 requirements was extracted from the specification. Six open-source clients in eight configurations ran against 69 crafted test vectors and the IAB's sample tags, under Node.js and in five browsers on three engines, with every request recorded. Grids, fuzzing and a sweep over 36 releases extend the catalog; Google's closed IMA SDK is a comparison. Results. The open-source clients have 78 findings and 3 to 21 must-level deviations per configuration. None of the tested open-source clients that follow redirect (Wrapper) chains fills the required macros in a Wrapper's request; the archived IMA 3.794.0 configuration tested does. One library's timeout throws an exception no caller can catch, ending a Node.js process. In a pod (ads played back to back), one player credits a finishing ad's completion to the next ad, fixed in release 5.3.0. A library can conform under jsdom and deviate in every tested Chrome- and Safari-family browser. Conclusions. The tested clients diverge on the duties other companies use to count and diagnose ads. A shared conformance suite run in real browsers could expose most graded deviations; the harness and vectors are released.

0.41

Reconciling Bottom-Up Metrics with Top-Down Reporting for Cloud Carbon Accounting

cs.DC ·2026-10-07 ·Philipp Wiesner, Loïc Lannelongue, Alexander Acker, Odej Kao
publishedsurveyposition similarity 0.47
Abstract

Organizations seeking to reduce the carbon footprint of their cloud applications must rely on two largely disconnected ways of measuring it, each with important limitations. Bottom-up metrics like Software Carbon Intensity (SCI) provide signals for carbon-aware optimization, but tenants lack the information needed to account for many provider-side overheads. Top-down reports by cloud providers provide a more comprehensive view of a tenant's carbon footprint but are coarse and methodologically opaque. Because the two approaches differ in scope and reporting frequency, the current state of the art treats them as decoupled: bottom-up metrics for optimization, top-down reports for corporate disclosure. We argue that the two signals should be reconcilable. A per-workload metric whose improvements never surface in the provider's audited report will not be adopted for accountability at scale. We survey the state of the art in cloud carbon accounting and propose a vision for reconciled SCI (rSCI): a per-workload metric that re-anchors a bottom-up energy estimate to the cloud provider's top-down report through a residual. By decomposing and allocating this residual according to its physical drivers, rSCI can preserve operational incentives while also attributing idle capacity and embodied carbon to the workloads that drive them. We show that today's top-down reporting is still too coarse and methodologically inconsistent to support credible reconciliation and lay out concrete steps in provider reporting and standards to make it practical.

0.30

Beyond Energy: When Sustainability Dimensions Reshape LLM Serving Decisions

cs.CY cs.DCcs.LGcs.PF ·2026-09-28 ·Tianyao Shi, Xipeng Shen, Yi Ding
similarity 0.47
Abstract · 41 pages, 30 figures, 13 tables

Large language model (LLM) serving has environmental impacts across energy consumption, carbon emission, water consumption, and biodiversity loss. Yet these dimensions are largely evaluated in isolation, leaving it unclear when and how they lead to different optimization decisions. We present PRISM, a unified framework for characterizing and optimizing LLM serving across energy, carbon, water, and biodiversity impacts. Our analysis reveals a fundamental distinction: computing configurations determine energy consumption, whereas where and when LLM serving is deployed determine its carbon, water, and biodiversity impacts. Under a fixed deployment choice and operational-only accounting, all dimensions preserve the same energy-based configuration ranking. Deployment rankings can diverge across dimensions, while embodied impacts can break configuration invariance when they exceed a lifecycle crossover boundary. PRISM identifies these conditions, quantifies cross-dimensional regrets, and balances the four dimensions. In regional-routing experiments, PRISM reduces median worst-case regret by 50.2% relative to the strongest baseline.

0.18

Beyond State-of-the-Art: Standardising Environmental Impact Metrics for AI Research

cs.AI ·2026-10-01 ·Lachlan McGinness, Dan Pagendam, Robert Offner
similarity 0.46
Abstract

As the capabilities and ubiquity of Large Language Models (LLMs) grow, so does their environmental footprint. Despite calls for responsible AI, the machine learning community lacks standardised practices for carbon accounting. Our automated literature review of the 5,285 papers accepted to NeurIPS 2025 reveals that reporting of environmental impact is nearly non-existent. To catalyse a shift toward sustainable AI, we define standardised sustainability metrics for evaluating model training efficiency, accompanied by simple heuristics to estimate the carbon cost of LLM inference. We implement these metrics in carbonbenchmark, a drop-in software solution for tracking and reporting emissions. Finally, to combat the pursuit of marginal accuracy gains at disproportionate environmental costs, we formalise the `Smallest Model that Achieves the Job' (SMAJ), a framework which challenges the field to prioritise computational efficiency and environmental accountability alongside traditional `State-of-the-Art' (SotA) accuracy.

0.04

Measured from the feed: the unsustainable growth of AI video generation

cs.AI cs.CVcs.CYcs.ET ·2026-11-13 ·Tristan Coignion, Aurélie Bugeau, Gael Guennebaud, Anne-Laure Ligozat
theory similarity 0.46
Abstract · Main paper + Supplementary paper Under submission at a journal

Text-to-video generation runs at commercial scale, but its broader environmental impacts remain, to our knowledge, understudied. Providers rarely disclose video volumes or energy needs; we measured the yearly video output of two commercial platforms and built a prospective model of such services' absolute footprint from training to storage. Our projections suggest that reducing emissions depends on both limiting growth in video generation and achieving substantial efficiency gains. Under continued growth, emissions rise nearly seventy-five-fold by 2030 despite technological improvements. When usage remains at 2026 levels, the same improvements reduce emissions by about two-fifths. These estimates are a conservative lower bound: they cover one AI service among many; other services and uses would push the total higher.

0.22

When Ad Networks Misbehave: Understanding Risks of Semi-Drive-By Splash Ads

cs.CR ·2026-09-09 ·Song Wu, Bo Wang, Yifan Zhang, Yinfeng Cao, Xueqiang Wang
top venue similarity 0.45
Abstract · This paper has been accepted by the CCS2026b,it is going to be published

We investigate the mobile splash ads ecosystem, i.e., full-screen advertisements shown at app launch, where monetization relies on interaction signals that are difficult to verify end-to-end. This setting is especially sensitive because incidental touches and sensor-driven callbacks are common yet easy to misattribute as engagement. Prior work has largely framed mobile ad fraud as a publisher-side problem, while some studies attribute fraudulent operations to embedded ad libraries. Yet an important risk remains underexplored: ad SDKs control how interaction signals are interpreted, measured, and reported, creating an opportunity to reinterpret ambiguous user or device signals as valid advertising interactions. We uncover a previously less-known form of fraud at the ad-network layer in which splash ads are triggered not by intentional user actions but by incidental or indirect interactions, which we term semi-drive-by splash ads. By translating non-ad interactions into billable engagement events, ad networks can inflate performance metrics, overcharge advertisers, and erode user trust. To expose this behavior in the wild, we design AdHive, an automated honeypot-like analysis framework that induces evasive splash-ad delivery and landing behaviors under realistic device conditions. AdHive reproduces human-like activity through LLM-generated usage traces and sensor dynamics, enabling execution paths that remain hidden in conventional analysis environments. Our large-scale measurement across thousands of popular Android applications shows that semi-drive-by splash ads are widespread and are often triggered by subtle signals such as minor sensor variations. We further confirm real-world impact by working with one of China's largest advertisers, identifying multiple ad networks engaging in this fraud and leading to enforced repayments of about 4 million Yuan (approximately US$600,000).

0.46