CS Paper Radar

Look Inside Each Video: Rethinking How Video Anomaly Detection Is Evaluated

Inpyo Song, Jangwon Lee

cs.CV ·submitted 2026-08-22 08:56 UTC · v2

Abstract

Video anomaly detection (VAD) aims to localize anomalous events by identifying when they occur. A common evaluation pools frame-level anomaly scores across all test videos and measures whether anomalous frames receive higher scores than normal frames (Micro-AUROC). This pooling creates comparisons both within the same video and across different videos. However, the pooled evaluation protocol commonly used in current VAD benchmarks makes Micro-AUROC heavily dependent on cross-video comparisons, which do not directly test whether anomalous frames rank above normal frames within the same video. To quantify this imbalance, we decompose Micro-AUROC into within-video and cross-video comparisons. Across four widely used weakly supervised VAD benchmarks, within-video pairs account for only 0.071-0.388% of all anomalous-normal frame pairs. This imbalance can make Micro-AUROC a poor indicator of within-video ranking. Video-level classifiers that assign a single score to each video achieve 81.40-97.18% Micro-AUROC while obtaining 50% Within-AUROC. For existing weakly supervised VAD detectors, replacing all frame scores in each video with their mean sets Within-AUROC to 50%. Across 120 runs, this replacement retains a median 98.8% of the original Micro-AUROC margin above chance. Because the decomposition depends on the evaluation protocol rather than the training supervision, the same distinction applies whenever VAD frame scores are pooled across videos. High Micro-AUROC alone therefore does not establish temporal localization. Our analysis reveals a limitation of pooled VAD evaluation and motivates reporting within-video ranking alongside Micro-AUROC.

Comment
Preprint

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Auditing Frame-Level AUC in Weakly Supervised Video Anomaly Detection: Granularity, Resolution, and Scene Bias

cs.CV ·2026-08-12 ·Sara Abdulaziz, Egor Bondarev
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.79
Abstract · Accepted at ECCV 2026 Empirical Theory (ET) Workshop v3: corrected a GT frame-alignment error in the prototype-based evaluation; prototype-A…

Frame-level area under the ROC curve (AUC) is the dominant evaluation metric for weakly supervised video anomaly detection (WSVAD). Its standard form measures whether an anomalous frame outranks a normal frame drawn from anywhere in the test set. We refer to this comparison as pooled AUC, since it aggregates frame pairs across test videos regardless of source. Pooled AUC therefore credits both event localization and differences between video sources. We audit this protocol on UCF-Crime across recent state-of-the-art models spanning different backbone families. Holding each model's frame scores fixed, we read them under three pairing granularities: global, per anomaly category, and within each video, then repeat the same three-granularity readout on zero-shot scores computed from the models' internal representations. We assess ranking reliability with a paired video bootstrap. Three findings follow. First, pooled AUC does not reliably predict within-video anomaly localization: models with similar pooled scores exhibit large localization differences and rank reversals under stricter granularities. Second, at the benchmark's test-split size, pooled AUC lacks the resolution to support state-of-the-art margins reported in the field. Within each backbone family, it resolves no comparison at those margins, while within-video AUC resolves several over identical predictions. Learned representations further reveal that within-video anomaly structure and detector localization are decoupled. Third, on normal footage alone, every model we examine separates videos by recording properties, such as resolution and color encoding, indicating that scene sensitivity is shared across the setting rather than specific to any architecture. We publicly release a granularity-aware protocol computable from existing predictions and scene-factor annotations for UCF-Crime.

0.57

Region-VAD: Video Anomaly Localization and Detection via Region Selection

cs.CV ·2026-11-16 ·Giacomo D'Amicantonio
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.73
Abstract · This paper has been accepted in the RWS workshop at WACV 2027

Anomalies are local events, yet weakly supervised video anomaly detection scores them globally. Most methods pool an entire frame into a single vector, rank frames by that vector, and derive a location afterwards as a saliency map of the score. Full-frame pooling mixes the anomaly with its background, so a detector can reach competitive benchmark scores from scene context without being able to show where in the scene the anomaly occurs. We introduce Region-VAD, which first selects a region and then detects the anomaly from that region alone. Region-VAD selects an explicit rectangle over the tokens of a frozen foundation model and scores anomalousness only from the tokens inside the box, through attention pooling followed by a standard temporal head. The rectangle is not learned, it is the box in which the frozen tokens change most between consecutive segments, in all four feature projections of the encoder, and it is found by exhaustive search over the rectangles of the token grid. Only the pooling and the temporal head are trained, from video-level labels without boxes, masks or frame-level annotations, and no trained component reads a token outside the selected region. Experiments on five datasets, with one localizer configuration shared by all datasets and backbones, show that Region-VAD achieves state-of-the-art anomaly localization on UCF-Crime and MSAD at competitive detection performance.

0.28

Anomaly-Guided Observation and Two-Level Semantic Feedback for Training-Free Video Anomaly Analysis

cs.CV ·2026-10-12 ·Hangil Park, Seungheon Kim, Tae-Kyun Kim
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Training-free language-based video anomaly detection (VAD) uses frozen vision--language models (VLMs) and large language models (LLMs) to localize abnormal events without task-specific model-weight optimization. Existing approaches increasingly exploit broader temporal and semantic context, yet generic context does not necessarily foreground abnormal events or specify how video-level semantics should modify local anomaly scores. We introduce a training-free semantic feedback framework that uses VAD-guided active observation for video anomaly understanding (VAU) and returns the resulting anomaly-focused description to refine temporal detection. Starting from an upstream anomaly-score curve, we adapt reasoning-based iterative frame selection: high-score regions seed the observations, and anomaly scores together with VLM relevance assessments guide subsequent temporal exploration. A frozen video-language model generates a single open-ended anomaly description from the selected frames. The description is returned through two complementary feedback levels: video-level feedback determines whether the score distribution should be suppressed, preserved, or sharpened, with selective visual rechecking, while local feedback retrieves event-related windows and promotes scores only after target-local visual verification. All model weights remain frozen, and feedback is applied once without regenerating the description. On the HIVAU video-summary evaluations of UCF-Crime and XD-Violence, VAD-guided observation improves GPT-rated reasonability, detail, and consistency over the matched CLIP-guided variant. For VAD, semantic feedback improves the re-evaluated upstream detector from 84.36% to 86.25% AUC on UCF-Crime and from 68.07% to 72.58% AP on XD-Violence, where the final AUC is 91.74%.

0.16

A VLM Answer Is Not an Anomaly Score: Rank Compression Across Image and Video Anomaly Detection

cs.CV ·2026-08-21 ·Inpyo Song, Jangwon Lee
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · Preprint

Anomaly detection aims to identify observations that deviate from normal patterns. Recent work has increasingly used pretrained vision--language models (VLMs) for training-free image and video anomaly detection without task-specific retraining. Anomaly detection is commonly evaluated by how well anomaly scores rank anomalous images or video frames above normal ones. Generative VLMs, however, assign probabilities to possible answers and then decode a single answer. This decoding step may discard ordering information. We call this loss decoded-answer rank compression. To isolate this effect, we compare two ways of scoring the same VLM output: one uses only the decoded answer, while the other computes a probability-weighted score over all possible answers. Probability-weighted scoring consistently outperforms decoded-answer scoring across image and video anomaly detection benchmarks, using different VLMs and answer scales. The mean gains range from 7.66 to 19.95 points on the primary metrics. Most of this gap comes from decoded-answer ties. Breaking decoded-answer ties with answer probabilities recovers at least 95% of the average performance gap on every benchmark. We further investigate how these ties affect evaluation. We find that evaluating tied scores one input at a time makes the reported AUROC depend on input order, and that linear PR interpolation can inflate reported performance. These results reveal that both how VLM outputs are scored and how discrete anomaly scores are evaluated affect reported anomaly-detection performance.

0.33

How to Explain your Unexplainable Video Anomaly Detector

cs.CV ·2026-11-16 ·Giacomom D'Amicantonio, Egor Bondarev
published similarity 0.67
Abstract · This paper has been accepted at the RWS workshop WACV 2027

Weakly-supervised Video Anomaly Detection (VAD) models assign anomaly scores from high-dimensional features, and their predictions remain unexplained. Saliency maps show where a model looks but not what it relies on, and the descriptions produced by Vision-Language Models (VLMs) are generated by branches that the anomaly score never reads. To address this faithfulness gap, we propose \textbf{Explain The Unexplainable (ETU)}, a classifier-agnostic framework that audits frozen VAD models through counterfactual interventions in their feature space. ETU maps video features to a discrete dependency graph of agents, actions and outcomes ($A_r \to A_a \to A_o$), regenerates the features by graph-conditioned diffusion with selected nodes of the graph masked, and measures the change in the score of a frozen detector; one set of interventions is applied unchanged to every detector. The generator is trained only to reconstruct the input features, so it cannot learn the contrast it is asked to measure, and we validate the audit with experiments that test every alternative explanation of its results, from the cost of regeneration to random deletions of matched size. On UCF-Crime features obtained from a CLIP encoder, we show that substituting the scene semantics results in the largest drop for most detectors, and that removing the outcome chain of the graph ($Δ_{rel}$) changes the anomaly score of all six audited detectors far more than removing the same number of random nodes, even though the random deletion perturbs the features about as much. We show that this targeted behavior comes from the divergence objective of the graph embedding. Without it, the two interventions become indistinguishable, and with a divergence objective in the generator as well, the score change of the detector follows the displacement of the reconstruction rather than the semantics that were removed.

0.33

Efficient Zero-Shot Video Anomaly Detection via Signal-Aware Adaptive Fusion (SAAF)

cs.CV cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-23 ·Khaled Waleed Dawoud, Muhammad Haris Khan
publishedcode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at WACV 2027

Deploying Vision-Language Models for video anomaly detection confronts a fundamental constraint. Their semantic reasoning demands computational budgets incompatible with the scale of real-world video streams. We present Signal-Aware Adaptive Fusion (SAAF), a framework that achieves efficient zero-shot anomaly detection through three key innovations. First, we introduce a dual-signal adaptive sampler operating in semantic embedding space: a delta signal captures sudden events via frame-to-frame cosine distance, while a drift signal detects static and gradual anomalies through deviation from rolling temporal context. Their OR-gated combination with adaptive EMA-based thresholding provides comprehensive anomaly coverage without training data. Second, we propose a threshold-gated cascaded architecture where lightweight frame-level scoring precedes expensive video-level temporal analysis, invoking it only when confidence warrants additional context. Third, we design a signal-aware weighted fusion mechanism that dynamically adapts score combination based on which signal triggered frame selection. Across four benchmarks, SAAF delivers competitive accuracy at substantially lower cost. Among training-free zero-shot methods, SAAF sets a new state of the art on XD-Violence (92.07%), MSAD (86.70%), and ShanghaiTech (80.54%) AUC-ROC, with XD-Violence and MSAD also surpassing supervised baselines. SAAF sustains 44.95, 48.61, and 41.06 FPS on XD-Violence, UCF-Crime, and MSAD, a 2.43$\times$, 2.63$\times$, and 2.22$\times$ throughput improvement over the prior best zero-shot method. Code: https://github.com/kdawoud91/SAAF

0.37

Auditing Observation-Quality Shortcuts in the Evaluation of Person-Centered Motion for Video Anomaly Detection

cs.CV ·2026-10-12 ·Chaehyun Kim, Changwon Lim
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 9 pages, 2 figures

Video anomaly detection (VAD) identifies deviations from normal patterns, but such deviations do not necessarily correspond to safety-critical events. We focus on human-centered emergencies and violence and investigate whether motion-based anomaly discrimination reflects task-relevant motion information or observation-quality differences arising from person detection, pose estimation, and tracking. We introduce an observation-quality-aware evaluation framework that combines quality diagnostics, quality balancing, motion orthogonalization, and robustness analyses. On human-centered categories of UCF-Crime, quality-only features match or exceed the discrimination of multi-cue motion in the original cohort, revealing a strong observation-quality shortcut. After cardinality matching brings all 11 measured quality variables below a prespecified marginal balance threshold, multi-cue motion consistently outperforms quality-only features across Logistic Regression, Random Forest, and RBF-SVM, yielding ROC-AUC gains of 0.046-0.141. Because nonlinear quality-only prediction remains above chance after matching, we interpret this result as additional discrimination beyond measured marginal quality rather than as evidence of quality-free or causal motion understanding. These findings show that high VAD performance should not be interpreted as evidence of abnormal-motion modeling without auditing the reliability of the person-observation pipeline. Our study provides a systematic protocol for evaluating observation-quality shortcuts and for assessing whether motion-based discrimination survives explicit control of detection, pose-estimation, and tracking reliability.

0.11

Probe-VAD: Ordinal Likelihood Probing for Training-Free Video Anomaly Detection

cs.CV ·2026-09-15 ·Jiawei Gu, Qilin Zhao, Tengkuo Guo, Zhiming Zhong, Shuangqing Zhang +4 more
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Under Review

Video anomaly detection (VAD) aims to localize anomalous events in untrimmed videos. Vision-language models (VLMs) provide rich visual understanding for training-free VAD, but existing approaches impose restrictive interfaces between visual understanding and anomaly scoring. Caption-based pipelines compress visual evidence into text, potentially discarding subtle cues, while direct numerical generation forces the model to express its judgment through a small set of predefined scores. Such interfaces can obscure subtle differences in anomaly severity, causing visually distinct clips to receive similar representations or scores and thereby limiting the resolution of anomaly ranking. We propose \textbf{Probe-VAD}, an ordinal binary-probing framework that directly probes severity preferences from a frozen VLM. Given raw video clips, Probe-VAD queries ten ordered severity thresholds and extracts constrained \textit{YES}/\textit{NO} continuation likelihoods. Their normalized preferences form a cumulative severity profile, from which tail evidence is aggregated into a continuous anomaly score, with isotonic projection enforcing ordinal consistency. Experiments on public VAD benchmarks demonstrate superior performance with low computational cost. Probe-VAD provides a simple interface for translating frozen VLM visual understanding into continuous, rank-sensitive anomaly scores without task-specific training or caption-based compression. Code is available at: https://github.com/yvestine/COVAS-VAD.

0.38