CS Paper Radar

Paraconsistent and paracomplete probabilities: Measuring reliable and unreliable beliefs

Verónica Borja Macias, Marcelo E. Coniglio, Alejandro Hernández-Tello

cs.LO ·submitted 2026-08-20 16:23 UTC · v2

Abstract

In this paper, we introduce the study of probability functions based on the 6-valued paradefinite (i.e., paraconsistent and paracomplete) logic LETK+. This logic is a powerful and versatile Logic of Evidence and Truth (LET) which is a conservative expansion of both classical logic and FDE. The framework introduced here allowed us to consider gaps, gluts, and reliability (or classicality) of the events, extending the detailed proposal for FDE-based probabilities presented by Klein, Majer, and Rafiee Rad. A distinctive feature of our proposal is the use of twist structure semantics, which gives rise to a natural interpretation of logical probabilities over LETK+ in terms of the three or six regions associated with each formula by a valuation in such models. The LETK+-probability functions are defined axiomatically and semantically, obtaining soundness and completeness results, as one would expect. Finally, conditional probabilities based on LETK+ are also studied. Specifically, both a semantic and a syntactic characterization of Jeffrey's update over LETK+-based probabilities is proposed, showing their equivalence.

Comment
The article's title was changed to a more informative one. The representation of the six regions defined by a formula was updated in Figs. 1 and 2. An example was added to Observation 12

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Essence and accident modalities meet Belnapian truth values

cs.LO math.LO ·2026-10-06 ·Yaroslav Petrukhin
published similarity 0.62
Abstract

This paper investigates many-valued generalisations of the classical essence and accident modalities. In two-valued logic, a proposition is essentially true (resp. false) if, whenever it is true (resp. false), it is necessarily true (resp. false); it is accidentally true (resp. false) if it is true (resp. false) but not necessarily so. Many-valued logics provide a natural setting for introducing further modalities of this kind. We focus on Belnap-Dunn's First-Degree Entailment (FDE), a four-valued system that generalises the classical truth values. More precisely, we consider an extension of FDE with Boolean negation and implication. In addition to modalities of essential and accidental truth and falsity, we define modalities of essential and accidental inconsistency and indeterminacy. We present a four-valued S5-based Kripke semantics and cut-free hypersequent calculi for the resulting logics. We then prove semantic and syntactic embedding theorems for these logics into a four-valued version of S5 with necessity and possibility modalities. These embeddings clarify the intended interpretation of the Belnapian essence and accident modalities and yield soundness, completeness, and cut-admissibility results.

0.39

Self-extensional logics of formal inconsistency: Decidability and limits for paraconsistency

cs.LO ·2026-08-28 ·Marcelo E. Coniglio, Héctor Federico Mallea
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · Revised and expanded version. coNP-completeness was proved for the principal extensions containing at least one of the six minimal explosive…

RmbC is a self-extensional paraconsistent logic in the family of Logics of Formal Inconsistency (LFIs). This system is obtained from mbC (the basic LFI) by adding the replacement property via two global inference rules. RmbC is characterized by a non-explosive negation $\neg$ and a consistency operator $\circ$, which recovers the principle of explosion in a controlled way. Together with its principal axiomatic extensions, RmbC admits a standard Lindenbaum-Tarski algebraization, with Boolean algebras with LFI operators (BALFIs) as its algebraic semantics. In this paper, we study how far this self-extensional paraconsistent behavior can be extended axiomatically, starting from RmbC. We classify pairs of very natural consistency axioms according to whether they preserve paraconsistency or force classical collapse; identify six minimal explosive combinations that collapse to a single algebraic core; and isolate a separate structural obstruction for the combination of excluded middle for $\neg$ with an involutive negation. We also investigate, for the first time, the decidability of this family of self-extensional LFIs. As a first result, we prove the finite model property for RmbC with respect to BALFI semantics via an algebraic filtration, which yields decidability, and transfer this result to several paraconsistent axiomatic extensions of RmbC. Finally, we establish a coNEXPTIME upper bound for the validity problem of RmbC and a coNP-hardness lower bound, and prove coNP-completeness for the principal extensions containing one of the six minimal explosive pairs.

0.18

A Unifying Perspective on Probabilities as Model Predictions

cs.CY stat.MLcs.LGmath.ST ·2026-09-09 ·Benedikt Höltgen
position similarity 0.56
Abstract

Although probabilistic statements are ubiquitous, foundational disagreements persist about their understanding, as exemplified by debates between Bayesians and frequentists; moreover, it is unclear when and why acting on them actually leads to desirable outcomes. Here, we argue that every probability is the output of a \emph{prediction method}, that is, it depends on both a particular way of constructing abstractions and a way of transforming them into predictions. Through this, we provide a unifying perspective on supposedly different kinds of probabilities and show that even supposedly objective ones are model-dependent. We demonstrate that when a finite calibration criterion is met, one can anticipate the distribution of utilities for a given policy and inform successful decision-making on finite sets of events. Based on the notion of prediction methods, inductive arguments, and the probability calculus, we explain the feasibility of the calibration criterion in many settings. Overall, we develop a coherent perspective on probabilities and their use, connecting key intuitions behind other interpretations along the way.

0.24

A hierarchy of faithfulness criteria for knowledge base completion

cs.AI ·2026-08-20 ·Olga Mashkova, Robert Hoehndorf
publishedcode/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · Accepted at NeSy 2026

Knowledge graph completion is evaluated by ranking observed triples above randomly corrupted ones, which treats every unobserved fact as false. When the object being completed is a description logic knowledge base rather than a plain graph, the open world assumption and deductive closure make this inadequate: relative to the knowledge base, a candidate axiom is entailed, contradictory, or undetermined, and a model that cannot separate a logically impossible axiom from a plausible novel one is not merely less accurate but semantically incorrect. We ask what it means for a knowledge base completion model to be logically faithful, and whether current embedding models are. We define a hierarchy of four increasingly strict criteria, discrimination, logical admissibility, monotonic logical faithfulness, and probabilistic logical faithfulness, and prove that they form a strict chain of implications. We ground the strongest criterion in the relative model count $P(α\mid\mathcal{O}) = \#(\mathcal{O}\cup\{α\})/\#(\mathcal{O})$, which recovers the trichotomy at its endpoints and ranks undetermined axioms in between. Evaluating knowledge graph and logic-geometric embedding models on $\mathcal{EL}$ ontologies, with entailed, contradictory, and undetermined test sets generated by a reasoner, we find that ranking accuracy does not imply logical faithfulness and that none of the evaluated models is faithful across the hierarchy. The code is available at https://github.com/bio-ontology-research-group/kbc.

0.42

Merging and Evolution of Data Bases: A Many-Logic Approach

cs.LO cs.DB ·2026-10-29 ·Manuel A. Martins, Abilio Rodrigues
published similarity 0.56
Abstract · In Proceedings NCL'26, arXiv:2610.34489

A new approach to information-based logics using many-logic modal structures (MLMSs) was recently proposed by Martins et al. In such a setting, it is possible to have worlds with different underlying logics within the same frame, all anchored to a base lattice that contains the semantics of each logic as a down-complete sublattice. In this paper, we take the lattice L6, defined by the six-valued semantics of the logic of evidence and truth LET + K , as our base lattice. We also consider four-, three-, and two-valued formal systems associated with down-complete sublattices of L6. These logics are capable of representing paracomplete, paraconsistent, and classical contexts with six, four, three, and two informational scenarios, respectively. As applications of MLMSs, we will discuss the merging and temporal evolution of databases whose underlying logics are two-, three-, four-, and six-valued. We will also investigate inconsistency measures in this context.

0.47

Evidential-Based Higher-Order Set Argumentation Framework

cs.AI math.LO ·2026-08-28 ·Shuai Tang
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Evidential argumentation extends Dung's abstract argumentation by requiring arguments and interactions to be backed by chains of evidence rooted in prima-facie elements. However, existing formalisms lack a unified treatment of evidential support, higher-order relations (attacks and supports targeting arbitrary elements), and collective interactions (sources as sets). In this paper, we introduce the Evidential-Based Higher-Order Set Argumentation Framework (EHSAF), which conservatively generalises several existing frameworks within a single expressive setting. We develop two complete semantics for EHSAFs: an \emph{adjacent complete labelling semantics} that admits multiple truth values (true, false, undecided) for arguments in support cycles, reflecting an open epistemic attitude toward future evidence; and an \emph{extension-based complete semantics} that follows a strict evidentialist stance, accepting only arguments with well-founded support chains. We show that these two semantics diverge in the presence of support cycles, and prove their equivalence under support-acyclicity. To enable computational reasoning, we provide a normal propositional encoding of EHSAFs and prove that, in three-valued Łukasiewicz logic, its models correspond precisely to the adjacent complete labellings. We further extend this encoding to continuous fuzzy logics (G{ö}del, Product, and Łukasiewicz), defining a continuous fuzzy normal encoded semantics. We establish that this fuzzy semantics satisfies key properties---continuity, monotonicity, boundary conditions, and solution existence---and that its ternarisation recovers the adjacent complete labellings under natural t-norm conditions. Our framework thus unifies expressive argumentation with principled three-valued and fuzzy semantics, bridging the gap between qualitative and quantitative reasoning about evidence.

0.20

Decoupling Evidence Sources in Paraconsistent Logic: A Generalized PAL2v Framework for Educational Assessment

cs.LO math.ST ·2026-09-08 ·Arthur Nakamura, David Drummond, Welbert Pereira, Gustavo Lahr, Kaique Matias de Andrade Roberto
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Paraconsistent Annotated Logic with two values (PAL2v) annotates a proposition with a pair $(μ,λ)$ of degrees of favorable and unfavorable evidence, drawn from a bilattice whose four extreme points are the values of Belnap and Dunn. In applications, however, the second coordinate is almost always taken to be the complement of the first, and several such annotations are then fused. We show that this practice determines the sign of the degree of contradiction in advance, independently of the data: for aggregation functions $F$ and $G$ the fused degree of contradiction equals $F-G^{d}$, where $G^{d}$ is the De Morgan dual of $G$, so that it vanishes identically when the two are dual, and has a constant sign otherwise. In particular the componentwise minimum used throughout the literature yields only consistent annotations, and the conjunction of annotated logic only exact ones; five of the twelve logical states, contradiction among them, are essentially unreachable by construction. We also give a decision procedure for the twelve states that is provably total, in place of the inequality lists in current use, which assign two states to about half of the non-extreme region. We then propose a construction in which the two coordinates are computed from disjoint families of evidence, show that every logical state is attainable. Educational assessment provides a natural instance, since summative and formative instruments are institutionally distinct: mapping examinations to $μ$ and disengagement to $λ$ makes the degree of contradiction equal to the gap between what a student demonstrates and what that student invests. Simulations over three cohort profiles illustrate the classification.

0.36

Bayes Rule for Conditioning Probabilistic Programs

cs.PL cs.LO ·2026-10-07 ·Feras A. Saad
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Probabilistic programs provide a rigorous programming-language foundation for expressing rich probabilistic models and offer language-level support for solving challenging statistical inference problems. A key theoretical challenge that probabilistic programs inherit from probability theory is conditioning a probability distribution on an observation that has probability zero. Many languages address this challenge by using computational rules for conditioning that may work well for some problems but are statistically unsound for others. This article introduces a principled mathematical approach for conditioning probabilistic programs. We first show that existing techniques based on "soft conditioning" and "neighborhood limits" exhibit semantic issues from the perspective of measure theory and produce inference results that disagree with sound statistical reasoning. By leveraging tools from geometric measure theory, we construct a novel disintegration-based semantics for probabilistic program traces that enables sound conditioning. The theory delivers an explicit Bayes rule representation of the conditional distribution, which is directly compatible with widely used probabilistic inference algorithms that require access to unnormalized posterior densities. Our Bayes rule handles probabilistic models with loops, branches, discrete, continuous, and mixed-type distributions, observations on manifolds, differentiable structure, and additional modeling motifs that arise in practice.

0.15