CS Paper Radar

Chameleon: Robust Defense Against Tor Website Fingerprinting via Many-to-Many Traffic Morphing

Yuwen Cui, Kai Wei, Kehan Shen, Ning Wang, Zhuo Lu, Yao Liu, Guangjing Wang

cs.CR cs.CY ·submitted 2026-08-20 15:16 UTC · v1

Abstract

Website fingerprinting (WF) attacks can infer users' browsing activities from encrypted Tor traffic by exploiting side-channel features. Although many WF defenses have been proposed, we find that most existing defenses create learnable web trace mapping features. We further show that robustness against adversarial training does not necessarily imply robustness against defense-aware autoencoder (DAAE)-based attacks. To address these limitations, we present Chameleon, a robust WF defense based on many-to-many randomized traffic morphing. Chameleon selects morphing candidates with high intra-class diversity and low inter-class disparity. Chameleon randomly maps each webpage trace to multiple candidates, and allows different webpages to share morphing targets, thereby increasing adversarial uncertainty. For practical Tor deployment, Chameleon introduces a radix-trie-based synchronization mechanism that enables pluggable transport (PT) endpoints to identify consistent morphing traces using packet-direction prefixes, together with trace mutation and normalized prefix matching to reduce overhead. We evaluate Chameleon against six state-of-the-art defenses and five WF attacks on three public datasets in closed- and open-world settings. Compared with Adaptive Tamaraw, Chameleon reduces adversarial-training-based attack accuracy by up to 36.74% while reducing bandwidth and time overhead by 34.12% and 60.38%, respectively. Under DAAE-based RF attacks on GTT23, Chameleon limits attack performance to 35.19% F1-score while Adaptive Tamaraw only limits it to 88.22% F1-score. In the real-world PT bridge evaluation, Chameleon substantially reduces the effectiveness of strong WF attacks while incurring only 16.25% time overhead.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Mitigating Proxy-Induced Traffic Drift in Website Fingerprinting via Model-Agnostic Traffic Tailoring

cs.NI ·2026-08-21 ·Linxiao Yu, Tianyu Cui, Xinhao Deng, Yuqi Qing, Jun Tao +2 more
similarity 0.74
Abstract

Website fingerprinting (WF) based on deep learning can effectively identify websites from encrypted traffic. However, users often rely on proxy protocols to bypass censorship, and the diversity of these protocols poses a major challenge, as WF models trained on traffic from one set of protocols perform poorly when evaluated on that from unseen protocols. We attribute this issue to proxy-induced feature drift, where traffic patterns of the same website vary with the proxy protocol, leading to discrepancies that WF models fail to capture and severe performance degradation. To tackle this issue, we propose PA3, a model-agnostic preprocessing framework to analyze and mitigate the proxy-induced drift. PA3 first fingerprints the protocol-specific drift. These fingerprints are then used to tailor the proxied traffic for feature alignment, which mitigates the drift and considerably improves the generalization of WF models on traffic from unseen protocols. Extensive evaluations demonstrate that PA3 substantially enhances generalization on unseen protocols with an average improvement of 0.12 in F1-score (roughly 27% relative), achieving up to a 0.41 absolute gain across models, which narrows the performance gap introduced by the drift. In the best case, PA3 enables WF models to obtain F1-scores above 0.96 on traffic from unseen protocols.

0.06

Understanding the Privacy-Preserving Potential of HTTP/2 Against Webpage Fingerprinting

cs.CR ·2026-09-04 ·Bogdan Cebere, Prateek Kumar, Sylvain Chatel, Wouter Lueks, Christian Rossow
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Website fingerprinting (WF) attacks can infer which webpage a user visits from encrypted HTTPS traffic alone, compromising privacy even without decryption. WF defenses commonly shape traffic through noise, padding, delays, or flow splitting, yet they are most often studied from the perspective of encapsulating protocols like Tor or VPN rather than at the application layer (HTTP). In this work, we focus on application-layer defenses enabled by the most widely deployed version of HTTP, HTTP/2. We demonstrate how known defenses can be emulated through HTTP/2 features at the client side (HTTPOS, LLaMA, FRONT, Tamaraw) and the server side (ALPaCA, Tamaraw). We further show that HTTP/2 features, such as proactive resource suggestion, multiplexing, and flow control, offer untapped potential for lightweight yet effective defenses deployable at both endpoints. We evaluate these defenses using a unified blueprint that calibrates defense parameters per dataset, then combines practical attacks, information-theoretic leakage estimates, and overhead measurements. For each defense, this framework identifies the strongest hyperparameter-tuned fingerprinting model and estimates the residual uncertainty induced by the defense using two information-theoretic leakage estimators, all while accounting for the defense's privacy-overhead trade-offs.

0.10

On the Effectiveness of NetFlow-Based Deanonymization of Tor Onion Services (Extended Version)

cs.CR ·2026-10-10 ·Jinseo Lee, Jongkook Han, Yixin Sun, Min Suk Kang
top venue similarity 0.68
Abstract · To appear at IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2027

In the context of Tor, deanonymization attacks via traffic correlation have long been studied for both clients and onion services. Complementing prior investigations that utilize fine-grained flow metadata such as packet sizes and timings, we study a relatively less explored yet easier-to-obtain adversarial capability: deanonymization using only coarse NetFlow-style telemetry, such as one-minute, 1-out-of-1,000 sampled packet counts. We first revisit active NetFlow-based traffic analysis attacks against Tor onion services and show, through large-scale experiments with live Tor data, that coarse telemetry is sufficient to deanonymize a targeted onion service when the adversary can induce discernible traffic patterns through controlled downloads. We then introduce a stronger active attack based on controlled introduction requests, which removes application-specific assumptions and gives adversaries more flexibility while achieving comparable success rates. Finally, we present a passive deanonymization attack that sends zero traffic to target onion services. The attack exploits Tor's puzzle-based DoS defense as a side channel: public puzzle difficulty reveals service-load changes that can be semantically matched against NetFlow traces. Our findings show that coarse network telemetry poses a practical deanonymization threat to onion services today and call for proactive mitigations and a redesign of the globally visible defense signals that may leak service-load information.

0.24

CipherSight: Robust Website Fingerprinting via Record-Resource Semantic Supervision under Distribution Shifts

cs.CR cs.AIcs.NI ·2026-08-14 ·Runhan Song, Qiqi Liu, Chuanzhou Pan, Zhenquan Ding, Youquan Xian +4 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

HTTPS website fingerprinting (WF) aims to identify visited websites from metadata observable in encrypted traffic. However, real-world deployments introduce a significant out-of-distribution (OOD) problem caused by temporal and geographic changes, while previously unseen websites are common in open-world scenarios. Existing methods primarily learn from raw TCP packet sequences and struggle to capture stable and generalizable website representations, resulting in performance degradation under practical conditions. We propose CipherSight, a TLS-record-based hierarchical framework for robust HTTPS WF. Unlike existing approaches that rely on TCP packet sequences and are sensitive to transport-layer artifacts, CipherSight learns website representations from TLS records by jointly encoding multiple record-level attributes. It introduces a hierarchical architecture that captures both intra-flow dependencies among TLS records and inter-flow interactions across concurrent flows, enabling the model to exploit structural patterns in HTTPS traffic. Besides, to learn robust representations, CipherSight employs a masked record modeling (MRM) task to capture contextual traffic semantics and leverages fine-grained record-resource annotations as privileged supervision through structure-aware objectives and semantic distillation. Experiments show that CipherSight achieves 95.41% accuracy across more than 2,000 website classes in the closed-world setting and maintains over 90% accuracy under both temporal and geographic drift, consistently outperforming all evaluated baselines.

0.37

Local Order Matters: A Lightweight CPU-Trainable CNN for Website Fingerprinting on Defended Tor Traffic

cs.CR cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-11-15 ·Puyang Xu, Zhizhao Wen, Yifan Jiang, Chao Wang, Yusi Gong
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 5 pages, 1 figure. Conference paper submitted to the 11th International Conference on Computer and Information Processing Technology (ISCIPT…

Website fingerprinting (WF) attacks let a passive adversary infer which site a Tor user visits from the encrypted cell sequence. On undefended traffic, hand-crafted-feature attacks are already near-ceiling, so deep learning offers only a marginal advantage there. We show that the decisive regime is defended traffic: against the FRONT padding defense, which injects dummy cells that corrupt the volume and count features feature attacks rely on, a compact 95,103-parameter 1-D convolutional network trained on the raw cell-direction sequence, on CPU only, stays robust while three implemented direction-only feature baselines degrade. On the closed-world WFlib FRONT set (95 sites), our model reaches 54.2% top-1 accuracy versus 38.5% for the strongest implemented feature baseline (k-FP-style RF), a gain of 15.7 percentage points (3 seeds; seed-0 paired-bootstrap 95% CI [+14.5, +17.0] pp on per-trace correctness, excluding zero). On undefended traffic the CNN reaches 94.1% versus 92.3% for k-FP-style RF. A controlled order-ablation permutes only nonzero traffic cells within each trace, preserving direction counts, retained length, and trailing zero-padding positions while destroying traffic order. This collapses the CNN below every feature baseline (from 54.2% to 7.6%, a 46.6 pp drop), showing that the model depends strongly on order-derived information under FRONT.

0.45

SCSM: A Traffic-Native Foundation Model for Transferable Website Fingerprinting

cs.CR ·2026-10-06 ·Xianwen Deng, Ruijie Zhao, Mingwei Zhan, Yijun Wang, Zhi Xue
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract

Website fingerprinting infers the websites visited by users from encrypted traffic metadata. However, models trained under fixed collection conditions often degrade as website sets, collection times, network paths, browsers, or defenses change. Existing transferable attacks either rely on handcrafted perturbations of individual traces or adapt language-oriented architectures to traffic, limiting their ability to capture traffic-native semantics. To address these limitations, we propose SCSM, a traffic-native foundation model for transferable website fingerprinting. Specifically, SCSM constructs pairs of pretraining views from the same group of unlabeled traces through Segmentation, Combination, Scaling, and Masking. These operations produce diverse observable patterns while preserving the underlying packet events and local traffic dynamics of real trace fragments. The corresponding windowed traffic counting matrices serve as inputs for contrastive pretraining of a state-space encoder without website annotations. The pretrained encoder is then fine-tuned on a small labeled support set, and predictions are aggregated across temporal scales at inference. Experimental results demonstrate that SCSM surpasses the strongest baselines by 16.4\% in average top-3 accuracy over six temporal-drift tasks on GTT23 and by 13.8\% in average macro-F1 over four cross-domain datasets. The code and datasets will be made available at https://github.com/SJTU-dxw/WF-SCSM.

0.23

FlowAtom: Atom-Based Evidence Aggregation for Multi-Label Website Fingerprinting

cs.LG cs.NI ·2026-09-24 ·Chongru Fan, Wentao Huang, Wei Wang, Zhenquan Ding, Jinqiao Shi +2 more
code/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 5 pages. Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Identifying the set of monitored websites in mixed encrypted traffic is challenging because an individual flow often provides only partial evidence of website identity. To address this challenge, we propose FlowAtom, which constructs shared prototypes, called Atoms, from flow representations without website labels. Specifically, FlowAtom pretrains a flow encoder on external unlabeled traffic and aggregates Atom responses across flows within each observation window into a fixed-dimensional, permutation-invariant representation for monitored website-set prediction. Across Direct HTTPS, Trojan, and VMess, FlowAtom achieves micro-F1 scores of 97.82%, 94.43%, and 93.92% in closed-world evaluation, respectively, and consistently outperforms the evaluated baselines in open-world evaluation on windows containing monitored visits. The code is available at https://github.com/aimafan123/FlowAtom.

0.34

Robust & Scalable Website Fingerprinting via Minimal DRAM Traffic

cs.CR cs.AR ·2026-11-06 ·Shubham Roy, Samar Perwez, Biswabandan Panda
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Website fingerprinting attacks infer websites visited by users and threaten their privacy. These attacks are classified as on-path, which monitor network traffic, and co-located, which exploit shared system resources. Existing co-located attacks, such as sweep-counting and loop-counting, achieve over 90% accuracy but suffer significant performance degradation on many-core systems. Loop-counting accuracy drops from 93% on 8 cores to 50% on 24 cores, while sweep-counting accuracy decreases from 84% to 45% across multiple Core Complex Dies (CCDs). To address these limitations, we propose memory-chasing, a scalable website fingerprinting attack that exploits DRAM traffic interference through pointer-chasing traversals with minimal interference. By counting DRAM accesses over fixed intervals, the attack generates distinctive traces for website classification. Evaluated on the top 50 websites, memory-chasing achieves 96% accuracy on a 24-core system, 86% across multiple CCDs, 80% across multiple sockets, and 97% in an open-world setting. Extensive evaluation across hardware configurations, browsers, operating systems, isolation mechanisms, system noise, and countermeasures demonstrates its robustness and scalability.

0.35