CS Paper Radar

Why Are LLM Backdoor Defenses Fragmented? A Feature-Level Explanation with Sparse Autoencoders

Yizhe Zeng, Chenxu Niu, Wei Zhang, Hao Huang, Yunpeng Li, Dongxu Han, Dan Du, Cheng Hong, Hequn Xian, Yuling Liu

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-08-31 07:55 UTC · v1
top venue

Abstract

Backdoor attacks pose a serious threat to large language models (LLMs), but existing defenses remain fragmented, failing to pro?vide unified defense against both dirty-label and clean-label attacks. To investigate why such fragmentation arises, we present the first systematic feature-level mechanistic analysis of LLM backdoors using sparse autoencoders (SAEs). Starting from a 2 x 2 comparison of clean and poisoned models on clean and triggered inputs, we trace backdoor-induced logit shifts to high-contributing SAE features and categorize them into four roles: interac?tion, suppressed, mixed, and weight-modified features. This taxonomy reveals system?atic encoding differences: dirty-label back?doors are dominated by isolated interaction features, whereas clean-label backdoors rely more on heterogeneous mixtures of mixed and weight-modified features. These differ?ences explain why existing defenses remain fragmented across attack paradigms. We val?idate this hypothesis through inference-time feature clamping, which reduces ASR to at most 10.8% in most dirty-label settings and at most 15.4% in the majority of clean-label settings, while preserving benign-task perfor?mance. These results show that SAE-based analysis can explain defense fragmentation and guide interpretable backdoor mitigation.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Backdooring Sparse Autoencoders

cs.CR cs.AIcs.CLcs.SE ·2026-10-05 ·Enrico Ahlers, Daniel Passon, Tobias Kiecker, Eik Reichmann, Lars Grunske
similarity 0.77
Abstract

Sparse autoencoders (SAEs) are increasingly used not only to interpret language models but also to intervene on their internal representations. We show that this creates a supply-chain attack surface: a maliciously modified SAE can induce attacker-chosen behavior when inserted into the forward pass of an otherwise unchanged language model. We introduce a decoder-only SAE backdoor that leaves both the underlying LLM and the SAE encoder frozen, restricting the attack to a single auxiliary component at a single insertion layer. Using code generation as a case study, we demonstrate high rates of unsolicited code insertion across three language models and a wide range of insertion layers, as well as trigger-dependent behavior conditioned on a prompt cue. We further evaluate the modified SAEs using HumanEval and selected SAEBench metrics. While attack effectiveness varies across models and layers, strong backdoor behavior can coexist with relatively small changes in several conventional SAE quality measures. These results establish that SAEs can carry behavioral backdoors without modifying the language model itself and should therefore be treated as security-sensitive components.

0.20

Removing the NEEDLE in the Haystack: Backdoor Removal in LLMs via Weight Orthogonalisation

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-09-29 ·Minoo Kim, Vasileios Lampos, George Drayson
similarity 0.74
Abstract

Backdoor attacks can be implanted in Large Language Models (LLMs) during training, causing unwanted behaviour when a trigger appears in the input. Existing backdoor defences for LLMs attempt to remove the backdoor but inadvertently shift the model's output distribution to benign prompts, which can result in degraded model performance and safety. We propose NEEDLE, a training-free method for targeted backdoor removal. Once a trigger has been identified, our method estimates a backdoor direction and a refusal subspace through activation vectors, then applies sequential weight orthogonalisation to suppress the backdoor while preventing changes in refusal-related representations. NEEDLE requires neither a clean reference model nor the original poisoned training data. Evaluation is conducted across multiple model families and attack types. NEEDLE achieves the lowest mean Attack Success Rate (ASR) among the evaluated defences, including 0% on challenging code injection attacks, while resulting in the lowest KL divergence and minimal changes in capability and safety.

0.17

LLM Forensics: Where Do Backdoors Hide? Localizing and Controlling Trigger Mechanisms with Sparse Autoencoders

cs.CL ·2026-09-07 ·Wissam Antoun, Francis Kulumba, Théo Lasnier, Benoît Sagot, Djamé Seddah
top venue similarity 0.73
Abstract · Accepted at Findings of EMNLP 2026

Even though backdoors in LLMs have been a growing concern, their inner workings are still under heavy scrutiny. Trigger-based backdoors are easy to define behaviorally, a rare input that makes the model switch to a chosen response pattern, but the mechanism between triggers and their responses is less clear. We study this mechanism in a controlled, harmless language-switching setting, where fixed trigger sequences make 1B and 8B language models continue English prompts in French or German. For this, we train sparse autoencoders (SAEs) across layers and transformer components, then compare triggered prompts with translation and pretraining controls to identify trigger-relevant feature directions. We show how SAE features separate triggered prompts from controls with near-perfect F1, but features that detect the trigger do not necessarily control the behavior. In intervention tests, attention and MLP features often fire reliably on triggered prompts, making them good detectors, but ablating them rarely suppresses the language switch and activating them rarely induces it. In contrast, residual-stream features can suppress triggered generation when ablated, and some selected features can induce target-language continuations without the trigger. In short, these token-trigger mechanisms decompose into distinct SAE feature directions, with separate features for trigger detection, residual-stream propagation, and later language tracking. This role-level decomposition is the part most likely to transfer to other trigger-based backdoors, even when the payload, layers, or circuit locations differ.

0.48

Backdoor Purification for LoRA-Tuned LLMs via Null-Space Projection

cs.AI cs.CRcs.LG ·2026-09-30 ·Jianwei Li, Jung-Eun Kim
published similarity 0.71
Abstract · NeurIPS 2026

With the rapid adoption of large language models (LLMs) and parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods, the risk of backdoor attacks has become more severe. Existing backdoor purification methods typically rely on at least one of the strong assumptions, such as prior knowledge of triggers, access to clean references, or aggressive retraining, and they often lack comprehensive evaluations. These constraints substantially limit their practical applicability. To overcome these challenges, our work proposes purifying LoRA-tuned LLMs without these assumptions and even without post-hoc retraining of the suspect parameters. Our objective is to significantly reduce the attack success rates (ASR) while preserving both (i) the base model's general capabilities and (ii) the new downstream skills learned through the adapter. Through a series of examinations, we progressively scale our approach from a single layer in a text classification setting to a full-parameter LLM in the generative task. Through careful data curation and feature approximation, we extract high-fidelity backdoor directions and, for each layer or head, construct orthogonal null spaces in both the input and output channels, onto which the LoRA updates are projected. Empirically, our null-space projection method reduces the ASR from nearly 100% to less than 10%, while preserving the base model's benign performance and the adapter's learned abilities during downstream task adaptation.

0.45

Poisoning-Based Backdoors Are Not Cryptographic

cs.LG cs.CL ·2026-10-20 ·Masahiro Kaneko
published similarity 0.69
Abstract · NeurIPS 2026

Defending against a backdoor requires recovering the verifier that decides whether an input is a trigger, since blocking individual triggers fails against an attacker who can generate new ones. If a verifier could be installed with the asymmetry of cryptographic authentication, where only the attacker can produce triggers and the defender cannot reconstruct the verifier, defense that learns the verifier from observations would be impossible in principle. We show that no such asymmetry can arise when the verifier enters training only through the labels of poisoned data, which covers the dirty-label backdoors that dominate the literature on language models. A training procedure that installs a verifier from poisoned data is itself a learner for that verifier. Hence any verifier that is hard to learn cannot be installed through poisoning, and any verifier that poisoning can install is reconstructible by a white-box defender holding as many labeled trigger observations as the attacker used. Hiding a secret key in the input or the weights does not change this. Experiments on instruction-tuned large language models confirm the dichotomy, with no configuration yielding a backdoor that is both effective for the attacker and irrecoverable for the defender.

0.18

MechAudit-40: White-Box Auditing across 40 LLM Attack Mechanisms

cs.CR ·2026-09-06 ·Zhen Guo, Shanghao Shi, Shamim Yazdani, Ning Zhang, Reza Tourani
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 31 pages, 18 figures, 13 tables

While LLM attacks span prompt optimization, multi-turn context manipulation, retrieval poisoning, and model backdoors, white-box defenses are typically evaluated on isolated attack families. Consequently, whether heterogeneous attacks leave internal representation shifts that generalize to unseen threat mechanisms remains unknown. We present MechAudit-40, a systematic evaluation of 40 attack mechanisms across five open-weight model architectures. Threat-specific success criteria, 100,000 matched clean-attack representation pairs, predefined categories, and grouped holdouts isolate genuine attack-induced displacement from target scale, corpus bias, and data-leakage shortcuts. Across this testbed, attacks induce structured multi-depth trajectories rather than isolated layer spikes. While raw peaks are non-portable across architectures, target-calibrated profiles preserve transferable geometric signatures: under complete mechanism holdout, hidden states alone recover the threat category of unseen attacks with 82.5% accuracy. Guided by this finding, we design MechAudit, a runtime auditor that operates under strict zero-oracle constraints without requiring clean baseline traces or attack metadata. MechAudit detects 81.1% of held-out attack executions at a 0.70% false-positive rate and maintains 78.1% recall when an entire functional category is withheld. In matched comparisons, MechAudit is the only detector that avoids mechanism-level coverage collapse, maintaining over 50% recall across all 40 mechanisms. Internal representations thus support cross-mechanism attack-exposure auditing against calibrated benign references, but decouple from downstream task compromise and parameter integrity.

0.22

An Empirical Study of Output-to-Input Loops for Black-Box Backdoor Detection in Fine-Tuned Open-Weight LLMs

cs.CR ·2026-08-11 ·Md. Nahid Hasan, Mohammad Arif Hossain
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Anyone can upload a fine-tuned large language model (LLM) to a public repository and claim it is safe. A backdoored model behaves normally on ordinary inputs until a hidden trigger fires, and a user with no training data, clean reference weights, or the trigger phrase has no clear way to check the model before using it. We introduce and empirically evaluate self-feeding, a black-box test method that feeds a model's own output back as its next input, so the text drifts away from the starting prompt and toward the data the model was fine-tuned on. We test self-feeding against a repeated same-prompt baseline on six open-weight LLMs (3B-15B parameters), each fine-tuned with backdoors spanning eleven attack categories, using twenty ordinary starting prompts and chains of up to ten steps. Self-feeding finds backdoors in five of six models at 92.0\% pooled precision, while the same-prompt baseline succeeds on only one of 120 prompt-model pairs; chains that begin with a joke request, an arithmetic question, or a coffee recipe all reach a trigger within a few steps. Recall per prompt is low (19.2\%), and we show why it still adds up to much higher detection at the model level once several starting prompts are used. We also report where the method falls short: one model was never triggered, and self-feeding produced two false positives that the same-prompt baseline cannot produce. Cutting the chains to four steps keeps every model-level detection at 100\% precision while using 60\% fewer queries. Needing only text-level query access and a way to recognize malicious output, self-feeding offers a cheap first check on a downloaded model.

0.04

Low-ASR Backdoors: Exploiting Attack Success Rate Reduction and Attacker-Defender Asymmetry

cs.CR ·2026-08-27 ·Arham Riaz, Ting Yu
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 25 page, 16 main, 9 appendix

Backdoor attacks are among the most effective and stealthy attacks in deep learning. Existing attacks and defenses are largely designed and evaluated under the assumption that successful backdoors exhibit high Attack Success Rates (ASRs). In this paper, we show that this assumption creates a fundamental weakness in existing defense paradigms. ASR is not an intrinsic property of a backdoor; rather, it is an attacker-controlled variable that can be deliberately reduced without eliminating the underlying backdoor behavior. We introduce a reverse-training framework that weakens the trigger-target association, producing low-ASR backdoor models while preserving clean-input performance. Through extensive evaluation across multiple datasets, diverse attack families, and multiple architectures, we show that state-of-the-art defenses fail consistently under low-ASR conditions, exposing a fundamental attacker-defender asymmetry.

0.18