CS Paper Radar

Causal Language in Post Titles Shapes Deeper Topological Structures of Online Conversations

Zhuoyu Shi, Fred Morstatter

cs.SI ·submitted 2026-08-23 00:32 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Causal reasoning is fundamental to human understanding and information organization. People prefer causal explanations because they offer coherence, predictability, and a sense of control. Conversational structures shape how knowledge and perspectives are shared, validated, and amplified in networked publics. Understanding the structural effects of causal language can reveal pathways to fostering deeper, more meaningful interactions online. In this work, we investigate how causal language influences the topology and temporal evolution of discussion threads in online conversations with a dataset of 17 million posts across 200 subreddits in 2023 on Reddit. Our results show that causal language is consistently associated with deeper, more sustained conversations, with effects emerging early in the lifecycle of a thread, as demonstrated through a counterfactual experiment. Importantly, emotional responses do not differ substantially between causal language and non-causal language, suggesting that structural depth arises from framing itself rather than affective escalation. A lightweight qualitative analysis shows that causal framing titles prompt users to elaborate more with reasoning and contribute personal experiences, supporting deeper multi-turn exchanges. These findings suggest that causal language acts not merely as a stylistic device, but as a cognitively grounded and structurally influential signal that shapes the topological structures of online conversations.

Comment
Accepted at CSCW 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

C$^{3}$T: Counterfactual Causal Reasoning for Sentiment Shifts in Social-Media Conversation Trees

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-02 ·S M Rafiuddin, Atriya Sen
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · 23 pages, 3 figures, 7 tables; accepted to the EMNLP 2026 Main Conference

Sentiment in social-media threads does not only vary across posts; it shifts as users react to claims, corrections, evidence, and hostility within a branching reply tree. We study why sentiment changes in rumor-centric conversation trees by treating discourse moves (e.g., denial/correction, evidence/link, toxicity/attack) as candidate interventions and asking (i) what sentiment a reply expresses, (ii) whether the sentiment shifts relative to its parent, and (iii) which prior message most plausibly drove the reply's sentiment. To support this setting, we introduce CaSiRe, a causal sentiment reasoning layer over public rumor conversation datasets that adds post-level sentiment labels, induced parent-child shift labels, calibrated multi-label intervention tags, and explicitly annotated causal-source labels. We then propose C$^{3}$T (Counterfactual Causal Conversation Transformer), a thread-structured temporal model that jointly predicts node sentiment and shifts, learns sparse ancestor attribution, and supports counterfactual queries by forcing conversational intervention embeddings on or off to estimate potential outcomes. Under an event-level split, C$^{3}$T improves out-of-event robustness and attribution over text-only, graph-based, and temporal baselines, and yields interpretable model-based effects: denials/corrections and evidence reduce downstream negativity, while toxicity increases it. We also benchmark open-weight LLM prompting baselines and find that added conversational context helps, but attribution remains less reliable, motivating structure-aware counterfactual modeling for social-media analysis.

0.35

The Emergence of Causal Curiosity from Prior Causal Belief Networks

cs.SI ·2026-08-23 ·Zhuoyu Shi, Xintong Jiang, Bohan Jiang, Fred Morstatter
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Presented as a 15-minute talk at NetSci 2026

Causal curiosity is foundational to human cognition. It is the desire to understand why events happen, what mechanisms underlie them, and how outcomes can be explained or anticipated. It motivates exploration, sustains attention, and fuels the search for new knowledge. However, despite consensus on the importance of causal curiosity, little is known about how causal curiosity arises from existing belief systems. In our work, we examine how causal curiosity emerges from prior knowledge structures. With Reddit data from 2020 to 2023, and leveraging language models to extract cause-and-effect relationship pairs and identify causal curiosity-driven questions, our findings reveal that causal curiosity is not random or independent, but largely rooted in prior knowledge structure. Particularly, \textit{positive} nouns are more likely to be the object of causal curiosity. Moreover, our findings indicate that concepts that serve more as \textit{causes} are more likely to appear in causal curiosity than those that serve more as effects. Lastly, our results also suggest that causal curiosity emerges from the \textit{central} of the prior belief network. These novel insights reveal that causal curiosity is not random but systematically grounded in prior knowledge structures, and suggest their implication to facilitate the human learning process by motivating people to actively explore and construct deeper understandings rather than passively receiving information.

0.31

From Web(logs) to Web(AI): Questions, Platforms, and Methods across Twenty Editions of ICWSM

cs.SI cs.CLcs.CYcs.HC ·2026-09-20 ·Koustuv Saha, Eshwar Chandrasekharan
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Over twenty editions, the ICWSM community has examined social life online as platforms, interactions, and research methods have changed. What can this body of research tell us at this critical juncture, as AI increasingly reshapes how people communicate online? We analyzed 2,139 indexed contributions from 2007 to 2026, distinguishing topics identified through nonnegative matrix factorization from problem framings captured through explicit textual cues. We find that platform mentions shift from blogs toward Twitter and, more recently, Reddit. Online community research maintains a similar topic share (10.5% to 10.0%), but governance cues within it increase from 4.0% to 34.3%. Harm-related cues also increase after restricting abstracts to a fixed length. Our review also traces advances in sampling, measurement, and causal and experimental methods. We discuss how AI-mediated interactions complicate these questions and provide a reporting checklist to support research across changing platforms.

0.21

Gender Attribution in Causal Beliefs

cs.SI ·2026-08-23 ·Zhuoyu Shi, Fred Morstatter
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted at ASONAM 2026

For centuries, women have been cast as the source of harm in public narratives, from witch hunts in early modern Europe to contemporary stereotypes about emotional instability. These cultural patterns reflect enduring biases in how people attribute causality and assign blame, often portraying women as agents of disruption and men as figures of rational authority. In this study, we examine how such gendered causal attributions appear in everyday language. Leveraging three complete 24-hour datasets of all English-language posts on Twitter, and using language models, we extract cause-and-effect relationship pairs and identify gendered attribution of causal agents. We then analyze how gender attribution relates to sentiment, the kinds of effects invoked, and the diffusion of posts through the social networks. Our findings reveal that female-attributed causes are more often associated with negative sentiment and emotional or relational outcomes, whereas male-attributed causes are more frequently linked to positive sentiment and abstract, structural effects. Moreover, male-attributed narratives spread more widely across communities. These results suggest that longstanding gender stereotypes continue to appear in how people express and amplify causal narratives in public discourse, in decentralized, high-velocity environments like social media.

0.24

LongSocialBench: Do Long-Context LLMs Understand Online Discussion Threads?

cs.CL ·2026-10-02 ·Xinyi Liu, Rinat Khaziev, Dilek Hakkani-Tür, Tarek F. Abdelzaher
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted to EMNLP 2026 Main Conference

Long-context LLMs can now ingest entire online discussion threads, but understanding their social discourse requires more than reading a long document: models must track parent-reply relations, turning points, scoped subtrees, cross-branch contrasts, and participant trajectories. To test this structure-aware social reasoning, we introduce LongSocialBench, a benchmark of 1,462 verified human-authored multiple-choice items drawn from 94 complete Hacker News, Stack Exchange, and Reddit r/ChangeMyView episodes, with a median length of approximately 73K tokens. Each item pairs a complete serialized discussion and reply structure with a four-option question, requiring models to recover structured social evidence. Released items are verified for answerability, option uniqueness, and evidence grounding. Across 18 models and 29 evaluation settings, current long-context workflows remain far below human performance. The best individual result comes from Claude-Opus-4.7, which reaches 63.0% when prompted to eliminate incorrect options before answering, compared with 72.4% for independent human readers. Averaged across all 18 models, the full-context Baseline scores 43.9%. Supplying the gold evidence scope raises this to 55.0%, showing that substantial errors remain even after the relevant thread region is identified. LongSocialBench shows that the missing capability is not context access or prompting alone, but social understanding over structured reply trees.

0.42

Interplay between Emotional Dynamics and Network Structure on the Social Media Vent

cs.SI ·2026-09-25 ·Yuina Takahashi, Sho Tsugawa
similarity 0.62
Abstract

The sharing and contagion of emotions on social media influence online interactions and users' psychological states. This study analyzes emotional dynamics on Vent, an emotion-sharing social media platform where users explicitly assign emotional labels to their own posts. Using a large-scale dataset, we examine how emotions in users' pre-posting timelines are associated with their subsequent emotional labels and how such associations vary across users. Our analysis reveals three key findings. First, users' subsequent emotional labels are associated with the emotional composition of their pre-posting timelines, with same-category emotions being overrepresented before posts in all analyzed categories. Second, several cross-category associations are observed; for example, Surprise was overrepresented before Fear posts; Affection and Happiness were overrepresented before Anger posts; and Affection was overrepresented before Sadness posts. Third, users differ in their degree of alignment with timeline emotional fluctuations, and highly aligned users tend to be located close to one another in the network. These findings provide large-scale observational evidence that emotional expression on Vent is associated with both short-term timeline context and network structure.

0.21

Using LLMs to Mimic the Conversational Dynamics of Reddit Communities

cs.HC ·2026-08-29 ·Vedaant Jain, Yoshee Jain, Ishq Gupta, Aditi Shrivastava, Koustuv Saha +1 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 5 pages, 2 tables, 1 figure

Online communities face a constant battle against toxicity and misinformation. While human moderators struggle to keep pace with the volume of content, LLMs offer a promising solution for automatically generating constructive responses and shaping online interactions. This paper preliminarily investigates if LLMs can mimic the communication styles of Reddit users using their comment history as context. We evaluate two prompting approaches: predicting a target comment and filling in masked comments. We find that LLMs outperform expectations at replicating comment structure and formality, but struggle to accurately capture nuanced emotions, e.g. understating joy and overstating anger. These findings highlight a promising direction for LLMs in guiding online conversations towards prosociality influencing emergent communication patterns and norms within the community. The results of our study inspire future work with more rigorous methods of evaluation to explore the LLMs' effectiveness across diverse online communities to better understand their broader societal impact.

0.25

Political Narratives in the 2024 Moldovan Presidential Election: Stance, Amplification, and Influence

cs.SI cs.AI ·2026-10-15 ·Andrea Piras, Osman Rahmoun, Elena Zheleva
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · 12 pages, 10 figures. To be published in the proceedings of the 13th IEEE International Conference on Data Science and Advanced Analytics (D…

Social media platforms play a central role in shaping political discourse during elections, particularly in geopolitically contested regions. We study how political narratives emerged, aligned, and propagated during the 2024 Moldovan presidential election by analyzing publicly available posts collected from X, Facebook, and Reddit between August and October 2024. Combining multilingual stance detection, coordination analysis, and causal inference, we examine both descriptive and causal mechanisms underlying online political discourse. First, we apply large language models to classify stance toward European integration, Russia, and the two main presidential candidates, revealing clear cross-platform and cross-linguistic differences in how political positions are expressed. Second, we construct retweet-based and semantic alignment networks on X to identify amplification and aligned framing of dominating narratives. Finally, we use a proximal causal inference framework to estimate peer influence effects in stance formation. Our results indicate consistently positive and statistically significant average treatment effects across major stance categories. These findings provide evidence that amplification and peer exposure contribute to the reinforcement of political narratives online. This work offers the first analysis of social media discourse surrounding the 2024 Moldovan presidential election and demonstrates the value of integrating language-based annotation, network analysis, and causal inference for studying political influence in multilingual and geopolitically sensitive contexts.

0.35