CS Paper Radar

Specification Portability Across LLM Development Agents: Cross-Agent Compatibility in Specification-Driven Software Migration

Oleg Grynets, Oleksii Ilchuk, Dariia Zatulna, Vasyl Lyashkevych

cs.SE cs.AIcs.LO ·submitted 2026-08-21 15:21 UTC · v1

Abstract

This paper investigates cross-agent specification portability using Oracle-to-PostgreSQL migration as a controlled software transformation task. The study combines two experimental stages. First, a specification-first migration pipeline was evaluated on 1,006 PL/SQL files, of which 623 were successfully regenerated and 380 generated scripts executed successfully in PostgreSQL 16. Second, cross-agent experiments were conducted on a dataset of 1,802 Oracle scripts with corresponding PostgreSQL implementations using Amazon Kiro, Google Gemini, and GitHub Copilot, with Claude Code and Cursor included in the initial single-agent evaluation. Native and foreign specifications were assessed using Token F1, exact match, SQL syntax validity, AST exact match, AST mean similarity, and immediate runnability. The results show that specification size alone does not predict implementation quality and that cross-agent transfer can produce substantial agent-dependent degradation. The strongest replicated case occurred when Gemini directly consumed a Kiro-origin specification, producing a Token F1 of 0.035, SQL syntax validity of 2.33%, and AST mean similarity of 0.015. Rewriting substantially improved Gemini in the tested configuration, compression did not provide a universal benefit, and retrieval-augmented ingestion was the only common strategy represented on the per-agent Pareto frontiers of both Gemini and Copilot. The findings suggest that specifications in heterogeneous SDD workflows should not automatically be treated as agent-neutral artifacts and motivate explicit consideration of specification portability, agent-specific interpretation, and retrieval-based access in multi-agent software engineering.

Comment
11 pages, 4 figures, 7 tables, 27 references

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Measuring What a Specification Determines: A Formal Semantic-Block Model and an Execution-Judged Benchmark

cs.SE cs.AIcs.CLcs.LO ·2026-08-19 ·Oleg Grynets, Dmytro Kostetskyi, Vasyl Lyashkevych
benchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.66
Abstract · 11 pages, 1 figure, 7 tables, 37 references

This work introduces a formal semantic-block model for specifications and an execution-judged benchmark for evaluating specification quality independently of model capability. A specification is represented as a structure comprising semantic blocks, dependency relations, block-owned rules, decision points, and explicitly open questions, subject to four machine-checkable well-formedness conditions: acyclicity, single ownership, constraint domination, and totality or ambiguity-stop. Determinacy is defined model-theoretically as agreement among all conforming implementations and is estimated empirically through convergence across independent implementers. The model is instantiated on an Oracle-to-PostgreSQL migration specification containing 18 blocks and 19 dependency edges. Computational validation shows that the five-layer decomposition reduces mean per-task context by approximately 71% through dependency closures, covers 85.5% of the study-defined Oracle construct taxonomy with all identified gaps triaged, is not Pareto-dominated by the tested alternative partitions, and is recovered at the 99.9th percentile from citation-derived edges not used to define the original structure. The benchmark keeps the implementer panel fixed, includes a mandatory no-specification control arm, and uses PostgreSQL 16 and a live Oracle instance as deterministic execution judges. Six designed studies, including three pre-registered manipulations and three diagnostic analyses, further examine specification effects. Repeated runs on a 25-unit subsample reveal an empirical variability floor with a median arm-delta spread of 14.4 percentage points. The results support determinacy as a formal concept but not as a standalone empirical quality metric for the evaluated contemporary LLM implementers.

0.58

CodeMeepo: A Multi-Agent Workflow for Repository-Level Code Migration and Optimization

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-10-25 ·Farzad Habibi, Changrong Wu, Jinzhou Jiang, Guohan Lu
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

Repository-level code migration rewrites an entire project in a new programming language while preserving its observable behavior. It is challenging because behavior spans interdependent modules, dependencies and build infrastructure must be adapted to the target ecosystem, and the source code is often the only specification. Large language model agents can now attempt these migrations end to end, but three challenges remain. First, an agent that writes both the translation and its acceptance tests may overlook the same requirements in both, leaving missing or incorrect behavior undetected. Second, large repositories can exceed a model's context window, and dividing the work into smaller tasks does not ensure that all required behavior is migrated. Third, even behaviorally correct translations may be slower than the original implementation. We present CodeMeepo, a multi-agent pipeline for complete and efficient migration of large repositories. Each milestone is evaluated against a fixed external oracle that the agents neither author nor modify. A separate parity assessment compares source and target components in scope and adds identified gaps back into the plan as required work. Ordered milestones limit the scope of each task, while cumulative regression checks guard against breaking already-migrated behavior. A benchmark-guided optimization phase addresses performance, followed by full-suite conformance testing and repair. Eight specialized agent roles communicate through file artifacts, and a deterministic state machine governs repair, deferral, scope changes, and termination. On nine subjects in three language pairs, CodeMeepo achieves the best pass rate on every subject and passes 18% more tests than a state-of-the-art multi-agent baseline using the same model. On a production daemon, its optimization phase improves half of the benchmarks, by 25% on average.

0.16

A Hybrid Dependency-Aware Framework for Task Decomposition and Dynamic Agent Generation in Oracle-to-PostgreSQL Migration

cs.LO cs.AIcs.MAcs.SE ·2026-09-13 ·Oleg Grynets, Oleg Kaskun, Alona Seletska, Daryna Tukalo, Vasyl Lyashkevych
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 18 pages, 9 figures, 11 tables, 36 references

Large language model (LLM)-based database migration is often treated as direct code transformation, although enterprise Oracle systems contain heterogeneous SQL and PL/SQL artifacts with different dependencies, execution order, complexity, and validation needs. This paper proposes a hybrid dependency-aware framework that identifies migration tasks, builds a cross-file dependency graph, condenses cyclic dependencies, and uses task specifications to generate specialized migration agents at runtime. The deterministic path combines ANTLR-based parsing with typed dependency extraction, while an LLM fallback is invoked only for units that cannot be parsed reliably. On a corpus of 116 Oracle files, the pipeline produced 1,037 units with zero coverage gaps and 1,271 AST-derived dependencies. The fallback processed 165 parse-error units, recovered 496 additional validated dependencies, eliminated unresolved-dependency units, and increased resolved internal edges from 446 to 527. The graph contained four dependency-respecting phases, while cycle handling was validated separately using Tarjan SCC condensation. A complementary experiment on 1,006 PL/SQL files regenerated 623 scripts (~62%), of which 380 (~61%) executed successfully in PostgreSQL 16. Tables achieved about 85% regeneration success, whereas no query regenerations succeeded under the evaluated specification-mediated baseline, and procedural objects remained strongly dependent on schema context. These results motivate dependency-aware context delivery, task-specific validation, and differentiated agent routing. The paper also formalizes task-to-agent mapping, introduces monitoring and diagnostics for execution feedback, and defines a controlled comparison of monolithic, static-decomposition, dependency-aware, and dynamically orchestrated migration strategies.

0.30

Agent4Spec: An LLM-based Agentic System to Optimize API Specifications through Automated Validation and Market Analysis

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-10-09 ·Yongjian Tang, Costel Moraru, Doruk Tuncel, Hanya Elhashemy, Steffen Klepke +1 more
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted to FLLM main track

API specifications serve as critical documentation for modern software development, directly impacting integration efficiency and client code generation. While recent advancements have leveraged Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate initial specifications from source code, existing approaches treat this process as a one-time event - overlooking the needs for continuous validation, long-term maintenance, and market-driven evolution of these artifacts. To address this issue, we present Agent4Spec, an autonomous multi-agent framework featuring two distinct pipelines: (1) a validation pipeline that detects and self-corrects OpenAPI syntax errors, and (2) a market analysis pipeline that conducts competitive research, identifies functional gaps against industry leaders, and automatically generates missing API-spec functionalities. We evaluate Agent4Spec on two curated datasets of API specifications spanning both general-purpose and industrial scenarios. Among 9 SOTA LLMs, the top-performer achieves 100% syntax error detection rates and over 95% implementation success for proposed corrections, while securing over 50% adoption rates for suggested endpoint improvements, representing a practical tool for API development.

0.29

Leakage-Resistant Evaluation of AI-Generated Database Specifications in Specification-Driven Migration

cs.SE cs.DBcs.LO ·2026-10-08 ·Oleg Grynets, Ivan Fedorchuk, Vasyl Lyashkevych
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · 11 pages, 5 figures, 5 tables, 41 references

This paper presents a leakage-resistant framework and benchmark (LRFB) for measuring evaluators of AI-generated Oracle PL/SQL specifications. The benchmark contains 494 labelled source-specification pairs across 19 quality metrics grouped into seven dimensions; each metric contains 26 records divided into development and held-out subsets of 13 records each, with three clean and ten defective specifications per subset. Ground truth is mechanically sealed from inference and checked with canary and label-permutation tests. Three LLM judges were evaluated with three runs per record and compared against two trivial baselines. On 247 held-out records, GPT-4o, DeepSeek V4 Pro, and Claude Sonnet 4.5 reached balanced accuracies of 0.87, 0.89, and 0.81, respectively, while a specification-length baseline reached 0.88. Exact paired tests did not separate any judge from that baseline. The judges nevertheless provided information unavailable to length: the labelled defect category appeared among findings in 84%-92% of violated records, and quoted evidence overlapped the labelled span in 92%-93%. The study therefore reframes specification evaluation from binary issue detection toward evidence-linked, typed findings and benchmark-validity controls.

0.35

Architecture as Capability Equalizer for Coding Agents

cs.SE cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-08-22 ·Arquimedes Canedo
similarity 0.63
Abstract

LLM-based coding agents generate complete software systems from high-level descriptions, yet little is known about how the format of architecture specifications affects the quality of generated code or whether this effect depends on model capability. We present a controlled experiment comparing five informationally equivalent specification formats (informal prose, Mermaid diagrams with constraints and ADRs, OpenAPI, C4/Structurizr DSL, and TypeScript interface contracts with ArchUnit-style rules) across six models from three vendor families (Anthropic Claude, OpenAI GPT, Google Gemini). Across 90 multi-turn agent trials, specification format shows a strong format x model interaction. On the strongest models (Sonnet 4.6, GPT-5), format barely matters (quality spread 0.17-0.92). On weaker models, format produces spreads of 0.83-2.42 points, with code-proximate formats (OpenAPI, TypeScript contracts) recovering most of the capability gap. Mid-tier models can consume more tokens than frontier models for worse output when they enter compilation debugging loops that stronger models avoid. Self-validation rates collapse from 100% (Sonnet) to 0% (Gemini Flash) across the capability spectrum. TypeScript contracts triple API route coverage for the weakest model (33% to 100%). Structured architecture specifications serve as a capability equalizer, with value inversely proportional to model strength and the largest returns for cost-optimized deployments.

0.47

LYNX: Analytical Program Synthesis via Grounding and Closed-Loop Refinement

cs.AI cs.DB ·2026-10-10 ·Ruichen Xia, Xiao Han, Dingyu Yang, Luwei Yang, Sai Wu +3 more
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract

LLM-powered data analytics aims to translate natural language instructions into executable analytical programs over underlying data. However, existing approaches, whether treating LLMs as intent-to-code translators or as standalone analytical engines, often fail to reliably align domain semantics with complex schemas and heterogeneous metadata, resulting in brittle execution and semantically inconsistent analytical outputs in real-world workloads. We present LYNX, a multi-agent framework that formulates LLM-driven analytics as a schema- and knowledge-constrained analysis problem rather than a single-pass generation task. LYNX organizes analytical synthesis into a closed-loop workflow of planning, generation, verification, and refinement through three role-specialized agents that collaboratively enforce schema grounding, semantic consistency, and execution correctness. To address domain ambiguity and schema misalignment, LYNX integrates Semantic-Structural Distillation and Stage-Aware Allocation (SSD-SAA). A delta-guided iterative revision continuously diagnoses and repairs semantic and execution-level failures, substantially improving synthesis robustness. We evaluate LYNX on two NL-to-SQL benchmarks, BIRD-SQL Mini-Dev and the more challenging Spider 2.0-Lite. Experimental results demonstrate strong performance and efficiency, achieving 10.66% to 59.54% execution accuracy across lightweight and commercial models, while reducing token consumption by 70.53% compared with the prior most efficient method. Our framework displays high generalization over different backbones, from open-source, lightweight models to the latest commercial models. Additional case studies on quantitative finance analytics and complex multi-relational SQL workloads further demonstrate the framework's robustness, scalability, and practical applicability in real-world analytical scenarios.

0.36

Code Transformation Rule Synthesis using LLMs: Potential and Limits

cs.SE ·2026-09-03 ·Axel Allain, Aymeric Blot, Djamel Eddine Khelladi, Mathieu Acher
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted at the 41st IEEE/ACM International Conference on Automated Software Engineering (ASE 2026)

Due to their black-box nature, LLMs suffer from limited explain- ability and a lack of determinism. Their usage cost can also rise, particularly with repetitive tasks on large codebases. To mitigate this, we conduct a novel empirical study targeting three domain- specific languages for transformation rules, namely Comby, GritQL, and Ast-Grep. We evaluate three LLMs (GPT-5.4, GPT-oss-120B, and Llama3.1-8B) on six diverse datasets covering four software- evolution tasks: API misuse correction, program repair, API migra- tion, and language version migration. Our results provide evidence that transformation rule synthesis moves beyond proof-of-concept with strong frontier models. GPT-5.4 achieves consistently high rule applicability rates and produces transformations closest to the ground truth across most benchmarks. Smaller and open-weight GPT-oss-120B and Llama3.1-8B models remain effective for simpler, localized changes but struggle with complex migration scenarios. We also observe non-negligible generalizability through the usage of meta-variables and through a high reuse score in the first quartile of many datasets. Finally, when compared to the anti-unification algorithm, LLMs outperform it in correctness, but underperform in rule applicability. Overall, our results show great potential for LLMs to generate sound, correct, generalizable, and reusable rules.

0.59