CS Paper Radar

Rational Dolev--Yao Attackers: Decidable Incentive-Aware Verification of Security Protocols in Strategic Logic

Ioana Boureanu, R. Ramanujam

cs.CR cs.GT ·submitted 2026-08-24 08:19 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Symbolic protocol verification models the network attacker as a Dolev--Yao (DY) intruder, which does everything its knowledge permits, whether or not it serves any purpose; real adversaries instead maximise utility, attacking only when the payoff is positive. We introduce a rational Dolev--Yao attacker, a DY intruder whose actions carry costs and whose security-violating goals carry rewards, and call a protocol rationally secure when no intruder strategy achieves a violation with strictly positive utility, expressed in a weighted fragment of ATL (WATL). We prove this decidable for a bounded rational DY intruder over a finite cost-annotated concurrent game structure, characterise its complexity, and show it strictly refines DY security: some protocols are DY-insecure yet rationally secure, separated by a computable threshold. We illustrate the framework on two contrasting use-cases: an authenticated payment under session uncertainty, where a rational intruder must strategise across indistinguishable sessions and its imperfect information strictly raises the attack cost a designer must price against; and ThreeBallot, a cryptography-free scheme where we pinpoint the bribe-to-benefit ratio below which no rational coercer attacks.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Repeated-Game Security for Restaking-Based Verifiable Inference

cs.GT cs.CR ·2026-08-10 ·Zhenhang Shang, Yingzhe Yu, Kani Chen
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Length: 29 pages total (15 pages main text, plus appendix and references). Figures: 5. Artifact: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Repeated-…

Restaking-based protocols enable verifiable LLM inference without the high proving cost of zkML or the hardware trust assumptions of TEEs. Their security is commonly justified by a one-round slashing condition: a rational provider should not cheat when the expected penalty exceeds the cost saving from dishonest inference. This paper shows that this condition can overstate security when inference is supplied repeatedly under the same stake. We model verifiable inference as a discounted repeated game and identify a repeated-game gap caused by proportional slashing: detected deviations reduce future penalty exposure, while cost savings are earned again across queries. We derive the gap in closed form, show that it persists under minimum-stake ejection, and extend it to memoryless bounded-slashing protocols covering deployed designs. We propose a deployable mechanism combining history-dependent challenges, reputation-weighted slashing, and stake vesting. The mechanism restores infinite-horizon subgame-perfect incentive compatibility against stationary mixed-strategy deviations above an explicit discount-factor threshold without per-query cryptographic verification. Evaluation across nine open-weight model pairs from 0.5B to 14B parameters shows that the audit signal has the required concave detectability response. A Stackelberg audit-budget analysis shows that improved signal responsiveness reduces the baseline audit rate by 2.6x at discount factor 0.95. Calibrated to deployed parameters, surveyed protocols pass one-round incentive compatibility but admit repeated-game deviations for discount factors between 0.92 and 0.98, with deviation-profit fractions of 1.5%--8%. Our mechanism reduces deviation profits by 31%--54% while maintaining low-latency economic verification.

0.50

Too Late to Slash: Coordinating a Risk-Free Equivocation Attack

cs.GT cs.CR ·2026-09-24 ·Hao Chung, Chen-Da Liu-Zhang
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Slashing is commonly argued to secure proof-of-stake blockchains by confiscating the stake of misbehaving validators. The usual justification is that, without slashing, validators can solicit an equivocation attack by signing conflicting blocks: if enough others join, the attack succeeds; otherwise, the attempt incurs no loss. Slashing is intended to make such attempts costly and thereby guarantee the security of applications whose economic value is comparable to the bonded stake. This rationale, however, rests on heuristic arguments rather than a formal game-theoretic guarantee. We challenge this rationale by constructing a risk-free coordination protocol for rational validators under algorithmic slashing. We show that the prescribed strategy profile, in which rational validators solicit other validators to equivocate, constitutes an ex post Nash equilibrium, even when validators do not know in advance how many others will participate. The equilibrium holds for any gain $ε>0$ from successful equivocation, however small relative to the bonded stake. Thus, slashing alone does not guarantee economic security proportional to the value of bonded stake. Our results expose a fundamental limitation of algorithmic slashing. Whereas conventional collateral arrangements in many real-world scenarios can rely on external enforcement, for example through courts, algorithmic slashing depends on the same consensus process that the attackers control. These findings call for a formal analysis of slashing's security, rather than overly simplistic arguments drawn from financial systems with independent enforcement.

0.25

Sustained Participation as a Security Resource: The Bounded Participation Channel

cs.CR ·2026-09-28 ·Homayoun Maleki, Nekane Sainz, Jon Legarda, Igor Santos-Grueiro
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 19 pages, 3 figures. Version 1

Can sustained, per-identity participation be engineered into a security resource? Most anti-Sybil defenses price identity creation rather than identity survival. Once admitted, an adversary may sustain many identities without paying a recurring cost. We introduce the Bounded Participation Channel (BPC), a formal primitive for repeatedly verifying participation window by window. BPC issues fresh, identity-bound challenges under a strict deadline and enforces four structural properties: identity binding, freshness, real-time response, and bounded per-channel throughput. Together, these yield a provable cost theorem: sustaining $s$ identities over $T$ windows requires $C(s,T) \geq sT/τ_h$ participation channel-windows. The guarantee is solver-agnostic: a channel may be operated by a human, an AI system, or a hybrid. We give a hash-based construction with publicly verifiable participation proofs, characterize four admissible challenge families, and evaluate two against GPT-4o, Gemini 2.5 Flash, and Claude Sonnet 4.5 across 600 trials. Despite near-perfect accuracy (97--100%) on the perceptual tasks, the evaluated automated channels remain throughput-bounded under the tested deployment conditions. The results illustrate a key distinction: solvability does not imply unlimited throughput. By requiring participation to be re-earned by every identity in every time window, BPC turns sustained participation into a measurable security resource with a linear structural cost floor, independent of whether the participation is supplied by humans, AI systems, or hybrids.

0.25

Beyond Incentive Compatibility: Rational Harm-Proof Transaction Fee Mechanisms

cs.GT cs.CR ·2026-09-25 ·Forest Zhang, Elain Park, Ke Wu
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

Transaction fee mechanisms (TFMs) allocate scarce block space in blockchains. Prior work focuses on incentive compatibility (IC): honest behavior maximizes the payoff of each strategic player. We introduce rational-harm proofness (RHP), which rules out deviations that harm honest participants without reducing the deviator's utility relative to honest behavior. IC alone does not exclude such costless harm: in a second-price auction, a losing bidder can raise the winner's payment without changing its own payoff. For finite block capacity k, we characterize TFMs satisfying RHP alongside user incentive compatibility (UIC) and miner incentive compatibility (MIC). In the plain model, where a single miner implements the auction, we prove a tight tetrilemma: no TFM simultaneously achieves positive miner revenue, UIC, MIC, and RHP against miner-user coalitions, while any three are jointly achievable. In the MPC-assisted model, where a committee of miners implements the auction using multi-party computation, we construct a randomized TFM with positive miner revenue satisfying UIC, MIC, and RHP against users, miners, and miner-user coalitions containing at most k users. Randomness is necessary to confirm transactions under congestion: any deterministic TFM satisfying UIC and user RHP in this model confirms no transactions when the number of submitted bids exceeds k. Finally, IC and RHP are incomparable for every strategic role in both models: mechanisms can satisfy either property without satisfying the other. These results extend transaction fee mechanism design beyond incentives to protection against costless harm.

0.15

Sybil-Proofness of Generalized Adaptive Clinching and Implications for Blockchain Mechanism Design

cs.GT econ.TH ·2026-10-27 ·Chengkai Zhang, Yuhao Li, Elaine Shi, Mengqian Zhang, Lirong Xia +1 more
position similarity 0.61
Abstract · Abstract shortened to comply with arXiv's character limit

The adaptive clinching auction of Dobzinski, Lavi, and Nisan (FOCS'08) is a cornerstone of mechanism design with budget-constrained bidders, and it has since inspired a broad range of extensions to substantially richer market settings. Adaptive clinching enjoys compelling guarantees: it is Pareto optimal, and truthful bidding is a dominant strategy whenever budgets cannot be overreported. In many real-world environments, however, identities are cheap to create, making resilience to Sybil attacks an additional requirement. Whether the guarantees of adaptive clinching survive when a bidder can split its budget across fake identities has remained open. We introduce a generalized framework for adaptive clinching and prove that it satisfies Sybil-robust incentive compatibility: a bidder cannot benefit from splitting into any finite number of identities with arbitrary value reports, provided their aggregate reported budget does not exceed the bidder's enforceable true budget. Sybil resilience thus joins the list of ideal properties of adaptive clinching. Our work is motivated by practical problems in decentralized finance, where automated market makers (AMMs) are among the most widely used applications. We design a new AMM mechanism that extends classical adaptive clinching in two ways: it supports a two-sided market and protects against two-sided strategies, and it allows the supply function to depend on the auction state. Its one-sided special case is captured by our generalized adaptive clinching framework, and our proof techniques show that the full two-sided mechanism simultaneously satisfies Sybil-robust incentive compatibility and a relaxed notion of Pareto optimality. We argue that these guarantees are essentially the best possible via impossibility results. More broadly, our work reveals new connections between classical algorithmic game theory and modern decentralized blockchains.

0.46

Beyond Identity Creation: Bilinear Sybil Cost in Identities and Time

cs.CR ·2026-11-04 ·Homayoun Maleki, Nekane Sainz, Jon Legarda, Igor Santos-Grueiro
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 16 pages, 4 figures. Main paper followed by the supplementary material. Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security

Sybil defenses price the creation of an identity, yet influence goes, again and again, to active identities. We study the cost of maintaining influence. A defense has a bilinear Sybil cost with ratio $A$ if keeping $s$ identities active for $T$ periods costs at least $sT/A$ honest units: the average cost per identity-window is at least $1/A$ times an honest participant's cost. Recurrence alone does not guarantee this cost. The cost can be carried over from earlier periods, shared among many identities, or be negligible when fast hardware does the work of thousands of honest devices. We give four sufficient conditions for a defense that checks every identity each period to achieve bilinear Sybil cost: identity binding, freshness, a shared deadline, and sequential, non-batchable work. They yield two guarantees: a bilinear total cost, with $A$ the speed advantage of the adversary's fastest hardware, and, because the work must be fresh and finished by a common deadline, a bound on the identities active in a period by the processors running at that time. We prove that none of the four follows from the other three. A verifiable delay function on an identity-bound input meets all four without payments, with $A$ of 2 to 8 for CPUs and about 28 for a hypothetical ASIC, against $10^3$ to $10^7$ for hash puzzles. We measure one active identity per core per period against about 80,000 under a signed heartbeat, no gain from batching up to 1,000 identities, and rejection of all tested attacks.

0.20

Decomposition Attacks Across Unlinkable Identities: Limits of Stateful Defenses for LLM Services

cs.CR cs.CL ·2026-08-18 ·Bowen Sun, Zhengyue Zhao, Xiaogeng Liu, Yinzhi Cao, Chaowei Xiao
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

Most large language model services use stateless defenses, which judge only the current request, to refuse harmful tasks. Decomposition attacks exploit this limitation by splitting a harmful task into individually permissible requests and combining their answers. Defending against them therefore requires a stateful monitor that considers requests together. If it can group all requests for one attacker task, it can stop the attack. However, attackers can use unlinkable identities and combine answers elsewhere, leaving no reliable grouping signal. We ask whether decomposition attacks can still be stopped under this setting. For a fixed attack strategy without retries, we prove that the achievable security and utility tradeoff depends entirely on how benign requests for the same capabilities are grouped. Persistent, recognizable groups permit a useful defense; fresh, indistinguishable groups do not. When attackers can retry and learn from Allow/Block decisions, this useful operating point disappears: the feedback reveals what passes but not whether a block was correct. Experiments on 91 executable tasks and 11,393 capability-matched benign requests support these results. Under a 1% denial cap for these requests and a 0.5% cap for unrelated background traffic, all ten tested policies, including one privileged policy with an exact request-to-operation map, either fail to stop attacks or exceed the budget. On defense-unseen task families, attack success is at least 99% after one attempt and 100% after two. Effective defenses therefore require additional evidence or mechanisms tied to grouping, such as reliable identity linkage, costs for fresh identities, or control over answer use.

0.48

Credible AUctions via MPC Gadgets: Bounding Information Leakage Under Abort

cs.GT cs.CRecon.TH ·2026-09-23 ·Matheus Venturyne Xavier Ferreira
publishedtheory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 32 pages, AFT 2026

The design of credible auctions---mechanisms where a revenue-maximizing auctioneer has no incentive to deviate from the protocol---faces a fundamental cryptographic barrier when the auctioneer controls shill bidders. While a natural approach is to use Secure Multi-Party Computation (MPC) to remove the trusted auctioneer, the impossibility of fair coin flipping of Cleve (1986) implies that monolithic MPC protocols grant the auctioneer a "free option": they can learn the auction's outcome and unilaterally abort if the revenue is unsatisfactory. Cryptographic commitments with ex-ante penalties mitigate this abort asymmetry, but no finite penalty suffices for heavy-tailed distributions. We circumvent this barrier by introducing the MPC Decomposition Principle. Rather than encrypting the entire mechanism, we use MPC strictly as an information-restriction tool. We isolate the winner determination problem into a minimal MPC gadget that computes and reveals the winner's identity but no payment information. This qualitative restriction mathematically bounds the information leaked upon an abort. By combining this gadget with sequential revelation and finite economic penalties, we design the Sequential Revelation Auction (SRA). We prove that bounding the information leakage strictly bounds the value of the free option, showing that a penalty of $k \geq \sum_{i=1}^n Rev(F_i)$ is sufficient for credibility, and tight: for equal-revenue distributions, every smaller penalty admits a profitable deviation. Using constant-round MPC, the SRA resolves an open question of Akbarpour and Li (2020) and Ferreira and Weinberg (2020) by providing a constant-round, incentive-compatible, revenue-optimal credible auction for all product distributions with vanishing revenue tails

0.43