CS Paper Radar

Shaping the Future of Generative AI for Black Communities: A Frame Analysis of Public Discourse and Empirical Scholarly Research

Angela D. R. Smith, Gabriella Thompson, Christopher L. Dancy, Mark Díaz, Seyi Olojo, Christina N. Harrington

cs.HC cs.CY ·submitted 2026-08-25 16:05 UTC · v1
publishedsurveyposition

Abstract

As generative AI (genAI) systems become embedded in education, employment, healthcare, and creative industries, the impact and engagement among marginalized groups have become both a widespread discourse and a focus in scholarly research. As a starting point, we examine public discourse and empirical research to explore the impact of genAI systems on Black communities. We conducted a systematic literature review (SLR) of 91 empirical papers alongside a media discourse frame analysis of 28 public resources, applying Entman's framing theory to map how each corpus defines problems, attributes causes, and proposes treatments. Our SLR reveals that scholarly research concentrates heavily on technical bias detection, reducing Blackness to measurable variables rather than engaging with cultural practices, structural conditions, or Black knowledge systems. Our frame analysis reveals that public discourse attributes genAI-related harm to historical and systemic forces, while scholarly research stops its causal accounts at the dataset and its treatment recommendations at technical reform. We demonstrate that this misalignment is structurally produced: anti-Blackness operates simultaneously across both registers, generating a shared evacuation of Black epistemic agency. We argue for frame analysis as an AI ethics methodology capable of surfacing what technical evaluation forecloses.

Comment
Accepted to the Ninth AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society (AIES 2026)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Whose Safety? Addressing Anti-Blackness in the Age of AI Safety

cs.CY ·2026-11-18 ·Mírian Silva, Serena Oduro
position similarity 0.63
Abstract

"AI safety" has grown from a niche contingent of actors into the dominant framing for artificial intelligence (AI) assessment and evaluation, overshadowing AI ethics. Through political and monetary influence, AI safety has shifted political focus within the US and abroad. The focus has shifted away from harms that currently affect the public toward threats framed as "existential risks". We argue that safety cannot be achieved while anti-Blackness is left unaddressed. We ground this argument in Sylvia Wynter's critique of the "overrepresentation" of Man: the modern, Western conception of the Human that is predicated on the subjugation and othering of Blackness. To analyze the state of addressing anti-Blackness in the age of AI safety, we conduct a two-stage, language model-assisted content analysis of 69,290 accepted main-track papers from ten leading machine learning (ML), natural language processing (NLP), and AI ethics conferences (2020--2025). Safety research grew from 0.5% of accepted papers in 2020 to 6.4% in 2025, overtaking ethics. Yet 94% of safety papers rely on automated metrics, and only 11% of safety papers mention harms that affect society directly, compared with 78% of ethics papers. Of the 2,182 safety papers, 8 mention race; none make it central, and none name Black or African-diaspora communities. Across all 254 identified as race-focused papers, only 3 describe racial harm in safety terms, and 55% appear at three ethics venues that publish 2.5% of the corpus. We offer this interdisciplinary examination of AI safety to argue that a just technological future depends on confronting anti-Blackness directly.

0.16

Method, Mind, and Morality: How People Make Sense of Artificial Intelligence

cs.CY cs.AIcs.CLcs.LG+1 ·2026-08-25 ·Jacy Reese Anthis, Erik Brynjolfsson, James Evans
published similarity 0.60
Abstract · Accepted to ACM CSCW 2026

How can humans make sense of the rapid takeoff of artificial intelligence (AI)? We studied the sensemaking dynamics of AI through an open-ended, mixed-methods study with computational text analysis of millions of AI-related newspaper articles and social media posts grounded in 57 semi-structured interviews with AI professionals in 2021 and 2023--before and after the recent surge of public interest. We identify a range of sociological frames (interpretive schemas that structure collective cognition) and show how AI professionals use frames to address significant cognitive challenges, such as assigning responsibility for societal impacts. We develop a framework of three primary debates across which frames are adopted and contested: (i) the $\textit{method}$ of AI development, between frames of top-down expert systems and bottom-up emergent capabilities, (ii) the $\textit{mind}$ of an AI system, ranging from a passive tool to a humanlike "digital mind," and (iii) the $\textit{morality}$ of how AI is used, particularly the decision of whether to slow down or speed up AI development. As humanity enters the era of transformative AI, technologists and policymakers must account for the framing dynamics that will circumscribe our beliefs, values, and actions.

0.41

Beyond Good Intentions: When Does the Framing of Multilingual and Low-Resource NLP Research Become a Caricature?

cs.CL ·2026-08-31 ·Nedjma Ousidhoum, Noopur Zambare, Mohamed Abdalla
top venue similarity 0.60
Abstract · Accepted at EMNLP2026 (Main)

Building language technologies and conducting NLP research for low-resource languages---particularly when led by native speakers or involving participatory research practices---are often framed as means of addressing inequality, serving local communities, and, at times, contributing to *decolonisation*. In this paper, we examine recently published NLP and ML papers, focusing on the narratives used to characterise multilinguality, low-resource languages, and underrepresented cultures. We propose a framework for analysing research framings and identify recurring rhetorical patterns that may hinder accountability and constrain equitable knowledge production for---and by---underserved communities. We further assess the evidential basis of assertions regarding community benefit and find that such statements are often weakly supported or left unsubstantiated. Although community ownership and participation are frequently presented as key objectives, our analysis, supported by statistics from the ACL Anthology, suggests that research outputs more often prioritise resource creation and benchmarking---important but distinct goals---over evidence of broader structural change. We conclude by offering practical recommendations to help authors, reviewers, and readers critically assess these assertions and avoid potentially misleading framings.

0.42

What Do We Mean When We Say 'F*ck AI'?: Moral Panic, Semantic Indeterminacy, and the Reification of Techno-Capitalism

cs.CY ·2026-11-03 ·Sasha Luccioni, Travis LaCroix
positionhot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract

Academic and (increasingly) public resistance to artificial intelligence (AI) often blurs the line between legitimate critique of techno-capitalist exploitation and (inflated) existential risk. Moreover, discourse around AI can sometimes resemble a "moral panic" where an apparently clear and identifiable scapegoat is targeted in lieu of the complex systemic problems that are causing (genuine and justified) social anxieties. However, AI is not a monolith. In this paper, we explore the environmental, political, and socio-technical consequences of the semantic indeterminacy of discourse about "AI" in conjunction with the increasing moral panic encompassing these technologies. We argue that since the umbrella term "AI" lacks a coherent, singular referent, the moral panic about AI inadvertently reifies the concept of an autonomous, singular agent with inherent and often autonomous tendencies, which aligns with corporate narratives. Hence, well-intentioned critique, activist pushback, and public protest paradoxically amplifies hype-based discussions of AI, thus validating the "threat" narrative that tech leaders deploy to exaggerate their products' capabilities and market value, further consolidating and centralising their political and socio-economic power. Moreover, if "AI" does not refer to a unified class of technologies, then policy intended to govern "AI" will systematically (and necessarily) fail. We conclude by proposing ways forward to improve AI literacy, enforce accountability, and repurpose existing regulation in order to imagine a more positive AI future.

0.28

"Black Mirror?": Public Sensemaking of AI-Powered Lifelogging

cs.HC ·2026-09-28 ·Ying Ma, Jarod Govers, Le Fang, Shuning Zhang, Yongquan 'Owen' Hu +2 more
published similarity 0.57
Abstract

AI-powered lifelogging wearables are emerging as a new class of consumer devices that transform everyday experience into searchable, AI-curated memory archives. We study early public sensemaking around these systems at the moment of their market entry, using the Looki L1 as an empirical lens. Analysing large-scale Chinese-language and English-language social media discourse (N = 5,053 comments), we combine topic clustering with inductive thematic analysis to examine how users interpret the social, moral, and political implications of AI-mediated memory. Across contexts, users reference dystopian surveillance imaginaries, express privacy resignation and bystander concerns, and debate assistive value alongside consumer logics. English-language comments more often framed these devices through interpersonal power, evidentiary use, and hacking anxieties, while Chinese-language comments more often foregrounded labour exploitation, governance surveillance, and technological inevitability.

0.23

The Many Morals of AI: The cautionary bias of North American news narratives in global perspective

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-13 ·Andrew Piper, Edie Pearman
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 4 pages, 5 figures

The stories told about artificial intelligence (AI) play a central role in shaping public understanding, policy debates, and expectations about technological change. News media are especially influential in this process. Using a cross-regional corpus of 12,924 English-language news articles about AI published since 2022, we examine how storytelling about AI varies across media systems in four regions: North America, China, India, and the Middle East. Leveraging large language models, we extract the implicit narrative lessons conveyed by each article---commonly known as story morals---capturing value-laden interpretations that extend beyond thematic content or sentiment. We find that North American AI coverage is uniquely characterized by narratives of caution, while under-emphasizing narratives of innovation and collaboration that are more prevalent elsewhere. However, this pattern is largely explained by a broader regional negativity bias in North American news sentiment, rather than by heightened concern about AI itself. Our findings bring into view the culturally conditioned nature of AI news narratives.

0.23

Contextuality and Contradictions: Exploring Real-World Identifications of AI-Generated Writing

cs.CL ·2026-11-05 ·Michelle Morgenstern, Julia Witte Zimmerman, Tabia Tanzin Prama, Kristine Harootunian, June Clark +3 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract

As AI-generated content spreads into nearly every domain of human interaction, practices and discourses of AI detection, both formal and informal, have become an everyday part of how people interact with text and with each other. In this paper, we explore the real-world practices and discourses of AI identification that have emerged in response to a shifting discursive landscape where the human provenance of a text can no longer be taken for granted. We pair qualitative coding with computational analysis of lexical change, grounded in linguistic anthropological perspectives on language and communication, to investigate AI identifications among English Wikipedia editors and students. We find that these identifications draw on a diversity of evidentiary types, from discrete textual features and judgments about content to circular sense-making claims and presumptions about the author's moral character, and that they are contradictory, dynamic, and contextually dependent. In practice, what often motivates an AI identification is not the presence of any specific textual element, but pragmatic infelicity: a perceived mismatch between the elements present and those deemed appropriate within the text's particular context. Consequently, real-world identifications of AI-generated writing do not merely neutrally point out the perceived presence of "AI-like" features, but can be leveraged as a discursive resource to maintain and define sociolinguistic norms: what can be said in a given context, what is appropriate, and, ultimately, what is human. Further, the design and implementation of systems and tools that treat AI-likeness as a context-free property of text may therefore inherit, and enforce at scale, the norms of whichever contexts they were trained on.

0.31

Govern, Map, Measure, Absorb: The Legibility Trap in Public Sector Participatory AI Governance

cs.CY cs.HC ·2026-10-02 ·Srijan Pandey, Devansh Saxena
published similarity 0.56
Abstract

Public sector agencies have adopted participatory design as a prominent procedural safeguard proposed against algorithmic harm. Across methods, institutional contexts, and well-intentioned implementations, the participation gap persists. Communities engage, input is documented, and systems are deployed largely unchanged. This paper locates the persistence of that gap in the mechanism institutions use to document participation itself. We develop the concept of the legibility trap, in which institutional mechanisms for documenting participation systematically select for forms of community input that fit institutional categories and filter out the forms that would most constrain state power, including foundational dissent, demands for non-deployment, and what Kelly Oliver calls witnessing to structural conditions of harm. Drawing on James Scott's theory of state simplification, we demonstrate the legibility trap through critical discourse analysis of twenty-two official, community-produced, and public-record documents across three public sector AI deployments: the Allegheny Family Screening Tool, Detroit Project Green Light, and the Community Control Over Police Surveillance (CCOPS) ordinances in Oakland. We identify the structural conditions under which participation partially escapes the trap, and we theorize that repeated non-response constitutes a harm to community subjectivity that AI ethics frameworks have not yet named.

0.21