CS Paper Radar

Managing Inherent Risk: On the Conceptualization of Risk in Defense Systems

NIklas Braun, Leon J. Brettin, Marvin Loba, Markus Maurer

eess.SY ·submitted 2026-08-28 08:59 UTC · v2

Abstract

Certain defense systems are, by nature, deployed in a civilian environment in order to serve a defensive function for that environment. However, the risk involved with their deployment and operation poses a challenge for the public acceptance of these systems. Compared to safety engineering for civilian systems, the risk constellation is quite different. While reducing risk of safety-critical systems is generally desirable, defense systems are required to produce intended mission effects, which may include harm to an attacking target. In both cases, not all risk can be eliminated. The complex risk constellation of defense systems has implications for the systems' designs. We compare the concepts of risk in existing standards from both the civilian and the military domains. An extended constellation of risks needs to be considered, including risk caused by external threats to security. By including this risk constellation in public communication about defense systems, we aim to stimulate a productive debate.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Batten the Hatches: Cybersecurity with Military Mariners

cs.CR ·2026-09-11 ·Ryan Von Brock, Anna Raymaker, Animesh Chhotaray, Frank Li, Saman Zonouz +1 more
top venue similarity 0.64
Abstract · 17 pages, 4 figures, To appear in the Proceedings of the 2026 ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS '26)

Cyberwarfare has become a key component of contemporary geopolitical conflict. However, there has been extremely limited systematic investigation into how cybersecurity is handled by military organizations and personnel. The military context is unique compared to other operational ones, with immense resource availability (U.S. military spending approached 1 trillion dollars in 2024), a rigid chain of command, and extraordinary consequences for its actions. Thus, military cybersecurity is a distinct yet understudied topic. In this paper, we take an early step at understanding military cybersecurity by investigating how service members understand, recognize, and respond to cyber risk. We focus on maritime services and carefully consider organizational barriers to design an unclassified study and conduct semi-structured interviews with 20 military mariners from U.S. Navy and Coast Guard vessels. Through our investigation, we identify unique consequences of compromising military systems, including weapon takeover and purposeful geopolitical escalation. We find that cybersecurity is organizationally abstract on ships, so mariners build cyber risk models from informal experience rather than formal instruction. They nonetheless make cybersecurity actionable by recognizing operational impacts and responding with a safety-oriented incident-response model that creates resilience but may delay cyber attribution and containment. These findings inform actionable recommendations to help military operators frame cyber threats, merge longstanding nautical doctrine with modern systems, and apply military insights to the civilian sector, all to secure the broader maritime environment.

0.41

Towards a Theory of Quantitative Vulnerability Analysis for Engineering Systems

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-10-01 ·Daniel A. Eisenberg, David L. Alderson
position similarity 0.62
Abstract · 18 pages, 1 figure, 10 tables

Since the 1980s, risk analysis for engineering systems has been defined based on a tuple of scenarios, $\mathcal{S}$, likelihoods, $L$, and consequences, $C$, where $Risk = (\mathcal{S},L,C)$. We argue that equating this triplet with risk alone is insufficient and potentially misleading. Instead, we define this tuple as a vulnerability space $\mathcal{V} = (\mathcal{S},L,C)$, which becomes risk only when one makes specific interpretations of likelihood and consequence. Here, an interpretation has mathematical meaning, and defines a map that assigns data elements about system vulnerability to a perspective. Formally, we define a vulnerability perspective as a specific choice of interpretations of likelihood and consequence data that allows vulnerability analysis measures to be defined and analyzed. We argue that risk is only one of four common perspectives on $\mathcal{V}$ and demonstrate mathematically why each perspective should remain a distinct concept. First, we show how interpretation of $C$ as a set-valued function produces reliability measures, not risk measures. Then, we show how interpretation of $L$ via possibility theory will produce adversarial and safety measures distinct from risk. This new theoretical framework clarifies the conceptual, mathematical, and practical differences between risk, reliability, adversarial, and safety perspectives---four common engineering system analyses often conflated in the literature. A consequence of our theory is that no single perspective will reveal all vulnerabilities of an engineering system, suggesting decision-making via risk analysis may incur unavoidable and underappreciated tradeoffs from other vulnerability perspectives.

0.31

From Security Events to Conflict States: A Three-layer Cyber Defense Scenario Model for Enhanced Cyber Situational Awareness

cs.CR ·2026-08-27 ·Miguel Requena Micó, Mario Fernandez-Tarraga, Daniel Díaz-López, Sergio López Bernal, Gregorio Martínez Pérez
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · 18 pages, 3 figures, 1 table, paper in proceedings of The International Conference on Availability, Reliability and Security, ARES 2026 in L…

Cyber defense in mission-critical environments requires integrated approaches capable of representing adversarial progression, defender-side uncertainty, mission impact, and defensive decision support within a unified framework. In operational domains, defenders must continuously estimate the evolving security posture while preserving the continuity and integrity of mission-critical functions under incomplete and noisy observations. This paper presents a mission-oriented cyber-defense framework for Cyber Situational Awareness (CSA) and decision support based on a three-layer integrated probabilistic model and an executable simulation prototype. The model combines: (i) an attack-graph model that represents possible adversarial progression through mission-relevant assets, (ii) an event model that transforms observed telemetry into posterior defender beliefs through Bayesian inference, and (iii) a state model that abstracts the inferred posture into conflict states and mission-risk levels. These components are connected to a one-step defensive action rule that balances estimated residual mission risk and operational cost. The framework is instantiated in a NetLogo agent-based simulation of an operational environment structured across the Tactical Edge Zone (TEZ), Mission Operations Zone (MOZ), and Enterprise Support Zone (ESZ). The proposal is assessed through mathematical consistency analysis, local robustness assessment under telemetry perturbations, and representative simulation traces. Results indicate that the framework and its implementation preserve coherent relationships between attack progression, telemetry-driven uncertainty management, mission-impact assessment, and cost-aware defensive decision support guided by mission-risk prioritization.

0.29

SatBleed: Security of Commoditized Communication Modules in Satellites

cs.CR ·2026-10-05 ·Ulysse Planta, Julian Rederlechner, Martin Strohmeier, Mathias Fischer, Ali Abbasi
top venuecode/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · Accepted at IEEE S&P 2026

Substantial reduction in launch and manufacturing costs has resulted in the accelerated deployment of small satellite missions, with commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) components becoming the prevailing standard for specific subsystems. However, this modular architecture introduces critical security risks, most notably in the Communication Subsystem (COM), which is continuously exposed by design and implicitly trusted as the entry point for command and control. We construct a tailored threat taxonomy for attacks targeting the COM subsystem and analyze representative COM systems from various vendors. Our findings uncover severe vulnerabilities across firmware, protocols, and architectural designs. This work presents the first in-depth security evaluation of widely deployed COTS COM modules employed in small satellites, identifying vulnerabilities affecting dozens of missions. To assess the real-world impact, we correlate our discoveries with open-source telemetry data, inferring at least 28 vulnerable missions in orbit that are susceptible to hostile takeover. Our work reveals that satellite COM subsystems form an attractive and dangerously neglected attack surface, necessitating urgent attention from the community.

0.61

Temporal Risk on Satellites

cs.CR ·2026-08-20 ·Shiqi Liu, Kun Sun
similarity 0.58
Abstract · Accepted at the Workshop on Security of Space and Satellite Systems (SpaceSec) 2026

Satellite vulnerabilities change over time as orbits shift, power margins tighten, and the space environment deteriorates. However, most cybersecurity risk frameworks still treat threats as static. In practice, the same exploit can be far more damaging during a critical maneuver than during routine operations. We propose a temporal risk assessment framework that makes time an explicit axis in satellite security analysis. It extends existing adversary behavior taxonomies with a five-dimensional temporal capability model and estimates exploitation difficulty across distinct temporal windows of a mission. Rather than producing a single risk score, the framework outputs a series of time-indexed likelihood-impact matrices. It discretizes missions into operationally meaningful time windows and environmental bands to show when systems are most exposed. This view helps operators avoid scheduling sensitive operations in high-risk periods and align defensive resources with a threat landscape that shifts over time.

0.57

Toward a Threat Actor Profiling Taxonomy for Pre-Release Risk Management of Open-Weight Frontier Models

cs.CY ·2026-08-26 ·James Zhang
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Pre-release risk management for frontier AI misuse risks routinely leaves threat actor assumptions implicit, inconsistently specified, or ungrounded. This capstone argues that explicit adversary characterization should be regarded as a prerequisite for evaluations that are interpretable, comparable, and faithful to the risks they target. We propose a six-attribute taxonomy (covering technical sophistication, prior domain knowledge, organizational capacity, operational infrastructure, financial capacity, and time horizon) with empirically grounded tiers derived from existing terrorism, biosecurity, and cybersecurity literature. The taxonomy is designed to function as research infrastructure: a common language for pre-specifying adversary assumptions before evaluations are conducted, analogous to pre-analysis plans for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in medicine and economics. Its application is particularly urgent for open-weight model developers, for whom release decisions are irreversible and must anticipate adversarial reasoning.

0.24

SCRM: An Actionable Framework for Space Cyber Risk Management

cs.CR ·2026-10-02 ·Ekzhin Ear, Caleb Chang, Shouhuai Xu
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Space infrastructures play critical roles in modern society, including satellite communications (SATCOM). Like the Internet, space infrastructures are vulnerable to cyber attacks, or space cyber attacks, highlighting the importance of managing cyber risks to space infrastructures, or space cyber risks. However, adequately managing space cyber risks is an open problem. In this paper, we propose the first Space Cyber Risk Management (SCRM) framework to systematically analyze and mitigate space cyber risks. The framework models space infrastructures, space missions, and space cyber attacks, while offering algorithms for space mission risk analysis and hardening. We demonstrate its usefulness by conducting a case study on real-world space cyber attacks against the SATCOM infrastructure implemented in our testbed. Our results show, among other things, that: (i) dealing with space cyber attack cascading effects is essential to space cyber risk management; (ii) the framework can effectively harden space missions; (iii) National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) security controls can effectively mitigate space cyber risks.

0.21

White paper: A perspective on civilian-to-defence research transfer to SDD

cs.SE cs.NI ·2026-08-10 ·Rute C. Sofia, Daniel Mendez, Simon Barner, Hao Shen, Julian Woermann +4 more
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Military capability is increasingly determined by software. Yet defence platforms are procured on decade-long timescales, while the software and AI models they carry must evolve in days or hours. This paper calls this mismatch the lifecycle paradox, and argues it is the central problem Software-Defined Defence (SDD) must solve. SDD rests on three dimensions: software and systems engineering (design, procurement, certification), AI engineering (sovereignty and trust of learned components), and connectivity and infrastructure engineering (timely exchange of information among sensors, AI, and operators). The proposed path to resilient SDD starts from civilian technologies, addressed through a continuous, DevOps-style loop: model-based systems engineering and simulation-based testing front-load design and verification; tactical connectivity and low-power edge execution carry that design into contested operation; continuous compliance, assurance, and variability management run as cross-cutting concerns. This loop is sustainable given capabilities already proven in automotive, manufacturing, space, and energy. The next step is validating them under adversarial or defence-certified conditions, with short-, medium-, and long-term paths to closing gaps. Closing the SDD gap while preserving civic benefits is a distributed responsibility: researchers must redirect methods toward adversarial conditions; industry must expose tooling to operational needs; policymakers must shape regulatory instruments; and defence agencies must validate results with operators. Recommendations span three horizons: a short-term baseline of adversarial testing and connectivity pilots; a medium-term pipeline of incremental certification; and a long-term validation closing the loop under operational conditions.

0.04