CS Paper Radar

Generative vs. Encoder Large Language Models for ASR Evaluation: A Comparative Study

Thibault Bañeras-Roux, Shashi Kumar, Driss Khalil, Sergio Burdisso, Petr Motlicek, Shiran Liu, Mickael Rouvier, Jane Wottawa, Richard Dufour

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-08-26 09:36 UTC · v1

Abstract

Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) is typically evaluated using Word Error Rate (WER), which poorly reflects semantic similarity. While embedding-based metrics correlate better with human judgments, the respective roles of encoder and decoder-based Large Language Models (LLMs) remain underexplored. This paper presents a comparative study of both families for ASR evaluation. We analyze BERTScore and SemDist across different LLMs, layers, and pooling strategies, showing that both metrics can achieve strong correlation with human judgments when properly configured. For decoder models, we investigate generative LLMs in two settings: pairwise hypothesis selection via prompting and direct qualitative error classification. Our results show that encoder-based metrics remain highly competitive, while generative LLMs perform strongly in hypothesis comparison and improve the interpretability of ASR evaluation.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Rethinking Human-Aligned Evaluation: An Analysis of Semantic Metrics Beyond WER

cs.CL ·2026-09-18 ·Hritika Sharma, Thibault Bañeras-Roux, Alessandra Pinto, Petr Motlicek, Hyunggu Jung +2 more
benchmarkdataset similarity 0.78
Abstract

Word Error Rate (WER), the most commonly used metric for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), treats every lexical deviation from the reference as equally costly, regardless of whether it changes meaning. This raises the question: does WER actually track how humans judge ASR transcript quality? We introduce HATS-en, an English dataset for human-centered ASR evaluation. Using this dataset, we benchmark lexical metrics against several configurations of BERTScore and SemDist, varying the language model, layer, and pooling strategy. We find that WER agrees least with human judgment among all metrics tested, that the best-performing SemDist configurations achieve the highest overall agreement, ahead of CER and BERTScore, and that no single model is best across settings. CER, despite its simplicity and low cost, remains remarkably close to these best configurations. In line with prior recommendations, our results support shifting ASR evaluation toward CER both for English and for morphosyllabic writing systems as it is a more interpretable and low-cost metric for what evaluation should actually capture, and using SemDist as a complementary evaluation.

0.18

SITAR: A Situational Distortion Metric for Automatic Speech Recognition Evaluation

cs.CL ·2026-10-15 ·Mingzhe Lu, Jinhao Liu, Yunpeng Li, Hang Su, Lichun Fan +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract · 33 pages, 4 figures, including appendices

In automatic speech recognition (ASR), transcription errors with similar lexical or semantic discrepancies can have markedly different consequences for the situation conveyed by speech. Capturing these differences requires not merely contextual assessment, but an understanding of what the spoken discourse describes, establishes, or seeks to bring about. However, relying on LLM judges introduces computational cost and scoring variability. We introduce SITAR, a situational distortion metric for ASR, realized through a comprehensive end-to-end construction framework. Specifically, this framework aggregates situational severity and cumulative extent into a unified score via a bounded recursive formulation. Using targets derived from this formulation with limited offline LLM support, we train SITAR as a lightweight BERT-family regressor that scores reference-hypothesis pairs in a single forward pass, entirely free of any prohibitive runtime costs. Recognizing that introducing a new metric demands rigorous justification, we formalize a principled validation protocol spanning both extrinsic validity, assessed at macro and micro levels, and intrinsic scorer reliability. The former, evaluated across diverse datasets and models, demonstrates that SITAR reliably tracks broad capability scaling while providing orthogonal diagnostic utility, whereas the latter, examined on a purpose-built controlled benchmark, confirms the operational soundness of the scoring instrument itself. Through systematic validation, we demonstrate that SITAR holds strong potential as a practical, lightweight complement to existing ASR metrics. We will release the full recipes (code, model weights, dataset, etc.) after the internal review to support community research.

0.18

Beyond Naturalness: Probing Automated Text-To-Speech Evaluators on Linguistically Grounded Dimensions

cs.SD cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-08-10 ·Oluwanifemi Bamgbose, Jash Shah, Simon Rosen, Lindsay Devon Brin, Hoang H Nguyen +4 more
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · Accepted to EMNLP 2026 (Main Conference)

Automated Text-to-Speech (TTS) evaluation methods (Mean Opinion Score (MOS) predictors and Audio Large Language Model (Audio-LLM) judges) are expected to reflect human perception, yet it is unclear how well they capture the distinct aspects of speech that listeners actually perceive. We deconstruct "naturalness" into a linguistically grounded annotation schema spanning 10 distinct perceptual dimensions, and use it to construct the first dimension-level meta-evaluation benchmark for TTS, comprising 860 utterances annotated by trained linguist raters. Results from benchmarking four MOS predictors and four Audio-LLM judges reveal that MOS predictors are more sensitive to acoustic signal-level properties at the prosodic and paralinguistic levels, while Audio-LLM judges show selective, prompt-dependent detection that favors word-level errors and does not generalize across all dimensions. Neither class reliably captures a breadth of linguistically structured, human-perceptible speech errors. Our dataset, annotation schema, and evaluation code are publicly released to support more targeted and interpretable TTS evaluation.

0.47

GSLM2: Multi-Stream Speech Representation Learning and Generative Spoken Language Modeling

cs.CL cs.SDeess.AS ·2026-10-31 ·Yosuke Higuchi, Tom Fizycki, Mahi Luthra, Charles-Éric Saint-James, Azeez Syed +12 more
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · Equal contribution by Yosuke Higuchi and Tom Fizycki. Core contribution by Mahi Luthra, Charles-Éric Saint-James and Azeez Syed

Generative spoken language models (SLMs) offer a route to learning linguistic structure purely from speech, yet they lag far behind text-based models in both capability and data scaling efficiency. We identify two bottlenecks underlying this gap: the limited linguistic quality of existing speech units and the reliance on a single stream of discrete units to represent speech. Multiple codebooks are widely used to encode acoustic features but rarely to represent speech semantics. We present GSLM2, which learns and models complementary properties of speech at multiple levels of abstraction. Its encoder, SpidR 2.0, uses self-supervised learning with differentiable prediction heads to induce high-quality discrete units at multiple levels. A multi-stream SLM then jointly models these units using a shared temporal backbone, stream-specific predictors, and an autoregressive head that captures cross-stream dependencies. Across training data sizes and model scales, up to 6M hours and 6.5B parameters, GSLM2 consistently improves linguistic competence while scaling more efficiently with data. As a result, it substantially narrows the gap between spoken and text-based LMs; across read and conversational speech domains, we shrink the gap by about two orders of magnitude on sWuggy, sBLIMP, and tSC, while also outperforming competitive speech-text systems on all three tasks. We open-source the training code and model checkpoints at https://github.com/facebookresearch/gslm2.

0.19

Rethinking Automated Voice Similarity by Shifting from EER to Embedding Geometry

eess.AS cs.SD ·2026-09-27 ·Szu-Chi Chen, Jia-Kai Dong, Yi-Cheng Lin, Sung-Feng Huang, Hung-yi Lee
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 5 pages. Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Speaker verification (SV) models are commonly assumed to better capture nuances among speaker characteristics as verification accuracy improves, leading to their widespread use as automated proxies for human voice similarity in speech generation tasks. However, by establishing a human perceptual alignment metric and conducting systematic analysis, we demonstrate that perceptual alignment is governed far more by how a model is trained (its learning objective) than by how well it performs (EER). Notably, standard margin-based classification losses (e.g., AAM-Softmax) yield substantially lower perceptual alignment than prototypical metric losses, while EER itself fails to track human judgment, directly challenging the community's implicit assumption. We trace this divergence to embedding geometry, where a model's effective dimensionality ($d_{\mathrm{eff}}$) tracks perceptual alignment with a $-0.95$ rank correlation, revealing that the dimensional spread favored by classification losses fundamentally clashes with the low-dimensional nature of human voice perception. Imposing a dimensionality bottleneck compresses $d_{\mathrm{eff}}$ and raises perceptual alignment ($ρ_{\mathrm{align}}$) from 0.08 to 0.74, establishing a principled geometric criterion for evaluating voice similarity.

0.33

Learning from Distribution: Rethinking One-Hot Supervision for ASR and QA in Speech Language Models

cs.SD ·2026-11-16 ·Yujie Guo, Hongjie Chen, Jiaming Zhou, Jian Kang, Jie Li +2 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Speech language models (SLMs) exhibit strong capabilities in automatic speech recognition (ASR) and general-purpose speech understanding, yet ASR-specific training often degrades spoken question answering (QA) performance. We revisit this conflict from the perspective of task-specific input--output mappings and one-hot supervision. Our findings reveal pronounced task-asymmetric effects: ASR-only training severely limits QA capability, whereas QA-only training retains reasonable ASR performance. We hypothesize that the relatively deterministic mapping of ASR, combined with single-reference supervision, biases models toward transcription-specific behavior. Motivated by this perspective, we advocate broadening ASR learning objectives while preserving recognition accuracy. We propose Learning from Distribution (LFD), which aligns speech-conditioned predictions with the conditional output distributions of a pretrained text LLM. Extensive experiments demonstrate that LFD improves both ASR and QA performance, exhibits superior data efficiency, and remains effective under full-parameter fine-tuning. CoT-ASR further supports the broader applicability of our proposed supervision principle.

0.09

A Comparative Evaluation of BERT-Based and LLM-Based Models for Indic Sentence Similarity

cs.CL cs.LG ·2026-11-14 ·Aishwarya Gunjal, Kanchan Khemnar, Pawan Poojary, Pranav Kulkarni, Raviraj Joshi
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

The relative effectiveness of BERT-based encoders and large language model (LLM)-based embeddings for Indic semantic textual similarity remains insufficiently characterized. We compare eight BERT-based and five LLM-based models on the 1,500-pair STS Benchmark development set translated into ten Indic languages and on the native Marathi MahaSTS test set. IndicSBERT achieves the highest Pearson correlation in all ten translated language sets, with a macro-average of 0.843, followed by BGE-M3 at 0.792. Harrier-270M is the strongest LLM-based model on translated STS-B, with a macro-average of 0.751. On MahaSTS, IndicSBERT and Bhasha-Embed-v0 achieve Pearson correlations of 0.901 and 0.900, respectively, while EmbeddingGemma leads the LLM-based models at 0.871. The highest-scoring BERT-based model thus exceeds the highest-scoring LLM-based model in both settings, although the magnitude of the difference varies across benchmarks. These findings indicate that LLM-derived embeddings do not uniformly improve Indic sentence similarity over established encoders and motivate evaluation that accounts for language coverage, task supervision, and benchmark construction.

0.15

Beyond Encoder Fusion: Multi-View Discrete Token Augmentation for LLM-Based ASR

cs.SD ·2026-09-20 ·Paul Moïse Gangbadja, Mickael Rouvier, Fabrice Lefèvre
published similarity 0.67
Abstract

Discrete speech tokens provide a compact interface between speech encoders and large language models for automatic speech recognition, but single-tokenization systems remain sensitive to the chosen encoder. We propose multi-view discrete token augmentation, a simple strategy that augments each training utterance by generating alternative token sequences from fixed SSL encoders, such as HuBERT, WavLM, and MMS-300M. These tokenizations are treated as complementary training views for a shared LLM decoder, exposing it to more diverse discrete speech representations without requiring multi-encoder inference. At test time, the model can operate with a single encoder. On LibriSpeech, the approach consistently improves all encoders over independently trained baselines, with WavLM reaching 3.30% WER on test-clean and 8.13% on test-other. Budget-matched controls show that the gains come from encoder diversity rather than data volume. ROVER over multi-view hypotheses further improves WER to 3.03% and 7.38%.

0.38