CS Paper Radar

From Click Modeling to Offline and Off-Policy Evaluation in Carousel Recommendation

Jingwei Kang

cs.IR cs.HC ·submitted 2026-08-22 15:56 UTC · v1
top venue

Abstract

Carousel interfaces are widely used in modern recommendation systems. Unlike traditional interfaces that present a single ranked list, carousels simultaneously present several ranked lists to the user, as horizontally swipeable rows stacked on top of each other. In this design, the rankings are closely tied to the two-dimensional layout. Consequently, user behavior is shaped not only by item preference, but also by row organization, viewport constraints, and item context. This tight coupling between ranking and presentation complicates the interpretation of user feedback, introducing new challenges for recommendation evaluation. My PhD research aims to address these challenges by rethinking how carousel clicks are modeled and how carousel recommendation policies can be evaluated from logged interaction data. So far, I have studied how users interact with carousel interfaces and developed a click model design framework that prioritizes mathematical relationships between observed variables over latent behavioral assumptions. Building on these results, my ongoing work includes a project using discrete choice models to represent clicks as choices, alongside a project that develops carousel-specific offline metrics. As a next step, I plan to develop off-policy evaluation methods that estimate the performance of recommendation policies from logged interactions. Taken together, the expected contribution of my thesis is a connected body of work that links carousel click modeling with offline and off-policy evaluation, so that carousel recommendation policies can be improved more reliably.

Journal ref
Proceedings of the 20th ACM Conference on Recommender Systems (RecSys '26), Minneapolis, USA, 2026, pp. 1932-1938
DOI
10.1145/3773078.3831937

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Revisiting N2DCG: An Empirically Grounded Reformulation of Carousel Recommendation Evaluation

cs.IR cs.HC ·2026-08-22 ·Jingwei Kang, Santiago de Leon-Martinez, Maarten de Rijke, Harrie Oosterhuis
top venue similarity 0.68
Abstract

Carousel interfaces have been widely used in video and music streaming services, yet it remains unclear how to properly evaluate recommender systems in these two-dimensional layouts. N2DCG has been proposed to address this gap by adapting NDCG to carousel-based recommendation, but it relies on unverified assumptions borrowed from the single-list web-search setting that do not transfer well to two-dimensional carousel layouts. We identify two substantial limitations of N2DCG: its ideal ranking, used for normalization, violates carousel constraints, and its discount function does not reflect user browsing behavior observed in empirical data. To address both limitations, we propose a reformulation of N2DCG that normalizes appropriately by respecting constraints and uses an empirically grounded discount function. We validate the proposed metric, showing that it better reflects users' empirical behavior on real-world eye-tracking data and better predicts the comparison results of carousel layouts simulated based on empirical examination patterns.

0.51

Ranking Bandits for Carousel Interfaces with Observable Browsing Depth

cs.LG ·2026-10-04 ·Takuma Yasuda, Atsuyoshi Nakamura, Dai Hai Nguyen
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · Some mistakes are fixed. One author is added

Carousel interfaces allow a recommender system to directly observe how far a user has browsed. This signal distinguishes displayed but unclicked items from items that were never displayed, whereas conventional ranking-bandit models, including cascade and position-based models, generally treat examination as latent. We formulate a ranking-bandit problem in which a learner presents a list of $L$ items, observes the user's maximum browsing depth, and receives click feedback only for positions up to that depth. The objective is to maximize the expected number of clicks under an unknown item-attractiveness vector and a browsing-depth distribution. We propose three algorithms based on UCB, Thompson Sampling, and DMED, all of which update item statistics only from observed exposures. We derive an instance-dependent logarithmic upper bound for our UCB-based algorithm and an asymptotic upper bound for our DMED-based algorithm that coincides with the lower bound as its parameter $α\downarrow 0$, establishing asymptotic optimality in this limit. Simulations in synthetic shallow- and deep-browsing environments, together with experiments parameterized from RecGaze interaction logs, show that OD-TS attains final mean regret similar to PBM-TS, while the proposed methods achieve lower final mean regret than PBM-UCB.

0.14

UserArena: Benchmarking Interactive User Simulation for Long-Horizon Shopping Agents

cs.IR ·2026-10-22 ·Jujia Zhao, Jiakai Tang, Jing Yu, Wen Chen, Jian Wu +4 more
benchmarkcommunity pick similarity 0.60
Abstract

Agentic recommendation pursues shopper goals through sequences of context-dependent decisions. Developing and evaluating such policies requires faithful recommendation world models that capture both the interactive shopping environment and users' behavioral responses over long interactions. Existing resources rarely provide long-horizon, fine-grained real-user trajectories or support trajectory-level evaluation and offline validation against production A/B results. We introduce UserArena, a real-world e-commerce interactive benchmark containing 64,729 session trajectories from 11,010 users, spanning 566,102 items and 13 action types. UserArena pairs these trajectories with an interactive environment and supports offline validation against outcomes from a controlled production A/B test, enabling five-level evaluation from output validity and local decisions to sequential behavior, personalization, and outcomes. To improve simulator fidelity over these long-horizon interactions, we further propose On-Policy Trajectory Distillation (OPTD), which uses trajectory-level intent to provide dense teacher targets on student-generated rollouts. Experiments show that OPTD achieves the strongest overall fidelity among the evaluated simulators under UserArena's evaluation protocol and most closely reproduces the production policy effect in offline simulation.

0.18

Beyond Independent Predictions: Learning the Browsing Journey for Sequence-Level Re-ranking

cs.IR ·2026-11-05 ·Jiayi Zhang, Jingxin Hai, Zhenjia Ma, Hongbin Pei, Dagui Chen +2 more
top venue similarity 0.59
Abstract

Re-ranking aims to present users with an ordered list that maximizes sequence-level utility. Industrial deployments widely adopt the Generator--Evaluator framework, where the generator proposes candidate sequences, and the evaluator scores them to select the best one for display. The fidelity of the evaluator's utility estimates thus directly governs recommendation quality. However, existing evaluators predominantly follow the \textbf{Independent Behavior Modeling (IBM)} paradigm, which simplifies the continuous user \emph{browsing journey} into independent per-item predictions (e.g., CTR). This oversimplification ignores two physical realities: (i) a click can occur only after the item has been reached and impressed, and (ii) items compete for finite user attention. As a result, IBM produces systematically biased evaluations and suboptimal sequence selection. To address this, we propose a \textbf{Joint Behavior Modeling (JBM)} perspective that explicitly models the \emph{display} $\rightarrow$ \emph{impression} $\rightarrow$ \emph{click} process to capture causal and competitive dependencies within a sequence. Building on JBM, we develop the \textbf{Impression-Click Evaluator (ICE)}, a plug-and-play framework that (i) predicts a browsing-depth distribution to estimate per-position impression probabilities, (ii) leverages predicted impressions to suppress spurious context from unexposed items during click modeling, and (iii) introduces a click distribution matching objective to capture intra-sequence dependencies. Extensive offline experiments across diverse backbones, together with a 14-day online A/B test in the Taobao App (+0.70\% clicks, +3.67\% revenue) and full-traffic deployment, validate the effectiveness and robustness of our approach.

0.32

IncVNM: An Interactive Recommender System with Incremental von Neumann-Morgenstern Utility Learning

cs.IR math.OC ·2026-11-01 ·Jiaxin Wei, Jia Liu
hot direction similarity 0.59
Abstract

In modern recommender systems, users are often presented with products whose outcomes are random. The values of such products depend on their entire outcome distributions and on users' attitudes toward risk, making them difficult to evaluate using traditional product-level recommendation methods. We propose \textsc{IncVNM}, an interactive recommender system that incrementally learns a user-specific von Neumann--Morgenstern (VNM) utility function from ordinal click feedback generated during ordinary webpage browsing. At each interaction, \textsc{IncVNM} converts the click order within a displayed product list into pairwise comparisons between outcome distributions and updates the nominal utility by minimizing its deviation from the previous estimate while incorporating the newly observed pairwise comparisons. To close the interaction loop, an entropy-regularized sampling policy balances exploitation of the learned utility against exploration for additional preference information. We evaluate \textsc{IncVNM} in a rolling-window experiment with different response-error probabilities and show that it substantially outperforms the expected-return, mean--variance, discounted-UCB, and distribution-aware BPR baselines.

0.29

Personalization Matters: Long-Horizon Conversation Agent with User-Centric Information in Online Shopping Interactions

cs.MA ·2026-10-08 ·Rena Gao, Yue Dai, Hao Guan, Shengxiang Gao, Wangyang Wu +2 more
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · accepted by AACL-IJCNLP 2026

Personalized conversational shopping requires maintaining preference consistency over multi-turn interactions, where users reveal constraints gradually. Existing approaches often rely on static profiles and do not explicitly control long-horizon interaction behavior. We propose a multi-agent, multimodal Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) framework that decomposes dialogue state tracking, recommendation retrieval, preference-aware reasoning, and response generation, while integrating product metadata, product reviews, image-derived descriptions, and user historical reviews. To evaluate interaction-level quality, we adopt a trajectory-level protocol with four dimensions: Global Preference Consistency, Cumulative Information Synthesis, Interaction Trajectory, and Tone Consistency. On an Amazon Reviews 2023 benchmark, retrieval-enabled variants outperform a no-RAG baseline on automatic trajectory metrics (average 4.82 vs. 3.74). In a small real-user study ($n{=}5$), the Full variant achieves the highest mean overall rating (4.60 vs. 2.20 for Baseline), providing exploratory evidence that role decomposition plus user-centric retrieval improves perceived personalization.\footnote{Code and dataset are available at: https://github.com/RenaGao/Multimodel_RAG_Indexing

0.54

Once Generated, Ranked: End-to-End Generative Slate Recommendation with Unified Semantic-Collaborative IDs

cs.IR cs.SI ·2026-08-18 ·Yang Hu, Jiayi Guo, Jingui Ma, Ning Li, Jiangling Qin +4 more
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 18 pages, 3 figures

Slate recommendation treats a slate rather than an individual item as the recommendation unit, requiring joint optimization of item interactions and slate utility. Existing approaches typically separate candidate generation from ranking and restrict optimization to retrieved candidates. Generative recommendation with Semantic IDs (SIDs) offers a path to end-to-end recommendation, but existing SID construction often lacks recommendation-aware semantics and effective local collaborative signals, while next-token prediction is misaligned with slate-level objectives. We propose OGR, an end-to-end framework that directly generates ordered slates-"Once Generated, Ranked." OGR first introduces TUSID, which adaptively fuses item-specific semantic and local collaborative information into hierarchical SIDs. It then uses list-wise preference planning and pipelined position-wise SID decoding to model global preferences and inter-item dependencies while generating ordered slates. We further propose SPA, a reward-guided conservative policy optimization method that aligns generated slates with user preferences beyond likelihood imitation. Offline experiments show that OGR outperforms representative baselines, with 48.2% and 27.2% relative NDCG@5 gains on industrial and public datasets, respectively. Online A/B testing on Kuaishou further yields a 1.120% improvement in Effective Views.

0.35

Dynamic Click Destinations: Personalizing Post Ad-Click Landing Experiences

cs.IR ·2026-10-31 ·Apurva Pathak, Yuya Shiraki, Iman Jenabzadeh, Nikhil Bhale, Yuwen Tan +2 more
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · 5 pages. Accepted to the IEEE ICDM International Workshop on AI for Personalization (WAIP 2026)

Apps that monetize outbound (offsite) ad clicks have multiple post ad-click levers that influence user and business outcomes, including the landing page shown on the advertiser's site, whether the click resolves to a webpage or an app on the user's device, and whether it resolves to a native in-product surface or an external website. We refer to personalization over these levers as post ad-click destination automation. The optimal destination is heterogeneous across users, advertisers, placements, devices, and inferred intent, making static, one-size-fits-all destination policies suboptimal. We present Dynamic Click Destinations (DCD), a production personalization framework that selects a destination for each eligible offsite ad click to maximize Advertiser Value (AV), a value-weighted conversion outcome. DCD applies to any post-click destination decision where the system can choose among destination options at click time and downstream conversion feedback is available. We describe an evolution of learning objectives from post-conversion destination inference, to two-task destination-conditioned conversion prediction, to a single-task policy model that directly predicts which of two destinations is better for a given click, trained with Advantage Actor Critic (A2C)-inspired soft labels derived from a higher-capacity destination-conditioned "critic" model. In a web-vs-app case study, online A/B experiments at scale on a major advertising platform show that per-click personalization with DCD outperforms both static routing policies, with the single-task objective delivering the largest gains. These results highlight post ad-click destination as an important and under-explored lever in conversion optimization and demonstrate that personalized destination automation can outperform one-size-fits-all destination policies.

0.33