CS Paper Radar

On Scope Classification and Current Knowledge-Editing Benchmarks: A Negative Result, with INLAY as a Gradient-Free Case Study

Aditya Pratap Singh

cs.CL cs.AIcs.LG ·submitted 2026-08-26 18:16 UTC · v1
benchmarkcode/data

Abstract

Every memory-based knowledge editor in the SERAC lineage depends on a scope decision: given a query, does a stored edit apply? We report that current knowledge-editing benchmarks cannot measure this decision at all. Using INLAY, a gradient-free editor we built to obtain exact per-query ground truth (the model is frozen, edits live in an external addressable memory, and applying an edit is a bias added along one token's unembedding direction at decode time), we execute every candidate router action on 1,689 queries spanning three datasets and three input conditions. An oracle router choosing the best action every time ties a one-line static policy to four decimal places in all nine dataset-by-condition cells: the maximum attainable gain of any per-query routing method is 0.00 points. Abstention is the sole winning action zero times out of 1,689. The cause is structural: these are counterfactual benchmarks whose evaluation question asks for the post-edit answer, so answering from parametric knowledge is wrong by construction, and a benchmark without negatives cannot reward a classifier's ability to reject. This generalizes beyond our system to the whole scope-classifier family the benchmarks are used to evaluate. We confirm the mechanism directly: constructing the missing condition ourselves, by withholding a query's own edit from the index for half the sample, moves pooled headroom from exactly +0.0000 to +0.0420 and gives abstention its first wins. We also report where INLAY itself does not win (WISE beats it on Qwen2.5-7B CounterFact, and retrieval-augmented generation beats every method we tested, INLAY included, on rigorously matched RippleEdits), and disclose two bugs found during a self-audit of our own routing machinery, neither of which changed a published headline number outside noise.

Comment
12 pages, 5 figures, 6 tables. Code and data: https://github.com/Aditya-PS-05/INLAY

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

ALLOT: Budgeted Hybrid-Memory Routing for Knowledge Updates in LLMs

cs.AI ·2026-09-26 ·Shanfeng Huang, Zhou Fang, Song Xiao, Hai Du
benchmark similarity 0.68
Abstract

For large language models (LLMs), parametric adaptation is costly when retrieval already suffices. We introduce ALLOT, a hybrid-memory routing framework that separates learned write priority from a hard parametric budget. A memory-aware router combines frozen text representations, retrieval confidence, and relation metadata; a single ranking supports multiple write budgets while preserving all facts in external memory. On CounterFact with Qwen3-4B, ALLOT reaches 0.760 accuracy at a 20% parametric-write budget and recovers 78.4% of the budget-matched oracle gain, with 80% fewer parametric writes than dual-writing every fact. At this budget, jointly adding retrieval and relation features to text improves normalized oracle gain by 6.2 percentage points. Complementary Qwen3-0.6B shared-store results achieve dual-write-level accuracy with 6-14.5% parametric writes, and cross-benchmark transfer retains approximately 88% of in-domain gain. These results support allocating adaptation capacity according to its incremental value rather than treating every factual update as an equally valuable training target.

0.16

ALOE: Semantically Addressed Low-Rank Operators for Knowledge Editing

cs.AI ·2026-09-24 ·Zeyan Li, Hu Xu, Jianfeng Xu
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Knowledge editing changes what a model knows by modifying parameters so that a requested fact updates while unrelated behavior is preserved. This is usually treated as a write problem, but editing also involves an address problem: deciding which hidden states should receive the new residual. An update that activates too narrowly memorizes one prompt, while one that activates too broadly disrupts neighboring knowledge. Parametric editors encode this scope implicitly, whereas memory-based editors make the selection explicit but keep it outside the edited model. We propose ALOE (Addressed Low-rank Operator for Editing), which learns semantic addresses from paraphrases and hard same-subject negatives, aligns them with autoregressive hidden states through rollout refinement and gate calibration, and embeds the resulting gated low-rank operator within one MLP layer, so that the deployed model runs in a single forward pass with no external retriever or auxiliary router. Evaluated on CounterFact, ZSRE, and KnowEdit across three 7--8B model families, ALOE achieves efficacy between 0.955 and 0.999 and locality between 0.981 and 1.000; mechanistic analyses confirm that the learned geometry separates competing edits and that calibration suppresses out-of-scope activation. The remaining errors concentrate in paraphrase coverage and write fitting.

0.21

Route Me If You Can: A Benchmark for Query Reformulation Selection

cs.IR ·2026-09-14 ·Hai Son Le, Negar Arabzadeh, Amin Bigdeli, Radin Hamidi Rad, Sajad Ebrahimi +2 more
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract

LLM-based query reformulation can improve retrieval, but no single reformulation strategy is consistently optimal across queries, domains, retrievers, or model backbones. This creates an inference-time decision problem: ``Given an original query and a pool of candidate reformulations, which one should be issued to the retriever?''. Existing studies are hard to compare because they use different reformulator pools, retrievers, relevance signals, training labels, and evaluation metrics. We introduce QueryRoute, a benchmark that freezes the expensive artifacts needed to study this decision reproducibly: original queries, generated variants, ranked lists under multiple retrievers, retrieval scores, and per-query oracle labels. The benchmark contains 3,757 queries, 11 candidate systems, five reformulator backbones, and three retrievers across TREC DL, BEIR, and BRIGHT, yielding 619,905 retrieval outcomes. We benchmark supervised classification, routing, QPP, and LLM-as-judge selectors. Results show substantial oracle headroom over fixed reformulators, but current selectors recover only part of it; selector rankings change across retrievers, and similar mean effectiveness can hide different query-level behavior. The released artifacts and evaluation harness allow future selectors to be compared without regenerating variants, rerunning retrieval, or rebuilding judge pipelines. Code and data are available at https://github.com/haisonle001/QueryRoute

0.49

MIRAGE: A Framework for Multi-hop Reasoning under Dynamic Knowledge Injection

cs.CL ·2026-11-18 ·Heyang Xu, HanWen Hao, Haifeng Wang, Haoyi Zhou, Jianxin Li
benchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract · Submitted to COLING 2027. 15 pages, 5 figures

Multi-hop Question Answering (MQA) requires large language models (LLMs) to retrieve and synthesize multiple pieces of evidence into a coherent reasoning path, which is essential for complex tasks. However, prior work on knowledge updating for MQA has largely focused on simple fact edits, overlooking a more challenging and realistic setting---\emph{Knowledge Injection}---in which the model must simultaneously accommodate both conflicting updates and entirely novel information. Under this setting, a hop-level answer is often wrong simply because the model trusts the wrong knowledge source: it clings to outdated parametric memory when the injected knowledge conflicts with it (K2), and it cannot answer when the required fact is entirely new (K3). To investigate this, we introduce NEXUS, the first benchmark tailored for multi-hop reasoning under Knowledge Injection, which explicitly covers both conflicting (K2) and incremental (K3) knowledge. We further propose MIRAGE, an efficient, training-free framework whose core component, the Correlation-aware Dual-path Reasoner (CDR), resolves such per-hop source-trust errors via P(True)-based confidence routing, complemented by a lightweight template-guided corrector for residual structural deviations. Extensive experiments across four LLM families and two benchmarks demonstrate that MIRAGE consistently improves both final-answer accuracy and hop-level reasoning accuracy, establishing a new state of the art in this challenging setting.

0.17

TableRoute: Capability-Aware Routing for Scalable Table Question Answering

cs.CL ·2026-11-19 ·Yuxiang Wang, Junhao Gan, Jianzhong Qi
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Table question answering with large language models remains difficult to scale: tables range from compact to million-token sizes, while questions require precise grounding of columns, values, and computations. Existing methods often specialize in a fixed inference strategy, which is brittle across different table scales and model capabilities. Full-table reading is efficient for compact inputs but suffers from irrelevant context. Table reduction helps long inputs but depends on reliable evidence localization, while execution is required when tables exceed the model context window and remains sensitive to schema and value grounding errors. We propose TableRoute, a capability-aware routing framework with evidence-conditioned inference for scalable TableQA. TableRoute first generates validated question--table evidence and identifies the required operations, then routes each instance among these three strategies according to serialized table length and calibrated estimates of how reliably the base model handles these operations. The validated evidence supports the selected route by grounding columns, values, and conditions. Across WikiTQ, WTQ-L, BirdQA, and TableBench, TableRoute consistently improves accuracy through complementary routing and evidence conditioning across table scales, while reducing online token cost. Code will be made available upon publication.

0.11

Sequential knowledge editing breaks a model's ability to tell good evidence from bad, without costing it accuracy

cs.AI ·2026-08-31 ·Atul Anand
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 10 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables. Code and experimental artifacts available on request

Knowledge editing is evaluated on whether the edited fact changed, whether paraphrases follow, and whether unrelated answers stayed put. A model can pass all three and still lose something none of them measures: the ability to decide, on facts that were never edited, which retrieved documents to believe. We score the log odds a model assigns to its remembered answer against the answer an injected passage asserts, before and after editing, holding the query, the passage and both candidate strings fixed. Our cleanest arm is a conservatively tuned LoRA: after 1,000 sequential edits on Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct it leaves MMLU unchanged to four decimal places, yet the spread of the arbitration quantity across untouched facts falls by 36%. Selective prediction degrades with it. Area under the risk-coverage curve rises by 0.107, against 0.005 for a norm-matched perturbation at the same MMLU, and error on the model's most confident quarter of arbitration decisions goes from 0.217 to 0.342. This is not capability loss. Sweeping random perturbation over five severities, damage bad enough to cut MMLU from 0.6275 to 0.3725 produces less harm (0.088) than MEMIT does at 0.6050 (0.102). The effect holds across three seeds, two model families, two datasets, two probe-disjointness criteria, three prompt templates and paraphrased queries. Layer ablation on saved weight deltas shows it is distributed: no single layer reproduces it, and removing any one recovers about half. Under retrieval with a frozen retriever, accuracy falls from 0.592 to 0.46. A secondary finding may matter more in practice. Three of five model and method pairings we ran collapse to chance MMLU at 1,000 sequential edits under published hyperparameters, while edit success stays at 1.00 and locality reads clean. Sequential-editing evaluations that never measure capability cannot see this.

0.17

ZoAQ: Adaptive Zeroth-Order Querying via Query-Reuse Coupling

cs.LG ·2026-08-19 ·Yangyang Feng, Yao Shu
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 40 pages, 13 figures, and 19 tables

Zeroth-order optimization (ZOO) estimates updates from function evaluations, making perturbation queries a primary cost. Fixed budgets spend the same number of queries at every step, while adaptive controllers may offset their savings by using additional oracle calls to test estimator reliability. We introduce ZoAQ, an adaptive ZOO method built around query reuse. Rather than discarding past evaluations after each step, ZoAQ makes them useful for both the next update and the decision to query further. This enables adaptive query allocation without extra validation queries. Our analysis characterizes when this agreement identifies an update that supports descent and guides the controller to a sufficient query budget. On synthetic objectives, ZoAQ reduces queries by 43-48% relative to fixed baselines using 1.2M queries. In black-box attacks, it reaches 100% success with 320 and 625 average queries on MNIST and CIFAR-10, respectively. Across four OPT fine-tuning settings, ZoAQ saves 43-46% forward evaluations relative to fixed K=4, with accuracy changes within tasks ranging from -0.018 to +0.010.

0.51

DynEdit: Dynamic Entropy-Guided Sequential Editing for Large Language Models

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-26 ·Jinhu Fu, Yan Bai, Yihang Lou, Li Sun, Jiahong Wu +2 more
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted by main conference of NeurIPS 2026 (poster)

Knowledge editing aims to update outdated or incorrect knowledge in large language models without full retraining. Existing parameter-editing methods remain limited for long-sequence knowledge: single-point editors provide insufficient coverage for extended targets, while fixed chunk-based editors distribute editing effort uniformly across rigid predefined windows, failing to prioritize difficult, information-dense tokens. In this work, we show that token entropy is closely associated with both editing difficulty and semantic importance: high-entropy regions are harder to edit and often contain key factual content. Motivated by this observation, we propose DynEdit, a dynamic framework for long-sequence knowledge editing. DynEdit uses token-level entropy to guide non-uniform sliding, increasing the coverage of difficult high-entropy regions, and further applies entropy-guided token-level optimization to strengthen updates on information-dense tokens within each editing window. Experiments on three benchmarks and two backbone models show that DynEdit consistently outperforms competitive baselines across diverse long-form editing settings, achieving gains of up to +14.0 BLEU points on challenging paraphrase queries and near-saturated semantic scores on several diverse knowledge domains.

0.19