CS Paper Radar

A Comparative Evaluation of Digitization Pipelines for Historiographical Sources

Marina Gómez Rey, Patricia Callejo, Mario Muñoz-Organero, Carlos Alario-Hoyos

cs.DL ·submitted 2026-08-25 16:03 UTC · v1

Abstract

Purpose: The digitization of historical documents presents fundamental challenges for modern information retrieval and Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems. Optical character recognition (OCR) errors in source corpora propagate through retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) pipelines, compromising the factual accuracy of generated outputs. Methods: This study presents a systematic evaluation of PDF-to-text extraction pipelines applied to historiographical secondary sources on the Visigothic period. We assess thirteen distinct approaches spanning three methodological families: direct extraction, Large Language Model (LLM) post-correction, and chunk-and-extract. Documents are stratified into five categories based on production method and visual complexity. Performance is measured using character error rate (CER) and word error rate (WER) against manually corrected ground truth. Results: Results demonstrate that direct extraction with Marker achieves superior performance (98.70% CER accuracy; 97.71% WER accuracy overall), while conventional OCR pipelines exhibit substantial degradation on scanned documents and complex layouts. Embedded-text extraction performs well on digital PDFs but fails on scanned documents. LLM post-correction does not provide systematic improvements and frequently degrades accurate extractions. Conclusion: End-to-end document parsing is the most reliable approach for heterogeneous historical collections. Document characteristics such as scan quality, layout complexity, and the presence of embedded text layers have a significant impact on extraction accuracy. LLM-based post-correction should not be assumed beneficial by default and requires validation before large-scale application.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Design Considerations in Low-Resource Archival OCR: A Case Study in Lakota

cs.CL ·2026-10-18 ·Téa Wright, Laura X. Ma, Claudia Iron Hawk, Hannah J. Haynie, Alexis Palmer +3 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Building and expanding access to digital archives supports language reclamation and creates lasting resources for community revitalization. Designing effective tools to support these efforts requires taking into account the community-, language-, and document-specific context. We investigate how small ($\leq$3B) vision-language models (VLMs) can be adapted as optical character recognition (OCR) tools for Lakota, a North American Indigenous language. In addition to benchmarking modeling approaches, we inspect four practical facets of low-resource archival OCR that arise in previous work and conversations with community members: constrained training budgets, segmentation noise, scan degradation, and orthographic variance. We demonstrate that fine-tuning VLMs for OCR post-correction on 35 pages of transcribed data decreases character error rate (CER) from 17.1 to 3.9\% on a bilingual corpus, and find that training only with nine pages increases CER by only 1.1\% over this. However, evaluating under realistic automatic segmentation nearly doubles the CER of the best-performing models, stressing the importance of taking realistic use cases into account. We hope this work encourages future research on developing language technologies grounded in the workflows and constraints of ongoing revitalization efforts.

0.17

Entity-Aware Evaluation of OCR Systems for Historical Document Transcription

cs.CL cs.AIcs.CVcs.LG+1 ·2026-10-07 ·Camilo Mariño, Diego Belzarena, Marina Gardella, Ignacio Ramírez, Gregory Randall +1 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted at URUCON 2026

Optical Character Recognition (OCR) is essential for digitizing historical archives, yet standard evaluation metrics such as Character Error Rate (CER) do not necessarily reflect whether meaningful information, such as names, dates, and identifiers, is preserved. In this work, we investigate entitylevel analysis of OCR errors as a complementary perspective for evaluating OCR quality in historical documents. Using a publicly available benchmark of 175 documents from the Berrutti Archive, augmented with 5,209 manually annotated entity mentions that will be released upon acceptance, we compare sequence-recognition OCR systems, OCR-specialized vision-language models, and general-purpose vision-language models. Beyond global transcription accuracy, we analyze entity preservation and recoverability under varying character-level edit tolerances. Our experiments show that OCR rankings depend on the evaluation criterion: while Qwen 3.6 achieves the highest entity coverage across all tested tolerances, several systems with lower exact-match coverage recover substantially when small errors are tolerated, suggesting that many of their errors correspond to localized character-level deviations rather than fundamentally incorrect entity transcriptions. Conversely, some systems remain unable to recover many entities even under relaxed matching. These findings show that OCR quality cannot be fully characterized by aggregate transcription metrics alone and highlight the importance of evaluating how OCR errors affect the preservation and recoverability of meaningful information.

0.43

Which papyrus HTR is good enough? Character-error-rate tolerance of four papyrological tasks on Greek texts

cs.CL ·2026-09-29 ·Anton Repushko, Elena Chepel
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

Purpose: Most Greek papyri remain unpublished and undigitised; a handwritten text recognition (HTR) pipeline that transcribes them automatically would let scholars discover documents and literary works that have so far gone unread. Recognition systems for Ancient Greek papyri are in statu nascendi, and how accurate they must be for a given papyrological task has not been examined. To answer this and set a benchmark for Greek papyrus HTR, we test a range of character error rates (CER) against four papyrological tasks, using published editions as ground truth. Methods: From 63,846 current editions of Greek texts in papyri.info, we imitate a letters-only "perfect HTR" output by removing the editorial layer, then degrade it with a seeded algorithm to exact CERs of 1 - 50%, with lost lines and four error-shape variants. On these data we train small models (TF-IDF, fastText, a character CNN, ByT5-small) for document type, dating and documentary-versus-literary classification, and apply eight keyword search methods. We compare models trained on clean text with models retrained at a specific CER level, and evaluate across CERs. Results: Tolerance differs by task. With clean-trained models, documentary-versus-literary classification retains 90% of its metric up to 20% CER; document type up to 7.5%; subtypes and search up to 5%; dating only up to 3%. Retraining on text containing character errors largely eliminates the sharp degradation that otherwise sets in above 15% CER. Models generally tolerate concentrated damage in a long document better than small errors spread across a short text. Conclusion: The study provides a CER target for each of the four tasks and shows that models trained on noisy text make current, imperfect text recognition useful for them.

0.29

UniLipi: A Unified Multi-Script OCR for Historical Indic Manuscripts

cs.CV ·2026-08-28 ·Tathagata Ghosh, Sai Madhusudan Gunda, Simran Singh Sandral, Ravi Kiran Sarvadevabhatla
top venue similarity 0.62
Abstract · To be published in ICDAR 2026

Optical character recognition (OCR) for handwritten Indic manuscripts is essential for large-scale digitization and computational access to manuscript heritage. However, existing approaches are typically developed for one script at a time and require substantial script-specific customization. This limits scalability and practical deployment across diverse collections. We present UniLipi, a unified multi-script OCR model for handwritten Indic manuscripts trained jointly across 13 Indic scripts within a single framework. UniLipi directly handles realistic manuscript conditions, including extreme variation in line geometry, large variation in line length, and partial interruptions caused by non-textual manuscript entities such as holes, stains, or pictorial illustrations. To operate effectively under ultra low-resource conditions, the model leverages script-aware synthetic manuscript data generation, substantially reducing reliance on large volumes of real annotated data. Beyond historical manuscripts, we show that UniLipi serves as an effective foundational pretrained model. Specifically, its learned representations enable good OCR performance for contemporary Indic handwriting and extend to several non-Indic scripts, including Tibetan, Italian, Latin, and Chinese scripts. In addition to transcription, UniLipi predicts script identity and per-line native character counts, supporting practical manuscript cataloging workflows.

0.35

Institutional Books - Visual Elements: An open-source pipeline for extracting, classifying, deduplicating, and captioning visual elements from digital book collections

cs.CV cs.DL ·2026-08-19 ·Jimmy Mendez, Matteo Cargnelutti, David Lowry-Duda, Catherine Brobston, Salwa Ismail +3 more
datasetcode/datahot direction similarity 0.62
Abstract

Historical book collections contain rich visual elements - such as illustrations, photographs, engravings, and decorative art - that are frequently under-explored in large-scale digitization projects. While Optical Character Recognition (OCR) has standardized the extraction of textual content, these visual components offer a layer of nuance and context that remains largely untapped by automated text extraction workflows. This technical report introduces Institutional Books - Visual Elements, an open-source end-to-end pipeline for detecting, classifying, deduplicating, and captioning visual elements from historical book collections. Alongside this pipeline, we release an initial dataset of 22.6 million visual elements extracted from the 983,004 scanned volumes that comprise the Institutional Books: Harvard Library dataset. This work contributes to ongoing, community-wide efforts to enable new use cases for digitized library collections through computational access, from artificial intelligence model training to digital humanities research.

0.45

InscriptionOCR: A Dataset and Method for Understanding Inscriptions

cs.CV ·2026-10-07 ·Jaidev Sanjay Khalane, Akbar Ali, V. N. Prabhakar, Shanmuganathan Raman
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Ancient script image restoration is a fundamental problem in computer vision, as it directly affects the reliable analysis and interpretation of historical documents and inscriptions. Ashokan Brahmi is an ancient script extensively used during the reign of Emperor Ashoka in the 3rd century BC, primarily for inscriptions in Prakrit. These inscriptions, including major and minor rock and pillar edicts, constitute a valuable yet largely unexplored source of data for computational analysis. The degraded nature of inscription imagery and the lack of standardized digital resources pose significant challenges for automated processing. We present an end-to-end AI-based framework for understanding ancient inscriptions that encompasses image enhancement, optical character recognition (OCR), transliteration, and neural machine translation (NMT). The proposed pipeline processes low-quality images captured directly from stone inscriptions, performs image restoration and Brahmi script character recognition, maps the recognized characters to the Roman script, and finally translates the resulting Prakrit text into English. We also introduce two new datasets: (i) InscriptionOCR Dataset: the largest publicly usable digital OCR dataset for Brahmi script to date, consisting of over 200,000 character images across about 600 classes, and (ii) a bilingual Prakrit-English parallel corpus comprising over 2,000 sentence pairs for NMT. We believe that the proposed framework and datasets will facilitate future research in ancient script analysis, low-resource OCR, and digital epigraphy.

0.13

Reading Beyond OCR Noise: Robust Cross-Lingual RAG for Legislative Archives

cs.CV cs.AIcs.IR ·2026-10-26 ·Radha Krishna Deshpande, Ajoy Mondal, Akash Manna, C V Jawahar
similarity 0.62
Abstract

India's historical public archives present severe computer vision and document image analysis challenges: decades of parliamentary records survive only as degraded, multi-column scanned pages featuring mixed scripts, complex layouts, and dense visual noise where OCR failure is the primary obstacle to information retrieval. We present an end-to-end framework that couples vision-based layout segmentation and multi-script OCR with an agentic retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) pipeline. Our approach specifically addresses how visual degradation and layout fragmentation propagate into text extraction errors, using an iterative agentic loop to navigate around OCR noise and layout ambiguities before generating answers. Evaluated on the 200,000-page Punjab Vidhan Sabha archive, our system demonstrates robust handling of historical document degradation, outperforming standard text-only baselines.

0.27

When Do VLMs Help Arabic Manuscript OCR? A Cross-Dataset Study

cs.CV ·2026-08-23 ·Moshiur Farazi, Firoj Alam, Abderrahmane Maaradji, Zakaria Maamar, Hamdy Mubarak +1 more
hot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract

Vision-language models (VLMs) are increasingly being used for document understanding, yet their role in Arabic and Islamic manuscript recognition remains underexplored. To address such a gap in this paper, we evaluate traditional OCR, general-purpose VLMs, Arabic-specialized VLMs, and OCR-conditioned VLM correction across eight Arabic text datasets spanning historical manuscripts, aged printed books, clean print, multi-domain documents, and handwriting. The results show that no single approach dominates across setups. On line-level historical manuscripts, VLMs are close to Tesseract; on page-level manuscript images, they perform better; and in several settings, an OCR-conditioned corrector improves over both standalone OCR and standalone VLMs. The central finding is an OCR-prior recoverability principle: OCR conditioning helps when the OCR output remains visually and textually recoverable, providing anchors that the VLM can refine against the image. It improves recognition on aged print, clean print, mixed-domain Arabic, and some Naskh manuscripts, but degrades performance when the prior is script-mismatched or systematically misleading, as in Maghribi manuscripts and realistic student handwriting. Additional diagnostics show that Arabic VLM-OCR is sensitive to diacritics, preprocessing, generation budget, and repetition loops. These findings support an adaptive OCR-VLM workflow that routes pages according to script, OCR-prior recoverability, length diagnostics, and failure-mode indicators.

0.24