CS Paper Radar

Unsaid, Unsafe? Implicit Security Obligations in LLM-Based RTL Code Generation

Guang Yang, Xing Hu, Xiang Chen, Xin Xia

cs.CR cs.SE ·submitted 2026-08-27 03:59 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) generate register-transfer-level (RTL) code with rapidly improving functional correctness. Security of LLM-generated code, however, has been studied mainly for software, where flaws can still be patched after deployment. Insecure RTL offers no such remedy once taped out into silicon. We construct SECRTL-GEN, a multi-language resource-access security benchmark grounded in real SoC IP: 392 tasks over five CWE families and four HDLs (Verilog, SystemVerilog, VHDL, and Python), each with black-box functional and security testbenches. Functional specifications intentionally omit security obligations, matching how obligations are often kept out of functional docs in practice. An empirical study of five frontier LLMs shows a sharp gap: under vanilla prompts they pass functional tests in about 73-79% of cases but security tests in only 14-35%, and stronger functional models are not safer. Adding CWE knowledge raises security, while unaided self-thinking helps less and both security-oriented prompts cut functional pass rates, showing that the bottleneck is missing weakness awareness in the specification, not an inability to write defensive RTL. We present RTL-Obliger, a neuro-symbolic framework that infers these implicit obligations. An LLM extracts a functional-semantic graph from the specification; a symbolic engine then matches it against a CWE pattern ontology to surface mitigation-evidence gaps and signal-level obligations; the LLM finally revises RTL under those obligations in a functionality-preserving two-stage generation. Across five models and four languages, RTL-Obliger raises mean all-pass from 49.6-51.4% (SecV/RESCUE) to 61.6%, with higher security and functional rates than these secure-generation baselines.

Comment
Under Review

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Newer and Bigger, but Safer? A Longitudinal Study of the Functionality-Security Gap in LLM-Generated Code

cs.SE cs.CR ·2026-10-06 ·Thiago Santos de Moura, Fynn Matuschek, Flavio Toffalini, Yannic Noller
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used to generate code. Although their functional plausibility keeps improving, the generated code often contains security vulnerabilities. The functionality-security gap captures code that passes functional tests but fails security tests. A recent longitudinal study of three model families concluded that LLMs become smarter but not safer, with the only considered open-weight family stagnating. Whether this holds for other (open-weight) families and particularly for compact models remains open. We present a longitudinal study of the gap across 32 LLMs from seven model families (five open-weight), covering three successive releases per family in flagship and compact variants. Using CWEval with 119 tasks in five programming languages and 31 CWEs, we compare trajectories across families, model sizes, and languages. Newer models do become safer in absolute terms, although no family closes the gap. Unlike prior work, we find that openness does not separate the families: every considered open-weight family narrows the gap significantly, while Gemini 3.1 Pro keeps a gap as wide as the one reported for Llama. Compact models usually produce less secure code than their flagship counterparts, with notable exceptions (e.g., Gemini 3.7 Flash). At the CWE level, we confirm persistent weaknesses such as log injection (CWE-117) and HTTP response splitting (CWE-113) and regressions in the newest proprietary models on memory and integer weaknesses, and show that the same CWE carries very different risk across languages. From these results, we derive implications for LLM vendors, researchers, and developers. In particular, developers should assume neither that upgrades improve security nor that proprietary models are more secure; they should rerun security checks after each model change and provide secure APIs in the model's context.

0.19

Secure and Functional Code Generation with Self-Evaluation

cs.CR cs.MAcs.SE ·2026-10-24 ·Md Afif Al Mamun, Gias Uddin
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.71
Abstract · 18 pages, 7 figures

Large Language Models (LLMs) can generate functionally correct code that remains insecure. Security-focused fine-tuning can be expensive and is not always available, motivating inference-time approaches. Security-oriented prompting and retrieval can reduce vulnerabilities, but may also remove required behavior or apply defenses incompatible with the task. The challenge is to identify relevant security knowledge and use it to improve security without sacrificing functionality. We present SecGent, an inference-time framework that retrieves weakness context from the Common Weakness Enumeration (CWE) database and applies it to secure code generation. By connecting task specifications to relevant textual CWE records, SecGent provides task-specific security guidance without relying on retrieved vulnerable or patched code examples. Complementary functional and security tests check the resulting implementation, and their execution feedback guides repairs toward satisfying both objectives. We evaluate SecGent with four open-source LLMs and Claude Sonnet 5.5 across five programming languages on the CWEval benchmark. It achieves the highest joint functional--security success against four inference-time baselines for all five models. Across the open-weight models, mean functional-security@1 (FS@1) improves by 15.5% over RAG, with gains in both functionality and security, and by 19.8% over the strongest prompt optimizer compiled for each model. On Sonnet, FS@1 reaches 92.1%, outperforming the strongest baseline AutoGen by 4.8%. In a separate comparison, SecGent outperforms Claude Code with security-focused prompting by over 6% in FS@1. Feedback-guided repair further improves FS@1 by up to 6.7% over generation without feedback, primarily by recovering functionality while checking security.

0.33

GRADE-RTL: Evaluating LLM-Generated RTL Beyond Compilation

cs.AR cs.PL ·2026-09-21 ·Hepziba Susan, Shivaranjani G. R., Malik Imran, Muhammad Rashid, Sumathi Gokulanathan +1 more
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) can generate register-transfer-level (RTL) code from natural-language specifications, but compilation alone does not establish structural completeness, functional correctness, or implementation efficiency. This paper presents a framework for evaluating LLM-generated RTL beyond compilation, which we named GRADE-RTL. Using fixed prompts and validation settings, GRADE-RTL applies five checks, such as Port Signature, Compilation, Elaboration, Module Completeness, and Functional Equivalence against trusted reference RTL. With the help of compact metrics, we identify where candidates fail and distinguish end-to-end success from eligibility for downstream synthesis. We evaluate nine general-purpose and RTL-specialized LLMs on ten edge-relevant intellectual property designs under a budget of three generation attempts with failure-directed feedback. End-to-end success ranges from 0% to 70% across the evaluated models, with failures extending beyond compilation to hierarchy resolution, incomplete logic, and behavioral mismatch. FPGA implementation and 65 nm ASIC synthesis results further show that functionally equivalent RTL can differ substantially in resource use, timing, area, and power. A PID-controller place-and-route case study illustrates the physical-design consequences of different RTL implementations. GRADE-RTL provides a practical basis for comparing LLM-generated hardware descriptions by separating structural validity, behavioral correctness, and implementation quality.

0.45

Beyond Single-Vulnerability Evaluation: Closing the Engineering Decision Gap Between C Retrofits and Native Safety

cs.PL cs.CR ·2026-08-16 ·Andrew Laramore, Joseph Spracklen, Murtuza Jadliwala
position similarity 0.68
Abstract

While decades of research have produced numerous retrofitted memory-safety protections for C, these mechanisms are almost exclusively evaluated in isolation, targeting specific vulnerability classes. This siloed evaluation paradigm leaves practitioners without a clear understanding of the cumulative performance costs, interoperability conflicts, and protection gaps that arise when layering defenses to achieve comprehensive safety. This paper presents a new evaluation paradigm that benchmarks natively memory-safe languages like Rust and Go against compounded C retrofits. Using standardized cross-language tasks, we evaluate the performance and protection tradeoffs of state-of-the-art mechanisms when deployed in combination. Our results demonstrate that layered C defenses incur compounding and workload-dependent performance penalties, can suffer from fundamental architectural incompatibilities, and fall short of the protection scope provided by native memory-safe languages. These findings expose a critical engineering decision gap where the true cost of backporting safety to C remains hidden from practitioners. We argue for a fundamental shift in memory-safety research: moving away from isolated evaluation toward holistic, comparative frameworks that inform the high-stakes choice between retrofitting legacy codebases and migrating to modern, safe languages.

0.04

Compared to What? A Human-Anchored Security Benchmark for LLM-Generated Infrastructure-as-Code

cs.CR cs.AIcs.MAcs.SE ·2026-08-28 ·Animesh Shaw
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · 14 pages, 12 figures, 10 tables. v2 corrects the prompt characterization: v1 called the scenarios functional-only, but a majority prescribe …

Large language models increasingly author Infrastructure-as-Code (IaC), where one insecure default is provisioned straight into production. Prior evaluations report vulnerability counts for models only, and so cannot say whether models are worse than the engineers they assist. We present GenIaC-SecBench: 100 deployment scenarios across 12 model configurations from six vendors, open and closed weights, yielding 1,196 artifacts scanned by three policy engines (Checkov, Trivy, KICS) at complete coverage. Crucially we scan 634 human-authored IaC templates with the identical toolchain, giving the first size-matched human security baseline for this task. Vulnerability density is strongly inverse to artifact size (Spearman $ρ=-0.55$, $p<10^{-77}$), so unmatched comparisons measure size, not security. Size-matched, every configuration exceeds the human baseline at $3.21\times$ to $3.87\times$, and the gap widens as tasks get simpler ($4.9\times$ at one resource, $1.4\times$ at twenty or more). A majority of scenarios prescribe a security state rather than specifying function alone, so we stratify by prompt class: pooled the gap is $3.50\times$, and excluding every scenario that explicitly requests an insecure configuration still leaves all configurations above baseline ($2.4\times$ to $4.2\times$). The corpus cannot isolate unprompted default posture, and we say so. Decomposing "reasoning" into standard generation, prompted chain-of-thought, and vendor extended-thinking APIs, extended thinking beats prompted CoT ($-12.0\%$, $p=0.0013$) while prompted CoT alone is indistinguishable from standard ($-1.3\%$, n.s.); it consumes under $1\%$ of the output budget, bounding the effect. Two negative results: more deployable models are not more vulnerable ($r=0.158$, $p=0.625$), and complete-case Friedman is uncomputable here, motivating Skillings-Mack. All code and data are released.

0.52

SecReason: Vulnerability Detection and In-Stream Self-Repair for LLM Code Generation

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-10 ·Ruidong Han, Zhensu Sun, Chengyan Ma, Yuqing Niu, Zhou Yang +2 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) may introduce security vulnerabilities into generated code, which can persist into production when verification focuses on functional correctness. Existing defenses act before, during, or after generation, but none inspects the code during generation. Security prompts and retrieved security knowledge act before any code exists, constrained decoding limits token choices but cannot guide repair, and post-hoc repair must regenerate the full response. Reasoning LLMs draft code early in their streamed chain of thought, and in this pre-delivery window the code exists only inside the reasoning stream. We present SecReason, an in-stream defense that monitors this window. Dual-track incremental scanning applies security rules, checking each statement as it is emitted and tracing dataflows across the accumulated code. When a security rule fires, SecReason interrupts generation, inserts an in-stream warning, and resumes decoding, so the model repairs the draft within the same reasoning trace without regenerating the full response. On tasks where unassisted generation introduces vulnerabilities, \system raises the share of runs delivering secure and functionally correct code from below 15\% to 72.8\%--98.1\% on \tool{CWEval} and \tool{SecCodeBench}. \system consumes fewer tokens than post-hoc repair, and when security rules misfire on secure code, it limits the functional regressions from false warnings.

0.27

LMSM: LLM Security Framework Inspired by Linux Security Modules

cs.CR ·2026-08-26 ·XiuYu Zhang, Bonan Ruan, Junfeng Fang, An Zhang, Tat-Seng Chua +1 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed with layered defenses, yet malicious prompts can still bypass them. Interpretability methods can expose model-internal signals along the generation path that could inform enforcement, but these signals are not security controls by themselves. Deployments that adapt them for safety typically couple each signal to its own calibration, policy logic, and intervention code, so each new artifact creates integration work instead of strengthening a shared defense. We present Language Model Security Modules (LMSM), a security framework that adapts the separation behind Linux Security Modules (LSM) to LLM serving. In LMSM, a selected security backend exposes calibrated evidence, a versioned policy evaluates active rules over trusted per-request context, and a separate gate authorizes buffered output release. This design separates mediation correctness from policy effectiveness, and it allows backend, rule, or schedule changes without rebuilding request handling or enforcement. Our prototype shows the separation working in practice: with Hugging Face Transformers and continuously batched vLLM, the same substrate hosts artifact-backed sparse autoencoder (SAE) and transcoder deployments and task-fitted dense probes, preserves request-specific decisions under scheduler churn, and selectively enforces and composes multiple rules per request. On Qwen3-4B, LMSM-Checkpoint reduces HarmBench attack success rate from 39.20% to 3.32%, with XSTest false refusals rising from 2.40% to 4.40%, while retaining 98.14% of the throughput of a matched serving path that performs no monitoring work at 32 active sequences. LMSM gives advances in interpretability and model-internal analysis a common path to runtime enforcement.

0.22

RTLGuard: A Lightweight Teacher-Student Defense for Poisoned RTL Code Generation Models

cs.CR cs.AR ·2026-08-26 ·Mahshid Rezakhani, Kimia Azar, Hadi Kamali
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · 8 pages, 4 figures, 7 tables. Accepted at the IEEE/ACM International Conference on Computer-Aided Design (ICCAD 2026)

The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) is driving a shift toward automated register transfer level (RTL) code generation, enabling designers to translate high-level specs. into synthesizable hardware. However, this reliance on pre-trained (3rd-party) fine-tuned models may introduce critical trust issues, as the training data and adaptation process of these models are often opaque. Thus, adversaries (even model providers) may embed hidden backdoor threats during fine-tuning, allowing malicious behavior, e.g., hardware Trojans, to be triggered by seemingly benign prompts given by victim user at inference time. In this paper, we introduce RTLGuard, to mitigate such a trust issue in AI-enabled IC supply chain. Rather than prohibitive computational cost of full-parameter retraining, RTLGuard leverages a teacher-student framework designed to sanitize compromised RTL generation models by (1) fine-tuning a small-scale, "clean" teacher model on a limited set of trusted RTL data, (2) guiding the poisoned target model via a composite teacher-student objective, and (3) incorporating feature alignment and knowledge distillation to suppress malicious behaviors. Our experiments across various LLM architectures demonstrate that RTLGuard significantly reduces the Attack Success Rate (ASR) while preserving the functional correctness and synthesizability of the generated RTL code.

0.37