CS Paper Radar

The geometry of AI validation: From structural blindness to reusable audits

Ricardo Fitas

cs.LG math.STstat.ML ·submitted 2026-08-21 15:18 UTC · v2
code/data

Abstract

AI systems increasingly search among candidate answers and deploy the highest-scoring one. Increasing search changes which errors matter, so a precise evaluation at one computation budget can leave another budget unresolved. We connect this information gap to the cost of closing it. For independent best-of-n search, aggregate reliability measurements identify deployment only through the directions they observe; we derive an exact ambiguity frontier when only small search widths are audited. Retaining candidate ranks and truth labels enables a constructive alternative: one audit can estimate reliability across all widths up to N. With known score percentiles, the minimax worst-coordinate mean squared error scales as (1 + log N)/T + N/M, capped at a constant, for expected budgets of T truth labels and M candidate observations. Matching lower bounds allow adaptive label acquisition, establishing that the distinct label and candidate costs are intrinsic to this experiment. An explicit design attains this order; a complementary record-based procedure supplies simultaneous guarantees without a known score distribution. Retrospective mathematical-reasoning and code-generation analyses show why search-dependent validation matters. In held-out CodeRM pools, a shared audit reduces the 95th-percentile maximum error across 100 widths by 58% and 40% relative to uniform labeling. These results turn structural ambiguity into a quantitative prescription for reusable validation.

Comment
19 pages, 5 figures. Substantially revised and extended version; includes supplementary material. Code and data: https://github.com/rfitas-lab/geometry-of-ai-validation

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Human-AI-Powered Hypothesis Testing: Cost-Aware Selective AI Scoring and Sequential Human Escalation

cs.AI cs.ITstat.ME ·2026-09-24 ·Dae Woong Ham, Xuejun Zhao, Stefanus Jasin, Fenghua Yang
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Large language models are increasingly used as inexpensive judges to evaluate outputs, label data, and assess whether a system meets a desired quality standard. Yet using AI judgments for formal statistical inference is fundamentally different from simply treating them as ground-truth labels: AI evaluations can be biased or noisy, and rigorous hypothesis testing requires explicit control of type-I and type-II errors. We study how to use AI judgments, together with selective human verification, to conduct a valid hypothesis test at minimum cost. We consider a population of items with hidden binary labels. After choosing a fixed pool of items, the decision maker can selectively query AI, send an item directly to a human, escalate an AI-scored item to a human after observing the AI report, or stop once sufficient evidence has accumulated. We derive an information-theoretic lower bound that captures the minimum cost of achieving prescribed testing errors and characterizes the value of AI information and human verification through a report-dependent information frontier. Motivated by this characterization, we develop SCALE, a sequential cost-aware policy that combines selective AI scoring with adaptive human escalation. SCALE is valid at finite sample sizes and matches the lower bound to first order as the target error probabilities vanish. We further extend the framework to an unknown AI-output model using paired AI-human pilot data. Numerically, SCALE approaches Human-only or AI-only testing when one source clearly dominates, while achieving its largest savings when inexpensive AI judgments and selective human verification are both valuable.

0.29

Test-Time Scaling via Budgeted Multi-Attribute Verification

cs.AI ·2026-09-28 ·Bo Xue, Ji Cheng, Shen-Huan Lyu, Yuanyu Wan, Shuang Qiu
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Verifying LLM-generated answers under a shared computational budget requires jointly deciding which candidates to inspect and which verification attributes to evaluate. We formulate this problem as multi-attribute good-arm identification under a global budget: each candidate is an arm evaluated along several costly attributes, and the goal is to certify as many candidates as possible whose mean scores exceed the prescribed thresholds on all attributes. We propose \textsc{BMA-GAI}, an algorithm that combines cost-aware arm selection with adaptive sampling of attributes. Every observation serves both to guide adaptive allocation and to support anytime-valid certification, which removes the need for a separate confirmation stage. We establish an asymptotic coverage guarantee for \textsc{BMA-GAI} and derive a matching information-theoretic converse that characterizes the intrinsic complexity of the problem, thereby proving that \textsc{BMA-GAI} is first-order optimal away from critical budget levels. Experiments on synthetic benchmarks and an LLM answer-verification task show that \textsc{BMA-GAI} allocates the verification budget more efficiently and certifies more high-quality candidates than competing methods.

0.54

DA-RAC: Distance-Aware Calibration of LLM Judges for Trustworthy AI Auditing

cs.CL ·2026-08-15 ·Cheng Wu, Vishal Anand, Jaya Krishna Mandivarapu, Xiya Liu, Rui Zhuang
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Generative AI systems are increasingly producing real-world artifacts, however their efficacy and validity are often evaluated via context-free LLM-scoring. These judges can be miscalibrated by irrelevant in-context reference examples, creating false confidence and allowing low-quality or harmful outputs to pass evaluation. We study this failure mode as context-induced miscalibration and introduce DA-RAC, a distance-aware reference-anchored calibration method for LLM judges. DA-RAC retrieves semantically and structurally similar labeled anchors for each judgement scenario, weights them by distance, and exposes neighborhood difficulty as a calibration and triage signal. On multi-run LLM-judge evaluation benchmarks, it improves calibration and reduces false-pass risk relative to zero-shot, chain-of-thought evaluation, and static-anchor baselines. Mechanistic analysis shows that judge scores vary systematically with anchor distance, while static references can induce misleading decision boundaries. Thus LLM-judgement requires not only better models, but also calibrated, auditable reference selection, especially when automated evaluation is used to support high-impact AI generated artifacts. Judgments should be grounded in relevant, inspectable, and contestable interpretive artifacts.

0.04

One-Sided Verification Under Limited Expert Review

cs.AI ·2026-10-13 ·Fan Nie, Haotian Ye, Shurui Liu, Zihao Wang, Stefano Ermon +1 more
highly cited similarity 0.66
Abstract

AI has become increasingly helpful in scientific discovery, yet human expert review remains essential for those problems without reliable automated evaluation, posing a fundamental challenge as candidate generation scales beyond available review capacity. This paper studies verification under limited human effort, where rare valid solutions need to be prioritized while invalid candidates should be filtered out to reduce human workload. We adopt the one-sided verification objective that maximizes the rejection rate of invalid solutions (TNR) under a constraint on the false-rejection rate of valid ones (FNR), making human review cost an explicit term to minimize. Drawing on the intuition that verifying a specific error can be easier than discovering one, we introduce OSVerify, an algorithmic framework that decouples error proposal from error validation. The error proposer searches for errors in solutions across different granularities by hierarchical decomposition, while the validator distinguishes substantial errors from minor or hallucinated ones. Experiments on competition- and research-level benchmarks show that OSVerify reduces the number of human reviews of invalid solutions by 46% on average compared to voting baselines under the same empirical low FNR constraint. Our post-training of the validator further improves the reduction to 57%. As high-impact real-world use cases, we apply OSVerify to identify errors in published research papers that are subsequently confirmed by the original authors and help resolve three Langlands open conjectures that are confirmed by experts, demonstrating its utility to facilitate human-AI research collaboration.

0.48

Strength Is Not Value: Rethinking Approximate Functional Dependency Measures for Error Detection

cs.DB ·2026-10-06 ·Xiaolong Wan, Xixian Han
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

Approximate functional dependency (AFD) strength measures are commonly used to prioritize candidate dependencies, including when selected dependencies support downstream tasks such as error detection. This practice implicitly assumes that dependencies ranked higher by strength are also better candidates for the task they are intended to support. We test this assumption directly for error detection. We evaluate detection value through precision and recall without imposing a single weighting on different error types, and introduce an explicit false-positive/false-negative cost only when a single candidate-selection objective is required. Across three real-world relations from an established AFD benchmark, $1{,}155$ corruption-and-detection runs, and $513{,}480$ candidate-level evaluations, we find a clear asymmetry. Strength measures tend to track precision positively, but their associations with recall are substantially less stable, with both magnitude and direction varying across measures and experimental settings. Strength-based prioritization is also unreliable at the ranking level: top-$k$ sets chosen by strength often have little overlap with those favored by actual detection performance, and strength-based selections can incur substantial regret. An important part of the recall mismatch is associated with structural detection opportunity under the candidate equivalence-class partition, which tracks recall more consistently overall than the strength measures we evaluate. Corruption mechanism and several static structural properties account for selected effects but do not provide a common explanation across settings, leaving part of the mismatch unresolved. Overall, AFD strength and detection value are distinct and should be evaluated separately.

0.38

The Double Measurement Confound in Agent Benchmarks: De-Scaffolding, Ground-Truth Scoring, and Reliability Beyond the Mean

cs.SE cond-mat.mtrl-sci ·2026-09-06 ·Yonghong Zhang, Shadi Motaali, Vu Phong Dinh, Avin Piroutiniya, Jorge E. López de Vergara +4 more
benchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.64
Abstract · 31 pages, 18 figures; supplementary material included as appendix

Agent benchmarks are increasingly used to compare large language models (LLMs) and guide deployment decisions, yet benchmark scores are meaningful only if they measure model capability rather than properties of the evaluation pipeline. We identify a double measurement confound: execution-critical decisions are performed by a fixed scaffold instead of the model, while the scorer evaluates outputs using criteria that may not reflect task correctness. We unify these issues within a measurement-theoretic framework that characterizes when benchmark scores can be interpreted as evidence of model capability, and instantiate it with an audit-and-repair protocol that (i) transfers execution-critical decisions from the scaffold to the model, (ii) replaces shape-based evaluation with seeded ground-truth scoring, and (iii) reports reliability beyond the mean through worst-case and tail-risk metrics. Experiments on ComtradeBench show that the joint intervention transforms a nearly flat leaderboard into a reliability spectrum that distinguishes both average performance and robustness across seeds. Applying the audit to existing benchmarks further shows that scorer validity is benchmark-specific, whereas scaffold ownership is an uncontrolled axis wherever we probed it. Our results suggest that benchmark scores should be interpreted together with their scaffolding level, scoring criterion, and reliability profile, providing a practical framework for more valid evaluation of LLM agents.

0.46

EPOCH: Reliable Discovery through Evidence-Governed Search

cs.AI ·2026-10-04 ·Binjie Guo, Aisheng Mo, Ruitong Li, Xinle Deng
benchmarktheory similarity 0.63
Abstract · 49 pages, 16 figures, including supplementary material

AI research agents are increasingly used to search over programs, mathematical constructions, and proofs. However, existing systems typically optimize evaluator feedback without adequately governing how that feedback is interpreted, challenged, and reused. As a result, promising but fragile candidates can be promoted as discoveries, while benchmark improvements, finite certificates, and theorem-level claims are too easily conflated. We introduce EPOCH, an evidence-governed architecture designed to close this gap. EPOCH implements an evidence-governed discovery loop by combining explicit task contracts, typed memory, active falsification, admission checks, and independent replay, so that each candidate is evaluated against the strength and scope of the claim it supports. EPOCH achieves state-of-the-art aggregate performance on AlgoTune, substantially exceeding the strongest baseline in mean normalized score (0.65 vs. 0.53), and attains the highest mean score on the internal Math14 suite (0.57). It further shows favorable held-out behavior under official-test replay and leads the descriptive aggregate on AgentHPO. Across ten discovery problems, EPOCH delivers substantial task-specific advances, including improved executable constructions, optimized algorithms, counterexamples, and proof-supported results. These advances demonstrate its ability to convert search into concrete progress across mathematical and computational domains. Together, the results suggest that evidence governance is a necessary step toward AI research agents that produce not only stronger solutions, but also more trustworthy scientific discoveries.

0.22

Reliable AI-Assisted Decisions via Selective Auditing

cs.LG stat.MLstat.ME ·2026-10-22 ·Isaac Gibbs, Elise L. Han, Ryan J. Tibshirani, Tijana Zrnic
similarity 0.63
Abstract

We consider online monitoring of an AI system that produces a sequence of decisions. At each round, the system outputs a proposed decision together with a confidence score estimating the trustworthiness of the decision. The decision and confidence score need not be produced by the same model: for example, one agent may propose a decision, while a separate verifier agent evaluates it and outputs a correctness or safety score. Based on this information, we must decide whether to accept the AI decision automatically or consult an expert, such as a human auditor, who reviews the proposal and either accepts or corrects it. We formulate this task as an online constrained optimization problem in which the goal is to minimize the frequency of expert auditing while guaranteeing that the fraction of AI errors that go unaudited stays below a user-defined threshold. We derive a family of algorithms with provable error-control guarantees with no assumptions, including a method that is optimally efficient: it asymptotically attains the best achievable auditing rate for both adversarial and i.i.d. data streams. Experiments on screening harmful requests to large language models, qualitative text annotation, and data labeling show that our methods achieve valid error control in practice while substantially reducing the need for human auditing compared to baselines.

0.18