CS Paper Radar

An Optimal Separation Between Certificate Complexity and Approximate Degree

Kaspars Balodis

cs.CC ·submitted 2026-08-31 07:08 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We prove that certificate complexity can be quartically larger than approximate degree. More precisely, we construct a family of total Boolean functions $G$ with $$ C(G) = \tildeΩ(\tilde{deg}(G)^4), $$ where $C$ denotes certificate complexity and $\tilde{deg}$ denotes $1/3$-approximate degree. This is optimal up to polylogarithmic factors, since every total Boolean function $f$ satisfies $C(f)\le O(\tilde{deg}(f)^4)$ by the classical block-sensitivity bounds of Nisan and Nisan--Szegedy. Thus the result closes the gap between these two measures and improves the previously best known separation $C(f)=\tildeΩ(\tilde{deg}(f)^3)$ by Balodis, Ben-David, Göös, Jain, and Kothari. The construction starts from the partial function they used to quadratically separate $0$-certificate complexity from unambiguous $1$-certificate complexity. It already has the required certificate hardness, but its $0$-certificates are unstructured, which blocks the derivation of a low-degree verifier. We keep its $1$-condition and restrict the $0$-inputs to those certified by a structured family whose validity admits a low-degree approximant, while preserving the quadratic hardness. The partial function with its low-degree verifier is then fed through the cheat-sheet framework to yield the total function $G$ with the claimed separation. The main technical ingredient is an approximate polynomial that verifies the certificate in degree $\tilde{O}(\sqrt n)$. The verifier forms a low-degree count $W$ of the candidate $1$-certificates that remain compatible with the asserted $0$-certificate, and tests whether this count is zero. Crucially, the construction ensures that $W$ never exceeds $\tilde{O}(n)$, instead of the $Θ(n^2)$ candidate pairs it counts bringing the verification down to degree $\tilde{O}(\sqrt n)$.

Comment
17 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Sensitivity and Block Sensitivity of Elementary Symmetric Boolean Functions of Arbitrary Degree

cs.DM math.CO ·2026-09-20 ·Yuan Li, Jing Zhang
theoryhot direction similarity 0.67
Abstract · 26 pages

Let $σ_{n,d}$ denote the elementary symmetric Boolean function of $n$ variables and degree $d$. We completely determine the sensitivity, average sensitivity, and block sensitivity of $σ_{n,d}$ for every $1\le d\le n$. Using Lucas' theorem, we obtain a uniform binary description of the Hamming-weight value sequence, from which the sensitivity and average-sensitivity formulas follow and the computation of block sensitivity reduces to at most four explicit candidates. Combining these results with the arbitrary-degree formula for certificate complexity, we determine the exact relations among sensitivity, block sensitivity, and certificate complexity. We also prove a general result for symmetric Boolean functions: every nonconstant symmetric Boolean function $f$ satisfies \[ \bs(f)\le \max\{s(f),C(f)-1\}. \] Consequently, only the three patterns \[ s=\bs=C,\qquad s=\bs<C,\qquad s<\bs<C \] can occur for nonconstant symmetric Boolean functions. For elementary symmetric Boolean functions, we give necessary and sufficient conditions for each of these three patterns, thereby completely classifying the relations among $s(σ_{n,d})$, $\bs(σ_{n,d})$, and $C(σ_{n,d})$. In particular, we obtain a necessary and sufficient characterization of the full strict hierarchy \[ s(σ_{n,d})<\bs(σ_{n,d})<C(σ_{n,d}), \] and exhibit infinite families for which it holds.

0.47

Block Sensitivity and Certificate Complexity of Rotation Symmetric Boolean Functions

cs.CC math.COcs.DM ·2026-10-12 ·Yuan Li, Jing Zhang
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract · Version 2, 44 pages

We investigate block sensitivity and certificate complexity of monomial rotation-symmetric Boolean functions, obtaining exact formulas and structural classifications for several families. For odd-degree monomial rotation-symmetric functions, the equality $s(f)=n$ established in our earlier work yields $bs(f)=C(f)=n$. For quadratic monomial rotation-symmetric functions, we determine both measures completely and prove that block sensitivity equals certificate complexity. For consecutive quartic monomials, we determine sensitivity, block sensitivity, and certificate complexity in every residue class of the number of variables. Our principal result is an exact global block-sensitivity formula for consecutive monomials of every even degree $d\ge4$. Writing $n=q(d+2)+ρ$, where $0\leρ<d+2$ and $q\ge\max\{2,d/2-1\}$, we prove \[ bs(F_{d,n})=n-\min\left\{\left\lceil\fracρ{2}\right\rceil,d+2-ρ\right\}. \] We also establish the corresponding sensitivity formula by a self-contained argument, yielding arbitrarily large gaps between sensitivity and block sensitivity as the degree varies. For certificate complexity, we obtain exact pointwise formulas for structured run-and-gap configurations and establish additional global equalities, including $C(F_{6,8q+5})=bs(F_{6,8q+5})=8q+2$ for $q\ge2$. Our methods combine cyclic run decomposition, parity arguments, explicit sensitive-block constructions, and constant-subcube certificates. The exact global certificate complexity for arbitrary even degrees remains open.

0.43

Randomized query complexity can beat certificate complexity

cs.CC quant-ph ·2026-09-14 ·Shalev Ben-David, Robin Kothari
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 6 pages

A long-standing open question in query complexity asks whether there is a total Boolean function f with R(f) << C(f), where R(f) and C(f) denote its bounded-error randomized query complexity and certificate complexity, respectively. We construct a function with R(f) = O~(sqrt{C(f)}), which is optimal up to log factors. The same function also has $Q(f) = O~(C(f)^{1/4}), where Q(f) is the bounded-error quantum query complexity of f, which is also nearly optimal.

0.32

Certification complexity of Boolean functions

cs.CC ·2026-09-22 ·Chandrima Kayal, Sophie Laplante, Émile Larroque, Krišjānis Prūsis, Jevgēnijs Vihrovs
publishedtheory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Certificate complexity $(C(f ))$ is a fundamental measure of complexity of Boolean functions f which counts the number of bits of an input that need to be known in order for the value of the function to be determined. A certificate can be viewed as a partial assignment, or a boolean subcube where the function is constant. Certificate complexity is well understood for deterministic query (or decision tree) complexity $(D)$ and other query models such as bounded-error randomized and quantum complexity $(R, Q)$, but not as well for quantum zero-error $(Q_0)$ and exact query complexity $(Q_E)$, where there is no agreed-upon certificate 'object' (even for $Q$). Instead, we study an operational notion of certification and apply it to various query-based models, with a focus on zero-error and exact quantum query complexity, but also on polynomial degree measures. We give new characterizations of $C, RC$ (randomized certificate complexity) and $QC$ (quantum certificate complexity), in terms of various measures such as classical and quantum sabotage complexity, unambiguous certificate complexity, and variants of polynomial degree. Certification complexity also gives rise to new lower bounds on $Q_E$ and $Q_0$, the quantum analogues of $D$ and $R_0$, complexity measures for which few lower bound techniques are known which are not already lower bounds for two-sided error quantum query complexity. We exhibit a total Boolean function for which our certification complexity measure gives a tight lower bound for $Q_0$, but rational degree and $Q$ are asymptotically smaller.

0.28

Certificate Complexity of Elementary Symmetric Boolean Functions of Arbitrary Degree

cs.DM math.CO ·2026-09-14 ·Jing Zhang, Yuan Li
theoryhot direction similarity 0.65
Abstract

Let $σ_{n,d}$ denote the elementary symmetric Boolean function of $n$ variables and degree $d$. Previous work determined $C(σ_{n,d})$ when $d$ is odd or a power of two, but the general even non-power-of-two case remained open. We determine the certificate complexity for every degree $1\le d\le n$, thereby completing the classification for elementary symmetric Boolean functions. Writing $d=2^t m$ with $m$ odd, we obtain an explicit formula in which the possible deficit from the maximal value $n$ is controlled by $2^t$, while the exact value is determined by a binary containment condition involving $m$. In particular, \[ n-2^{ν_2(d)}+1\le C(σ_{n,d})\le n, \] and we characterize when the upper bound is attained. Moreover, we determine the least positive period of the certificate-complexity deficit $Δ_d(n)=n-C(σ_{n,d})$: it is $1$ for odd $d$, equals $d$ when $d$ is a power of two, and equals $2^{\lfloor\log_2 d\rfloor+1}$ for even non-power-of-two $d$. This least-period problem is distinct from the classical periodicity of the underlying value sequence $\binom{j}{d}\bmod 2$. The known odd-degree and power-of-two formulas are recovered as special cases.

0.51

The Complexity of Choosing Parity Projections

cs.CC ·2026-10-30 ·Karthik Sheshadri, Nicholas Smirnov
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

Cube attacks in cryptanalysis seek small sets of Boolean variables (cubes) whose parity sum is constant. We study the bounded constant derivative problem introduced by Smirnov (2026), which seeks a smallest cube with sum 1, and its sum-0 analogue. Despite their similarity, the problems differ sharply in parameterized complexity: the sum-1 problem admits a $2^{O(k^2)}\operatorname{poly}(N)$-time algorithm, where $k$ is cube size, whereas the sum-0 problem is not fixed-parameter tractable unless $\mathrm{FPT}=\mathrm{W}[1]$. Without a bound on cube size, both problems are $Σ_2^{\oplus\mathrm{P}}$-complete and NP-hard to approximate within $N^{1-\varepsilon}$ for every fixed $0<\varepsilon<1$. Our hardness proofs use a crown construction that embeds maximal monomials of parity-projected circuits into positive 2CNF. This yields completeness and inapproximability results, as well as a dichotomy for Boolean constraint languages of arity at most two: the bounded constant derivative problem is in P when all relations are affine and $Σ_2^{\oplus\mathrm{P}}$-complete otherwise. We also give algorithms parameterized by the number of quadratic rounds, treewidth, or ordered branching-program width, with lower bounds for the first two unless $\mathrm{NP}\subseteq\mathrm{SUBEXP}$. The treewidth lower bound holds for circuits; the case of 2CNF remains open.

0.23

Degree Lower Bounds for Symmetric Boolean Functions: Breaking the Prime-Gap Barrier

cs.CC math.CO ·2026-11-19 ·Xiaoming Sun, Chengu Wang
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

We prove that every nonconstant symmetric Boolean function on $n$ variables has exact real polynomial degree at least $n-O(n^{1/3}(\log n)^{2/3})$. This makes progress toward the conjecture of von zur Gathen and Roche that the degree is always at least $n-3$. The original prime-gap argument of von zur Gathen and Roche yields a degree deficit of $O(n^{0.525})$ using the theorem of Baker, Harman, and Pintz, or $O(n^{0.52})$ using an estimate claimed in a recent preprint. Our $\widetilde{O}(n^{1/3})$ bound on the degree deficit improves upon the $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{n})$ bound obtainable from the prime-gap approach, even assuming the Riemann hypothesis or Legendre's conjecture. Notably, our proof avoids prime-gap estimates entirely. The proof combines vanishing binomial moments with the arithmetic of linear recurrences. A quantitative form of the integer Hankel determinant method in the Pólya--Carlson theorem forces the function's values on a central interval of Hamming weights to satisfy a short rational recurrence. A second determinant argument bounds the number of characteristic roots near $-1$. Through the binomial transform, these roots can then be cancelled by a polynomial test of degree below the deficit. An integer annihilator and contour estimates make the test isolate the first failure of the recurrence, yielding a contradiction with the vanishing-moment conditions. If the recurrence agrees with the function on a sufficiently long interval, arithmetic height bounds instead force a bounded period, which is ruled out by a separate polynomial test. Every numbered result in the paper has been formally verified in Lean~4.

0.18

On Non-Deterministic Representation of Boolean Functions

cs.CC ·2026-11-09 ·Sudharshan Rajagopalan, Nitin Saurabh
publishedtheory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 15 pages, to appear in FSTTCS 2026

We study non-deterministic representation of Boolean functions by polynomials, introduced by (de Wolf, 2000). A polynomial $p(x)$ is said to be a non-deterministic polynomial for a Boolean function $f$ if for all $a\in\{0,1\}^n$, $p(a)\neq 0$ iff $f(a)=1$. The non-deterministic degree of $f$, denoted $\mathsf{ndeg}(f)$, is the minimal degree of a non-deterministic polynomial for $f$. In this work, we show the following main results: - Almost all Boolean functions on $n$ variables have non-deterministic degree at most $n/2 + O(\sqrt{n\log n})$. This confirms a conjecture of (Iyer et al., 2023). Together with the lower bound of (Iyer et al., 2023) it establishes a tight bound on the rational degree of a random Boolean function up to lower order terms. - We disprove a conjecture of (Kothari et al., 2026) about effective hypercube nullstellensatz for more than two polynomials. On the positive side, we also identify a constraint under which an effective hypercube nullstellensatz holds for many polynomials.

0.22