CS Paper Radar

From Metrics to Improvement: A Lifecycle-Aware LLM Feedback Framework for Research Software Quality

Nafis Tanveer Islam, Nafiseh Soveizi, Yutong Li, Zhiming Zhao

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-08-24 11:28 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Research software is increasingly central to scientific workflows, yet it is often developed by researchers with limited software engineering expertise. This can lead to quality issues that hinder maintainability, reproducibility, reuse, and sustainability. Existing static analysis tools can identify such issues, but their outputs often require expert interpretation and provide limited support for translating quality assessments into actionable improvements. To address this gap, we propose a lifecycle-aware framework that integrates quantitative software quality assessment with Large Language Model (LLM)-based code refinement. The framework comprises two stages. First, a lifecycle-aware Quality Model is developed from established software quality standards and practitioner requirements. The model defines five quality dimensions and 25 candidate metrics, of which 14 are operationalized using existing analysis tools and custom measurements. Second, the resulting quality diagnostics are used as structured feedback within an iterative LLM-based refinement process, enabling generated improvements to be repeatedly reassessed against the Quality Model. We evaluate the framework on notebook-centric research software using multiple LLMs and compare iterative structured feedback with single-step feedback and unstructured prompting. The results show improvements in specific quality attributes, particularly code duplication and structural quality, while also revealing trade-offs among maintainability, code size, documentation, and complexity. These findings demonstrate the potential of metric-driven LLM feedback for research software quality improvement while highlighting its inherently multi-objective nature \footnote{The source code and experimental data are publicly available at https://github.com/QCDIS/Software_Quality_Control_LLM . }

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Large Language Models for Requirements Engineering: A Cross-Task Empirical Evaluation

cs.SE ·2026-08-21 ·Jacek Dąbrowski, Manjeshwar Aniruddh Mallya, Alessio Ferrari, Mohammad Amin Zadenoori, Yijun Yu
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract

Requirements-related information is scattered across heterogeneous artefacts such as user feedback, developer discussions, and software repositories, making the extraction of actionable requirements knowledge labour-intensive and hard to scale. Large Language Models (LLMs) can support many Requirements Engineering (RE) activities, from classification and traceability identification to specification and explanation generation, but existing evidence is fragmented across tasks, artefact types, and evaluation settings, and studies rarely offer cross-task evaluations or replication packages. We present two complementary empirical studies evaluating LLMs across five RE-related activities. The first is a controlled experiment on five lightweight open-source LLMs for feedback-driven requirements classification and specification generation. The second is an exploratory industrial case study on two frontier LLMs for traceability link identification and traceability explanation generation using real project artefacts. Classification and traceability identification were assessed with quantitative metrics, and generation tasks through human evaluation. LLM performance is strongly task-dependent, ranging from moderate to high, and no single model consistently outperformed the others, indicating that effective adoption depends on selecting models and prompting strategies per task. Our contributions are: (i) the first cross-task empirical evaluation of LLMs spanning five RE-related activities, (ii) replication materials supporting reproducibility, and (iii) a broader understanding of the capabilities, limitations, and practical readiness of current LLMs for RE.

0.47

From Static to Dynamic: Benchmarking Real-World Code Review with MCR-Bench

cs.SE cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-08-27 ·Dewu Zheng, Yanlin Wang, Xiwen Wang, Kefeng Duan, Hongyu Zhang +3 more
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at ISSTA 2026

In real-world software development, code review typically involves iterative interactions between developers and reviewers to improve software quality, making the process costly and time-consuming. Although recent work explores large language models (LLMs) for automated code review, most approaches oversimplify code review into a single-round, static decision task, which fails to capture the multi-round interactive nature and the complex problem-solving processes inherent in realistic review scenarios. To bridge this gap, we introduce MCR-Bench, the first defect state-aware benchmark designed for realistic multi-round code review. MCR-Bench covers five commonly-used programming languages and consists of 2,269 real-world multi-round code review tasks, each of which is annotated with fine-grained defect information and cross-round state labels. Each task in MCR-Bench is equipped with fine-grained defect metadata (e.g., description, type, severity) alongside dynamic state annotations, capturing the complete evolutionary trajectory of a defect throughout the multi-round process. We obtain several findings through extensive experiments on MCR-Bench with mainstream LLMs. (1) Limited overall capability: experiments reveal that mainstream LLMs exhibit limited overall performance in defect detection and defect lifecycle state tracking, with performance degrading significantly as the number of interaction rounds increases; (2) Defect-sensitive performance: LLMs' performance varies substantially across different defect types and severity levels, with semantically complex or low-salience defects being significantly more likely to be missed; (3) Underlying Failure Mechanisms: our in-depth error analysis dissects the distinct drivers of false positives and false negatives, revealing critical weaknesses such as cross-round temporal misalignment and inadequate long-range memory.

0.53

Continuous Autonomous Refactoring: A Research Roadmap for AI-Driven Code Quality Maintenance

cs.SE ·2026-09-01 ·Xin Sun, Daniel Ståhl, Kristian Sandahl, Christoph Kessler
top venue similarity 0.66
Abstract · The paper was accepted in ICSME 2026 in the Visions and Emerging Results Track

Large language models have shown promising capabilities in code refactoring, but existing approaches remain limited to method-level tasks. In this paper, we envision LLM-based refactoring as a continuous component of software maintenance rather than a tool invoked only for occasional manual refactoring. Under this vision, AI agents continuously monitor, evaluate, and improve codebases against explicit and evolving notions of software quality. We present a roadmap organized around five dimensions: the multi-objective optimization problem, quality definition and evaluation, multi-timescale integration of heterogeneous signals, architecture and design pattern, and trust in autonomous refactoring. We further identify integration into continuous delivery pipelines and cost considerations as cross-cutting concerns. For each dimension, we analyze the underlying challenges and pose open research questions. These dimensions define a research agenda for advancing autonomous refactoring from isolated code improvements to system-level quality maintenance.

0.36

PreMaQ: Predicting Maintainability-Related Quality of LLM-Generated Code Before Generation

cs.SE ·2026-10-05 ·Taiki Wakamatsu, Yuta Ishimoto, Masanari Kondo, Yasutaka Kamei
benchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract · 10 pages, 4 figures

As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly capable of code generation, adopting generated code in software development requires assessing not only its functional correctness but also its maintainability-related quality. If such quality could be estimated before generation, developers could avoid the cost of generating, reviewing, and discarding low-quality code. Although prior work has shown that the functional correctness of the LLM-generated code can be predicted in advance, it remains unclear whether maintainability-related quality is similarly predictable. We introduce Pre-Generation Maintainability-Related Quality Prediction (PreMaQ), which predicts the Code Smell Score (CSS) and Maintainability Index (MI) of generated code from the internal representations of LLMs before generation. Our evaluation covers four open-weight LLMs and four Python code generation benchmarks, comprising 2,695 tasks in total. Our results show that predicted CSS and MI consistently correlate with their observed values across all 16 model-benchmark combinations, achieving mean Spearman rank correlations of 0.57 and 0.65, respectively. When used for model selection, PreMaQ achieves 59.5% of the maintainability-related quality improvement attainable by an ideal maintainability-based selector over random selection on tasks for which multiple models generate functionally correct code. Combining predictions from PreMaQ and prompt embeddings increases this proportion to 60.7%, indicating that the two signals are complementary. These findings suggest that PreMaQ can be used to predict and improve the maintainability-related quality of LLM-generated code.

0.20

Beyond Passing Tests: A Systematic Review and Controlled Re-evaluation of Techniques for Improving the Quality of LLM-Generated Code

cs.SE cs.CLcs.LG ·2026-10-28 ·Prashank Kadam
surveybenchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract · 55 pages, 5 figures, plus 120 pages of supplementary material

Large language models pass most functional-correctness benchmarks, but passing tests says little about whether their code is readable, efficient or secure. Many techniques claim to improve these qualities, yet their evidence is scattered, usually covers one quality dimension and is rarely compared at an equal compute budget. We contribute a systematic review and a controlled re-evaluation. A systematic literature review of 628 primary studies (July 2021 to October 2026), with disclosed, author-reviewed LLM assistance, organizes the techniques by stage, signal source and quality target. Most studies measure only the dimension they target, gains often come with unchanged or unreported correctness, single automated quality signals are gamed, and compute, variance and contamination are rarely reported. A controlled re-evaluation runs ten techniques on four models at matched budgets on correctness, maintainability, efficiency and security benchmarks, extends it to thirteen current models and repository-level tasks, and compares 66 highlighted techniques head-to-head on Gemma 4 31B. At one call, quality prompting raises analyzer issue counts and leaves complexity and judge scores almost unchanged. At matched budgets, best-of-n sampling with an analyzer-weighted ranker matches or beats prompting, planning, self-refinement, a reviewer agent and retrieval on measures the ranker does not optimize, while an analyzer feedback loop and fine-tuning beat it only on analyzer issue counts. Large correctness losses on HumanEval+, a likely contaminated benchmark near its ceiling, do not appear on contests held after the models' training cutoffs. In the head-to-head, 1 of 66 techniques beats best-of-n on its primary target beyond the 95% interval, a rate consistent with chance. Gains should be reported against a budget-matched sampling baseline and on measures independent of the technique's own signal.

0.19

Architectural Degradation: How to Measure and to Remediate

cs.SE ·2026-10-01 ·Noman Ahmad, Ruoyu Su, Matteo Esposito, Andrea Janes, Valentina Lenarduzzi +1 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Context. Architectural degradation undermines software maintainability, evolvability, and quality. However, existing research remains fragmented across measurement approaches, metrics, tools, and remediation strategies, limiting our understanding of how these elements relate across the degradation lifecycle. Aim. We consolidate the state of the art on architectural degradation by examining how researchers measure it, which metrics and tools support its assessment, and how existing approaches address remediation. Method. We conducted a Multivocal Literature Review of 284 peer-reviewed and grey-literature studies. We supported screening, data extraction, and classification with a locally executed LLM-assisted pipeline combining Retrieval-Augmented Generation, multi-model validation, and human adjudication. We then analyzed the resulting taxonomies and their cross-dimensional relationships. Results and Conclusions. We identified 277 measurement approaches, 357 metrics, 238 tools, and 395 remediation approaches. Research strongly concentrates on static and structural analysis, structural metrics, and detection-oriented tools. In contrast, remediation spans heterogeneous code-level, architectural, and organizational interventions and shows substantially less consolidation. Overall, the field has developed a mature diagnostic apparatus but has made less progress in connecting degradation detection with effective remediation. Our results provide a structured view of the available techniques and identify the diagnosis-remediation gap as a key direction for future research.

0.16

SafeLLM4SE: Statistical Evaluation and Reporting for LLM-based Software Engineering Systems

cs.SE cs.LG ·2026-09-29 ·Francisco Ortin
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · This work has been submitted for possible publication. Copyright may be transferred without notice, after which this version may no longer b…

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used for software engineering tasks, yet their stochastic behavior challenges the validity, reproducibility, and comparability of their evaluations. Conventional practices such as reporting a single output, an average score, best-of-N, or pass@k performance can obscure variability and estimation uncertainty, potentially leading to misleading conclusions about system reliability. This article presents SafeLLM4SE, a practical methodology and reporting standard for statistically principled evaluation of LLM-based software engineering systems. Rather than treating generated outputs as deterministic artifacts, SafeLLM4SE treats them as realizations of a stochastic process and distinguishes quality, stability, and estimation uncertainty. It combines adaptive sampling with confidence intervals, distribution-aware statistical comparisons, effect sizes, and a minimum reporting standard covering model configuration, reproducibility, evaluation procedures, and resource usage. SafeLLM4SE is also provided as an open-source software package available on PyPI, enabling researchers and practitioners to reproduce and extend the methodology. We illustrate its application by comparing two LLMs on HumanEval, a benchmark of programming problems assessed through functional tests.

0.25

Reshaping the SDLC for Data- and AI-Centric Systems

cs.SE ·2026-08-18 ·Mamdouh Alenezi
similarity 0.64
Abstract

The traditional Software Development Lifecycle (SDLC) assumes that system behavior is determined primarily by source code, allowing correctness to be specified, implemented, and verified through code-centric practices. Data-intensive and AI-enabled systems challenge this assumption because their behavior emerges from the interaction of code, data, and learned models, while performance may degrade as real-world conditions drift from training data. This paper examines how integrating data engineering and software engineering practices, operationalized through DataOps, MLOps, and LLMOps, reshapes the SDLC for these systems. We make four contributions. First, we synthesize literature across software engineering, data management, machine learning systems, and human-centered computing into a phase-structured account of lifecycle transformation spanning requirements, architecture, development, testing, deployment, monitoring, governance, and organization. Second, we provide a lightweight formalization in which system behavior is defined over code, data, and model configurations; requirements become evaluation-led specifications with probabilistic acceptance regions; and promotion is controlled through statistically grounded validation gates. Third, we develop an adaptive five-layer lifecycle framework comprising artifact, contract, gate, control, and governance layers, positioning maintenance as a closed-loop control problem under configuration drift. Fourth, we propose a conceptual research model linking data engineering integration to measurable lifecycle outcomes and critically assess the evidence base. While the direction of transformation is increasingly established, its magnitude remains insufficiently quantified. We conclude with a research agenda for an empirically grounded, adaptive SDLC for data- and AI-centric systems.

0.30