CS Paper Radar

The Software Supply Chain as a Market for Lemons: A Multivocal Review of Trust Signal Collapse

Ranindya Paramitha, Christian Kästner, Laurie Williams

cs.CR cs.SE ·submitted 2026-08-21 02:23 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Practitioners evaluating open-source dependencies rely on cheap trust signals, e.g., stars, download counts, and contributor activity, as substitutes for direct code inspection, assuming those signals reflect genuine trustworthiness. Prior work has documented individual signal gaming, but the landscape of collapses across all dependency-adoption signals, as well as the ecosystem's response, remains unexplored. The goal of this study is to aid software practitioners in understanding the reliability of dependency adoption trust signals, such as download counts and contributor activity, by conducting a multivocal review of 252 Google Search sources and 870 Reddit threads. After coding the corpora, we find that cheap trust signals collapse under three simultaneous forces: adversarial manipulation, gaming techniques indistinguishable from legitimate behavior, and non-adversarial AI-driven inflation. The documented responses are more advice than actual action: 54.6% of Google Search sources contain advice on what practitioners should do, with no actual action taken. Responses proposed substituting one cheap signal for another or aggregating multiple signals, which are now also gameable. Non-adversarial inflation, i.e., degradation caused by the emergence of legitimate AI tooling, lacks documented actual behavior change in either corpus. The gap between known remedy and actual practice points toward a market for lemons: when faking signals costs less than earning them, good and bad dependencies become indistinguishable. Relying on individual practitioners to verify the cheap signals is not sustainable. Costlier signals, such as cryptographic attestation, should be made mandatory so that they become the default for all, not a voluntary choice for the few.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Rising Cost of Trust: Practitioners' Trust Signals, Controls, and Responses in the Software Supply Chain

cs.CR ·2026-08-21 ·Ranindya Paramitha, Siri Paidipalli, Laurie Williams, Christian Kästner
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract

The software supply chain is becoming more complex, and AI is reshaping its threat landscape, e.g., raising concerns about the quality of AI-generated dependencies. Seen through the lens of trust, the stakes of eroding trust in the software supply chain are high, yet we lack an empirical baseline on practitioners' trust. The goal of this study is to aid software practitioners in taking informed actions as trust in the software supply chain evolves, through an interview study with 38 practitioners. We conducted semi-structured interviews with industry and open-source practitioners, focusing on their revealed preferences (the controls they adopted) rather than their stated attitudes, and analyzed the data using thematic analysis grounded in established trust concepts from the social sciences. We find that trust is eroding, which is becoming costly: aware practitioners are accumulating controls. To cope with the rising cost of trust, practitioners automate verification, delegate trust decisions to guardians, or consider exiting the software supply chain entirely. Understanding software supply chain dynamics through the lens of trust provides the vocabulary and concepts (e.g., guardians of trust, system trust, signals) to shape future interventions for a well-functioning supply chain with appropriate levels of trust.

0.41

Do AI Coding Assistants Check Before They Install? A Pre-Registered Demand-Side Audit of Trust Signals in the Research Software Supply Chain

cs.CR cs.AIcs.SE ·2026-09-07 ·Pengyin Shan
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · 18 pages, 11 figures, 8 tables. Pre-registered protocol deposited 2026-08-22 (10.5281/zenodo.22062503); tooling v0.2.1 at 10.5281/zenodo.225…

AI coding assistants now select, install, and configure software, and attackers have exploited that position through invented package names, compromised maintainer accounts, and manipulated repository text. In response, the supply-chain community publishes machine-checkable trust signals: software bills of materials, signed releases, build provenance attestations, and declared official channels. Whether coding assistants read or act on those signals has not been measured for any of these classes on research software. We pre-registered and ran a controlled study on six open-source research software projects (three HPC, three quantum computing) drawn from an 87-project corpus, with protocol, seed, panel, and analysis plan deposited with a DOI before any trial. W created nine modified copies for each project: no signal, one per signal class, two with a signature or attestation from the wrong issuer, one with all four signals, and one reproducing documented conflicts in the project's own metadata. Three models under two ways of operating an assistant, with and without an approval step, gave 1,920 registered trials, plus a supplement on three frontier models. We scored behavior from container logs rather than from what the assistant said, and recorded the cost of every trial. Verification was rare under every condition: in 9 of 1,920 registered trials (0.5%), the assistant opened any provenance signal before installing in 0 of 384 control trials, and no trial ran a verification command, so signal presence had no measurable effect. We drew three conclusions: publishing signals is necessary but not sufficient; price did not buy verification (the model that verified most often costs $0.10 per trial; the most capable, at $1.00, verified nothing); verification must be built into the program that runs the assistant. We release the per-trial cost ledger, the protocol, and every log.

0.39

DCI: Dependency Confidence Index for Assessing Open-Source Dependency Trustworthiness

cs.SE cs.CR ·2026-08-17 ·Clemens Albrecht, Stefan Reitmann
surveycode/datahot direction similarity 0.62
Abstract

Selecting trustworthy open source software dependencies remains a major challenge in software supply chain security. We present the Dependency Confidence Index (DCI), a composite formative index that combines nine empirically weighted trust factors into a single normalized composite score for dependency selection. DCI's trust factors combine insights from a systematic literature review and an exploratory Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) survey of ten software developers, highlighting security, source code quality, and project health as the most influential dimensions. Following Goal-Question-Metric methodology, we implemented 12 automated measurements using SonarQube, GitHub APIs, and OpenSSF Scorecard data, deployed in a containerized evaluation platform. We conducted a pilot evaluation of the normalized DCI on 92 popular PyPI packages, observing moderate agreement with OpenSSF Scorecard scores and perfect test--retest reliability. Analysis reveals process-based factors (dependency management, CI) dominate scores on high-quality packages, while security metrics saturate---suggesting DCI's complementary role to existing tools. Our publicly available implementation provides a foundation for open source software trustworthiness research and practical dependency auditing.

0.48

An Exploratory Study of Dependabot Cooldown Adoption in Open-Source GitHub Projects

cs.SE ·2026-09-15 ·Hidetake Tanaka, Rikuto Tsuchida, Kazumasa Shimari, Raula Gaikovina Kula, Kenichi Matsumoto
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 32 pages, 11 tables, 2 figures

Automated dependency updates can rapidly propagate malicious package releases before maintainers and the broader community have enough time to detect them. In July 2025, GitHub made Dependabot cooldown generally available as a defense against software supply chain attacks. However, the effects of its early adoption remain unknown. In this exploratory study, we empirically examine how popular open-source GitHub repositories adopt and configure the feature and investigate their motivations. We find that security concerns motivated 83 of 92 adoption events with known motivations. Security linter warnings triggered 43 of 75 security-only adoptions. Among 251 ecosystems within repositories that retained cooldown, 97.2% set a general delay. Of these, 64.3% used seven days, while use of each update type setting was below 10%. Early adopters therefore favor simple default delays over fine-grained controls. These findings suggest that tools could provide robust defaults reflecting ecosystem support and reserve fine-grained controls for dependencies with clear update priorities.

0.64

Sign Here: Attributing a Source for a More Trustworthy Software Supply Chain

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-20 ·Derek Garcia
code/data similarity 0.59
Abstract

Software supply chain attacks continue to be on the rise, exploiting the trust that helps open source ecosystems thrive. Recent incidents like the Shai-Hulud worm and the Axios compromise demonstrate that a single malicious package can have wide reaching and devastating impacts overnight. These high profile attacks can be traced back to the same culprit: package registries. Although they are a useful convenience to pull prebuilt packages from, is such a commonly exploited component of the software supply chain worth the risk? In this paper, we investigate whether removing the registry from the developer workflow by building packages directly from source can serve as a malware prevention strategy - effectively removing an entire attack surface. Our hypothesis is that malicious packages avoid attributing a source to minimize visibility, while benign packages seek exposure and therefore link to their repositories. We evaluate this through three research questions: how effective is building from source at avoiding malware, how feasible is it to build from source in the current state of the supply chain, and how the building from source strategy compares to state-of-the-art security scanners. To do so, we (1) construct an aggregate dataset of 47,066 malicious packages from four academic and one industry malicious datasets source across npm and PyPI ecosystems, (2) build a snapshot index of all 3.9 million npm and 764 thousand PyPI packages, and (3) analyze all malicious samples alongside a statistically significant sample of 16,569 packages from each registry, totaling 33,138 packages. We find that simply checking for a source has a success rate between 87.7 and 99.9 percent of preventing malware, depending on the level of source vetting. Consequently, there is a significant lack of transparency within benign packages, with only 47.4 percent attributing a source an end user could build from.

0.20

Measuring the Security of the Evolving Software Supply Chain: a Research Agenda

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-09-08 ·Sarah Meriem Ourari
top venuesurveyposition similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted at IEEE ICSME 2026 , 6 pages , 3 figures

Software supply chain security has become increasingly critical due to the widespread reliance on third-party dependencies and the growing attack surface of modern software ecosystems. However, existing quantitative, measurement-based analysis and vulnerability management approaches remain largely fragmented and ecosystem-specific, limiting their ability to provide comparable risk assessments across environments. This paper presents a structured research plan, starting with a Systematization of Knowledge (SoK) to synthesize the current state of research and identify key gaps, highlighting the limitations in dependency modeling and vulnerability propagation analysis, particularly in the treatment of transitive dependencies and their real-world exploitability. Based on these insights, we argue for a unified measurement perspective capable of consistently representing and analyzing the cross-ecosystem dependency structure. We further identify emerging challenges introduced by AI-assisted software development, where coding LLMs are likely to contribute to new dependency patterns that are not captured by traditional Software Composition Analysis (SCA) tools. These shifts motivate a rethink of dependency modeling to account for evolving software-generation practices and their long-term structural impact on software security.

0.34

CRiDiT: Instantiating a run-time testbed for trust calibration in AI-infused systems

cs.HC ·2026-09-21 ·Yuntian Ding, Nicolas Herbaut, Camille Salinesi
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract

The integration of AI into larger technical infrastructures has made the alignment of human trust with system trustworthiness, known as trust calibration, a critical engineering concern, since misplaced trust in either direction leads to operational and safety risks. While conceptual frameworks provide a strong foundation for understanding trust calibration, their translation into running systems remains a challenge, because there are few testbeds in which human trust inputs, machine trustworthiness evidence, gap detection and remediation operate together within a closed loop. This paper instantiates CRiDiT (Computational Risk-Sensitive biDirectional Trust) as a run-time testbed, operationalising machine-side trust with Dempster-Shafer Theory and PCR5 redistribution, human-side trust with Subjective Logic, and calibration with a threshold-based trust gap. Following the Design Science Research methodology, we exercise the artifact across three high-stakes scenarios (hiring, financial, legal), producing 144 logged interaction steps across fifteen sessions. The analysis shows that the artifact captures trust calibration dynamics as intended, and reveals three points at which the instantiated policy departs from its design requirements: the machine-side estimate begins from a global benchmark rather than task-relevant evidence; risk-sensitive thresholds do not produce risk-sensitive triggering; and the calibration policy assigns explanatory prompts to over-trust, where corrections narrowed the gap in all 6 observed cases. Since the first two arise from the same design decision, to make the difference of two estimated scalars the calibration criterion, they point toward a common requirement: that the criterion should operate on the evidence rather than on scalars derived from it. The third concerns what follows detection, and shows that the action vocabulary inherited from trust repair does not align with what the interaction logs show to be effective. The work contributes the artifact, a characterisation of its run-time behaviour, and the requirements this characterisation elicits.

0.15

Assay: Claims That Decay With the Code. Content-Addressed Evidence Graphs for Accountable AI-Assisted Software Delivery

cs.SE ·2026-09-28 ·Om Shankar Tiwari, Tangi Vass, Gagan Deep Singh
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 8 pages, 4 figures, 5 tables. Code, experiments, and paper source: https://github.com/OmShiv/assay-research

AI coding agents fail in two coupled ways. They spend most of their context window rediscovering where things live, and they assert success without evidence when the work gets hard. Repository indexes address the first with cheap context, and orchestration frameworks with adversarial review address the second with accountability. Both describe the same object, the structure of the codebase, at two timescales: what is true of the code now, and what was verified to be true, at which revision, by whom. Assay makes that observation operational. Every claim an agent makes (tests pass, no secrets, behavior preserved) is bound to the Merkle hash of the dependency cone of the code it covers, so the claim is stale exactly when that code or anything it depends on changes. We show the binding is sound and minimal, and that the blast radius of a change is precisely the set of claims it invalidates. On the graph we place a risk-proportional evidence obligation, a bounded review protocol with separation of duties, and a merge gate that consults no model: coverage, freshness, signatures, exit codes, plausibility, evidence monotonicity (the mechanical form of "do not delete the failing test"), and review status. Assay is a dependency-free Python tool with an MCP server. On five public repositories a 600-token brief costs 14x to 114x less than an exploration proxy, warm rebuilds are up to 5x faster than cold ones, cone binding re-verifies 7.9% to 81.9% of claims where repository binding re-verifies all of them while per-module binding misses 23% to 68% of required invalidations, and the gate blocks 9 of 9 scripted adversarial behaviours while admitting the honest ones. Every number in this paper is generated by the released scripts.

0.60