CS Paper Radar

Missing the Butterfly and Predicting the Past: Features or Bugs of Accurate AI Weather Models?

Pedram Hassanzadeh, Weidong Li, Y. Qiang Sun, Jiangdi Wang, Alexander Wikner, Justin Finkel, Jonathan Q. Weare

cs.AI physics.ao-ph ·submitted 2026-08-26 14:14 UTC · v1

Abstract

AI weather prediction (AIWP) models rival physics-based models, yet the sources of their unexpected forecast accuracy and the degree of their physical fidelity remain unclear. Here, across a hierarchy spanning observation-based reanalysis, a general circulation model, and the multi-scale Lorenz system, we show that AI models can be trained to skillfully predict the past (backcast), though backcasts are systematically less accurate than forecasts. However, skillful backcasting appears to violate the second law of thermodynamics, and all these forecasting and backcasting models miss the butterfly effect. We trace the surprising forecast accuracy, missing butterfly, and skillful backcasting to a single cause: inevitable coarse-graining of training data, which removes fast, small scales and/or some variables. From the Lorenz system to official Pangu-Weather models, reducing coarse-graining makes AI predictions more physics-like (arrow of time and butterfly-like effects emerge), but forecast accuracy declines. Results offer an explanation for AIWP models' forecast skill: unlike physics-based models, they implicitly learn how fast, small scales affect large scales without inheriting their rapid error growth. Broader implications are that AI models' proliferation calls for revisiting predictability theories and long-term climate emulation strategies, and backcasting offers a useful, new lens for such analyses.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Interpretability of AI weather models via intermediate decoding

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-10-16 ·Matthias Beylich, Kirsten I. Tempest, Tobias Selz, George C. Craig
similarity 0.71
Abstract · 16 pages, 10 figures, 1 table. Supplementary material in the ancillary files

AI weather prediction models are often regarded as black boxes. Despite their impressive skill, there is little understanding of how the input data is processed during inference to produce the forecast. This limitation arises from the use of high-dimensional latent representations in which individual dimensions are no longer directly interpretable in physical terms. To gain insight into how forecasts are constructed, we propose the method of intermediate decoding for AI weather models and apply it to GraphCast, Aurora and ArchesWeather. In this approach, latent states from intermediate depths are decoded back into meteorological fields. To do this, we use the decoder that has been trained to output the forecast at the end of processing. Since latent states at different depths do not share a consistent basis, we train affine transformations that align intermediate latent states with the decoder's expected input space. Applying this framework to the three models yields the following results. First, the skill of forecasts at intermediate stages of processing improves gradually through the processor layers. Second, bypassing all processor blocks shows that the encoder-decoder pair is not an identity mapping returning the input, but instead plays a significant role in the forecast construction. Third, by examining increments of individual processor blocks across model depth, we show that all three models progressively refine the forecast from coarse to finer spatial scales. Finally, we assess the physical consistency of the intermediate decoding forecasts and find that large scales remain physically balanced throughout processing, while small scales become more balanced with each additional processor block.

0.35

Auditing Learned Dynamics in Weather Models

cs.LG ·2026-11-18 ·Skylar Gu, Christina Last
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Learned weather models are experimentally accessible computational systems whose internal representations can be inspected and manipulated. Using sparse autoencoder features from GraphCast, DeepMind's autoregressive weather forecasting model, we test whether causal relevance requires physical semantics, a question that matters for auditing whether AI forecasters used in high-assurance settings rely on reliable mechanisms. We also look at whether physically associated latent directions can be steered to improve extreme-event forecasts, where interventions are applied to the model's internal activations during the rollout. We find that ablating a feature locked to GraphCast's computational mesh increases global geopotential height error despite lacking conventional physical semantics. Second, suppressing convection- and low-level-vorticity-associated features weakens predicted tropical-cyclone deepening (the fall in central pressure during intensification), while amplifying them reduces intensity error, with amplification of convection features through feature scaling achieving a median of 51\% error reduction over seven storms. Together, these results separate interpretable, physical association from causal utility and establish sparse features as experimental coordinates for auditing and intervening on learned weather dynamics.

0.20

Beyond the record: evaluating probabilistic AI weather forecasts deep in the tail

cs.LG ·2026-10-18 ·Bastiaan Van Velthoven, Cas Decancq, Diego G. Miralles, Stijn Luca, Thomas Mortier
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Can probabilistic artificial intelligence (AI) weather forecasts retain skill beyond their training domain? We compare four state-of-the-art AI models (ArchesWeatherGen, U-Cast, WeatherNext2 and GenCast-mini) with the physics-based IFS-ENS over land in 2022, at 1.5° resolution and lead times of 2--10 days. Monthly ERA5 records from 1979--2021 define common historical boundaries, and we characterize new records set in 2022 by their depth, i.e., the exceedance margin relative to local historical variability. Two proper scores, record-threshold weighted CRPS and Brier score, assess the magnitude and probability of record exceedances across all eligible cases, retaining both missed extremes and false alarms. Verified against ERA5, AI models outperform IFS-ENS for heat and cold records at almost every lead and depth. For heat, the advantage strengthens with depth, partly because IFS-ENS over-forecasts deep records, and largely persists for deeper records under HRES-fc0 verification. For wind, gains erode for deeper records and longer leads. Better tail scores can nevertheless coexist with aggregate probability deficits or surpluses, and some improvements arise chiefly on non-exceedances. Increasing underprediction on progressively more extreme observed subsets can also arise through outcome selection, even for an ideal conditional-mean forecast. These findings establish that native probabilistic AI ensembles retain, and for heat increase, their advantage over IFS-ENS as thresholds move beyond local records, although all advantages narrow with lead time. They caution against generalizing the extrapolation failure reported for deterministic AI forecasts to probabilistic systems, and motivate common verification conventions that separate comparative tail skill, performance on realized extremes, and probabilistic calibration.

0.09

Artificial intelligence pathways from weather to climate

cs.AI physics.ao-phcs.LG ·2026-10-07 ·Tom Beucler, J. David Neelin, Hui Su, Shivanshi Asthana, Chris Bretherton +8 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 33 pages, 10 figures. Submitted to "Science Advances"

Deep learning has made rapid advances in weather forecasting: autoregressive models trained on atmospheric reanalyses now rival dynamical models across nowcasting, medium-range, and subseasonal-to-seasonal lead times, producing well-calibrated ensemble forecasts at reduced cost. We review these advances and consider their extension to climate horizons, where the challenge shifts from initial-condition skill to producing reliable statistical responses under altered forcings. AI-powered climate prediction systems must produce credible forced responses to drivers (e.g., greenhouse gases, land-use change) typically outside the observed record. We propose two minimum requirements for AI in climate modeling: (i) external forcing agents must enter explicitly enough to support interventions in which they vary independently; and (ii) robustness must be stress-tested in out-of-distribution regimes, including extremes and counterfactual trajectories. Using leading AI autoregressive emulators and hybrid physics-AI models, we identify development and coupling challenges. Comparing the reported throughput of these models with that of GPU-ported dynamical models highlights how AI can reduce time-to-solution by advancing only the target variables at the required resolution and using longer time steps, rather than integrating a full high-frequency, multivariate state. Diverse AI downscaling strategies can partially substitute for explicit fine-scale resolution, paving the way toward inexpensive local hazard assessment across prediction horizons.

0.10

Domain-Adaptive Data Assimilation for Global AI Weather Forecasting

cs.CE ·2026-10-02 ·Minseok Seo, Noah Brenowitz, Doyi Kim, Hyesook Lee, Changick Kim
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · 27 pages, [This project is open source.]

AI weather forecasting models are commonly trained on the ERA5 reanalysis, which is unavailable in real time. Operational deployment therefore relies on initial conditions produced by numerical or AI analysis systems that differ from those encountered during training. This mismatch can degrade forecast skill, while retraining for every analysis system is costly. Here, we present Domain-Adaptive Data Assimilation (DADA), an observation-guided framework that adapts external analyses to pretrained AI weather models. Starting from a background state, DADA optimizes only an initial-state perturbation while keeping the forecast model frozen. The perturbed state is propagated through the model, and its short-range trajectory is constrained by real-world observations through a learned observation operator. The resulting initial condition is shaped jointly by observational constraints and the dynamics learned by the target model. We evaluate DADA across five global AI weather models using backgrounds from the Global Forecast System and the AI-based HealDA. Across deterministic and probabilistic forecasts, DADA substantially reduces short-range skill loss caused by changes in the initial-condition source. More broadly, DADA turns observations into a common interface between independently developed analysis and forecasting systems, enabling pretrained AI weather models to accommodate evolving operational initial conditions without reconstructing ERA5 or retraining the forecast model.

0.33

Uncertainty-Aware End-to-End AI Weather Forecasting: Disentangling Observation and Model Contributions

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-08-31 ·Rodrigo Almeida, Noelia Otero, Jost Arndt, Simon Baur, Wojciech Samek +1 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 25 pages, 16 figures

End-to-end weather forecasting systems produce skillful global gridded and station forecasts directly from raw Earth observations, replacing the numerical weather prediction pipeline, including data assimilation, at a fraction of its cost. These systems are deterministic and issue no uncertainty. Here we render the Aardvark Weather model probabilistic by attaching one stochastic mechanism to each component: learned, input-dependent noise at the observation encoder, aimed at the uncertainty inherited from the observing system, and Monte Carlo dropout in the processor, aimed at the uncertainty of the learned dynamics. The resulting nested ensemble attributes forecast spread to the two sources through a law-of-total-variance decomposition, cross-checked by withholding observation streams. Probabilistic finetuning significantly improves the mean forecast, by 11% on average across variables and lead times. The ensemble is close to calibrated against ERA5 through the medium range, is at least as accurate as the deterministic model at weather stations while beating it in relative economic value at every lead time, and remains considerably behind the operational ECMWF IFS ensemble. The encoder branch behaves as observation-driven uncertainty. Component-attributed uncertainty makes end-to-end forecasts more transparent, a step toward observation-driven digital twins of the atmosphere.

0.22

Bridging short- and medium-range weather forecasting with machine learning

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-08-27 ·Timothy A. Smith, Mariah Pope, Sergey Frolov, Brett Basarab, Daniel Abdi +2 more
position similarity 0.68
Abstract

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) employs independent prediction systems for distinct forecast products. While some separation is practical, we argue that combining short- and medium-range weather into a single prediction system would provide the public with a useful distillation of global weather and its impacts. To this end, we present Nested-EAGLE (Experimental Artificial intelligence Global and Limited-area Ensemble): a 0.25° global weather model with a 6 km refinement over the Contiguous United States (CONUS). The model achieves significantly lower mean-squared error in near-surface and low-level quantities over CONUS compared to NOAA's Global Forecast System and High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR), while remaining competitive throughout the rest of the global atmosphere. We show that the skill gains for near-surface fields stem from incorporating high-resolution regional analysis data into training through the nesting process. Forecasts of precipitation amounts are less skillful than those from HRRR, owing to deterministic training. However, we show that Nested-EAGLE provides the most accurate forecasts of storm locations at longer leads, despite blurred extrema. Our results motivate future work to extend the skill gains beyond CONUS and improve precipitation representation.

0.42

DIAL: Dynamic and Informed Adjustment of the Native Stochastic Law for Reliable Weather Ensembles

cs.CV ·2026-10-15 ·Yucheng Wang, Haonan Guo, Tianhao Zhao, Di Wang, Yu Wu +2 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 17 pages, 5 figures, including appendix

Ensemble weather forecasts can look reliable in global averages while hiding too little spread in some cases and too much in others. These errors vary across variables, spatial scales, lead times, and weather states. Adapting randomness during forecasting can correct these errors, but training fixes stochastic behavior beforehand and output calibration acts afterward. Inference guidance also acts during forecasting, but typically scores ensemble members separately rather than the ensemble as a whole. Reliability feedback arrives at the end, and tracing it backward through many chaotic forecast steps is expensive and unstable. We therefore introduce Dynamic and Informed Adjustment of the Native Stochastic Law (DIAL), which controls a frozen model's native stochasticity. DIAL learns from past forecasts to predict whether each variable and scale needs more or less spread. As a forecast develops, it estimates how possible noise changes will affect later forecast accuracy and reliability. It combines these predictions to make small noise updates at each step. This loop avoids retraining the weather model and full backpropagation through the forecast. We evaluate DIAL on FourCastNet 3 (FCN3) using later ERA5 years unseen during training. DIAL provides better scale-resolved reliability than learned postprocessing and reward-based control baselines. Relative to the unmodified Native FCN3 reference, DIAL achieves an 8.27% improvement in the primary multiscale continuous ranked probability score (CRPS).

0.14