CS Paper Radar

Evaluating Smart Home Device User Responses to their (Un)Confirmed Privacy Expectations

Tania Khatun, Mahdieh Sheikh Rezaei, Danny Yuxing Huang, Oded Nov, Reza Ghaiumy Anaraky

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-08-20 10:35 UTC · v1

Abstract

Users of smart home devices are often unaware of how their devices handle personal data. We examine how revealing these data practices influences user trust, satisfaction, and coping behaviors, including decisions to block device communications. Using Expectation-Confirmation Theory, we conducted two complementary studies to balance ecological validity with experimental control. An in-situ field study used network monitoring to reveal actual device traffic, and an online experiment presented simulated reports with manipulated levels of advertising-related communications. Across both studies, when data practices aligned with user expectations, satisfaction increased, strengthening intentions to continue using the device. Defensive responses, however, followed different pathways: satisfaction predicted willingness to block in the in-situ field study, whereas collection concerns were the primary predictor of blocking in the experiment. Together, these findings show how transparency reshapes attitudes and behaviors among existing smart-home users, underscoring the role of expectation confirmation in real-world, continued-use contexts.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Neglect to Resignation: Understanding the Evolution of Mobile Privacy

cs.HC ·2026-10-17 ·Yibo Meng, Ziqi Liu, Lionel Z. Wang, Shuning Zhang, Xiaolan Ding
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted by IMWUT 2026

This decade-long longitudinal qualitative study follows 31 smartphone users in China across four interview waves (2014-2023) to examine how mobile privacy understanding evolves alongside shifting computing infrastructures. Findings reveal three stages shaped by distinct interactional mechanisms: early functional acceptance of permission-based data access, growing vigilance triggered by behavioral tracking feedback loops, and eventual resignation as AI-driven inference made ecosystem-level profiling feel inescapable. Rather than a stable attitude, digital resignation emerges through cumulative infrastructure exposure, as each new system layer retroactively reinterpreted earlier permissions and exhausted users' capacity for self-management. The study challenges permission-centric design assumptions and proposes inference visibility, context isolation, and automated privacy agency as system-level responses.

0.60

User Perceptions of Deceptive In-Vehicle Infotainment User Interfaces

cs.CR ·2026-11-18 ·Pedram MohajerAnsari, Iwinosa Aideyan, Anna Galeano, Arjun Arunasalam, Bart Knijnenburg +2 more
top venue similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted to the Network and Distributed System Security (NDSS) Symposium 2027

Modern vehicles collect extensive data about drivers, passengers, and vehicle use, with privacy and consent decisions increasingly mediated through infotainment software. Although dark patterns have been widely studied in web, mobile, and e-commerce interfaces, little is known about how they appear in automotive infotainment systems or how users perceive them. We study this problem through Android Automotive OS (AAOS), conducting a three-phase empirical analysis. First, 26 HCI and privacy annotators audit four OEM AAOS emulators (Honda, Volvo, GM, and Polestar), documenting 17 dark-pattern types across 65 observations. Second, a user study with 100 participants compares OEM-specific implementations of five dark patterns across GMC, Honda, and Volvo, finding that implementation choices affect user perceptions. Third, an independent study with 49 participants compares automotive and e-commerce dark-pattern clips before and after a brief tutorial, showing that automotive's initial rating advantage largely collapses after instruction. Together, the studies identify a sophistication paradox: subtler dark patterns are less likely to trigger user suspicion and may therefore be harder to identify. These findings indicate that oversight should evaluate not just the presence but also the specific implementation of dark patterns.

0.61

The Privacy Paradox Is a Misnomer: Data Under Structural Uncertainty

cs.CY cs.HC ·2026-10-21 ·Ignacio Cofone
published similarity 0.56
Abstract · 2 figures, 4 tables

The infamous privacy paradox refers to the apparent inconsistency between people's stated concern for privacy and their readiness to disclose personal information. This phenomenon has sparked two largely disconnected literatures: one offering experimental evidence of inconsistent behavior, and another providing qualitative accounts and defending the importance of privacy. The Article presents an online field experiment that bridges those literatures and shows that the so-called paradox arises from a mischaracterization of the underlying behavior. The Article finds that it is structural uncertainty about risk that drives seemingly paradoxical privacy decisions. It does so by isolating discounting mechanisms and empirically testing whether observed privacy choices reflect temptation or rational responses to uncertainty. The results suggest that privacy behavior is not paradoxical but, rather, consistent with choices shaped by incomplete information. The Article then discusses the policy implications of this reframing. As privacy decisions stem from structural uncertainty, which operates as a market failure, regulation should aim to reduce that uncertainty. This supports regulation that prioritizes transparency (for people to assess the risks of data collection) and flexibility mechanisms that accommodate evolving contexts. Such reframing provides a new argument for the right to be forgotten, which allows people to revisit prior disclosures as new risks become apparent. By shifting the focus from individual inconsistency to structural uncertainty, the findings call for privacy law to better reflect the reality of people's decision-making environments.

0.74

Mobile Apps vs. Web Browsers: A User Perception Study with Android Apps and Google Chrome

cs.CR ·2026-08-13 ·Harel Berger
survey similarity 0.54
Abstract · An updated version of the SOUPS 2024 poster

This study examines user perceptions of mobile applications (apps) versus web browsers for accessing online services, with an emphasis on security, privacy, and usability aspects. Through a combination of an experiment and a survey with Android smartphone users, the research seeks to identify the key concerns and preferences that influence their choice between mobile apps and web browsers. The findings will offer valuable insights for developers to improve the security, privacy, and usability of both platforms by addressing user concerns and misconceptions.

0.04

Understanding the "Why": Investigating the Design of Privacy Support Tools (PSTs) through the Lens of Psychological Needs

cs.HC ·2026-10-13 ·Sara Hahn, Verena Zimmermann, Simon Althaus, Andreas Heinemann, Ephraim Zimmer +2 more
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 4 pages, 3 figures

Privacy Support Tools (PSTs) help users control their digital data, but face low adoption due to resignation and overwhelm. While current regulations aim to enhance privacy control, users still struggle to manage their privacy. To address this, we explore how PSTs can be designed for long-term adoption by applying the theoretical lens of psychological needs, as their fulfillment motivates users to use a digital product. We conducted in-depth interviews with 15 users and identified Security, Autonomy, and Competence as key psychological needs. From our results, we derive implications and recommendations for the need-sensitive design of PSTs.

0.18

Not All Nudges Land: Behavioral Controllability and Elaboration Quality in AI-Supported Journaling

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-08-12 ·Nadia Mehjabin, Henry Kautz, Subigya Nepal
published similarity 0.51
Abstract

AI journaling tools can tailor prompts to a person's own sensed behavior, but it is unclear which behaviors respond to them. We analyzed 369 journal entries from an eight-week passive sensing study. An LLM labeled each entry as expressing an intention to change a behavior or not, and we measured follow-through against 26 sensor features with a 3-day before/after comparison. Responsiveness depended most on whether a behavior involves other people. Behaviors that depend on others improved in only 15 to 22% of cases, while behaviors a person can act on alone improved more often, up to 50 to 63%, though unevenly. How users wrote mattered less. No single text feature separated improved from unimproved entries; writing carried signal only within specific behaviors, most clearly for text messaging and for longer, more personal intention entries. The sample is small, so we treat these as exploratory patterns that point to where AI journaling nudges are most likely to work.

0.17

To Stop or Not to Stop: Exploring the Intention-Behavior Gaps in Smartphone Usage

cs.HC ·2026-09-08 ·Jian Zheng, Eun Kyoung Choe
published similarity 0.51
Abstract · MobileHCI 2026

As smartphones become integral to daily life, researchers have sought to identify when the use becomes problematic. Previous studies have operationalized problematic smartphone usage (PSU) from either an intention or a behavior perspective. Both risk delivering interventions not welcomed by users. We propose a novel approach to operationalizing PSU as the intention-behavior gap (IBG). We collected self-reported data on intentions to stop phone usage, alongside usage behavior data, from 37 participants over two weeks. We calculated IBG, examined effects of demographic and contextual variables, and developed machine learning models to predict IBG in real time. We found that IBG was explained by gender, time, app, and input interactions, among other factors. Intention was predicted most accurately with only personal data, whereas behavior and IBG were predicted most accurately with both personal and global data. Our findings can inform the design of future intervention tools optimized for timing and adaptive intensity.

0.53

The CAST-framework: Measure and model social media use as a multi-level phenomenon through real-world applications

cs.HC cs.CYcs.SI ·2026-09-14 ·David Grüning, Jasper Doeninghaus, Zina Efchary, Yui Kondo, Kevin Dunnell +6 more
similarity 0.51
Abstract · 21 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables

Designing social media experiences that support well-being requires understanding when, how, and for whom use matters. Screen-time totals omit content and context, and connecting these with behavior and experience requires coordinating measurements across timescales. We introduce the CAST framework to connect measurement choices with person-specific models of exposure, behavior, physiology, and experience. Its dimensions specify where observations occur, how they are obtained, what they measure, and at what temporal resolution. Responses to interventions, such as whether to proceed after an app-opening pause, enter as behavioral measurements. We propose four synchronized measurement modules linking mobile and wearable data with self-reports and intervention responses. A synthetic demonstration with 120 simulated participants over 28 days illustrates how daily aggregation can obscure opposing effects of different activities under specified generating assumptions. The framework guides selection of measures and outcomes for evaluating social media interfaces and interventions.

0.25