CS Paper Radar

Beyond the Bethe Approximation of the Permanent

Nima Anari

cs.DS math.CO ·submitted 2026-08-28 07:47 UTC · v2
theorycode/data

Abstract

The canonical Bethe approximation gives a deterministic approximation to the permanent of every nonnegative matrix within a factor of $(\sqrt{2})^n$. We improve the base of this exponential factor: for some absolute constant $c<\sqrt{2}$, there is a deterministic polynomial-time $c^n$-approximation for the permanent of every nonnegative matrix. This shows that the canonical Bethe guarantee is not a barrier for deterministic approximation of the permanent. The proof augments the Bethe lower bound with a new certificate tailored to matrices on which that lower bound loses nearly the full factor. The author supplied the high-level plan of attack, and the proof was developed in an interaction with ChatGPT 5.6 Sol Pro. The author subsequently verified the results. Codex assisted with proof checking, manuscript assembly, and typesetting.

Comment
34 pages. Accompanying Lean 4 formalization: https://github.com/nimaanari/formalization-beyond-bethe. Palomar Registry entry: https://palomar-registry.org/entry?id=PALOMAR-2026-08-29-000006&version=1

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Structural Corrections to the Bethe Approximation of the Permanent

cs.DS math.CO ·2026-08-31 ·Ijay Narang, Will Perkins
hot direction similarity 0.80
Abstract

We study deterministic approximation algorithms for the permanent of a nonnegative matrix through the Bethe permanent, an approximation computable in polynomial time. The tight analysis of Anari and Rezaei gives a universal comparison between the permanent and the Bethe permanent within a factor $(\sqrt 2)^n$. The simple example of the unweighted $4$-cycle $C_4$ (or a union of disjoint $C_4$'s) shows that this bound is tight. We show that such $4$-cycle obstructions can be identified and exploited algorithmically. Given a Bethe optimizer, our algorithm identifies nearly isolated weighted $2\times2$ blocks and peels off a vertex-disjoint family of them. If the total weighted correction is large, we can improve the Bethe approximation; if it is small, we show that the Bethe permanent is within a factor of $(\sqrt2 - \varepsilon)^n$ of the truth. Combining these facts, we obtain a deterministic polynomial time $(\sqrt2-\varepsilon)^n$-approximation algorithm for the permanent of an arbitrary nonnegative $n\times n$ matrix, where $\varepsilon>0$ is some absolute constant.

0.45

Optimal girth-dependent bounds for the Bethe approximation of the permanent

cs.DS math.CO ·2026-09-02 ·Dingding Dong, Vishesh Jain
theoryhot direction similarity 0.69
Abstract · 21 pages; comments welcome!

For an $n\times n$ nonnegative matrix $A$, the Bethe permanent, which is computable in deterministic polynomial time, satisfies the tight universal comparison \[\operatorname{Bethe}(A) \leq \operatorname{per}(A) \leq 2^{n/2}\operatorname{Bethe}(A).\] The lower bound, due to Gurvits, is attained on forests. The upper bound, due to Anari and Rezaei, is attained by the adjacency matrix of a disjoint union of $4$-cycles. Confirming a conjecture of Anari, we provide an optimal girth-dependent refinement of the above comparison. More precisely, we show that if the bipartite support graph of $A$ has girth at least an even integer $g \geq 4$, then \[\operatorname{Bethe}(A) \leq \operatorname{per}(A) \leq 2^{2n/g}\operatorname{Bethe}(A).\] The upper bound is attained by the adjacency matrix of a disjoint union of $g$-cycles.

0.47

Subexponential Approximation of the Permanent in Deterministic Polynomial Time

cs.DS cs.CCmath.CO ·2026-09-09 ·Sergei Kudria, Jason Luo, Mahbod Majid
theory similarity 0.68
Abstract · 44 pages

We give the first deterministic polynomial time algorithm that approximates the permanent of arbitrary nonnegative rational matrices within a subexponential factor. For a matrix of order $n$, the approximation factor is \[ \exp\!\left(O\!\left(\frac{n(\log\log n)^2}{\log n}\right)\right)=\exp(o(n)). \] All previously known deterministic polynomial time guarantees for unrestricted inputs had approximation factors $\exp(Ω(n))$. Our proof uses convex optimization to tighten an upper bound on the permanent. The bound is based on weighted sums over all matchings in a bipartite graph representing the matrix, and correlations between unmatched vertices control its error. We approximate these sums deterministically using correlation decay and a bound on the effect of vertex deletion.

0.45

An $\widetilde{O}(n^3)$-time FPRAS for the Permanent

cs.DS cs.DMmath.COmath.PR ·2026-09-17 ·Xiaoyu Chen, Heng Guo, Eric Vigoda, Xiongxin Yang
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 62 pages

We give an FPRAS for the permanent of an $n\times n$ $0/1$ matrix with running time $\widetilde O(n^3)$. Our algorithm extends to a strongly polynomial FPRAS for arbitrary nonnegative matrices with the same running-time bound (but in the unit-cost arithmetic model). Jerrum, Sinclair, and Vigoda (2004) gave the first FPRAS for the permanent of a nonnegative matrix. The running time was subsequently improved to $\widetilde{O}(n^7)$ by Bezáková, Štefankovič, Vazirani, and Vigoda (2008), and recently to $\widetilde{O}(n^6)$ by Chen, Vigoda, and Yang (2026). We introduce a multicommodity-flow bound inspired by electrical flows, replacing the usual path-length factor by routing energy. For the classical JSV chain with perfect-matching weights multiplied by $n^2$, we prove a relaxation-time bound of $O(n^3\log n)$ and obtain comparable bounds for estimating the stationary probabilities of having a specified pair of unmatched vertices. We use a separate chain on assignments to generate a warm start at any given temperature, avoiding the long initialization of the JSV chain. Finally, we replace the JSV chain with a new chain that uses only $n$ hole weights and speeds up hole-weight learning by a factor of $n$.

0.20

A deterministic $(1+\varepsilon)^n$ approximation for the permanent of a nonnegative matrix

cs.DS math.CO ·2026-09-10 ·Dingding Dong, Vishesh Jain
similarity 0.63
Abstract

For every fixed $0<\varepsilon\le1$, we give a deterministic strongly polynomial algorithm that, given a nonnegative matrix $A\in\mathbb{R}_{\ge0}^{n\times n}$, returns $Q$ satisfying $\operatorname{per} A\le Q\le(1+\varepsilon)^n\operatorname{per} A$.

0.21

Lossless Hardness Condensation in Deterministic Communication Complexity

cs.CC ·2026-09-23 ·Simon Mackenzie
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 33 pages, 8 figures

A communication problem can have far more possible inputs than its communication cost would suggest. Must its difficulty already be present on a much smaller set of inputs? We prove that every finite total Boolean matrix of deterministic communication complexity $c\ge4$ has a submatrix on $2^k$ of its original rows and $2^k$ of its original columns, with $k=Θ_\varepsilon(c)$ and complexity at least $(1-\varepsilon)(k+1)$, for every fixed $0<\varepsilon<1$. Since $k+1$ is the maximum possible cost on such a square, the retained problem can be arbitrarily close to maximally hard. This answers affirmatively the lossless condensation question of Hamed Hatami; Göös, Newman, Riazanov, and Sokolov (STOC 2024), who recorded it as Open Problem 2, conjectured a negative answer. Hrubeš previously guaranteed input length $Ω(\sqrt c)$. The same argument gives an original $2^{c-2}$-by-$2^{c-2}$ square retaining at least $c/3-O(\log c)$ bits of communication complexity. The proof builds on Hrubeš's counting and covering argument. We count submatrices equipped with short communication protocols: a player names a covering submatrix, then the players run its protocol. This avoids the loss from converting rectangle partitions into protocols. A recursion on rectangles makes the argument constructive. For fixed rational $\varepsilon$ and any target depth $d\ge4$, a deterministic algorithm returns either a protocol of depth below $d$, or a square of original inputs at input length $Θ_\varepsilon(d)$ with the same near-maximal guarantee. Its running time is $2^{O(2^d)}$ times a polynomial in the table size. If the original complexity is at least $d$, the algorithm necessarily returns the square. An extension gives constant-factor condensation for any fixed number of number-in-hand players, with bounds independent of the finite output alphabet.

0.23

Improved Degree Tables for Secure Distributed Matrix Multiplication

cs.IT math.CO ·2026-09-06 ·John Byrne, Rafael G. L. D'Oliveira, Michael Tait
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

In secure distributed matrix multiplication, a user wishes to compute the product of two matrices with the assistance of servers, in such a way that any $T$ colluding servers learn nothing about either matrix. Degree tables are a combinatorial tool for constructing polynomial codes for this problem and underlie several state-of-the-art schemes, including $\mathsf{GASP}_r$, $\mathsf{GASP}_{r,s}$, and $\mathsf{DOG}_{r,s}$. We introduce a periodic-gap framework for constructing degree tables that contains these three families as special cases and leads to two new constructions, $\mathsf{SHIFT}_{r,s}$ and $\mathsf{COVER}_r$. We determine their exact recovery thresholds and show that, in many cases, they outperform the current state of the art. We also prove a new lower bound on the recovery threshold of ordinary integer degree tables. In the balanced case, in which the partitioning parameters and the security parameter are equal, we sharpen this bound to match $\mathsf{SHIFT}_{r,s}$ up to lower-order terms, showing that it is asymptotically optimal among degree-table constructions.

0.14

Matrix Samplers and Quantum-Proof Extractors: Their Correspondence and Almost-Optimal Constructions

cs.CC quant-ph ·2026-10-27 ·Kuan Cheng, Ruiyang Wu
similarity 0.61
Abstract

We establish an equivalence between matrix samplers and quantum-proof randomness extractors. The classical sampler-extractor equivalence is established by a seminal work of Zuckerman (Random Structures & Algorithms, 1997). Using this equivalence, we construct explicit strong matrix samplers with optimal randomness overhead and near-optimal sample complexity via constructing quantum-proof extractors. Specifically for matrix dimension $D$, accuracy $\varepsilon$ and failure probability $δ\leq\varepsilon$, our matrix sampler uses $$ m+O_α(\log(D/δ))\text{ random bits and } O_α\!\left(\varepsilon^{-2-α}\log^{1+α}(D/δ)\right)\text{ samples}, $$ for any constant $α>0$. Compared with the matrix sampler of Xun and Zuckerman (CCC 2025), our construction has improvements in two aspects. Under optimal random seed length, we can replace the $\operatorname{poly} D$ dependence in the number of samples by $O(\log^{1+α} D)$. Under the same scale of sample size, we can remove their $\log\log D$ factor in the length of the random seed. Our underlying strong quantum-proof extractor has output length $n-O_α(a+\log(1/η))$ and seed length at most $(1+α)\log a+(2+α)\log(1/η)+O_α(1)$ for $n$-bit sources with conditional min-entropy $n-a$ and error $η$. We also obtain strong quantum-proof extractors for every constant entropy rate, for any error as small as $2^{-Ω(n)}$, having optimal seed length $O(\log(n/η))$ and output length $Ω(n)$, improving previous constructions.

0.09