CS Paper Radar

Beyond F1: Evaluating Coverage and Failure Recovery in AI Model Security Scanners

Qianlong Lan, Vinothini Pandurangan, Anuj Kaul, Indranil Sanyal

cs.CR cs.AI ·submitted 2026-08-27 17:49 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Static scanners are increasingly used to identify executable or otherwise unsafe content in machine- learning artifacts, yet conventional evaluation metrics characterize only cases where a scanner yields a usable security judgment. We evaluate ModelScan, ModelAudit, and Fickling using a controlled, artifact-backed benchmark on a synthetic corpus of 170 Pickle and PyTorch focused artifacts across 145 specimen families, 135 of which have binary security ground truth and 10 of which are intentionally malformed without labels. We explicitly distinguish non-N/A coverage, analysis completion, definitive security decisions, non-security findings, and unsupported outcomes. On labeled families, ModelAudit produced definitive security decisions for all 135 families (100%), Fickling for 110 (81.5%), and ModelScan for 67 (49.6%). Conditional on making a definitive judgment, ModelScan achieved 100% precision, recall, and F1. Fickling identified no unique true- positive families beyond those found by the combination of ModelAudit and ModelScan. Furthermore, for the 48 malicious families where ModelScan failed to complete its analysis, both ModelAudit and Fickling generated detections consistent with ground truth. These findings underscore the need to separate judgment accuracy from judgment availability, as well as incremental detection coverage from tool-level redundancy.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

MaliciousSkillBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Malicious Agent Skill Detection

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-20 ·Yue Wang, Yi Liu, Gelei Deng, Ying Zhang, Yuekang Li +2 more
benchmarkcode/datahighly cited similarity 0.67
Abstract · Project page: https://protectskills.github.io/MaliciousSkillBench/

Agent Skills extend LLM agents with reusable instruction packages that may also include scripts, resources, and service configuration. This creates a direct distribution channel for malicious behavior, yet existing malicious-Skill datasets are fragmented across sources, artifact formats, evidence regimes, and benign coverage; duplicated and structurally related content further complicates direct aggregation and evaluation. We present MaliciousSkillBench, a comprehensive benchmark for malicious Agent Skill detection. We consolidate 13 public sources, 11 of which contribute Core malicious artifacts, and reduce 8,414 raw malicious records to 7,539 normalized-unique identities in 4,588 operational structural families. After conservative cross-label conflict exclusion, the primary benchmark contains 9,740 Skills: 7,505 malicious and 2,235 benign. To characterize its coverage, we harmonize 11 attack categories for 4,983 malicious identities with supported source-native mappings and find substantial differences in threat composition across sources. We then evaluate three learned text detectors and three off-the-shelf Skill scanners. Learned detectors achieve 0.882-0.932 Random Macro-F1 but only 0.653-0.665 under Source-Disjoint evaluation; the strongest word TF-IDF SVM scores 0.932/0.916/0.665 on Random/structural-disjoint/Source-Disjoint while retaining 95.6% malicious recall but producing 62.4% benign FPR on held-out sources. Off-the-shelf scanners occupy different but also unsatisfactory operating regimes, reducing false positives only at the cost of sharply lower malicious recall. Together, these results show that reliable malicious-Skill detection requires both broader cross-source benchmark coverage and evaluation that jointly measures attack detection and benign over-flagging.

0.49

SkillScreen: High-Recall Screening of Malicious Agent Skills with Decision Models

cs.CR cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-10-13 ·Jerrold Huang, Junwei Quan, Saiyue Lyu, Zihan Guo, Yingqiang Ge
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · 21 pages, including references and appendices

Agent skills turn natural-language instructions into actions, creating a security challenge: legitimate automation and malicious behaviour can look deceptively similar. A practical screen must catch nearly every attack while keeping the review load manageable. We present SkillScreen, a compact decision model trained to score skill maliciousness directly from SKILL$.$md in a single forward pass. On MaliciousSkillBench, SkillScreen flags 20-25% of benign skills at 99% recall on unseen attack families, substantially fewer than the word-level classifier and prompted LLM judges tested. Under the same training protocol, it also generalizes better than a fully fine-tuned encoder to unseen sources. Yet unfamiliar benign sources sharply increase false positives, showing that recognizing new attacks does not ensure reliable screening of new skill collections. Our results demonstrate the value of task-trained decision models for high-recall skill screening. Project page: https://jerroldh.github.io/SkillScreen-webpage/

0.48

EGAMA-RC: Risk-Calibrated Evidence-Gated Adaptive Malware Analysis for Robust and Interpretable Memory-Forensic Triage

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-08-24 ·Isaac Kofi Nti
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Machine-learning malware detectors often achieve high clean-data accuracy, but operational triage also requires evidence about uncertainty, novelty, robustness, interpretability, latency, and review cost. This paper presents EGAMA-RC, a risk-calibrated evidence-gated framework for memory-forensic malware triage. Building on SHAP-guided feature refinement, EGAMA-RC combines dataset-specific refinement, model-pool evaluation, adversarial and open-family testing, novelty scoring, explanation-conditioned evidence, and runtime-aware routing. Low-risk samples are accepted automatically, while uncertain, high-risk, or potentially novel cases are routed to review, escalation, or novelty-aware handling. Across three malware datasets and a frozen multi-seed protocol, the selected hybrid gate accepts 93.12% of pooled samples with 99.86% accepted accuracy and a 0.136% false-accept rate. Novelty calibration reduces over-restrictive review behavior while preserving a low unsafe-accept profile. XGBoost provides lightweight fast-path inference with p50/p95 latency of 0.0054/0.0059 ms per sample. The results show that dependable malware analysis requires risk-calibrated routing, novelty awareness, and controlled analyst review, not classification accuracy alone.

0.19

Activation Probes Surface Code-Security Signals that the Model's Output Misses

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-08-10 ·Ivan Wiryadi
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · 6 pages, 1 figure. Accepted at the TAIGR workshop, ICML 2026

AI coding agents now write a growing share of production code, and human security review does not scale at the rate code is generated. The agents in widest use are closed-weight, so a deploying team cannot read their internals. It can instead run an open-weight model as a reviewer over the agent's output. That reviewer's activations are readable. We ask whether reading those activations recovers a security signal that simply asking the same reviewer misses. We fit a single linear probe per model on a corpus of paired vulnerable-and-fixed Python functions, then test it without retraining on real disclosed vulnerabilities whose weakness type the probe never saw in training, across five open-weight reviewer models. On the vulnerabilities fixed by changing a single function, the probe scores the vulnerable function above its fix on 61-67% of cases for every model, beating the 50% chance line. It also beats the same model's prompted YES/NO win-rate read from its logits, under every prompt we try. Asking the model for a written verdict, even with chain-of-thought, returns the same answer on the vulnerable and fixed function most of the time and so cannot tell them apart. Model activations carry a code-security signal that prompting the same model misses.

0.23

From Guidelines to Practice: Defining Requirements for AI Red-Teaming Tools

cs.CY ·2026-11-03 ·Gia Phong Tran, Thai Duong Huynh, Randolph Loh, Balachandar Gowrisankar, Zihao Wang +4 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has seen significant developments and increased usage in recent years. AI benefits various tasks, automates decision-making, and enhances efficiency. However, AI also introduces additional attack surfaces for threat actors to perform attacks like prompt injection and jailbreaking, making security a great concern. AI security testing aims to imitate adversarial attacks or malicious inputs via manual testing or with the assistance of tools. Thus, it is critical that organizations are aware of the capabilities and limitations of the tools before using them. Existing studies provide insights on the overall architecture of AI security testing tools and raise concerns on their reliability, but their analysis is limited to attack performance. Selection of a tool for AI risk assessments should also depend on their alignment with the recommendations of industry standards, but to our knowledge, previous studies have not utilized such guidelines. To bridge this gap, we analyze several industry standards and guidelines to identify the requirements of AI testing tools. We discuss and highlight desirable features across various AI security testing tools for a variety of different AI systems. We evaluated six tools across six Large Language Models, reported on our insights, and identified gaps that should be considered by future tools.

0.14

When AI Investigators Cannot Trust Their Tools: Conflict-Aware Evidence Verification for Cyber Threat Investigation

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-10-30 ·Yuchen Zhang
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at WAITI 2026 (3rd Workshop on AI for Cyber Threat Intelligence), co-located with ACSAC 2026

LLM agents increasingly triage security alerts by combining the outputs of several detection tools, implicitly treating those tools as trustworthy. Unlike prior work on conflicts between a model's knowledge and its context, we study conflicts among the tools themselves: what happens when this machine-generated evidence is conflicting or wrong. On the corrected CIC-IDS2017 dataset, four heterogeneous detectors emit labels and confidences that we corrupt under a threat model varying the number of corrupted tools, the persistence of the corruption, and the confidence attached to wrong outputs. Across open-weight LLMs from 3B to 14B parameters, unverified investigators are fragile: one corrupted detector out of four lowers naive accuracy to .50-.72, three lower every unverified investigator to .13 or less, and honest disagreement alone makes them abstain on up to 63% of flows. We propose Conflict-Aware Evidence Verification (CAV), built from established components: an equal-weight vote that ignores reported confidences, an evidence-conflict gate, and an independent nearest-neighbour trust check that tests the leading candidates. With its prompt frozen before testing, CAV-LLM improves on the naive investigator in every corrupted condition ($p < 0.001$), reaching .84-.88 with three corrupted detectors against at most .08, while calling the LLM on 0.4% of clean traffic. A fixed verification rule is as accurate or better unless most tools are corrupted. When we make the independent channel itself noisy, CAV inherits its errors: it stays ahead when two or more tools are corrupted, but adding the channel as an extra voter is better when at most one is. Verification thus moves trust from the tools to the check, which must be measured and protected in turn.

0.20

Evaluating System One Models for Agent Security Decisions: Reliability, Calibration, and Selective Automation

cs.CR cs.AIcs.SE ·2026-09-27 ·Yixuan Liu
highly cited similarity 0.65
Abstract

Agentic software connects language models to tools that modify files and interact with external services. Developers use model-based security checks to screen external content and user requests before agents act. System One models answer developer-defined questions with probabilities over predefined answers such as safe or unsafe, but classification accuracy alone does not establish whether these probabilities support reliable automation. We evaluate Jev, Laya, Decider, and Bespoke Nimble against specialized classifiers and language-model judges across prompt-injection detection, interaction-risk judgment, and harmful-request screening, examining decision accuracy, calibration, and selective automation. (1) High overall accuracy and low average calibration error can conceal attacks classified as safe with high confidence within particular groups. Developers should test candidate models on the intended security task and examine errors within relevant attack groups. (2) Policies selected under strict miss limits allow few test inputs automatically, and choosing allow and block thresholds separately increases automation mainly through additional blocks. Developers should verify limits on missed unsafe inputs and blocked benign inputs on independent data, and report the allowed and blocked fractions separately. (3) Comparing predictions on the same inputs shows that a language-model judge can detect unsafe inputs missed by a System One model, but can also repeat the System One model's confident mistakes and falsely flag benign inputs. Developers should test which missed unsafe inputs their review rule forwards, then measure the review model's misses and benign false alarms on those inputs.

0.44

DITTO: A Context-aware Pickle-based Pre-Trained Model Scanner for Effective Security Audits

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-07 ·Qiaolin Qin, Wanpeng Li, Benoit Baudry, Lorenzo De Carli, Heng Li +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract

Pre-trained models (PTMs) are widely distributed as serialized binaries, but their reuse often exposes software supply chains to deserialization attacks. Despite the emergence of safer serialization formats, the unsafe Pickle format remains prevalent: our analysis of over 10,000 popular Hugging Face repositories reveals that 9.3% rely on Pickle. While many defense mechanisms have been proposed, state-of-the-art model scanners suffer from a coverage-precision gap, missing security-sensitive behaviors and generating excessive false alerts. In this paper, we introduce DITTO, the first stack-based, context-aware scanner for Pickle-based PTMs. DITTO faithfully tracks Pickle virtual machine state transitions and performs context-aware semantic analysis to infer model intentions. We also present PickleBench, a benchmark of 959 benign and 92 malicious real-world models, including extension registry attacks previously missed by existing tools. Across multiple evaluations, DITTO achieves 100% scanning coverage, a 0% false-negative rate, and a 0.7% false-positive rate, yielding an F1 score of 0.966, significantly outperforming state-of-the-art scanners. By minimizing false alerts while preserving detection accuracy, DITTO generates actionable security reports with contextual evidence, enabling safe PTM reuse and strengthening software supply chain integrity.

0.29