CS Paper Radar

A tale of perfect fit and phantom optima: how data-driven models can fail in real-time optimization

Prithvi Dake, Rahul Bindlish, James B. Rawlings

eess.SY cs.AI ·submitted 2026-08-24 22:51 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Real-time optimization (RTO) relies on process models to locate economically optimal operating conditions. Because developing first-principles models requires significant process knowledge, data-driven alternatives are increasingly attractive. Modern machine-learning models can fit historical plant data accurately and often pass standard validation tests. Whether such models can be trusted for economic optimization, however, remains unclear. We investigate this question using a vinyl acetate monomer benchmark process with a unique, well-conditioned economic optimum. We train a structured hybrid model that combines known mass balances and thermodynamics with a neural-network closure for unknown kinetics, and a fully data-driven neural ordinary differential equation (ODE) model. Both models reproduce plant measurements accurately and exhibit little variation in predictions across random initializations. Yet their economic optima differ substantially from that of the plant. Where the plant returns a single optimum on multistart search, the trained models return many phantom optima. We further show that the training optimizer alone can be yet another source of error. Even with noise-free data and initialization at weights that recover the plant optimum, stochastic gradient training can drift to weights that yield substantially worse RTO solutions. The identified model is thus an artifact of the training optimizer as well as the data. These results demonstrate that a good predictive fit of all available measurements does not guarantee reliable economic performance. A data-driven model for RTO should at least be required to recover the optimum on a decision-oriented benchmark like the one developed here before being considered for plant testing and application.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Physics-informed neural networks in the small-data regime: A controlled comparison with classical PDE surrogates

cs.CE cs.AImath.NA ·2026-11-09 ·Kirill Katsuba, Oleg Rudenko, Egor Bugaev, Alexander Tarakanov
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Neural surrogates for engineering models are often trained on large collections of simulated solutions. We investigate whether physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) can achieve accurate predictions from scarce labelled observations by incorporating governing equations and prescribed initial and boundary conditions. We introduce hierarchical loss weighting (H-PINN) and its gradient-direction-aware extension (HO-PINN), which adjust the emphasis on physical constraints according to higher-priority losses. Hierarchical PINNs are compared with Vanilla PINN, tuned gradient boosting, support-vector regression, and Gaussian-process regression on a heat equation and three heterogeneous two-phase-flow benchmarks. Experiments use 20--1000 labelled states and ten paired seeds. Each label is one coordinate--state observation, not a complete simulation. At least one PINN variant achieves the highest mean primary-target \(R^2\) in each interpolation and equation-assisted forecasting comparison at 20 and 50 labels. The advantage for water saturation persists across all tested budgets. Hierarchical weighting reduces variability across runs in selected settings. These results demonstrate that known physics can support accurate neural surrogate predictions from very few solution observations, at substantially higher fitting cost than the tested classical regressors.

0.22

Differentiable Hybrid Modelling for Learning and Optimising Chemical Transport Processes from Experimental Data

cs.CE cs.LGmath.NA ·2026-09-03 ·Arthur Jessop, Mohammed Alsubeihi, Ben Moseley, Ashwin Kumar Rajagopalan
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Transport models underpin the design and optimisation of chemical processes, yet their constitutive laws are typically hand-picked, their experimental initial conditions are assumed exact, and their computational cost restricts optimisation to a handful of process variables. Here we introduce a differentiable hybrid modelling framework that embeds neural networks within a GPU-accelerated population balance equation solver to discover constitutive laws and assimilate initial conditions directly from experimental crystallisation data. Using thirteen real experiments with multi-dimensional size and shape measurements, we show that treating measured initial conditions as exact yields a physically inconsistent rate law despite improved predictive accuracy, whereas assimilating them recovers a physically consistent, non-linear law and reduces trajectory error sevenfold relative to conventional modelling. End-to-end differentiability further enables gradient-based optimisation of high-dimensional operating profiles, identifying a 300-variable temperature profile that reduces crystal aspect ratio by 25% at constant mass, facilitating superior product attributes. Our framework augments, rather than replaces, mechanistic modelling, offering a general route to learning transport models from data and optimising processes with them.

0.13

Two-Timescale Reinforcement Learning for Real-Time Optimization and Economic NMPC: Experimental Validation

eess.SY ·2026-09-28 ·Saket Adhau, Jose Matias, Sebastien Gros, Sigurd Skogestad
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 12 pages, submitted to Journal of Process Control

We propose a reinforcement learning (RL) framework that tunes both Real-Time Optimization (RTO) and Economic Nonlinear Model Predictive Control (ENMPC) to address plant--model mismatch in process systems. Drawing on modifier-adaptation concepts, the method parameterizes the dynamic model, stage costs, constraints, and RTO modifiers, and uses Q-learning to adjust these parameters at two timescales: a fast update for the ENMPC layer and a slow update for the RTO layer. The framework is experimentally validated on a laboratory rig emulating a three-well subsea oil-production network. Using plant measurement data, the proposed RTO-RLMPC scheme achieves 8.6% higher economic profit than nominal ENMPC, preserves input feasibility of the deployed ENMPC policy and empirically satisfies the path constraints under disturbances and measurement noise, and drives the learned model parameters toward reference plant values, independently identified from experimental data, along the directions that most affect the economic objective. This work provides one of the first experimental demonstrations of RL-tuned ENMPC integrated with RTO.

0.24

A Simulation-Driven Digital Workflow Integrating Bayesian Optimization for Early-Stage Process Design: A Methyl Acetate Production Case Study

cs.LG physics.chem-ph ·2026-10-18 ·Trung Ngoc Trinh, Trung Thanh Nguyen, Nikolaos Tsakoumis, Roman Tschentscher
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 53 pages (including appendices), 12 figures, 4 tables

Methyl acetate production via direct carbonylation of dimethyl ether and carbon monoxide involves strong nonlinear interactions among reactor operation, recycle structure, and energy consumption, making conventional simulation-based optimization computationally demanding. In this work, a data-driven framework integrating steady-state process simulation, surrogate modeling, and Bayesian optimization was developed for process intensification. A dataset of 2730 steady-state simulations was generated using a Python-based automated process simulation workflow and a structured design of experiments across the operating domain. Surrogate models were trained to predict carbon conversion yield (C-yield) and cost of specific energy consumption (C-SEC), with neural network-based models showing the best predictive performance and robustness. These models were integrated into a multi-objective Bayesian optimization framework to identify optimal operating regions. Results indicate that high C-yield (up to ~95%) can be achieved with reduced energy cost through lower recycle flow rates and compression demand. Pareto analysis revealed a nonlinear trade-off between C-yield and C-SEC, where further improvements near the conversion limit require disproportionately higher energy input. Validation against rigorous simulations showed deviations below 3% for C-yield and 10% for C-SEC.

0.21

RL-PaO: Prediction as Action in Decision Making under Uncertainty

cs.LG ·2026-09-29 ·Jiahui Feng, Dafang Zhao, Zheng Chen, Zhengmao Li, Lingwei Zhu
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Decision-making under uncertainty often relies on predicted parameters, yet accurate prediction does not necessarily lead to good operational decisions. Aligning prediction with downstream optimization requires learning from the consequences of the decisions those predictions induce. We introduce RL-PaO, a reinforcement learning framework that integrates system formulation, optimization, and decision execution into a single environment. This yields a Markov decision process in which prediction is regarded as action: it shifts the environment to produce subsequent context and reward that explicitly aligns prediction error with realized cost, and learning the optimal policy does not require differentiating through the black-box solver. We evaluate RL-PaO on day-ahead energy scheduling using real historical data. On the test year, RL-PaO achieves the lowest annual cost among the non-oracle baselines, achieving on average $10\%$ cost reduction. Moreover, RL-PaO is capable of further analyses to provide strong interpretability both from the policy evolution perspective and the cost-accuracy trade-off.

0.24

A Scalable Learned Iterative Solver for Nonlinear MPC via Temporal Decomposition

cs.LG math.OCeess.SY ·2026-10-09 ·Lukas Lüken, Sergio Lucia
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract · 16 pages, 7 figures, 7 tables

Nonlinear model predictive control (NMPC) can be applied to large nonlinear systems with complex objectives while enforcing constraints, but the cost of solving the underlying optimization problems limits real-time application for systems with fast dynamics or many states. Neural networks can reduce this online cost by approximating the control law, but may violate constraints and typically require many precomputed optimizer solutions for training. The learning-based iterative solver for constrained optimization (LISCO) instead learns to predict primal-dual steps toward satisfaction of the Karush-Kuhn-Tucker (KKT) conditions through self-supervised training without precomputed solutions, but its dense, monolithic architecture grows with the prediction horizon. We remove this horizon dependence by exploiting the temporal structure of the problem in the solver architecture, which makes the network size independent of the horizon while leaving the training loss and the solver iteration unchanged. A closed-loop resampling strategy further aligns the training distribution with closed-loop operation at no additional sampling cost. On an economic NMPC benchmark of a CSTR cascade, the proposed solver scales to larger problems than monolithic LISCO and achieves median speedups of up to a factor of four over IPOPT. In closed loop, it achieves comparable control performance to IPOPT with no observed constraint violations.

0.32

Turnpike properties in nonlinear system identification

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-02 ·Julian D. Schiller, Matthias A. Müller
similarity 0.59
Abstract

We analyze the problem of learning general discrete-time nonlinear state-space models using the simulation error minimization (SEM) method. In this setting, model parameters are typically learned by minimizing the mismatch between simulated and measured outputs over a training dataset, or shorter subsequences extracted from it. Specifically, we study the cumulative output turnpike property of the underlying SEM optimization problem, which requires optimal output sequences emanating from a fixed initial state to approach and remain close to an optimal output sequence of the corresponding SEM problem with free initial state. In the presence of non-unique optimal output sequences---as may arise, for instance, in fully black-box system identification using neural networks---the property is formulated with respect to the closest such sequence. Turnpike behavior is generally desirable in practice, as it provides a theoretical justification for employing computationally more tractable SEM formulations with fixed initial states while ensuring that their optimal output sequences remain close to unconstrained optimal ones. Under a mild reachability condition, we establish equivalence between the cumulative turnpike property, coercivity of the value function, and a tailored notion of strict dissipativity. We additionally introduce a cardinality turnpike property and show that it is strictly weaker than the cumulative notion. Finally, we establish sufficient conditions for turnpike behavior based on incremental output stability, convexity of the stage cost, and a suitable optimality condition, and illustrate the theory by means of a numerical example.

0.38

Artificial Neural Networks as Surrogate Models in Black Box Optimization

cs.NE cs.AI ·2026-09-16 ·Md Khadimul Islam Zim, Martin Holeňa
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Black-Box Optimization (BBO) is often applied in several engineering fields and can utilize an advancement of numerical measure- ments and simulation technologies. It deals with the optimization func- tions, where an analytical description is unavailable. It relies on meth- ods that require only an input point in the search space, paired with its corresponding objective function value, obtained through non-analytical means, e.g., sensors, experiments, or simulations. Common approaches include evolutionary optimization and other metaheuristics. Since BBO methods rely solely on objective function values, they typically require many evaluations, which becomes problematic when evaluating the ob- jective function is time-consuming or expensive. This leads to using surrogate-based optimization which evaluates selected true objective val- ues and trains a regression model to approximate the objective function across the search space. Surrogate-assisted black-box optimization is a small-data learning problem because the optimizer must approximate an expensive objective function from limited evaluations. Surrogate models act as data-efficient regressors, guiding the search toward promising or informative points under a restricted evaluation budget. In this paper, a new surrogate model using artificial neural networks, called Adaptive- Fidelity Nexus Covariance Matrix Adaptation Evolution Strategy (AFN- CMA-ES), is proposed for the selective evaluation of objective functions. The experimental results show its competitive performance compared to state-of-the-art surrogate-assisted BBO methods.

0.28