CS Paper Radar

Rust for Secure Backend Development: A Critical Review and Extended Vulnerability Comparison with Node.js and Django

Md Zarzees Uddin Shah Chowdhury, Rabib Jahin Ibn Momin, Rifat Shahriyar

cs.PL cs.CR ·submitted 2026-08-23 22:15 UTC · v1

Abstract

The Rust programming language is widely credited with eliminating entire classes of memory-safety and concurrency vulnerabilities, but the security implications of adopting it in practice extend well beyond memory safety. This paper presents a critical review of prior work on Rust's security posture in industrial settings, and extends that analysis in a direction the original study did not cover: backend web development. We first assess the strengths and limitations of the existing vulnerability classification of Rust against C, C++, and Java under the SANS Top 25, OWASP Top 10, and the 19 Deadly Sins of Software Security frameworks, identifying gaps including limited empirical validation, a small interview sample, and the absence of a secure development lifecycle discussion. We then contribute an original comparison of Rust against Node.js and Django using the same three-level classification (Rare and Difficult, Safeguarded, Unprotected), supported by side-by-side code experiments for out-of-bounds writes (CWE-787), use-after-free (CWE-416), and race conditions (CWE-362). Our results indicate that Rust's compile-time guarantees dominate at the systems layer, while managed backend frameworks offer stronger built-in defenses at the application layer, suggesting that Rust adoption in web contexts requires complementary safeguards rather than reliance on language-level safety alone.

Comment
10 pages, 5 tables. Critically reviews and extends Gasiba and Amburi, "I Think This is the Beginning of a Beautiful Friendship: On the Rust Programming Language and Secure Software Development in the Industry," CYBER 2023, pp. 19-26

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Building Sound Evaluation Practices for Rust-Based Security Frameworks

cs.CR ·2026-10-14 ·David Paaßen, Lucas Davi
similarity 0.78
Abstract

Background: Rust is a modern programming language known for its focus on usability, concurrency, and security. However, empirical studies reveal that Rust is still affected by software vulnerabilities, with hundreds of memory safety issues found in Rust programs, including Rust's standard library. As a result, additional tool-assisted security testing is crucial to enhance the security of Rust code. Evaluating such tools, however, is highly complex. While there is substantial research on evaluating C/C++ security frameworks, including test sets, serious issues in published evaluations have been identified, undermining their scientific soundness and reproducibility. In practice, selecting an inadequate implementation (e.g., a fuzzer) can lead to missed vulnerabilities ultimately compromising a program's security. Aims: Our methodology aims to help researchers to conduct scientifically sound evaluations in order to prevent similar issues with the evaluation of security tools and frameworks in the Rust ecosystem. Method: We systematically analyze existing evaluation literature to develop the first sound methodology for Rust based evaluations. Our guidelines provide enough flexibility to support a variety of use cases. To quantify the performance of a security tool, we introduce an automated approach to inject unsafe code coverage oracles, which require no forward porting, avoid overfitting, and allow updating test sets in the future. We also present methods to quantify the diversity of a Rust test set, ensuring that the results are applicable to a large set of existing Rust programs. We practically apply our methodology in our evaluation of the most popular Rust fuzzers. Results: We show the practical applicability of our design and conduct an evaluation with a diverse test set of 20 Rust projects. [...]

0.18

Evaluating and Improving Static Application Security Testing Tools for Rust

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-15 ·Huaien Zhang, Zhengjie Zhao, Yu Pei, Tian Dong, Minxue Pan +2 more
similarity 0.75
Abstract

Rust has become a popular systems programming language in recent years because of its strong guarantees on memory and concurrency safety. Many types of system software have been re-implemented in Rust. However, Rust programs can still suffer from common memory and concurrency vulnerabilities due to unsafe code and misunderstandings of its complex mechanisms. To mitigate such vulnerabilities, developers often rely on static application security testing (SAST) tools. However, the effectiveness of existing Rust SAST tools on real-world vulnerabilities remains underexplored. In this paper, we first conduct an empirical evaluation of mainstream Rust SAST tools using security vulnerabilities identified in real-world Rust applications. We systematically assess their effectiveness, uncover common weaknesses, and analyze the root causes behind them. Motivated by the study, we propose TRUST, a large language model (LLM)-assisted automated testing framework. TRUST automatically analyzes the official Rust reference to derive and implement semantics-preserving transformations. It leverages these transformations to generate mutant programs for evaluating Rust SAST tools and uncovering potential faults within them. Overall, TRUST has revealed 46 faults across six popular SAST tools, 17 of which have been confirmed. In addition, our study yields ten empirical findings and four practical lessons that provide actionable guidance for developing more effective, robust, and maintainable Rust SAST tools.

0.15

C-to-Rust Fallacy: Automatic Refactoring != Memory Security

cs.CR ·2026-09-22 ·Hung-Mao Chen, Xu He, Bo Lu, Xiaokuan Zhang, Kun Sun
similarity 0.74
Abstract

Rust has emerged as the leading system programming language, offering strong memory and type safety guarantees without compromising performance. This positions it as a compelling alternative to traditional languages like C and C++, which are susceptible to memory security bugs. However, manually transforming C to Rust requires in-depth domain knowledge of the Rust language features, which requires significant effort for developers. To address this, tools for automatic C-to-Rust refactoring aim to generate safe Rust code leveraging static analysis and Large Language Models (LLMs). While these tools claim to achieve safety by reducing the unsafe Rust, the correlation with improving security is not clear. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive empirical study on the reliability, safety, and correctness of various C-to-Rust refactoring methods. Specifically, we evaluate C2Rust-analyze, CROWN, C2SaferRust, and FLOURINE using a dataset of 116 C programs with memory security bugs from the NIST Juliet Test Suite. Based on 464 Rust programs generated by these tools, our evaluation focuses on three key aspects: the compilation correctness of the refactored programs, the effectiveness in mitigating original C bugs, and the tendency to introduce additional Rust bugs. The results indicate that 342 Rust programs fail to compile, 177 Rust programs inherit memory security bugs from the original C programs, and 77 new Rust bugs are introduced. We examine the rationale behind tool design and analyze the root cause of errors across various refactoring methods. Our findings indicate that current automated refactoring tools deliver memory safety as they define it, but not the broader memory security when adopting them.

0.06

Beyond Single-Vulnerability Evaluation: Closing the Engineering Decision Gap Between C Retrofits and Native Safety

cs.PL cs.CR ·2026-08-16 ·Andrew Laramore, Joseph Spracklen, Murtuza Jadliwala
position similarity 0.69
Abstract

While decades of research have produced numerous retrofitted memory-safety protections for C, these mechanisms are almost exclusively evaluated in isolation, targeting specific vulnerability classes. This siloed evaluation paradigm leaves practitioners without a clear understanding of the cumulative performance costs, interoperability conflicts, and protection gaps that arise when layering defenses to achieve comprehensive safety. This paper presents a new evaluation paradigm that benchmarks natively memory-safe languages like Rust and Go against compounded C retrofits. Using standardized cross-language tasks, we evaluate the performance and protection tradeoffs of state-of-the-art mechanisms when deployed in combination. Our results demonstrate that layered C defenses incur compounding and workload-dependent performance penalties, can suffer from fundamental architectural incompatibilities, and fall short of the protection scope provided by native memory-safe languages. These findings expose a critical engineering decision gap where the true cost of backporting safety to C remains hidden from practitioners. We argue for a fundamental shift in memory-safety research: moving away from isolated evaluation toward holistic, comparative frameworks that inform the high-stakes choice between retrofitting legacy codebases and migrating to modern, safe languages.

0.04

TRACTOR Benchmark for Evaluating C to Rust Translators

cs.SE cs.CRcs.PL ·2026-09-20 ·Hamed Okhravi, Brandt Ogden, Noah Luther, Ian McQuoid, Howard Mak +1 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.69
Abstract

Memory-safety vulnerabilities remain a persistent source of security risk in critical software, much of which is implemented in memory-unsafe languages such as C and C++. Recent advances in programming languages, program analysis, and artificial intelligence have created new opportunities to modernize these legacy systems through automated translation to memory-safe languages such as Rust. The DARPA Translating All C to Rust (TRACTOR) program seeks to develop scalable techniques for translating large C codebases into safe, performant, and maintainable Rust. MIT Lincoln Laboratory serves as the program's independent test and evaluation organization and has developed a standardized benchmark for systematically assessing C-to-Rust translation tools. This report describes the TRACTOR benchmark, including progressively challenging test batteries and larger milestone projects, as well as the supporting evaluation infrastructure and metrics for assessing correctness, safety, idiomaticity, and performance. The benchmark and associated evaluation infrastructure are publicly available to support the broader development and evaluation of C-to-Rust translation technologies.

0.25

X.js: A Live Benchmark for Node.js Taint-Style Vulnerabilities

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-13 ·José Afonso, João Madeira Pereira, Ronghao Ni, Limin Jia, José Fragoso Santos +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · 21 pages, 12 figures

JavaScript vulnerabilities in npm packages pose a significant risk to the Node$.$js ecosystem, and a growing body of work aims to detect, exploit, and mitigate them. Studying and evaluating this work requires up-to-date collections of real vulnerabilities, yet the most commonly used datasets stop recording vulnerabilities in 2022. We present X$.$js, a live benchmark of real-world Node$.$js taint-style vulnerabilities covering code and command injection, prototype pollution, and path traversal. Built from 1,738 advisories collected through mid-2026, primarily from the GitHub Advisory Database, X$.$js pairs each vulnerability with precise source and sink locations, a validated executable exploit and its execution trace, and, when available, a patched version of the package. X$.$js supports long-term reproducibility and growth: dependencies are mirrored in a self-hosted registry to guard against package removal from the ecosystem, and dedicated infrastructure generates and validates exploits for newly reported vulnerabilities. The current release contains 1,159 validated exploits for 965 packages. Using X$.$js, we characterize how the frequency, structure, and complexity of Node$.$js taint-style vulnerabilities have evolved over time. We find that these vulnerabilities are increasingly reported in large packages: the median vulnerable package grew from roughly 250 LoC in 2021--2022 to 6,100 LoC in 2026.

0.46

UnsafeChecker: Finding Soundness Bugs in Rust Safe Abstractions

cs.PL ·2026-09-09 ·Xizhe Yin, Yaokun Zhang, Yang Feng, Baowen Xu
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Rust guarantees memory safety without garbage collection through a strict ownership and borrowing system. However, for low-level systems programming, many widely used libraries rely on the unsafe keyword. These libraries encapsulate raw-pointer operations behind safe APIs to form safe abstractions. A single mistake in this internal unsafe code can break its safety contract, rendering the abstraction unsound and allowing safe clients to trigger undefined behavior. Detecting these potential soundness violations is challenging. Existing static analysis tools for C/C++ ignore Rust-specific safety contracts, while current Rust tools lack the deep semantic modeling required to track the contexts that raw pointers erase. To address this gap, we present UnsafeChecker, a compiler-integrated static analysis framework for detecting potential soundness violations in Rust safe abstractions. UnsafeChecker analyzes Rust MIR using a flow-sensitive abstract interpretation that maintains a shared state with three components: ownership, object validity, and layout. Each warning rule consumes the subset of facts needed for the corresponding Rust safety obligation. UnsafeChecker reports both instruction-level undefined behavior and boundary-level contract violations that may escape through safe APIs. We evaluate UnsafeChecker on a benchmark of 46 RustSec vulnerabilities, which contain 53 ground-truth bugs. UnsafeChecker outperforms several state-of-the-art tools, detecting 32 CVEs and covering 36 bugs (67.9% recall) with 51.6% alert-level precision. Furthermore, in a large-scale scan of real-world crates on crates.io, UnsafeChecker uncovered 114 previously unknown bugs across 83 crates, with 45 confirmed and 27 already fixed by maintainers.

0.09

Security Is More Than a Library Call: How Security Features Live in Code

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-05 ·Kevin Hermann, Sven Peldszus, Thorsten Berger
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract

Implementing security features---functionalities that protect sensitive data or prevent malicious actions by attackers---is important for ensuring the security and integrity of software systems. Correctly implementing access control, cryptography, or other security features is challenging as they require substantial domain expertise, careful design, and custom implementation to integrate them within the software system. Previous work has thoroughly studied security awareness, perception, practices, and expertise via surveys, interviews, and experiments. While they have shown that the implementation of security features are often supported by security libraries and frameworks, they have also shown that developers rarely are security experts, and make mistakes that introduce vulnerabilities into software when using them. Despite this extensive knowledge of security practices and developer behavior, we still lack a comprehensive understanding of how security features actually manifest at the code level across full software systems. We close this gap by conducting a mining study of security features in 9 popular and large open-source Java systems. We manually inspected 2,127,761 lines of code across 19,121 files, identifying and annotating 183,395 lines implementing 561 security features corresponding to 54 security features in our taxonomy. We analyzed the characteristics of the identified security features, such as their size, scattering, tangling, common implementation patterns, and the use of internal and external functionalities. Our findings show that security features are far more than mere calls to external libraries. Security features, such as access control, can grow large in size, scatter across the whole codebase, and frequently tangle with each other. External security libraries are commonly used, but they require substantial amounts of code for integration.

0.33