CS Paper Radar

UML Class Diagram Evaluation and Repair Strategies based on LLMs

Jie Liang, Peng Liang, Chong Wang

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-08-28 19:10 UTC · v1

Abstract

UML class diagrams are a crucial tool for defining the structure of software systems, but designing accurate and comprehensive class diagrams is a challenging task. Traditionally, creating UML models relies on the expertise and experience of professionals. However, with the development of AI technologies, particularly LLMs, new opportunities for software modeling have emerged. Despite this, there has been limited research on the application of LLMs in software modeling, especially in UML class diagram modeling. This study conducts experiments on several typical software system cases. Combining SDMetrics with expert manual review, this paper comprehensively evaluates the practical performance of mainstream LLMs in UML class diagram modeling from multiple dimensions, including size and completeness, relationship correctness, inheritance hierarchy, and design rule compliance. Focusing on typical defects in LLM-generated UML class diagrams, this study reveals that LLMs exhibit uncertainties analogous to human memory. Accordingly, three targeted repair strategies are proposed, including memory reinforcement, external knowledge injection, and detection-guided automated targeted repair. Experimental results obtained from the case studies indicate that (1) compared to expert-crafted class diagrams, LLM-generated UML class diagrams exhibit several issues, such as incomplete identification of key classes, confusion or omissions in relationships, insufficient or absent inheritance relationships, unused classes, and circular dependencies, and (2) after applying the repair methods, all the LLMs show varying degrees of improvement in addressing these issues. The average repair rate for key class identification reaches 85%, the coupling relationship repair rate is 46%, the inheritance relationship repair rate is 69%, while repair rates for unused classes and circular dependencies both reach 100%.

Comment
30 pages, 5 images, 8 tables, Manuscript submitted to a journal (2026)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Tracing Hallucinations in LLM Reasoning for UML Class Diagram Generation: An Empirical Taxonomy and Mitigation Study

cs.SE cs.CL ·2026-10-22 ·Mojdeh Rahmanian, Foutse Khomh, Yanchao Yu, Ashkan Sami
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) can generate UML class diagrams from natural language requirements, but hallucinations may compromise the correctness and completeness of the resulting diagrams. Existing evaluations mostly assess the final diagram, without examining the intermediate traces of reasoning-capable LLMs, which can reveal where these hallucinations arise. We develop an empirical taxonomy of eleven hallucination sub-types organised into three dimensions: Prompt Faithfulness (deviations between requirements and reasoning), Code Faithfulness (discrepancies between reasoning and generated PlantUML code), and Reasoning Quality (problems within the reasoning). The taxonomy was derived from 60 manually annotated DeepSeek-R1 traces, applied to 120 further DeepSeek-R1 traces through a dual-LLM annotation pipeline, and examined on 20 DeepSeek-V4-Pro traces. Code Faithfulness was the most frequent dimension for DeepSeek-R1 in both datasets, whereas Prompt Faithfulness dominated for DeepSeek-V4-Pro, suggesting model-dependent failure patterns. In the manually annotated traces, reasoning-trace length showed no significant monotonic association with hallucination frequency, whereas requirement complexity was negatively associated with it, particularly for Prompt Faithfulness errors. In a mitigation experiment on 13 Golden UML ModelSet cases with three Qwen3-based models, adding Prompt Faithfulness and Reasoning Quality constraints to the generation prompt raised the pooled mean F1 score by 4.0 percentage points, whereas a post-hoc Code Faithfulness review provided no consistent further benefit. Relationship modelling remained the lowest-scoring element throughout. These results suggest that localising hallucinations within the generation process can inform targeted, prompt-based mitigation. Whether these findings generalise beyond the DeepSeek and Qwen3 model families remains to be tested.

0.34

Breaking Models to Test the Judge: A Mutation Testing Approach for Semantic Evaluators of Domain Class Diagrams

cs.SE ·2026-08-14 ·Kevin Delcourt, Meriem Ben Chaaben, Abdelhamid Rouatbi, Luciano Marchezan, Houari Sahraoui
top venue similarity 0.60
Abstract · Paper accepted at the ACM/IEEE 29th International Conference on Model Driven Engineering Languages and Systems (MODELS 2026)

In software engineering, many semantic modeling tasks lack a unique ground truth, as human judgments are both costly and subjective. This paper explores mutation testing as a scalable alternative for evaluating semantic judges (e.g., LLM-based) of models. We propose a mutation testing approach in which controlled semantic defects are injected into domain class diagrams. Starting from pairs of PlantUML class diagrams and textual system descriptions, we apply mutation operators (e.g., removing a class) to generate faulty variants. A candidate judge is then evaluated based on its ability to detect the injected defects. We define 11 mutation operators for the task of comparing a domain class diagram against a textual description and evaluate the proposed approach against a conventional manual assessment of judgment validity. Across six judge configurations (three LLMs and two prompt variants), the automated mutation testing approach is largely consistent with the manual assessment in identifying the better-performing configurations. The results suggest that mutation testing may serve as a scalable proxy for analyzing semantic judges.

0.67

Is there a future for models in the LLM era?

cs.SE ·2026-09-28 ·Marco Calamo, Massimo Mecella, Monique Snoeck
similarity 0.57
Abstract

In an era where software development is deeply tied with Large Language Models, does Model Driven Engineering (MDE) still make sense? This raises the question of the extent to which MDE can be successfully combined with an LLM approach to address the downsides of each approach separately. In this paper, we try to answer that question by investigating a central Research Question: Can Agents powered by Large Language Models improve code generated from UML diagrams and text specifications by Model Driven Engineering (MDE) tools? To investigate this problem, we developed a novel LLM-powered Multi-Agentic approach called ARTHUR (Architecture Refactoring Through Hybrid UML Reasoning), a framework that aims at combining the reliability of MDE and the ease of use of LLMs. ARTHUR is designed to refactor legacy Java code produced by traditional, rule-based, MDE code generators from UML diagrams. To asses the answer to our question, we have refactored the legacy code of several projects from our custom dataset crafted for this purpose. \name{} which made it possible to add support for modern frameworks like Spring Boot, while ensuring compliance with Model-Based Testing techniques to verify that the code still corresponds to the initial model's specifications. We then measured the results obtained in terms of time and cost, passing test rate, and \texttt{compile@k}, \texttt{pass@k} and \texttt{pass$^k$} metrics. We also observed the effect of generating code directly from the conceptual model without the refactoring. Our preliminary test results show that MDE could not be more far from retirement, after all.

0.19

When Does UML Software Modeling Pay Off? A Contingency Model of Industrial Modeling Value

cs.SE ·2026-10-17 ·Kleinner Silva Farias de Oliveira
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 5 pages, 1 figure

With the emergence of specification-driven development (SDD), software modeling has regained strategic importance as a way to translate human intentions, requirements, and design decisions into precise specifications that can guide both developers and AI-assisted development tools. Despite the renewed relevance of modeling in SDD, empirical evidence remains limited on when its benefits outweigh the socio-technical effort required to create, communicate, synchronize, and maintain software models in industrial practice. This study investigates when software modeling generates value in industrial practice. We analyzed 405 survey responses collected from software practitioners. The questionnaire combined closed items concerning UML use, benefits, barriers, and improvement mechanisms with open-ended questions about current use, difficulties, and worthwhile contexts. Most respondents associated modeling with integration discussions (90 percent) and shared understanding (82 percent), but also reported time pressure (85 percent) and the effort required to create and maintain models (80 percent). Selective modeling, model-code synchronization, and collaborative support emerged as conditions that improve its viability, whereas only 24 percent reported daily UML use. Software modeling pays off when its expected contextual value exceeds the socio-technical friction required to create and sustain it. Its value is therefore contingent, not universal.

0.24

Constructing Dynamic Master Logic Models as Knowledge Graphs for Complex System Diagnostics Using Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models

cs.AI ·2026-08-12 ·Saman Marandi, Yu-Shu Hu, Mohammad Modarres
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 36 Pages, 8 Figures

Dynamic Master Logic (DML) provides a hierarchical framework for representing system behavior by linking functional objectives to underlying structural elements. However, DML construction typically relies on expert interpretation of technical documentation, limiting scalability for complex systems. This study presents a framework for automated construction of DML models from system descriptions and their representation as Knowledge Graphs (KG-DML), using Retrieval-Augmented Generation and Large Language Models as enabling tools. Building on prior work with small-scale systems, the framework extends automated KG-DML construction and evaluation to substantially larger and more complex systems. Model construction proceeds across the DML hierarchy using targeted retrieval while preserving functional dependencies and explicit logical relationships. The resulting KG-DML supports diagnostic reasoning, safety assessment, upward failure propagation, and downward dependency tracing. A multi-level validation methodology evaluates layer-specific precision and recall, logical gate consistency, and overall structural integrity. Application to the Low-Pressure Coolant Injection system of a decommissioned Boiling Water Reactor demonstrates consistent reconstruction across repeated runs. The results show that automated KG-DML construction can transform technical documentation into executable functional models for diagnostic and reliability analysis.

0.10

Rethinking Automated Program Repair: The Impact of Bug Complexity, Fault Localization, and LLM Cost-efficiency

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-08-14 ·Junchi Liu, Ali Bigdeli, Roya Daneshi, Atu Ambala, Sudipto Ghosh +1 more
top venue similarity 0.54
Abstract · 20 pages, 6 figures, 10 tables. Accepted at ESEM 2026

Background: Software bugs remain a critical challenge in development, necessitating effective Automated Program Repair (APR) techniques. While Large Language Model (LLM)-based APR systems have shown promise, prior studies primarily focus on overall repair effectiveness. The effects of bug complexity, fault localization, reasoning settings, and repair cost-effectiveness remain insufficiently explored. Aims: This study presents a comprehensive empirical analysis of LLM-based APR, focusing on how repair performance is shaped by bug complexity, fault localization, reasoning settings, and costs. Method: We evaluate two APR techniques (ChatRepair and CodeCorrector) using three LLMs (DeepSeek, GPT, and Llama), and examine their performance across diverse levels of bug complexity and localization strategies through a multi-dimensional empirical framework and statistical analysis. Results: Although structurally complex bugs and imprecise fault localization make repair more challenging, LLM-based APR techniques still achieve competitive repair effectiveness. Imprecise fault localization can substantially enlarge the performance gap between APR techniques. Furthermore, higher-cost LLMs and stronger reasoning settings do not consistently yield better cost-efficiency, revealing a nontrivial trade-off between repair effectiveness and computational cost. Conclusions: Over 50% of moderately complex bugs can be repaired by low-cost LLM-based APR techniques. The repair effectiveness gap between APR techniques becomes larger as fault localization becomes less precise. GPT-5 repairs 7 and 39 more complex bugs than DeepSeek-V4-pro and DeepSeek-V3.2, respectively; whereas the total repair cost of DeepSeek-V3.2 shows the best cost-efficiency performance.

0.68

Externalizing Requirement-to-Repair Artifacts as Observable Traces for LLM-Based Program Repair

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-09-14 ·Zewen Tao, Shin-nosuke Ishikawa
code/data similarity 0.54
Abstract · Accepted at REALM Workshop, EMNLP 2026. Code: https://github.com/ForeverMJ/THEMIS

Repository-level repair requires not only correct patches but also inspectable records that explain how issue requirements are translated into code changes and post-edit evidence. We contribute THEMIS, a stage-aware repair workflow that externalizes this requirement-to-repair process through semantic interpretation, a runtime requirement-code graph, graph-derived Developer guidance, retained repair rationale and patches, and post-edit audit records. A retrospective audit of 300 SWE-bench Lite cases demonstrates that these artifacts provide broad support for cross-stage inspection: a complete Developer rationale is available for 288 cases, and 214 cases (71.3%) retain a complete audited field set connecting the selected stages. The retained records further enable systematic measurement of cross-stage correspondence: target symbols recur in 62.6% of Developer rationales and in 62.8% of patches, rising to 75.8% when related symbols are included. In a paired 100-case comparison, the relational workflow resolves 19 cases versus 9 for the direct same-input condition; because the two conditions also differ in Analyzer output, graph-derived distillation, and Judge records, we report this as preliminary, workflow-level evidence rather than a causal effect of the graph component. Together, these results show that THEMIS makes otherwise implicit requirement-to-repair transitions inspectable, enabling systematic examination of how repair decisions persist, align, and evolve across stages.

0.36

Learning from Past Mistakes: AI-Assisted Analytics of Software Defects and Their Fixes for Future Defect Prevention - An Industrial Case Study

cs.SE ·2026-10-14 ·Vehid Goruslu
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Context. Despite advances in software testing and quality assurance, defects continue to recur in industrial software systems. Defect data are routinely collected in issue-tracking systems, but their use is largely confined to detection, reporting, and short-term resolution, leaving the knowledge embedded in historical defects and their fixes under-exploited for prevention and long-term improvement. Objective. This paper investigates how historical defect and defect-fix data can be analyzed, with AI assistance under human oversight, to identify the human-error origins of recurring defects and to feed that understanding back into prevention and QA improvement. Method. We developed an AI-assisted, human-in-the-loop analytics approach that classifies defects by failure type and by human-error origin across the SDLC, determines how each could have been prevented, and synthesizes engineer-focused capability-building insights. It was deployed and evaluated in a large software company through an industrial case study, using practitioner surveys and interviews, classification-reliability checks, and an effort-normalized analysis of defect density. Results. Practitioners and independent review judged the classifications accurate; the outputs were rated useful and actionable; and defect density decreased after the introduction of the feedback, a tentative association we interpret as consistent with, but not proof of, a positive effect, given the study's uncontrolled pre/post design. Conclusion. AI-assisted, human-governed analysis of defect-fix data can help shift organizations from defect detection toward prevention, continuous learning and improvement.

0.25