CS Paper Radar

Universality and sharp thresholds for ellipsoid fitting

Frederic Koehler, Youngtak Sohn

cs.DS math.PRcond-mat.dis-nncs.LGmath.ST ·submitted 2026-08-27 17:09 UTC · v1

Abstract

We establish a sharp phase transition for fitting random vectors by an ellipsoid. The random vectors have independent subgaussian coordinates with mean zero, variance one, and a common fourth moment, and the number of vectors is proportional to the square of the dimension. We identify an explicit satisfiability threshold such that, with high probability, a positive definite ellipsoid passes through every data point below the threshold, whereas no positive semidefinite fit exists above it. We also determine the optimal squared fitting error throughout the unsatisfiable regime. In particular, the threshold depends on the coordinate distributions only through their common fourth moment, revealing a fourth moment universality phenomenon. For standard Gaussian data the threshold is $1/4$, resolving the ellipsoid fitting conjecture.

Comment
79 pages, 4 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Spectral Distribution of Matrix Least Squares Solutions, and the Ellipsoid Fitting Problem

cs.DS math.PRmath.STstat.ML ·2026-11-17 ·Afonso S. Bandeira, Yue M. Lu, Petar Nizić-Nikolac
similarity 0.71
Abstract · 40 pages

We study the spectral distribution of the least squares solution to a random linear system whose unknown is a symmetric matrix. In the normalized and isotropic setting, we derive a closed-form description of the support of the spectral distribution. As an application, we consider the ellipsoid fitting problem: given $n$ standard Gaussian vectors in $\mathbb{R}^d$, does there exist a centered ellipsoid passing through all of them? It was recently shown that this problem has a sharp phase transition at $n \approx d^2/4$. On the satisfiability side, unlike earlier results, these sharp results do not rely on least squares candidates. We show that the least squares candidates considered in earlier works have a threshold of positive semi-definiteness at $n \approx d^2/10$, which was previously observed numerically and predicted non-rigorously using statistical physics methods. Moreover, we show that the corresponding least squares dual certificates have a threshold of positive definiteness at $n \approx 2d^2/5$. Our approach combines several matrix concentration tools. A key technical ingredient, which may be of independent interest, is showing that a certain kernel matrix is well-conditioned with high probability until $n \approx d^2/2$.

0.39

The sharp SAT/UNSAT phase transition in random ellipsoid fitting

cs.DS math.PRcond-mat.dis-nnmath.ST+1 ·2026-08-10 ·Theodor Misiakiewicz, Garrett G. Wen
theory similarity 0.69
Abstract

Let $x_1,\ldots,x_n$ be independent standard Gaussian vectors in $\mathbb{R}^d$. An \emph{ellipsoid fit} is a matrix $S \succeq 0$ such that $x_i^\top S x_i =d$ for every $i$, so that all the points lie on the boundary of the centered ellipsoid $\{ x : x^\top S x = d\}$. Saunderson, Parrilo and Willsky conjectured that, as $n,d \to \infty$, this semidefinite feasibility problem undergoes a sharp transition at $n \sim d^2/4$. We prove this conjecture. If $\lim \sup n/d^2 = α^* <1/4$, then, with probability tending to one, an ellipsoid fit exists; moreover, one can choose $S$ with all eigenvalues in a fixed interval $[λ_- , λ_+] \subset (0,\infty)$ depending only on $α^*$. Conversely, if $\lim \inf n/d^2 > 1/4$, then, with probability tending to one, no ellipsoid fit exists, without any spectral restriction. Our proof builds on the Gaussian-equivalence framework developed by Bandeira and Maillard (2025) and closes the two gaps left open in their work: establishing exact fitting and removing the operator-norm constraint. On the satisfiable side, the new ingredients are a head-tail decomposition of the dual vector, exact correction of the sparse head constraints, and a Gaussian comparison principle for the low-influence tail. On the unsatisfiable side, we split a candidate into a low-rank spectral head and a Schatten-3 diffuse bulk, Gaussianize the bulk conditionally on the head, and apply a projected Gordon escape argument. The threshold is governed by the statistical dimension $d(d+1)/4$ of the positive semidefinite cone.

0.32

Phase Transitions in Heavy-Tailed Mean Estimation under $\ell_p$ Norms

cs.LG math.ST ·2026-11-15 ·Ishaq Aden-Ali, Yeshwanth Cherapanamjeri, Mikael Møller Høgsgaard, Kasper Green Larsen, Nikita Zhivotovskiy
top venuebenchmarktheory similarity 0.56
Abstract · Accepted at NeurIPS 2026

We study the problem of estimating the mean of a random vector in $\mathbb R^d$ under $\ell_p$ norms, assuming only the existence of a covariance matrix. In the Euclidean norm, the sample mean is already optimal in expectation, and robust estimators are usually needed only to obtain high-probability tails. Our results show that this picture changes for $\ell_p$ norms with $p>2$: robustification is already necessary even for the expected risk. We prove that the minimax risk exhibits a sharp phase transition, controlled by the interaction between the sample size $n$, the dimension $d$, and the norm parameter $p$. In the large-sample regime, the classical Gaussian rate remains achievable. In the complementary regime, heavy-tailed distributions create a genuinely non-Gaussian obstruction. Furthermore we show that the simple estimator: coordinate-wise median of means whose number of buckets chosen according to the geometry of the loss, optimally tracks this phase transition in its expected risk minimax. We also show that natural projection-based median-of-means estimators for general norms, despite achieving the optimal confidence trade-off relative to the sample-mean benchmark of Lugosi and Mendelson (Probab. Theory Relat. Fields, 2019), can be polynomially suboptimal for $\ell_p$ norms even in the constant-probability regime.

0.31

Restricted Eigenvalues Beyond Gaussian Width: Threshold Occupancy under Heavy Tails

cs.LG ·2026-09-03 ·Shi Fu, Huibo Xu, Qixin Zhang, Dacheng Tao
benchmark similarity 0.54
Abstract

Restricted eigenvalue (RE) bounds govern stable recovery by norm-regularized estimators. For isotropic sub-Gaussian measurements, the benchmark sample size is $1+w(A)^2$, where $w(A)$ is the Gaussian width of the normalized descent cone. The COLT 2015 open-problem note (Banerjee et al., 2015) asked whether the same law follows for heavy-tailed designs from a uniform small-ball condition alone. We give an explicit and systematic negative answer to the general question as formulated there: the proposed law fails in its full dimension-free, arbitrary-set form, and the missing obstruction is simultaneous threshold occupancy. A constant-width polyhedral descent cone with fixed small-ball constants has zero empirical RE on every sample path up to half the ambient dimension. More generally, every finite range space admits exact threshold encoding in an arbitrarily narrow spherical cap and a lift to a full polyhedral descent-cone section. For every fixed threshold VC dimension $d$, as $β\downarrow0$, the sharp worst-case sample complexity is $Θ(β^{-1}[d\log(1/β)+\log(1/δ)])$. The separation persists under exact isotropy and all finite moments: on the same constant-width cone, Gaussian measurements succeed with $O(1+\log(1/δ))$ samples, whereas an isotropic heavy-tailed design fails pathwise for $n\lesssim\sqrt{p/\log p}$. Gaussian smoothing yields an everywhere-positive $C^\infty$ density while retaining arbitrarily poor RE. Under isotropy, a distribution-free fallback governed by affine dimension times squared enclosing radius is sharp on this family.

0.27

Exact Limits of Random Projections for Preserving Geometry: Distance Recovery, Nearest-Neighbor Rankings, and Covariance Shape in Gaussian Models

cs.LG cs.ITmath.NAmath.PR+1 ·2026-09-02 ·Piyush Sao
code/data similarity 0.53
Abstract · 41 pages, 6 figures, 4 tables. Reproducibility code: https://github.com/piyush314/random-projection-geometry (pinned as a submodule). Compan…

The Johnson-Lindenstrauss (JL) lemma guarantees that a random projection of $n$ points to $m=O(\varepsilon^{-2}\log n)$ dimensions preserves pairwise squared distances within relative error $\varepsilon$ with high probability, and this dimension order is asymptotically optimal. In high dimensions, however, distances concentrate around a baseline while key geometric information lies in much smaller fluctuations. We show that the JL bound can therefore be uninformative about retained geometry: an independent Gaussian replacement map can satisfy it even though the replacement cloud is independent of the original data. We then ask how well any decoder can recover a feature $f(D)$ of a squared distance $D$ from a linear sketch. Under squared-error loss, the optimal decoder is conditional expectation, so recovery defines a linear operator whose singular values quantify feature recovery. For isotropic Gaussian data ($Σ=σ^2 I_d$), we diagonalize this operator in closed form. For fixed $k$ with $m,d-m\to\infty$, its $k$th singular value satisfies $\ell_k\approx(m/ d)^{k/2}$. This yields three sharp consequences. A rank-$m$ sketch retains at most an $m/d$ fraction of the variance of any feature of one squared distance. If $m\to\infty$ and $m/d\to0$, the expected Kendall correlation is $\frac{2}π\sqrt{m/d}(1+o(1))$; for fixed $q$, nearest- neighbor agreement tends to $1/q$. Yet one projection can satisfy the JL bound while mean Kendall correlation vanishes when $\log n\ll m\ll d$. After removing scale, Haar-averaged retained covariance-shape information is $(m/d)^2$. Thus JL distance preservation does not quantify the geometry available for comparison or inference.

0.38

Ellipsoids from Tangents

cs.CV cs.CG ·2026-10-11 ·Efrat Dahan, Michael Werman
unusual similarity 0.53
Abstract · 8 pages, 7 figures. Written in 2016; posted in 2026 with revised exposition. Results unchanged

This paper presents an algorithm for detecting and fitting multiple ellipsoids in 2D, 3D and higher-dimensional data. The representation is based on tangents to the ellipsoid together with their contact points, rather than on points alone. A tangent contributes d independent equations where a point contributes one, so each hypothesis needs fewer samples, which in turn reduces the number of iterations required to recover every ellipsoid. The problem is posed as sets of linear equations whose solutions -- the ellipsoid parameters -- are recovered robustly by clustering in parameter space. The algorithm works in all dimensions and outperforms the state of the art in 2D. The approach applies in general to the robust solution of linear equations, and so has utility beyond ellipsoid fitting.

0.27

Improving the Constant in the Aharonov--Regev Theorem

cs.CC ·2026-10-07 ·Shuhong Gao
theory similarity 0.53
Abstract

The Aharonov-Regev proof that $\mathrm{GapCVP}_{c\sqrt n}$ lies in $\mathsf{NP}\cap \mathsf{coNP}$ uses a verifier that tests dual lattice vectors; its proof gives $c=100$. We study this verifier through a linear program in which a certificate is modeled as a sample from a probability distribution on the dual lattice. This viewpoint gives an exact analysis of the close-target tests: adding gradient and Hessian checks increases the certified close radius from $σ^{-1}/4$ to $σ^{-1}\sqrt{3/16}$, and higher derivatives cannot improve it within this framework. With Gaussian certificates for far targets, we obtain $$\mathrm{GapCVP}_{c\sqrt n},\ \mathrm{GapSVP}_{c\sqrt n}\in \mathsf{NP} \cap\mathsf{coNP}$$ for every $c>2/(π\sqrt3)\approx0.3676$. An appendix gives a finite-bit implementation of the verifier. We also show that the Gaussian certificate is not always optimal and solve the unbounded-support program exactly for targets of order two, where its value is determined by the spectral capacity of an odd dual coset.

0.21

Improved Private Sparse Covariance Estimation with Multiscale Threshold Tests

cs.LG ·2026-09-19 ·Zihan Zhang
theory similarity 0.53
Abstract

We study differentially private covariance estimation in operator norm for mean-zero sub-Gaussian distributions with unknown covariance support and at most $k$ nonzero entries per row. We develop a multiscale random-threshold algorithm with sample complexity $\ot(k^2/α^2+k\sqrt d/(α\varepsilon))$ for $(\varepsilon,δ)$-differential privacy and error at most $ασ^2$, where $d$ is the dimension and $σ$ is a known sub-Gaussian scale. The bound improves the privacy-dependent term of the existing $\ot(k^2/α^2+k^{3/2}\sqrt d/(α\varepsilon))$ \citep{kumar2026curse} upper bound by a factor of $\sqrt k$, and matches the lower bound of $\widetildeΩ(k^2/α^2 + k\sqrt{d}/(α\varepsilon))$ in its applicable parameter regime. Our key technical ingredient is a direct operator-norm bound on the centered fluctuations of an ideal reconstruction, exploiting conditional independence rather than accumulating entrywise errors across each row. A multiscale allocation of threshold tests balances reconstruction variance against query sensitivity. Together, these ingredients sharpen the trade-off between approximation error and privacy protection, removing the additional $\sqrt{k}$ factor from the privacy-dependent sample complexity.

0.31