CS Paper Radar

Learning Proportional Committees from Violation Feedback

Frank Connor

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-08-31 00:53 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We study violation-feedback learning of proportionally representative approval-based committees. In each round, a learner proposes a committee of size $k$. An oracle either accepts the proposal or adversarially selects a representation violation with respect to a single fixed hidden approval profile. We compare \emph{full-witness feedback}, which reveals the violation level, an omitted candidate, and the affected voter group, with \emph{candidate-only feedback}, which reveals only that candidate. The target notions are proportional justified representation plus (PJR+) and extended justified representation plus (EJR+). In every setting we study, the number of rejected proposals can be bounded solely in terms of $k$, with no dependence on the numbers of voters and candidates. For PJR+, the optimal deterministic and randomized rejection complexities equal $k$ under both feedback models. For EJR+, the picture is more nuanced. Under full-witness feedback, we prove an $Ω(k^{3/2})$ deterministic lower bound and give a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm using $O(k^2\log k)$ rejections. Under candidate-only feedback, randomization achieves $O(k^2\log k)$ expected rejections via uniform random deletion, while deterministic exhaustive branching gives a $2^{O(k^2(\log k)^2)}$ rejection bound. Even with full-witness feedback, randomized learners may require $k$ rejections.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Distortion of Threshold Approval Multiwinner Voting

cs.GT ·2026-10-09 ·Mohamad Latifian, Marzieh Nilipour, Alexandros A. Voudouris
similarity 0.68
Abstract

We study multiwinner voting with $n$ voters and $m$ candidates, where the goal is to select a committee of size $k$. Voters have unit-sum cardinal utilities but report only coarse information induced by $t$ utility thresholds. In particular, each voter partitions the candidates into approval sets, with the utilities of all candidates in the same set lying between the same pair of consecutive thresholds. We model the utility of each voter for a committee as a normalized monotone symmetric norm, capturing, among others, additive welfare, best-representative utility, top-$r$ welfare, $\ell_p$ welfare, and normalized non-increasing ordered weighted averages. We design a deterministic rule with distortion at most $2(2m)^{1/t}$ and a randomized rule with distortion at most $2\min\{m^{1/(t+1)},m/k\}$. These guarantees hold for every committee size $k$ and every norm in our framework. Consequently, a single threshold yields distortion $O(m)$ for deterministic rules and $O(\sqrt{m})$ for randomized rules, while $O(\log m)$ thresholds suffice for constant distortion. We complement these results with norm-dependent lower bounds that asymptotically match our upper bounds for constant committee sizes, including the single-winner case.

0.18

Multi-Winner Elections: Justified Representation, Strategyproofness, and Risk-Avoiding Truthfulness

cs.GT ·2026-08-15 ·Yizhou Ai, Biaoshuai Tao
theory similarity 0.67
Abstract · 35 pages

We study approval-based multi-winner elections with Justified Representation (JR) when voters strategically report their ballots. We prove that there does not exist a strategy-proof mechanism that outputs JR committees, even when the mechanism can be randomized and only Ex-Ante strategyproofness is required. The impossibility already holds with three voters, four candidates, and target committee size three, even when the mechanism may select fewer than three candidates. It applies to every common strictly increasing cardinality-based utility function and scales to every target size $k\geq3$, every number of voters divisible by $k$, and every candidate-set size at least $k+1$. Motivated by our negative results, we then ask for weaker strategy-proof guarantees under voters' partial information. We use the notion of Risk-Avoiding Truthfulness and its RAT-Degree proposed by Hartman, Segal-Halevi, and Tao (EC'25), the number of other voters whose information a manipulator must know before a safe and profitable deviation is possible. Standard proportional rules, such as Greedy Approval Voting, Proportional Approval Voting, and the Method of Equal Shares, have poor performances under the RAT-Degree metric (with low RAT-Degrees). Finally, for $n$ voters, we construct a JR mechanism with RAT-Degree at least $n-5$, without a polynomial-time bound. We then use the same idea together with algebraic ballot encodings to obtain a polynomial-time JR mechanism with RAT-Degree at least $n-7$. When voters also have immutable private identifiers and both the identifiers and ballots of unknown voters are unobserved, we obtain a polynomial-time JR mechanism with RAT-Degree at least $n-1$ for $2\le k<m$. This degree is exactly $n-1$ when $k\ge3$ and $k$ divides $n$.

0.38

Sparse Disapproval Guarantees a Nonempty Hare Core

cs.GT ·2026-09-03 ·Jiarui Fang
theorycode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · 4 pages, code and other materials are available at: https://github.com/Baymax-ray/approval-core-corank-two

An approval committee is Hare-core stable if no coalition meeting the Hare quota can strictly improve by moving to another candidate set. Whether every approval election has such a committee remains open. We prove nonemptiness when each voter disapproves at most two candidates, with no bounds on the numbers of candidates, seats, or voter types. The result also permits arbitrary positive rational voter weights. Our deterministic rule represents a committee by its missing set. It first maximizes weighted coverage of two-candidate disapproval sets and then maximizes total disapproval incidence. An exact coverage inequality excludes targets one seat below the committee. The incidence objective excludes unanimous equal-size targets, while targets of size at most $k-2$ cannot improve any voter. Two implementation-level independent verifiers audit overlapping finite grids. The symbolic proof, not this bounded enumeration, establishes the theorem's unbounded quantifiers. The argument identifies complement-side coverage as a tractable mechanism for a broad parameter range within a sharply defined preference domain.

0.31

Finding Representative and Approximately Efficient Committees

cs.GT ·2026-09-07 ·Dominik Peters, Rohit Vaish, Jatin Yadav
similarity 0.66
Abstract

In approval-based committee voting, proportional approval voting (PAV) is a well-studied rule that combines proportional representation with Pareto efficiency. However, computing a PAV committee is NP-hard, raising a natural question: Can the proportionality and efficiency properties of PAV be achieved via computationally efficient procedures? We make two contributions toward answering this question. First, building on the known proportionality guarantees of the local-search-based variant of PAV (or local PAV), we systematically study its efficiency properties. We show that local PAV committees are weakly Pareto optimal, meaning that no other committee is strictly preferred by every voter. We also identify limitations: Local PAV guarantees only a $2$-approximation to fractional Pareto optimality ($2$-fPO) and a $2/3$-approximation to the optimal PAV score, and both bounds are tight. In contrast, global PAV is Pareto optimal and satisfies the stronger $α^\star$-fPO guarantee, where $α^\star \approx 1.346$ is the unique solution of $\int_0^{α^\star} \frac{1-e^{-y}}{y} \, dy = 1$, and this approximation is tight. Second, we design a polynomial-time algorithm that combines the best of these guarantees. The committee returned by our algorithm satisfies EJR$+$ (a proportionality guarantee), $α^\star$-fPO, and weak Pareto optimality. It also achieves a $0.79$-approximation to the optimal PAV score, matching the best possible polynomial-time approximation assuming $P \neq NP$. Our algorithm works by pipage rounding a concave relaxation of the PAV objective and using that committee to initialize local PAV, thereby combining global approximation guarantees with local search stability.

0.42

Best-of-Both Worlds Proportionality in Structured Committee Elections

cs.GT ·2026-10-20 ·Dimitris Avramidis, Mark de Berg, Ulrike Schmidt-Kraepelin
similarity 0.65
Abstract

We study randomized committee elections with additive preferences, where we seek best-of-both-worlds proportionality. That is, we strive for strong guarantees for the selection probabilities ex ante and each realized committee ex post. We focus on structured preferences and introduce antichain single-peakedness, a restricted domain generalizing single-peaked additive preferences as well as several well-studied approval domains. Our approach first computes a fractional committee and then decomposes it through a rounding rule called systematic rounding. Among profile-oblivious rounding rules, we characterize systematic rounding as the unique rule satisfying natural quota guarantees, and thereby the only promising rule for our two-step approach. We show that ex-ante core stability is incompatible with ex-post justified representation $JR$, even under single-peaked preferences. However, applying systematic rounding to certain fractional allocations that form so-called Lindahl equilibria yields ex-ante core stability and ex-post core stability up to one. Alternatively, we retain exact ex-post proportionality and approximate the ex-ante core using two parameters: $α$ raises the utility gain required for a deviation, while $β$ reduces the coalition's proportional share. We establish the tight threshold $αβ$=2. Below it, ex-post JR is incompatible even under single-peaked preferences; at and above it, adapting a fractional rule called BestRepresentative [Pierczyński and Skowron, 2022] and applying systematic rounding to its output yields ex-ante $α, β$-fractional core stability and ex-post PJR under antichain single-peaked preferences.

0.07

The Complexity of Membership, Uniqueness, and Counting for Optimal Proportional Approval Voting Committees

cs.GT ·2026-09-08 ·Yizhou Ai
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 18 pages

Proportional Approval Voting (PAV) chooses committees that maximize a sum of harmonic utilities. We study the set of maximizing committees: whether a candidate belongs to some or all of them, whether the optimum is unique, and how many optima exist. When the committee size is part of the input, the three decision problems are $Δ_2^\mathrm{P}$-complete. Uniqueness remains hard for instances with at most two optimal committees. Counting optimal committees is $\#\!\cdot\!\mathrm{OptP}$-complete under metric reductions: every function $f$ in this class reduces to an election with exactly $f(x)+1$ optimal committees. The reductions encode satisfying assignments directly as committees and use harmonic marginal rewards to realize binary objectives with polynomially many voters. Each satisfying assignment has a unique committee representation, and fixed clause ballots give these representations the same clause score. We also prove Turing equivalence with $\#\mathrm{SAT}$ and show that membership of the counting problem in $\#\mathrm{P}$ would imply $\\mathrm{NP}=\mathrm{coNP}$.

0.27

Metric Distortion of Social Welfare Functions

cs.GT cs.MA ·2026-08-22 ·Fatih Erdem Kizilkaya, Aaryaman Aggarwal, Evi Micha
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 11 pages, 1 table

Metric distortion has primarily been studied for social choice functions, which select a single winner from ordinal preferences. We extend this framework to social welfare functions, which output a ranking of $m$ candidates. We associate each voter $v$ with a monotone weight vector $\mathbf{w}_v = (w_{v1},\ldots,w_{vm})$, specifying the importance of the $i$-th position for voter $v$, and define the cost of a ranking as the position-weighted sum of their distances to the ranked candidates. This model generalizes both single-winner voting and committee selection. We consider three information regimes. First, we study the setting where the positional weight vectors are known. A natural approach recursively applies a single-winner rule with distortion $β$ to construct the ranking one position at a time. We show that this yields distortion at most $3β$ in general. This gap is not merely an artifact of the analysis: we show that no analysis based solely on per-round guarantees can certify a bound better than $2β$. By exploiting structural properties specific to Fractional Veto of Kizilkaya and Kempe, we show that its recursive extension achieves the optimal distortion of 3. Second, when all voters share the same unknown weight vector, recursively applying any social choice function with distortion $β$ achieves distortion at most $1+(β-1)\text{range}(\mathbf{w})$, where $\text{range}(\mathbf{w})=(w_1-w_m)/w_1$ denotes the normalized range of the common weight vector $\mathbf{w}$. Finally, we study unknown heterogeneous weights. Without further assumptions, every rule has unbounded distortion. We therefore consider two natural normalizations: unit-sum, where each voter distributes one unit of value across the ranking, and unit-top, where every voter assigns unit value to the first position. Under both models, we show that the optimal distortion is $Θ(m)$.

0.40

Full Justified Representation in Temporal Voting: Efficient Computation and Verification

cs.GT ·2026-09-22 ·Nicholas Teh
highly cited similarity 0.64
Abstract

In temporal voting, a fixed set of voters makes a collective decision in each of several rounds, and proportionality requires that groups with shared interests be represented across these decisions. Full justified representation (FJR) is among the strongest proportionality axioms known to be satisfiable in this setting, since it allows different members of a group to be satisfied by different selected candidates. However, whether an FJR outcome can be computed in polynomial time has remained open. We resolve this question by introducing temporal FJR+, a strengthening of both FJR and extended justified representation+ (EJR+) that can be computed and verified in polynomial time. The axiom measures a group's agreement in each round by the largest number of its members who approve a common candidate, and requires some member to attain the integer part of the group's proportional share of its best attainable average satisfaction, with a shortfall of at most one unit when this share is an integer. We show that verification reduces to counting approvals among the voters below each satisfaction threshold. For computation, we observe that local search for Proportional Approval Voting (PAV) can stop at an outcome violating FJR. Somewhat counterintuitively, the remedy is to subtract a small multiple of the minimum voter satisfaction from the PAV score: every FJR+ violation then admits a single-round change whose improvement guarantees polynomial running time. We further show that temporal FJR+ is strictly stronger than FJR and EJR+ combined, and coincides with lower quota on party-list preferences. Finally, temporal FJR+ and multiwinner FJR+ are incomparable in general, but coincide when approvals are static and each candidate-round pair is treated as a separate candidate.

0.32