CS Paper Radar

Perceptually Better, Semantically Worse: Measuring Speech Enhancement Impact on LLM-Based Voice Systems

Randy Frans Fela, Pejman Mowlaee

cs.SD eess.AS ·submitted 2026-08-31 07:06 UTC · v1
top venuebenchmark

Abstract

Speech enhancement (SE) is commonly applied as a preprocessing step in spoken AI pipelines under the assumption that better audio quality improves downstream task performance. Whether SE-induced distortions propagate to downstream LLM task performance remains an open question. We introduce Output Divergence Rate (ODR), which measures how often SE changes an LLM's intent classification relative to clean speech, and benchmark five conditions on 2,974 SLURP clips using Whisper large-v3 and wav2vec2-large cascades. Every condition produces ODR significantly above zero ($p < 0.001$, binomial test). MetricGAN{+} more than doubles ODR versus unenhanced noisy speech (0.318 vs. 0.135) despite improving PESQ, and unmitigated echo reaches an ODR of 0.836 through speaker substitution, a failure WER cannot capture. Audio quality metrics range from near-zero to moderate correlation with ODR (SQUIM-MOS $ρ=-0.068$, PESQ $ρ=-0.467$). The MetricGAN{+} and echo results replicate across ASR architectures, indicating that standard audio quality metrics are insufficient for LLM pipeline quality.

Comment
Accepted at EMNLP 2026. 12 pages, 4 figures, 8 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Perceptual Quality Loss or Loss of Perceptual Quality?

eess.AS cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Danilo de Oliveira, Tal Peer, Maurício do V. M. da Costa, Timo Gerkmann
similarity 0.74
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 27

Contemporary deep speech enhancement (SE) models are often trained with specific auxiliary terms in the loss function as a way to improve their performance in terms of perceptual metrics. Nevertheless, a higher score on a perceptual metric does not necessarily correlate with an improved listening experience. Through objective and subjective experiments, we assess the performance of SE models trained with two different types of auxiliary PESQ loss terms. The numerical evaluation on a suite of standard metrics suggests that, while models optimized for PESQ naturally obtain higher PESQ scores in the test set, for most other metrics the scores do not significantly change. In some cases, the PESQ loss even results in worse PESQ scores on mismatched data. A formal listening experiment reveals that the models without a PESQ loss were generally preferred over models that include it, across all settings. Finally, we analyze the relative importance of PESQ in the composite metrics CSIG, CBAK and COVL, and find that PESQ dominates all of them. Our study highlights the perils of over-reliance on PESQ and stresses the importance of a complete evaluation procedure for SE.

0.14

Scalable Audio-LLM System for Speech MOS Evaluation: A Diagnostic Case Study and Adaptation Roadmap

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-10-30 ·Dimitrios Kokkinis, Panagiotis Kakoulidis, Nikolaos Ellinas, Chrysovalanti Lymperi, Alexandra Vioni +8 more
benchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract

The continuous deployment of enterprise voice systems creates a critical operational bottleneck: evaluating the acoustic quality of synthetic speech across high-volume production updates. While human Mean Opinion Score (MOS) remains the quality gold standard, it introduces severe operational costs and turn-around delays that make continuous integration infeasible. In this work, we present a system design case study for a scalable, low-cost and offline evaluation pipeline capable of scoring large batches of synthetic speech at marginal cost. First, we use Qwen2-Audio-7B-Instruct in a zero-shot setting for granular MOS estimation, noticing perceptual blind spots and inherent biases. Then, we analyze SOMOS dataset and construct a diagnostic benchmark that operationalizes two prosodic dimensions associated with human naturalness ratings. Finally, we adapt Qwen2-Audio-7B-Instruct through a parameter-efficient finetuning (LoRA) on the task of MOS evaluation, observing improvements over base model and widely used neural baselines like UTMOS and establishing a practical blueprint for enterprise-grade speech quality assurance.

0.11

Rethinking Language Model-Based Generative Speech Enhancement in the Latent Space of a Neural Audio Codec

eess.AS ·2026-08-12 ·Yihui Fu, Zhengyang Li, Tim Fingscheidt
published similarity 0.69
Abstract · Accepted at IWAENC 2026

Language model (LM)-based speech enhancement (SE) has recently emerged rapidly using latent space features of neural audio codecs (NACs). In this paper, first, we present a unified framework covering six popular LM-based generative SE modeling paradigms based on discrete/continuous latent NAC features: discrete or continuous autoregressive (D/CAR) SE, discrete or continuous non-autoregressive (D/CNAR) SE, discrete diffusion (DDiff) SE, and continuous flow matching (CFM) SE. Second, we are the first to compare their performance in a unified experimental setup and synopsis with diverse intrusive and non-intrusive metrics, enabling a fair and comprehensive evaluation. Third, we propose a fine-tuning strategy with auxiliary losses on reconstructed speech to improve both intrusive and non-intrusive metrics. Trained and evaluated on URGENT 2025 Speech Enhancement Challenge data splits, all continuous-domain paradigms excel their discrete-domain counterparts. The overall best approach turns out to be CNAR. We further show that our proposed auxiliary loss fine-tuning strategy helps to improve DNSMOS, NISQA, PESQ, and POLQA consistently in all six paradigms.

0.19

SURE-Voice: A Front-End Baseline for Speech-Evidence Filtering in Speech LLMs

eess.AS cs.CLcs.SD ·2026-08-27 ·Mengzhe Geng
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

Speech language models (speech LLMs) can generate plausible outputs from audio that contains no usable speech evidence. We study this failure as a pre-generation support-estimation problem and present SURE-Voice, a training-free front end that decides whether an audio prompt contains intelligible speech evidence before calling a speech LLM. We build SURE-Challenge with a 640-example SURE-Core split and a 1,920-example SURE-Extended split derived from 120 LibriSpeech source utterances. Using one fixed operating point, an energy screen plus Whisper token confidence raises unsupported accuracy on the held-out Extended test from 0.000--0.133 to 0.919 for six non-degenerate speech LLM backbones, while supported accuracy remains 0.919--0.970 and downstream calls fall from 480 to 287. A 500-clip ESC-50 sanity set shows the same pattern on real environmental audio, with vocal non-speech as a residual failure mode. An overlap diagnostic shows that source attribution remains separate from speech-evidence filtering. The evidence supports a controlled benchmark baseline and a deployment-oriented analysis; it does not establish universal robustness to semantic answerability, gain variation or natural conversations.

0.17

The ISCSLP 2026 Real-World Audio-Visual Speech Enhancement Challenge: A Benchmark with Natural Mixtures and Degraded Video

eess.AS cs.SD ·2026-08-24 ·Kai Li, Wenze Ren, Junjie Li, Cheng Yu, Peijun Yang +9 more
benchmark similarity 0.68
Abstract · The First Real-World Audio-Visual Speech Enhancement (AVSE) Challenge; Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Audio-visual speech enhancement (AVSE) uses a target speaker's visible articulation to recover that speaker's voice from overlapped speech. Yet most evaluation protocols rely on synthetic mixtures and reliable video. The ISCSLP 2026 Real-World AVSE Challenge addresses both gaps. Track~1 combines naturally recorded two-talker mixtures, which lack a clean reference, with reference-available remixes of the same speakers; Track~2 additionally degrades the target video in five ways and adds 3-m far-field recordings. Sixteen and twelve teams were ranked on speaker-disjoint test data by rank averaging over waveform fidelity, predicted quality, transcription accuracy, and speaker similarity. On Track~1 remixes, the best system reaches 12.7~dB SI-SDR and 0.85 STOI, but natural recordings remain harder: even the lowest CER rises from 9.0\% to 14.7\%. The leading systems use video mainly for speaker attribution rather than signal reconstruction, and the top two lose under 0.5~dB SI-SDR on Track~2. UTMOS and DNSMOS rank systems differently from the other metrics, so no single metric captures target-speech recovery. We release the baselines, evaluator, and official results.

0.23

Unsupervised Speech Enhancement via Drifting

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-09-28 ·Diego Caviedes-Nozal, Liang Xu, Rasmus Kongsgaard Olsson, W. Bastiaan Kleijn
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 5 pages, 2 figures. Submitted to ICASSP 2027

This paper addresses unsupervised speech enhancement in the unpaired setting using drifting methods, where training relies on separate collections of degraded and clean audio without corresponding pairs. While recent drifting approaches enable unpaired training, they do so at a heavy cost: because the objective optimizes only a marginal prior over clean speech, the enhancer gradually loses the input's linguistic content and speaker identity. To fix this, we introduce input-conditioned drifting. We preserve the pull of the clean corpus while re-tethering the output to the degraded input via two mechanisms: an anchor encoder supplies the missing likelihood by pulling toward the input's features, and a key encoder conditions the prior by re-weighting retrieved frames. Neither requires labels or paired data. Using a training-free encoder selection criterion, Word Error Rate on VoiceBank-DEMAND falls to 10.1% (unprocessed: 11.7%), speaker similarity recovers from 0.490 to 0.879, and the recipe transfers in part to dereverberation on WSJ0-REVERB: content improves, rendering quality does not.

0.19

Speech Block Influence: Component-Specific Layer Scoring for Pruning Speech LLMs

cs.SD ·2026-09-24 ·Siyu Yao, Du Q. Huynh, Lian Xu, Mark Reynolds
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 5 pages, 3 figures. Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Speech LLMs are costly to deploy in resource-constrained settings. Layer pruning can cut this cost, but existing scoring metrics transfer poorly to speech LLMs: they assume a decoder-only architecture with homogeneous token sequences, whereas speech LLMs add encoder and adapter components and process multimodal sequences. We propose Speech Block Influence (SBI), the first layer-importance scoring framework designed for speech LLM pruning that consists of two component-specific scores: SBI-Enc measures the effect of encoder-layer removal at the adapter's output to better reflect downstream impact; SBI-Dec measures layer-wise input-output similarity over text-token positions only to avoid audio-token dominance. Across three speech LLMs, SBI improves pruning robustness, with stronger encoder performance at higher pruning rates and more reliable decoder layer selection by scoring text tokens rather than the audio-dominated full sequence. We further find that text-only calibration yields decoder rankings highly correlated with those from speech-text calibration, suggesting a cheaper alternative to measure decoder layer importance.

0.33

Noisy Target Training Meets Drifting for Weakly-Supervised Speech Enhancement

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-10-23 ·Yoshiki Masuyama, Dominik Klement, Christoph Boeddeker, Julius Richter, Kohei Saijo +3 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 2027

In speech enhancement, standard supervised training requires pairs of noisy and clean speech. Such pairs are typically created by artificially degrading clean speech, leading to a domain mismatch between synthetic training data and real recordings. Noisy target training (NyTT) mitigates this limitation by training an enhancement model to predict a noisy recording from a noisier version generated by adding extra noise. However, since the training target is noisy, NyTT might learn to leave residual noise in the enhanced output. In this paper, we address this issue in NyTT by incorporating a Sinkhorn drifting loss that matches the distribution of the enhanced speech to that of unpaired clean speech. The Sinkhorn drifting loss attracts enhanced speech toward high-density regions of the clean-speech distribution while repelling it from the current enhanced-speech distribution in latent space. This loss uses only unpaired clean speech rather than the clean counterpart of each degraded recording, preserving the weakly-supervised nature of NyTT. Experimental results on VoiceBank-DEMAND and CHiME-3 real recordings demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed combination.

0.09