CS Paper Radar

Consistently Good vs. Occasionally Great: A Rubric for Open-Ended Feedback Quality from Humans and Machines

Binglin Chen, Rajarshi Haldar, Max Fowler, Matthew West, Craig Zilles

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-08-22 08:48 UTC · v1

Abstract

Providing high-quality feedback on student work is essential for learning, yet delivering such feedback at scale remains challenging. In this paper, we focus on feedback for open-ended short answer questions in introductory programming, with the goal of nudging students toward success on reattempts without revealing the correct answer. We develop a five-criteria rubric grounded in educational literature for evaluating feedback quality: (1) acknowledging correct portions of the student answer, (2) identifying at least one flaw (if present), (3) providing actionable guidance for improvement, (4) maintaining appropriate concealment of the answer, and (5) using an appropriate conversational tone. Using this rubric, we compare feedback generated by a frontier LLM (OpenAI o1) to feedback from nine teaching assistants across 90 student responses, with three researchers and an LLM independently scoring all feedback. Our results show that while one TA often produced the best feedback, the LLM demonstrated consistently higher average performance than TAs, as evaluated by humans. However, we also uncover significant self-preference bias when using LLMs to evaluate feedback quality: the LLM systematically rated its own outputs higher than human experts did. This bias, which research suggests persists even in cross-model evaluation, raises important methodological concerns for researchers employing LLM-based evaluation. We provide detailed characterization of both TA and LLM performance, analyze sources of variance in TA feedback quality, and discuss implications for deploying LLM-generated feedback in educational settings.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond Score Accuracy: Examining the Diagnostic Quality of LLM-Generated Structured Assessment in Higher Education

cs.CY ·2026-10-07 ·Xi Zhao, Xinyue Jiao, Zhen Xu
similarity 0.72
Abstract

As Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly adopted for automated grading and feedback in higher education, their structured outputs, including multi-dimensional rubric scores, detailed feedback comments, and improvement suggestions, create an appearance of thorough analytic evaluation. This study examines whether these outputs deliver what they appear to offer. Using the JorGPT dataset of 3,041 student responses to 50 open-ended computer science questions, scored by both human instructors and three commercial LLMs, we identify three systematic discrepancies between the apparent and actual quality of LLM-generated grading and feedback. The sub-dimension scores are highly correlated (r = 0.82-0.99, VIF up to 45), providing redundant rather than independent diagnostic information. The textual feedback rarely detects student misconceptions (5-7% vs. 15-31% for teachers), functioning as a coverage checklist rather than a diagnostic instrument. The feedback tone remains uniformly positive regardless of response quality, lacking the severity modulation observed in human feedback. Additionally, grading accuracy varies significantly by knowledge domain, with procedural topics most reliable. These findings provide empirically grounded guidance on which aspects of LLM-generated grading and feedback can be relied upon and which require continued human oversight.

0.08

Making AI-Generated Feedback Matter: A Large-Scale Study of Feedback Workflows and Student Enactment

cs.AI ·2026-08-12 ·Omar Alsaiari, Nilufar Baghaei, Jason M. Lodge, Dragan Gaševi'c, Naomi Winstone +1 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Feedback processes strongly influence student learning, yet their educational value depends on addressing two distinct challenges: providing high-quality, timely, and individualised feedback at scale, and supporting students to interpret, evaluate, and act on that feedback productively. Generative AI offers a credible means of addressing the provision challenge, but students' uptake of AI-generated feedback remains limited. We conducted a large-scale quasi-experimental sequential cohort study comparing three AI-mediated feedback workflows across 13,037 students and 51,296 student-authored resources. In Directed Feedback (n = 3,723), students received AI-generated feedback comments without structured support. In Self-Directed Feedback (n = 3,951), students could initiate optional AI-supported dialogue. In Enacted Feedback (n = 5,363), students were prompted to select feedback suggestions, evaluate their relevance, and engage in targeted AI-supported dialogue anchored to those selections. Enacted Feedback was associated with significantly higher uptake of AI-generated feedback, with an estimated probability of 26.2%, compared with 14.1% for Directed Feedback and 0.1% for Self-Directed Feedback. It was also associated with significantly higher self-assessment confidence and submitted-work quality than both comparison conditions. These findings suggest that the educational value of AI-generated feedback depends not only on the quality of feedback comments, but also on workflows that actively structure students' enactment of feedback literacy processes. The results have implications for the design of AI feedback systems that position learners as active participants in judgement, dialogue, and improvement rather than passive recipients of comments. Overall findings show that AI access alone is insufficient; purposeful workflow design is central to productive feedback use.

0.04

Evaluating Feedback Focus and Pedagogical Adaptivity in LLM-Generated Feedback on Student Writing

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-23 ·Norah Almousa, Shayan Peyghambari Oskoui, Raquel Coelho, Gayle Rogers, Xiang Lorraine Li +1 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at AIME-Con 2026. Camera-ready version

We investigate whether state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) generate feedback that reflects the pedagogical practices of expert teachers in terms of feedback focus and adaptivity. Previous evaluation efforts have examined feedback characteristics, its impact on learning, and its target, yet the focus of feedback and its adaptivity remains largely overlooked. To bridge this gap, we adopt and refine Narciss's taxonomy into seven feedback focus types to annotate teacher and LLM-generated feedback across three university writing courses. We release FeedType, a benchmark containing annotated teacher and LLM feedback from six LLMs under three prompting strategies. We assess the coverage and distribution of feedback focus types, and examine whether LLMs adapt their feedback across draft stages and student performance levels as an expert instructor does. Our findings show that while most LLMs cover most feedback focus types, they fail to reflect teacher feedback distributions and show varying levels of adaptivity, with none matching the teachers' adaptive behavior. We believe FeedType will support future research on pedagogical alignment in LLM feedback generation.

0.35

ValiAssist: Scaling LLM-generated Programming Feedback Validation by Demonstration

cs.HC cs.AIcs.CY ·2026-10-19 ·Xiaohang Tang, Rehema Abulikemu, Peng Gao, Yan Chen
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Generative AI can create programming feedback at scale, but validating its alignment with instructors' pedagogical goals and strategies remains challenging. Instructors may struggle to fully specify validation criteria upfront, as these often emerge through inspecting concrete examples and revising misaligned feedback. We present ValiAssist, a validation-by-demonstration system that infers reusable validation logic from instructors' revisions of AI-generated feedback and allows instructors to inspect and refine that logic as it is applied across other student submissions. In a comparative study with 16 instructors, ValiAssist helped instructors create and refine validation criteria, producing feedback that better aligned with their pedagogical intent (91% vs. 57%) and more than doubling the accuracy of correcting problematic criteria (77% vs. 32%). Our findings suggest that validation by demonstration can help instructors turn judgments they know how to make on individual cases into explicit, reusable logic, while progressively clarifying where those judgments do and do not generalize.

0.08

Edhivo: An AI-Native Platform for Scalable Assessment and Instant Feedback in Higher Education

cs.CY ·2026-10-27 ·Moraish Kapoor, Jiawei Zhou
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Scaling assessment in higher education faces two intertwined bottlenecks: the cognitive burden of authoring assessments and the inability to semantically evaluate open-ended responses, which together create a persistent feedback gap that hinders student learning outcomes. To address these challenges, we present Edhivo, an AI-native pedagogical platform that addresses both bottlenecks through a vertically integrated system for content delivery, assessment, and reporting. Edhivo employs a Dual-LLM pipeline: one model generates context-aware assessments for both multiple-choice and open-ended questions, from instructor-provided materials, while a second model performs multi-criteria, rubric-based evaluation of student responses, enabling near-instant qualitative feedback at multiple hierarchical levels. All AI interactions are source-grounded to reduce hallucination risk, and a Human-in-the-Loop review process preserves instructor authority. We demonstrate Edhivo's efficacy through a pilot deployment at Stony Brook University in a real classroom environment in 2026 spring, where it supports high-frequency assessment creation and evaluation for a cohort of 36 students throughout a full semester, significantly reducing authoring effort and feedback latency while enabling novel pedagogical designs centered on active learning.

0.17

From Preferences to Principles: Rubric-Based Alignment for Grounded Knowledge Answers

cs.CL ·2026-08-24 ·Aman Saini, Priyanshu Kumar, Eric Peng, Kai Yuan, Harsh Girase +1 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 18 pages, 5 figures, 3 tables

Designing effective reward signals for open-domain question answering is challenging because high-quality responses must simultaneously satisfy multiple aspects of answer quality that are difficult to capture with a holistic scalar objective. We introduce a rubric-based reward framework that generates query-specific rubrics grounded in retrieved evidence and decomposed into multiple quality dimensions, providing fine-grained supervision during post-training. Averaged across three evaluation axes (composition, grounding, and instruction-following), our approach improves over the instruction-tuned baseline by 6.5% and over flat rubric variants by 4%, with consistent gains across all evaluation datasets. Conditioning rubrics on retrieved evidence improves factual support, while decomposing rubrics into quality-specific dimensions further improves coherence, organization, and adherence to query requirements. Our results show that grounded, multi-dimensional rubrics provide more effective reward supervision for complex open-domain question answering.

0.27

Evaluating LLM-Generated Feedback on Handwritten Mathematics: Feedback Quality and Subsequent Exam Performance

cs.CY ·2026-10-20 ·Arne Vanhoyweghen, Vincent Holst, Melika Mobini, Lukas Van de Voorde, Tibo Vanleke +5 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 10 pages, 2 figures

We evaluate the quality of feedback and practice exercises generated by GPT-5.1 from handwritten university mathematics answers and their grades, and examine whether receiving this feedback improves subsequent exam performance. We use six weekly bonus tests in an English (n=343) and a Dutch (n=236) cohort. Tests 1 and 3 used a crossover feedback design; otherwise, all attendees received feedback. To evaluate the feedback, six reviewers assessed 157 messages from three English-cohort tasks using six criteria scored from 0 to 3. The practice exercises received the highest proportion of strong ratings (95.5%), while diagnostic specificity (41.1%) and clarity and tone (33.4%) received fewer. Feedback for the lowest-scoring answers was rated as less actionable, suggesting that these students may need more targeted guidance from instructors. Comparisons of related exam questions showed mixed results, with no statistically significant differences after adjustment across four comparisons. Greater attendance and feedback exposure were associated with higher exam scores, but the contribution of feedback could not be separated from attendance and practice. Our findings show the potential of an integrated framework merging instructor guidance with automated feedback generation to provide personalised learning support at scale.

0.14

"High-Quality" Data for Early-Stage Instruction Tuning: An Empirical Study of Data Quality Metrics

cs.CL ·2026-10-25 ·Vladimir Necula, David Gvadzabia, Sofia Serrano
similarity 0.63
Abstract

"Data quality" is widely invoked in instruction tuning, but the term is often underspecified. We study it as an operational property by asking which simple example-level metrics, drawn from prior work on data selection, text quality, and instruction tuning, best predict training utility under a fixed finetuning budget. For each metric, we sort instruction-response examples by score, partition them into low, middle, and high bins with roughly equal token mass, finetune separately on each bin, and compare validation perplexity and LLM-as-judge scores for the models' generated answers as a function of cumulative training tokens. Our results suggest that answer-dense supervision, as captured by response ratio, is a stronger and more portable predictor of instruction-tuning utility than commonly used alternative proxies.

0.20