CS Paper Radar

Comparative Evaluation of 3D Reconstruction Methods for Immersive Visualization of Laboratory Objects

Brian De La Cruz, Aaron Y. Zhao, Maitrey Gramopadhye, Sawyer J. Lazar, Xianming Tan, Daniel Szafir, David S. Lawrence

cs.GR cs.CVcs.HC ·submitted 2026-08-27 16:05 UTC · v1
unusual

Abstract

In this study, we examined whether current 3D reconstruction methods can support the creation of realistic holographic representations of laboratory objects for educational use. In this regard, we compared four approaches: photogrammetry, a neural radiance field (NeRF)-based method, Gaussian splatting, and LiDAR. These methods were used to generate holographic models of common laboratory items and their fidelity was evaluated by graduate students. Participants assessed the models for shape, color, texture, and visual defects using a repeated-measures design. Across objects, the NeRF-based method produced the most consistently high-fidelity representations, particularly for transparent, reflective, or low-texture items that were difficult to capture with other approaches. Shape and color were generally reproduced more successfully than texture, suggesting that some visual properties remain more challenging to represent accurately in educational holograms. Beyond identifying the strengths and limitations of each reconstruction method, the study demonstrates a practical workflow for creating immersive learning objects that may support pre-laboratory preparation, spatial reasoning, and student engagement in AR/MR-based educational environments. These findings offer design-relevant insights for educators and researchers developing immersive digital learning experiences.

Comment
36 pages, 18 figures, 16 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

HoOPOE: A Holography-Optimized Perceptual ObjectivE function

cs.GR ·2026-10-12 ·Ethan Chen, Xi Peng, Alexandre Chapiro, Dario Seyb, Michael Grundmann +4 more
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.54
Abstract · To appear in SIGGRAPH ASIA 2026

Holographic devices must reconstruct an entire light field given a finite number of spatial light modulator (SLM) pixels, and must do so using scalar-wave diffraction from coherent illumination alone. As a result, computer-generated holography (CGH) often has speckling artifacts. We propose HoOPOE (Holography-Optimized Perceptual ObjectivE function), a CGH-specific, perceptually-aware loss function that hides speckles from human vision. HoOPOE is effective for CGH optimizations because it accounts for the human visual system's sensitivity to spatio-temporal frequencies and color, and its parameters are tuned to maximize its performance as a loss function for CGH. We use HoOPOE to generate holograms for mesh-derived focal stacks. We then conduct a user study to benchmark HoOPOE-generated holograms against existing loss functions. HoOPOE yields the most visually pleasing results; users prefer HoOPOE 68% of the time over the next best objective function on average.

0.37

RouteBridge: Reliability-Routed Bidirectional Distillation Between Neural Radiance Fields and 3D Gaussian Splatting

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-09-09 ·YuanHang Wang, Xin Cao
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Neural radiance fields (NeRFs) and 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) encode a scene with complementary inductive biases, but existing cross-representation distillation typically fixes one representation as teacher for the entire scene. A globally fixed teacher can propagate local reconstruction errors. We present RouteBridge, a bidirectional framework that selects the teaching direction for each ray. Its reliability estimator combines photometric residuals with representation-specific geometric evidence and routes supervision from NeRF to 3DGS, from 3DGS to NeRF, or abstains. A renderer-independent interface transfers color, opacity, and normalized depth without shared features or point correspondence. On mip-NeRF 360, the NeRF and 3DGS exports reach 28.56 and 28.77 dB, respectively. The 3DGS export improves over 3DGS by 1.56 dB and over NeRF-GS by 0.45 dB while reducing LPIPS to 0.207. On static three-view DTU, RouteBridge obtains 21.12 dB. Ablations show that both adaptive routing and geometric ray targets contribute to the improvement.

0.19

Active Inference for Slow and Fast Interaction Loops in Holographic-Type Communication

eess.SP ·2026-09-30 ·Kamran Fotovat, Kian Fotovat, Nika Hosseini, Martin Maier
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 4 pages, 4 figures, 1 table

Holographic-type communication requires a new hologram when the viewer moves beyond the display's angular viewing zone, whereas image-to-3D reconstruction takes tens of seconds per asset. We separate these operations into a slow loop that reconstructs a persistent mesh and a fast loop that renders each viewpoint from the stored mesh. The fast loop takes 0.117 s independently of camera motion, compared with 13.8-14.8 s for a full reconstruction. An active-inference controller determines when to begin reconstruction from learned user-state transitions, whether to perform a full or regional update, and how much computation to allocate based on a monocular-depth detail measure. Regional updates preserve geometry outside the edited area. In a modeled 100-event session, separating the loops reduces mean latency per event from 14.8 to 4.4 s (3.4-fold); predictive reconstruction reduces it further to 1.7-2.9 s, depending on user routine strength.

0.36

Hologram Representation via Quadratic Phase Gaussian Splatting

cs.GR cs.CVcs.LG ·2026-09-10 ·Haolong Wang, Yicheng Zhan, Kaan Akşit, Simeng Qiu
published similarity 0.51
Abstract · SIGGRAPH Asia 2026 Technical Communications

We introduce Complex-Valued Quadratic Phase Gaussian (CVQPG), a novel hologram representation method that augments each 2D Gaussian primitive with a quadratic phase profile controlled by a learnable curvature parameter. Against the planar Gaussian baseline, CVQPG improves the average PSNR of holographic reconstructions by 0.19 dB (RGB) and 0.33 dB (grayscale) at equal primitive counts, and by 0.05 dB (RGB) and 0.08 dB (grayscale) at equal parameter counts, where it still leads in all visual quality metrics. Our frequency-domain analysis shows that CVQPG better preserves the mid-to-high frequency band of natural images, where the reconstruction MSE drops by up to 11% (RGB) and 22% (grayscale), indicating that modulating primitive wavefronts is an effective and lightweight enhancement.

0.38

CTBakeGS: training-free baking of photorealistic CT volume renderings into 3D Gaussian splats

cs.CV cs.GR ·2026-10-27 ·Haruki Fukuda, Constantin Lux, Wolf Schweitzer, Tadashi Hosoya, Lars Ebert
code/data similarity 0.51
Abstract · Code and project page: https://github.com/BocchiSlice/CTBakeGS

Photorealistic volume rendering of computed tomography (CT) may convey anatomy intuitively, but it needs the CT data, dedicated software and a powerful graphics processor. Three-dimensional Gaussian splatting (3DGS) displays photorealistic scenes in real time on less powerful devices, but existing medical approaches train each scene for minutes to hours. We aimed to convert a CT volume rendering directly into a 3DGS model without training. Splats were placed on an adaptive octree of millimetre-sized cells. Their colour and opacity were computed on the graphics processor with the renderer's lighting, cell opacity was converted analytically into splat opacity, and faint splats were retained stochastically above the 1/255 opacity floor of standard 3DGS rasterisers. Six public CT scans (1.5-mm voxels) were converted with three transfer functions and compared with converged references by peak signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR), structural similarity and a learned perceptual metric. Two-million-splat models reached a PSNR of 32.6 +/- 0.9 dB for bone, 30.1 +/- 1.0 dB for contrast-enhanced vessels and 32.3 +/- 1.5 dB for skin and bone. A conversion pass (usually two or three per model) took 4-30 s on a current laptop and 9-60 s on a desktop with a 4-GB graphics card. On the laptop, the models rendered at 68 frames per second at 800 x 800 pixels. Training-free conversion produced real-time 3DGS models of photorealistic CT renderings in about a minute or less per conversion pass on ordinary computers, with fidelity that we consider sufficient for interactive viewing.

0.24

Integrating Multi-view Multi-light Surface Reconstruction into Cultural Heritage Workflows

cs.CV ·2026-09-14 ·Baptiste Brument, Robin Bruneau, Benjamin Coupry, Vincent Demoulin, Jean Mélou +4 more
top venuecode/data similarity 0.51
Abstract · 15 pages, 9 figures. Accepted at VISART VIII, ECCV 2026 workshops

Cultural heritage documentation increasingly relies on image-based 3D surface reconstruction, with photogrammetry software making such workflows accessible to archaeologists, conservators, and heritage technicians. These tools have been successful for conventional multi-view acquisition, but they do not routinely exploit richer multi-view, multi-light data, despite its potential for improving fine-scale surface reconstruction. This limitation is particularly relevant in heritage contexts, where controlled-light acquisition devices such as RTI domes are already used to capture illumination-varying image sets. The challenge is therefore to connect these existing acquisition practices with recent computer vision methods in a form that can be used within operational heritage workflows. In this work, we address this need by integrating state-of-the-art components from computer vision for multi-view, multi-light surface reconstruction into Meshroom, an open-source photogrammetry framework. Rather than proposing a new reconstruction algorithm, our contribution is to assemble and expose existing advanced methods, namely a complete photometric stereo ecosystem (calibrated, self-calibrated and universal), automatic object masking, and multi-view normal-and-reflectance integration, within a usable heritage-oriented workflow. The proposed system thus provides an intermediate software layer between computer vision research code and practical cultural heritage applications, making recent techniques easier to use and evaluate.

0.65

Directionally Factorized Illumination with Spherical Harmonic Rotation

cs.CV ·2026-10-17 ·Yimeng Dou, Adam M. Saunders, Andre T. S. Hucke, Michael E. Kim, Adam W. Anderson +3 more
similarity 0.50
Abstract · Submitted to ICRA

Many real-world capture scenarios involve an active light source rigidly attached to the camera: camera flashes for dark-environment imaging, underwater vehicle lights, and endoscopic/laparoscopic medical procedures. As the camera moves, the co-mounted light moves with it, causing the illumination direction at each surface point to change across views. Neural rendering methods (NeRF, Gaussian Splatting) encode this pose-dependent illumination as surface coloration, producing appearance inconsistencies and making it harder to recover the underlying scene. We present \textbf{DaFISH}, which can be plugged into any novel-view synthesis (NVS) pipeline such as NeRF. It factorizes per-point emitted color into surface albedo and a spherical harmonic (SH)-represented illumination factor. During training, the SH illumination is evaluated directly, enabling stable joint optimization of albedo, lighting, and geometry. \textbf{DaFISH} provides analytical generalization of illumination to arbitrary camera poses without retraining. Building on the closed-form SH-to-irradiance conversion, the training pipeline is fully differentiable from SH evaluation through volume rendering. Averaged over the held-out frames of the five scenes, \textbf{DaFISH} attains the best mean PSNR (38.91\,dB), SSIM (0.9613), and LPIPS (0.0582) among all compared methods. It improves over the strongest splatting baseline as well as the closest NeRF-based baseline, while recovering the scene consistently across views compared to prior methods.

0.16

Point-Based 3D Reconstruction from Sparse Views under Known Illumination

cs.CV ·2026-08-20 ·Magnus Kaufmann Gjerde, Joakim Bruslund Haurum, Jeppe Revall Frisvad, Markus Worchel, J. Andreas Bærentzen +1 more
similarity 0.50
Abstract

Sparse view 3D reconstruction is commonly addressed with neural implicit surfaces or dense point-based representations such as Gaussian splatting. Surface-aware splatting methods improve extracted geometry through oriented primitives and regularization, while RadiosityGS incorporates differentiable light transport through a radiosity inspired finite-element surfel formulation. We propose a differentiable point rendering method based on opacity-bearing beta surfels. An opacity explicit adjoint light transport formulation provides gradients for surfel geometry and appearance parameters, allowing physically based light transport to constrain reconstruction. Across five synthetic objects reconstructed from ten posed views, our method achieves the lowest mean symmetric Chamfer distance among the evaluated baselines and reduces mean Chamfer distance by 28.5% relative to the strongest point-based baseline while using only 267 surfels on average, approximately ~161 fewer primitives. Directional Chamfer results further show improved accuracy and competitive completion relative to related point-based methods. These results show that, in the controlled direct illumination setting, compact beta surfels combined with transport-based optimization can recover surfaces without relying on the tens to hundreds of thousands of primitives used by the evaluated baselines.

0.24